
Carl H. Baxmeyer is the President of the St. Joseph County Board of Commissioners, holding the District 1 seat. He did not win the seat first — his party handed it to him. In August 2022 the county Republican organization chose him by caucus to replace a commissioner who had stepped down, and days later he was the board's president, on a vote that included his own. The voters elected him that November. On November 3, 2026, they took the seat back: he lost the seat, 11,924 votes to 16,735 in the county's unofficial results.
This file began as an accountability review of his record published in October 2026. For this dossier, every claim in that review was re-checked against the underlying record — the minutes, the packets, the agreements, the audits, the court files. What survived that check is printed here at its verified weight. What did not survive is not silently dropped: it is named in §15, The Open File, with the reason and the pull that would settle it. Two corrections from that check are printed where they belong: the Portage Manor sale critic was Council President Bryan Tanner, not a "Council attorney Jason Tanner," and the claim that Baxmeyer once voted to replace public comment with written forms is contradicted by the county's own 2024 agendas and does not appear in this file as fact.
SEATED BY A PARTY CAUCUS IN AUGUST 2022 — ELECTED THAT NOVEMBER
DEFEATED FOR RE-ELECTION, NOVEMBER 3, 2026 — 11,924 TO 16,735 (COUNTY UNOFFICIAL RESULTS)
The record between those two lines is a consequential one: a nursing-home closure that ended with him as the named defendant in a federal civil-rights suit; a 35-year tax deal for Amazon and a $53 million cap the county signed with Microsoft; two state audit findings; a $695,000 jail settlement; an announced investigation of two of his own senior administrators that has produced no public report; and a snowplow study with his former employer that arrived at the board already signed. Each is printed below from the paper, section by section.
Carl H. Baxmeyer, a Republican, is the St. Joseph County Commissioner for District 1 and the President of the three-member Board of Commissioners — the office county documents have styled him by throughout 2025 and 2026. He serves alongside Vice President Tony Hazen and Commissioner Mary Morton.
His profession is planning. Michiana Business News reported in May 2023 that he was a senior planner at Wightman, the Benton Harbor–based consulting firm he had joined in 2016, and that he was retiring after a 40-year career in the field — the 40 years measured his career, not his time at Wightman. He took the commissioner's seat in August 2022 while still a Wightman senior planner; the retirement came nine months into his first year in office.
The District 1 seat was held before him by Andy Kostielney. How Baxmeyer followed him is the next section — because the sequence matters to everything after it.
Baxmeyer was not elected to the seat he has held for four years — not the first time. The South Bend Tribune reported that when Commissioner Andy Kostielney stepped down in August 2022, months before his term ended that December, the St. Joseph County Republican Party chose Baxmeyer by caucus to fill the vacancy.
Days later, on August 30, 2022, he was the board's president. The Tribune reported that he voted for himself, that Commissioner Debra Fleming joined him, and that Commissioner Derek Dieter opposed the move and called it "garbage" at the time.
On November 1, 2022, the board's scheduled meeting was canceled and Dieter sat alone at the board table. In a press release, Dieter said Baxmeyer was in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and called the board under Baxmeyer dysfunctional. That account is Dieter's, printed there in his own words.
The voters got their say that same month: he won the November 2022 general election for the District 1 seat and the full term that followed. He held the seat through the term — and put his name before the voters again in 2026.
In the November 3, 2026 general election, Baxmeyer sought re-election against the Democratic nominee. The county Election Office's own Election Summary Report — the final election-night count, run at 9:07 p.m. on November 3, covering all absentee ballots and all vote centers — records the result:
| CANDIDATE — COMMISSIONER, DISTRICT 1 | VOTES | SHARE |
|---|---|---|
| Democratic nominee (D) — winner | 16,735 | 58.39% |
| Carl H. Baxmeyer (R), incumbent | 11,924 | 41.61% |
Those figures are labeled UNOFFICIAL: they are the county election office's own election-night report, and certification by the county election board was still pending when this file was checked on November 9, 2026. An earlier partial figure carried in election-night coverage (60 percent for the winner) was superseded by this final county report — the numbers in the table above are the ones that stand.
