
Julian Wachner spent a decade on some of the most visible podiums in American church music — a Grammy-nominated conductor at Trinity Wall Street in New York. In September 2024 he walked into a different room: a fourth-grade math classroom at an Indianapolis charter school, hired after the school’s background check came back clean.
Two court systems have now had him, and this file keeps them apart, because the record does. The state case is closed: charged in Marion County in 2025, he pleaded guilty to five felony counts of possessing child sex abuse material and one count of possessing cocaine, and on September 9, 2026 a judge sentenced him to six years of probation — not prison — with ten years on Indiana’s sex offender registry. The federal case is open: on October 21, 2026, a federal grand jury indicted him on receipt and possession charges. Those charges are allegations. Nothing in the federal case has been proven, and §07 prints it that way, every line.
This file is built from the paper: the court documents as reported from both cases, the sentencing documents and the hearing record, the school’s own statement, and the reporting that followed him from New York to Indianapolis. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §08 lists every pull that would raise a grade — including the two case numbers’ paper trails, stated exactly as far as the record in hand reaches and no further.
One rule governs every line: no student or child is named, described, or pointed to in this file, and no detail of any material appears beyond the charges’ own words. Nothing in either case alleges an offense against any student of his school, and this file does not imply one. The subjects of this file are the teacher, the sentence the state gave him, and the indictment that followed it.
Julian James Wachner built his career in sacred music. He took his doctorate at Boston University in 1996, and in 2011 he became Director of Music and the Arts at Trinity Wall Street in New York City — the podium over the Choir of Trinity Wall Street and the Trinity Baroque Orchestra, and the founder of its contemporary ensemble, NOVUS NY. Alongside it he directed The Washington Chorus (2008–2017) and, from 2020, held a professorship at the General Theological Seminary in Chelsea.
His 2012 recording of Handel’s Israel in Egypt, with the Trinity Choir and the Trinity Baroque Orchestra, was nominated for a Grammy Award for Best Choral Performance. He recorded five albums with Trinity’s ensembles, published more than sixty compositions, and stood as a guest conductor in front of ensembles including the Philadelphia Orchestra, San Francisco Opera, and Juilliard Opera. By every public measure the record of those years is the record of a man at the top of his profession.
That is the height this file starts from, because the paper does: the same biographical sources that carry the Grammy nomination and the Trinity appointment carry what ended them, and §02 takes it up in the order it happened.
What ended the New York career was an allegation, and this section prints it as one — with its denial and its outcomes attached, because the record holds all three and this file suppresses none of them.
On February 28, 2022, Mary Poole, a former employee of the Juilliard School, publicly alleged that Wachner had groped and kissed her during a 2014 music festival at which she had hired him for a directing job. The allegation was published in The New York Times on March 13, 2022. Wachner denied it. In a statement he posted to his website and later deleted, he described the encounter as consensual.
Trinity Wall Street placed him on leave on March 1, 2022, and fired him on March 14, 2022 — without having concluded its investigation of the 2014 allegation, on the stated ground of “recent information that Julian has otherwise conducted himself in a manner that is inconsistent with our expectations of anyone who occupies a leadership position.” The General Theological Seminary removed him the same day.
The matter’s endings are part of its record: no criminal charge was ever brought over the 2014 allegation, and when Wachner sued the Juilliard School for defamation in December 2022 — arguing the school had never investigated and had made false statements about him — the New York Supreme Court dismissed his case with prejudice in June 2023. An allegation, a denial, two lost posts, and a dismissed lawsuit: that is everything the paper holds on the New York matter, and this file makes no finding in it.
After New York, Wachner moved to Indianapolis. In September 2024 he began teaching fourth-grade math at Invent Learning Hub, a kindergarten-through-eighth-grade charter school on the city’s southeast side. He got the job the ordinary way: according to the Indianapolis Star, he passed a background check — and his New York history, which had played out in national newspapers, did not stop the hire.
He kept one foot in his old world while he taught. In 2025 he took a conducting appointment with the Foundation Concerto Vocale, and he was scheduled to conduct the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra and Chorus in December 2025. Both ended when the charges came: the foundation cut its ties, and his name came off the orchestra’s website. The classroom, though, is where the record puts him when it turned — a fourth-grade teacher, eleven months into the job, when the investigation that had begun that August reached him.
The state case began, on paper, with money. According to the court documents in that case, between August 2024 and February 2025 Wachner sent almost $900 in cryptocurrency to digital wallets associated with child sex abuse websites. The transactions sat in the record for months; reporting on the case says they did not lead to an investigation until August 2025.
The Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department’s charging documents, as reported, state that in an interview with detectives on August 20, 2025, Wachner admitted downloading and later deleting such material over the course of several years. That statement is printed here as the charging documents reported it — attributed, in their terms, and no further: this file carries none of the interview’s other reported content, and the admission’s weight is the weight the plea in §06 gave it.
On August 20, 2025, Wachner was booked into the Marion County Jail on preliminary charges of child exploitation and child pornography. The school acted the same day. In its statement to NPR, Invent Learning Hub said: “Effective immediately, Julian Wachner is no longer an employee of Invent Learning Hub” — adding that “at no time were our employees or board members aware that Mr. Wachner was under investigation,” and that its hiring process had included thorough background checks under its established policies.