The South Bend Tribune reported that the result returns the Board of Commissioners to 2-1 Democratic control. Baxmeyer serves out the term he won in 2022, which ends December 31, 2026.
This file makes no endorsement. It is the record of the term, printed so the vote — whichever way a reader cast it — was cast over paper, not slogans.
Portage Manor was the county's nursing home — a 144-bed facility for low-income residents with mental-health, developmental, and substance-use needs, and a place the county had operated since the 1800s. Its closure was the defining fight of Baxmeyer's first year, and it ended with him as the named defendant in federal court.
The vote. On February 14, 2023, the board took up Resolution R-2-C-2023, the transition-household assistance plan tied to the home's closure. The official minutes record that Commissioner Fleming's motion to postpone "dies for the lack of a second"; that Dieter moved to adopt and Baxmeyer seconded; and that the resolution was adopted 2-1.
The press release. The minutes also record what happened after a county press release described the closure decision as the County Council's. Council member Diana Hess told the board the council had made no such decision and called the statement false. Baxmeyer's words, verbatim in the minutes:
"The wording said the decision had been made by the Council and that was the wrong word. We shouldn't have used the word decision. I take responsibility for that."
The lawsuit. On June 26, 2023, four Portage Manor residents — Randy Joseph Nowak, Edward Douglas McLellan, David M. Burns, and Melissa McDonald — sued him by name in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana: Nowak v. Baxmeyer, Case No. 3:23-cv-00589, individually and as representatives of a class. The complaint charged violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Rehabilitation Act, the Federal Nursing Home Reform Act, the Fourteenth Amendment's due-process and equal-protection guarantees, and Indiana law. Those are allegations the plaintiffs pled; no court ever ruled on them — see how the case ended.
How it ended. The case was dismissed on August 28, 2023 because the parties settled. Under the settlement, the defendants agreed to pay up to $195,000 in total, with per-resident awards tied to where each resident would live — $25,000 in the most restrictive settings up to $60,000 for those able to live independently, as WSBT's reporting on the settlement described it. It was a private settlement that mooted the case before any ruling: neither a vindication nor a judgment.
The security bill. Guarding the emptying facility cost real money. ABC57 (reporter Kevin Warmhold, in its "Portage Manor Money Pit" investigation) reported from county records that "more than $335,000 was paid to Trinity Protection services LLC in 8 months" for security at the vacant facility. The home closed July 31, 2023. (The story's own page could not be read directly in this pass; the figure is printed here as reported, from the reporter's reproduction of the story — see Sources.)
The sale. On October 6, 2026, the board voted 2-1 — Commissioner Morton opposed — to sell the Portage Manor property to Saint Thomas More Academy, Inc. under Resolution R-13-C-2026: a $400,000 purchase price and a committed $9,000,000 renovation investment. The October 7, 2026 sale was the last chapter of the closure he had voted to begin.
"The agreement requires $9 million in renovation or repair but specifies no completion deadline, milestones, performance security, or express renovations-related reverter or fallback."
The agreement itself does contain default remedies: Section 18 gives either party the right to terminate on an uncured material default, and lets the county cancel on fifteen days' notice if the school's use of the property ends. What it does not spell out — the President of the County Council's point — is a deadline, milestones, or security behind the $9 million promise. Both things are in the paper; both are printed.
The Amazon deal. On August 13, 2024, the Board of Commissioners approved the county's economic development agreement with Amazon Data Services unanimously (Resolution R-8-C-2024), and defended it publicly — Baxmeyer among its defenders. The terms, as reported from the county's own proceedings: a 50% real-property tax abatement for 10 years on each of the project's roughly 16 data-center shells, and an 85% enterprise-technology exemption for 35 years on the computer equipment inside them (County Council Bill 84-24). Sources say "abatement" for the real property — the October review's word "deduction" is corrected here.
The ask that went nowhere. By March 2026, four Republican members of the County Council had written to Amazon asking the company to renegotiate the deal and give up part of the break — and Amazon declined to discuss renegotiating it publicly. Councilman Randy Figg put the status plainly in October 2026: the request "hasn't moved forward on Amazon's side." Print the corrected version: the ask was made; the deal stands unchanged.
New Carlisle. In December 2025, Baxmeyer signed a December 2, 2025 joint letter giving the proposed third Amazon rezoning at New Carlisle the county's "full support," and called the project "a no-brainer" at its press conference. Eight days later, on December 10, 2025, the County Council rejected the rezoning 7-2.
The moratorium. By late May 2026, residents were pressing for a pause on data-center approvals. On May 30, 2026, WVPE's "Coffee with Your Commissioners" recorded Baxmeyer opposing a moratorium and favoring stronger ordinances and enforcement instead (as reported from the program's published summary).
The Microsoft cap. The county's second memorandum of understanding with Microsoft — MOU II, in the Redevelopment Commission's October 6, 2026 special-meeting packet — puts a hard number on the county's exposure for interchange and infrastructure work. Section 7.1 of the agreement, verbatim:
"Microsoft shall not be obligated to reimburse the County for its Costs exceeding $53,023,257.70 in the aggregate (the 'Reimbursement Cap'). The County agrees that it shall be solely responsible for any amounts expended in excess of the Reimbursement Cap for the Scope of Work, unless Microsoft has approved any such excess in writing as a signed amendment to this MOU."
The same section reserves the county's option to stop work if projected costs would exceed the cap. The staff memo in the packet (Bill Schalliol, October 2, 2026) puts the two Microsoft agreements together at $65,600,632.70. No overrun has been established — the point is structural, and it is in the document: above $53,023,257.70, the county pays, unless Microsoft agrees in writing to pay more.
On January 7, 2025, the commissioners approved outsourcing custodial services for multiple county facilities to Gobel's Commercial Cleaning Services (the firm's name is spelled both "Gobel" and "Goebel" across county and news sources). County staff said at the time that the move would save roughly $295,000 in 2025. The contractor committed to offer interviews to the county's current custodial employees and to match 2024 pay rates for those it hired.
The price comparison reached the public record two months later. At the board's March 18, 2025 discussion of the contract, the county's Director of Physical Assets, Bree Roberts, reviewed the competing proposals: two other companies had proposed roughly $832,000 and $878,000 a year, against Gobel's roughly $337,000 a year — the lowest of three proposals by a wide margin. The same follow-up recorded that the firm had brought four former county custodial workers into full-time positions, with transferred employees paid $18.90 an hour.
Three specifics from the October review could not be re-verified from the paper in this pass — the contract's exact figure to the cent, the claim that nineteen custodial positions were eliminated, and a January 14, 2025 minutes quote attributed to Baxmeyer. They are carried in §15, The Open File, at their true weight — not stated as established anywhere in this file.
The October review paired a series of campaign contributions with a series of county contract approvals. The two halves of that pairing verified very differently, and this file prints them separately so the reader can see exactly which half is paper and which half is still a pull.
The contract approvals are documented — each from the county's own packets:
| DATE | FIRM & ACTION | TERMS IN THE PACKET |
|---|---|---|
| January 27, 2026 | Jones Petrie Rafinski Corp (JPR) — as-needed preliminary engineering services (the name is spelled several ways across county documents) | Not to exceed $100,000 |
| February 10, 2026 | DLZ Indiana, LLC — as-needed preliminary engineering and related services | Not to exceed $200,000.00 |
| March 3, 2026 | Lochmueller Group — selected for construction engineering, Pierce Road (Des. No. 1702832, US 31 to Juniper) | Staff letter: "most responsive and qualified"; fee negotiation stage — no amount appears in that record |
| August 11, 2026 | Lochmueller Group — as-needed professional services, county projects | Not to exceed $300,000.00 |
The contribution half is not documented in this file — not because it was disproven, but because the filings that would prove it are paper this pass could not reach: Baxmeyer's campaign reports (CFA-4s) are local filings held by the county election board and are not published online. The figures the October review reported from those filings are listed in §15, The Open File, labeled as reported there and not re-verified here.
The contract approvals are documented in the county's own packets, above. Whether the campaign money the review described moved alongside them awaits the election-board pull. A payment in exchange for a vote is not documented anywhere, and this file does not claim one.
On July 21, 2026, the Board of Commissioners published a letter signed by all three members — Baxmeyer as President, Hazen, and Morton — answering public calls to fire two of the county's senior administrators: Bill Schalliol, the Economic Development Director, and Shawn Klein, the Planning Director, amid controversy over a proposed solar farm and the Midwest Continental Divide Trail. The letter's operative sentence:
"The Board announces it will retain independent outside counsel to investigate allegations."
As of November 9, 2026 — the date this file was checked — no completed report, no findings, no retained firm's name, and no cost for that review has been published in any source searched for this file. The county's own August 21, 2026 release on the solar question still described it as "their ongoing investigation." The announcement is documented. The ending is not.
The trail money. The paper trail underneath the controversy is documented, and it runs through the Redevelopment Commission — a separate body. Baxmeyer is not a member of it and cast no votes on these items; they are printed here because the contract at issue belonged to his administration's economic-development office, and they show what the paperwork underneath the July announcement actually contained:
Schalliol's February 5, 2026 memo to the RDC states the trail project's September 2024 contract with Community Redevelopment Partners LLC was a not-to-exceed $300,000, and that an "additional fee of $37,500.00" was requested for design services. At the RDC's March 10, 2026 meeting, Schalliol explained on the record why the amendment as drafted had overshot: the Third Amendment's text replaced the $300,000 figure with $375,000, and its Exhibit A carried a second $37,500 line (for third-party reimbursements) — a $75,000 total increase where only $37,500 had been approved. A corrected Revised Third Amendment was approved that day, 3-0. Commissioner Gary Fox's summary, in the minutes: "Just an error, we're cleaning up an error." The separate $37,500 in design services, Schalliol told the commission, "is going to be covered by the City of South Bend."
A precision note: a Tribune report of March 13, 2026 described the discrepancy as "$70,000." The RDC's own minutes put it at $75,000. Where the paper conflicts, the minutes control — this file prints $75,000.
Sharon McBride directed the county's DuComb Center. Her own dossier in this library (File No. 6) carries her record in full; this section carries only the part that belongs to Baxmeyer and the board he led.
The board initiated a county investigation of McBride on February 21, 2024, terminated her employment effective February 23, 2024, and ratified the termination unanimously on March 5, 2024 — Resolution R-1-C-2024, signed by Baxmeyer, Dieter, and Hazen — effective retroactively to February 23. The county's investigation was later taken over by the Indiana State Police.
The criminal question underneath it was pay: the investigation put at issue $134,644.56 in salary for 2,514 hours in which her keycard logged no activity, measured against a computed requirement in which her card logged 648 hours against 3,162 "required" hours between January 1, 2022 and February 22, 2024.
"The credible and admissible evidence is not sufficient to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a criminal offense has occurred."
Gaal's report also took apart the method the original case had been built on. The keycard system, he found, "was not intended as a direct time-keeping record"; the forensic methodology "relied on speculation" by imputing required hours from a standard schedule — although the director's own job description allowed her duties to be performed off-site. The termination stands as the board's act. The criminal case ended in November 2025 with no charges, on the prosecutor's own words.
What the county spent pursuing it — legal services by named attorneys, and a personnel investigation — could not be itemized from any source located in this pass. Those figures are carried in §15, The Open File.
Two findings from the State Board of Accounts' audits of St. Joseph County sit on this board's watch — one about settlement money charged to a federal grant, one about the county's books themselves. The Auditor's Office that prepares the county's financial work is separately elected; the findings below are the audit's own words, and the responses quoted are the county's.
The federal single audit of the county's COVID-relief spending (Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds) found unallowable activity charges, including "satisfaction of settlements and judgments," with "Questioned costs totaling $190,000." The county's own Corrective Action Plan described the same money as "expenditures of $190,000 in settlements." The plan records the ending: the $190,000 "were paid back by the County's Worker's Compensation/Casualty Fund on June 14, 2024." The 2024 audit's schedule of prior findings lists Finding 2023-002: Status: Resolved.
The 2024 audit found a material weakness in the county's financial-reporting controls. The stated cause, verbatim: "There was a lack of detailed supervisory review of the 2024 financial statements and related supporting schedules." The finding carries the line "Identification as a Repeat Finding: Yes" — the prior year's control finding (2023-001) is recorded in the same audit as only "Partially resolved."
Put together, at their verified weight: in 2023, $190,000 of settlement spending was charged where federal rules did not allow it, found by the auditors, and repaid from a county fund the following June. And across two consecutive audit cycles, the state's auditors found the county's financial-reporting controls weak — the second time as a repeat, with the first only partly fixed.
The Anderson settlement — $695,000. On May 26, 2026, the board approved a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release with the estate of William B. Anderson. The agreement's words: "The County shall pay to Plaintiff and Plaintiffs attorney, Fieger Law, the sum of Six Hundred Ninety Five Thousand Dollars" — $445,000 in cash and $250,000 to New York Life to fund periodic payments for Cayden A. Anderson.
The death behind it: Anderson was arrested on April 6, 2021 and taken to the St. Joseph County Jail. As the federal court's opinion in the estate's case (Anderson v. St. Joseph County, Case No. 3:23-cv-00211, Judge Leichty's order of August 28, 2023) recites the allegations: he was found "unresponsive, pale, pulseless, apneic" in his cell on the morning of April 8, 2021; life support was removed on April 11 after a CT scan confirmed brain death; and the postmortem examination concluded his cause of death was complications of drug withdrawal, including dehydration. The precision the record requires: he was found in his jail cell, and he died at Memorial Hospital three days later.
Every event in the Anderson case happened in April 2021 — more than a year before Baxmeyer took office in August 2022. The death is not on his watch; the settlement vote is his board's. And the paper itself conflicts: the recitals in the county's own settlement agreement give the year of these events as 2022. The federal court's 2023 opinion and the case's March 2023 filing date put them in 2021. Where the county's agreement and the court's record disagree, this file prints the court's dates — and prints the disagreement.
The Collins settlement. On January 27, 2026, the board approved a claims settlement and release for Carlton Alphonzo Collins, unanimously. Presenting it, attorney Peter J. Agostino explained the settlement arose from a mistaken hold — two people sharing the same name — and that the amount was substantially less than the expected cost of federal litigation. The amount itself does not appear in any record read for this file; the figure carried in the October review is in §15, unverified.
The October review also carried a third, smaller jail settlement from January 2023. Neither the name-figure pairing nor the amount could be tied to any record read in this pass — the January 17, 2023 minutes approve a settlement that names neither party nor amount. It is carried in §15, and the review's three-settlement total is not printed in this file, because only one of the three amounts survived re-verification.
The county attorney. On September 3, 2024, the commissioners accepted the resignation of County Attorney Michael Misch and appointed Pete Agostino interim county attorney. The meeting record is explicit about what the board did not say: it gave no additional substantive public details about the circumstances of the resignation. That is the whole of what the public record establishes — a mid-term departure of the county's top lawyer, accepted without a public explanation. An account attributing specific explanations to Baxmeyer could not be located in this pass and is carried in §15.
The election lawyers. Two years earlier, in the middle of an election Baxmeyer himself was contesting, the board hired outside counsel to watch the county's own election board. The South Bend Tribune reported on October 11, 2022 that after the Indiana Republican Party filed suit against the St. Joseph County Election Board, the commissioners — Baxmeyer and Fleming approving — retained the firm Taft Stettinius & Hollister to "monitor" the potential litigation. Baxmeyer's stated purpose, in his own words at the time: "our goal was to avoid a lawsuit" — and, he said, "our hand was forced."
He won his own race that November. What the October review added to this episode — that he seconded the motion, and a $450-per-hour cap on the firm's rate — appears in no record read for this file, and is not printed as fact.
The January 6, 2026 agenda packet contains a memorandum dated December 24, 2025, subject "Ratification of Snowplow Route Study," attaching an agreement with Wightman Associates to perform a snowplow route study in the northeast area of St. Joseph County for a not-to-exceed fee of $80,000. Its closing lines, verbatim:
"This agreement was previously reviewed and executed. We recommend your ratification of the agreement."
Wightman is Baxmeyer's former employer — the planning firm where he was a senior planner from 2016 until his retirement in May 2023 (§01). The document does not show who signed the agreement before it reached the board, and this file does not guess.
What happened to it: the October review reported the item was tabled in January 2026. The minutes of the January 6, 2026 meeting could not be read in this pass, and no later approval or payment of the study appears in the records searched. The ratification request is documented; its disposition is not — the minutes are the open pull (§15).
On February 10, 2026, the board approved a settlement agreement in Donna Hurley v. St. Joseph County, Case No. 3:24-cv-907 (N.D. Ind.), a federal employment case that had been mediated on October 15, 2025. The agreement is with "Donna Hurley, now known as 'Donna Reed.'" Its terms, from the document: the county delivers two checks "which in combination total the amount of $50,000.00" — $24,670.44 to Reed for back pay and pecuniary loss, and $25,329.56 to her counsel, Patrick F. O'Leary, for fees and expenses.
The agreement states, in its own words, that it "does not amount to an admission of liability by Employer… and shall in no way be construed as an admission of liability by Employer." The underlying claims were never adjudicated; the settlement is the whole of the ending, and it is printed here at exactly that weight.
One distinction, to keep the paper straight: an earlier, separate Hurley release — $5,000, approved March 21, 2023 — is a different document. The two are not the same settlement and must not be merged.
This file began as an accountability review published October 15, 2026. Every claim in it was re-checked for this dossier. What follows is everything from that review that this pass could not re-verify from the underlying paper — printed here at its true weight, with the pull that would settle it. Nothing in this section is stated as established anywhere in this file, and none of it belongs in any summary of the verified record.
The review reported these contributions to Baxmeyer's campaign, drawn from his campaign filings: DLZ Indiana, $6,500 (2025); Susan Al-Abbas, $9,000 personally (2025) — her title, Vice President & Indiana Market Leader at Lochmueller Group, is verified from the firm's own site; Jones Petrie Rafinski, $700 (2025) and $2,500 (March 2026); APID (American Structurepoint) PAC, $5,000 (March 2026), alongside contributors whose names match Lochmueller executives; and Gobel's, $1,500, reported as received June 16, 2025. Status of every figure: NOT RE-VERIFIED. His CFA-4 reports are local filings held by the St. Joseph County Election Board and are not published online; no contribution figure is stated as fact anywhere in this file. The contract approvals in §07 are verified independently from county packets. The settling pull: his CFA-4s at the county election board.
The review also reported contributions from three of his appointees — Andrew Jones, Phillip Garrett, and Peter Agostino. No filing of Baxmeyer's committee located in this pass shows any of them. A warning the paper itself requires: a CFA-4 that surfaces in searches and does list an Andrew Jones contribution ($2,000, June 17, 2025) is another candidate's filing (Amy Rolfes's) — the same document even records a $100 contribution from "Carl Baxmeyer for Commissioner." It is not his report and must not be cited as his. Also on the record: Peter J. Agostino (the litigator who served as interim county attorney) and Frank J. Agostino (a deputy county attorney on the January 2026 appointments list) are two different people; the record must not merge them.
The public-comment claim fails. The review stated that in February 2024 the board replaced spoken comment on agenda items with written forms, that Baxmeyer defended the change, and that the state Public Access Counselor found it legal. No reporting of any of that was located — and the county's own agendas cut against it: the March 5, 2024 agenda, and the board's agendas through the rest of 2024, all provide for in-person, at-the-podium comment on agenda items, with speakers called by the board attorney. The only related minute found runs the other way: on February 14, 2023, Baxmeyer himself said, before a vote, that he would "like to change the rules an[d] allow for public comments." The claim as written is contradicted by the paper and is excluded, not carried. And the three-settlement total fails: with only the Anderson amount verified, the review's combined $710,000 figure for jail settlements is not printed anywhere in this file.
Every load-bearing claim in this file traces to the records below. Grades are printed on the label line: VERIFIED (read directly in the primary document), REPORTED (a named outlet's reporting of the document or event), SINGLE-SOURCE (one source carries it), and NOT PULLED (the record this file names but has not yet obtained — printed so the gap is visible).
Official minutes of the county Agenda Center (Minutes _02142023-1614): Resolution R-2-C-2023, Fleming's postponement motion dying for lack of a second, Baxmeyer's second, the 2-1 adoption, Council member Diana Hess's objection, and Baxmeyer's press-release responsibility statement, verbatim. Also the separate entry in which Baxmeyer said he would "like to change the rules an[d] allow for public comments."
Named in: §04, §15, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The complaint (filed June 26, 2023; plaintiffs Nowak, McLellan, Burns, and McDonald) and the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse's case record (Case 44227), which records the August 28, 2023 dismissal on a settlement of up to $195,000.
Named in: §04, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The per-resident structure of the Portage Manor settlement ($25,000 to $60,000 by placement). Corroborates the Clearinghouse's "up to $195,000" total.
Named in: §04 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The investigation reporting "more than $335,000 was paid to Trinity Protection services LLC in 8 months" for security at the vacant Portage Manor. ABC57's own site could not be read directly in this pass; the figure was read in the story's reproduction on the reporter's Muck Rack page, and the grade reflects that.
Named in: §04 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The Portage Manor purchase agreement with Saint Thomas More Academy, Inc.: the $400,000 price, the $9,000,000 renovation obligation (§2), and the default and termination remedies (§18).
Named in: §04 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The 2-1 sale vote (Morton opposed) and Council President Bryan Tanner's objection to the agreement's missing deadline, milestones, performance security, and reverter, quoted verbatim.
Named in: §04 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The caucus appointment replacing Kostielney, the August 30, 2022 presidency vote (Baxmeyer voting for himself; Dieter's "garbage"), and the canceled November 1, 2022 meeting. Read in the Tribune's story as republished by ND Insider.
Named in: §02, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The county election office's final election-night report (run 9:07 p.m., November 3, 2026; all absentee ballots and all vote centers): Commissioner District 1 — Democratic nominee 16,735 (58.39%), Baxmeyer 11,924 (41.61%). Read as reproduced by The South Bend Paper and carried identically by WNDU. Certification was pending at the check date.
Named in: §03, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The unanimous August 13, 2024 approval of the Amazon Data Services agreement (Resolution R-8-C-2024) and Baxmeyer's public defense of it; the County Council's consideration of Bill 84-24 the same day.
Named in: §05 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The deal's terms: the 50% real-property abatement for 10 years per shell (Tribune), and the 85% enterprise-technology exemption for 35 years (Bill 84-24 summary; IndyStar corroboration).
Named in: §05 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The four Republican council members' renegotiation request to Amazon; Amazon's declining to discuss renegotiating publicly; and Councilman Randy Figg's assessment that the request "hasn't moved forward on Amazon's side."
Named in: §05 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The December 2, 2025 joint letter of "full support" for the New Carlisle rezoning (Baxmeyer a signer), his "a no-brainer" remark, and the County Council's 7-2 rejection on December 10, 2025.
Named in: §05, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Baxmeyer's opposition to a data-center moratorium and support for stronger ordinances, read via the program clip's published summary.
Named in: §05, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The agreement's §7.1 (the $53,023,257.70 Reimbursement Cap; the county's sole responsibility above it absent a signed amendment; the stop-work option) and Bill Schalliol's October 2, 2026 staff memo (combined MOU I + II total, $65,600,632.70).
Named in: §05 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The January 7, 2025 approval of the Gobel's custodial contract, staff's roughly $295,000 projected 2025 savings, and the pay-rate-match commitment; and the March 18, 2025 discussion (Director Bree Roberts's three-proposal comparison; four former county workers brought to full-time at $18.90 an hour). Read via meeting-record summaries of the county's proceedings; the underlying packet is the open pull named below, and the grade reflects that.
Named in: §06, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The contractor approvals: JPR as-needed engineering, not to exceed $100,000 (January 27, 2026); DLZ Indiana as-needed engineering, not to exceed $200,000.00 (February 10, 2026); Lochmueller Group selected for Pierce Road construction engineering, "most responsive and qualified," no amount in the record (March 3, 2026); Lochmueller as-needed professional services, not to exceed $300,000.00 with the staff letter of August 4, 2026 (August 11, 2026).
Named in: §07, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The board's published letter (signed Baxmeyer, Hazen, Morton) announcing it "will retain independent outside counsel to investigate allegations" concerning the solar-farm and trail controversies; corroborated by the July 14, 2026 meeting record and the county's August 21, 2026 "ongoing investigation" phrasing.
Named in: §08, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Schalliol's February 5, 2026 memo (the $300,000 contract; the "additional fee of $37,500.00"), the Third Amendment's text ($375,000) and Exhibit A (a second $37,500), and the March 10, 2026 minutes recording the on-record explanation, the corrected amendment's 3-0 approval, and the City of South Bend covering the design-services $37,500. The Tribune's March 13, 2026 "$70,000" figure conflicts with the minutes' $75,000 and was not used.
Named in: §08, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The McBride termination spine: investigation initiated February 21, 2024; termination effective February 23, 2024; unanimous ratification March 5, 2024, signed by Baxmeyer, Dieter, and Hazen; the investigation's later transfer to the Indiana State Police. Cross-checked against this library's launched McBride file (File No. 6).
Named in: §09, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The report closing the McBride criminal investigation without charges: its conclusion, its criticism of the keycard methodology, and its underlying figures (648 keycard hours against 3,162 computed required hours; $134,644.56 questioned for 2,514 hours). Read via contemporaneous reporting of the filed report; the report itself is an open pull.
Named in: §09 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Finding 2023-002 (questioned costs of $190,000; unallowable "satisfaction of settlements and judgments"; the county's Corrective Action Plan and the June 14, 2024 repayment) and Finding 2024-001 (material weakness; the supervisory-review cause; "Repeat Finding: Yes"; 2023-002 listed Resolved; 2023-001 partially resolved).
Named in: §10, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release: the $695,000 payment ($445,000 cash; $250,000 to New York Life for periodic payments for Cayden A. Anderson). The agreement's recitals give the events' year as 2022; the federal court's record (below) gives 2021 and controls.
Named in: §11, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Judge Leichty's opinion and order reciting the estate's allegations and the postmortem conclusion: arrest April 6, 2021; found "unresponsive, pale, pulseless, apneic" April 8, 2021; life support removed April 11, 2021; cause of death complications of drug withdrawal, including dehydration.
Named in: §11 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The agenda item "Approval of Claims & Settlement Release Agreement – Carlton Alphonzo Collins" and the meeting record of its unanimous approval on attorney Peter J. Agostino's presentation (a mistaken hold; two people sharing the same name). The settlement amount appears in no record read.
Named in: §11, §15, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The acceptance of County Attorney Michael Misch's resignation and the appointment of Pete Agostino as interim, with the record's note that the board gave no additional substantive public details.
Named in: §12, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The commissioners' retention of Taft Stettinius & Hollister to "monitor" the Indiana Republican Party's suit against the county Election Board — Baxmeyer and Fleming approving — and Baxmeyer's "our goal was to avoid a lawsuit" / "our hand was forced." No record read supports a second or a $450-per-hour cap.
Named in: §12 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The December 24, 2025 ratification memorandum: the $80,000 not-to-exceed snowplow route study with Wightman Associates, and its statement that the agreement "was previously reviewed and executed."
Named in: §13, §16 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Baxmeyer's Wightman career (senior planner; joined 2016; retiring after a 40-year career in the field) — and the source of this file's lead photograph.
Named in: §01, §13 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
The settlement agreement in Hurley v. St. Joseph County, 3:24-cv-907: $50,000 total ($24,670.44 to "Donna Reed"; $25,329.56 to counsel), the no-admission-of-liability clause, and the October 15, 2025 mediation. The separate March 21, 2023 Hurley release ($5,000) is a different document, verified from its minutes and packet.
Named in: §14 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Named so the gaps are visible: Baxmeyer's CFA-4 campaign reports (St. Joseph County Election Board — local filings, not published online); the January 14, 2025 and January 6, 2026 commissioners' minutes; the signed Collins agreement and the January 17, 2023 settlement packet; the Amazon agreement text and Bill 84-24 exhibits; the ABC57 "Contract Concerns" full text (February 14, 2023); the WVPE reports the October review cites (December 2025; September 2024); the special prosecutor's report itself; the outside counsel's engagement and report on Schalliol and Klein; and the board's October–November 2026 minutes, unposted as of November 9, 2026.
Named in: §06, §08, §09, §11, §13, §15 · Last checked November 9, 2026.
Register checked November 9, 2026. Where a source is graded below VERIFIED, the section that uses it says so in its own text.