This section and the next are the state case, and it is closed. Marion County prosecutors filed against Wachner in Marion Superior Court 31, Judge Jeffrey Marchal presiding: ten felony counts of possession of child sex abuse material and one count of possession of cocaine. The case is published in coverage of the court’s own settings as Cause No. 49D31-2508-F4-026083; the direct pull of the court’s case summary stands in §08 as this file’s first open verification, and the number is carried here at the grade of the record that prints it.
Wachner pleaded not guilty and was released on a $15,000 bond. Then the case waited: its jury-trial date was set and reset five times across eleven months, until it stood at July 20, 2026. It never reached a jury. What it reached, five days before that last setting, was a signature — and §06 is where the state case ends.
On July 15, 2026, Wachner signed a plea agreement with the State of Indiana. He pleaded guilty to five counts of possession of child sex abuse material and to the one count of possession of cocaine. The remaining five possession counts were dismissed — dismissed, and printed as dismissed wherever this file counts the charges. He waived his right to appeal the sentence. The agreement fixed no punishment; it was, in the words of the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office, “for a sentence up to 10 years in the Indiana Department of Correction.” The judge would decide, anywhere under that ceiling.
On September 9, 2026, Judge Marchal decided. The sentence: six years of probation, with alcohol and drug treatment; credit for five days in jail; and ten years on Indiana’s sex offender registry. His probation could end after four years if he is not accused of a violation. No prison.
How that number was reached is in the hearing record, and this file prints it as record, not commentary: the prosecution did not ask the court for any specific sentence, including prison — no particular term was ever requested by the State. The defense asked that the sentence be served through Marion County Community Corrections, and the court heard that the sex-and-violent-offender unit cannot monitor people in that program. Judge Marchal told Wachner from the bench: “I don’t have a lot of great options.” Afterward, the prosecutor’s office said its prosecutors had pushed for a sentence harsher than the one imposed. The Indianapolis Star reports that the sentence drew public outcry, and criticism of the prosecutor’s office, and this file carries that reaction in the Star’s terms and no further.
With that, the state case closed: a conviction on his own plea, a sentence of probation, a registry term of ten years. He walked out of Marion Superior Court a free man under supervision. Six weeks later, a second sovereign filed — and §07 is a different case, in a different court, in a different posture, and nothing in this section is evidence in it.
This section is the federal case, and it is open. Everything in it is an allegation. An indictment is a grand jury’s charge, not a finding; Julian Wachner is presumed innocent of every count below; nothing in this section has been proven, admitted, or adjudicated, and no outcome exists. This file prints the indictment as what it is and stops there.
On October 21, 2026, a federal grand jury in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana indicted Wachner on four counts of receipt of child pornography and one count of possession of any material containing child pornography, according to the court records reported by the Indianapolis Star, WTHR, and WXIN. Those are the indictment’s allegations, stated in its terms.
On the morning of October 22, 2026, Wachner was taken into custody, according to a source who spoke to WTHR; his initial appearance was scheduled for 3 p.m. that day, and the Star reported him in the custody of the U.S. Marshals Service, with no attorney yet listed online for the case. The court documents, the Star reports, put the maximum penalty on the charges at up to 20 years in prison — a ceiling stated in the paper, not a prediction, and not a sentence anyone has imposed.
One thing this file does not print is the federal case number, and the reason is the file’s standing rule: a number is printed from a record, never guessed. No coverage of the indictment carries it, and the federal docket archive’s search refused anonymous access when this file was built. The pull stands open in §08. When the docket is in hand, this section will carry the number and the case’s true posture in the docket’s own words — and until then, the indictment stands here exactly as the record leaves it: filed, pending, and unproven.
The license. One screening in this record is documented: the charter school’s own background check, which Wachner passed in 2024. What the State of Indiana’s educator-licensing record holds on him — whether a license or permit stood in his name, and whether any action followed a felony conviction for possessing child sex abuse material — appears in no coverage this file could reach. This file claims nothing about his license, in either direction, and leaves the question standing here in the open until the record answers it.
The open pulls. Every gap in this file is registered, none is papered over:
• JW-01 — The state case summary. A direct pull of the court’s chronological case summary in State v. Wachner, 49D31-2508-F4-026083 (Indiana MyCase, live-browser route): confirms the cause number against the court’s own sheet, the per-count levels and dispositions, the plea entry, and the sentencing order’s exact terms.
• JW-02 — The federal docket. The case number and current posture of United States v. Wachner (S.D. Ind.): the docket archive’s search refused anonymous access on November 11, 2026, and no coverage prints the number. PACER, when the account’s mailed authentication token arrives, or a credentialed archive pull closes it. The number is not guessed in the meantime.
• JW-03 — The registry entry. Wachner’s entry on Indiana’s sex and violent offender registry (Marion County), as posted: the sentencing order’s ten-year term is verified from the sentencing documents; the entry itself stands behind the registry’s interactive search.
• JW-04 — The educator-license record. The Indiana Department of Education’s licensing record for Wachner: what credential, if any, he held, and what action, if any, followed the conviction.
• JW-05 — The photograph. LANDED at launch: his August 2025 Marion County booking photograph leads this file — published by WRTV (captioned a provided Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department photo) and by FOX59 (captioned a Marion County Jail mugshot), its face checked against the verified 2016 BRIC festival photograph before the swap, and cropped from the broadcast graphic to the booking photograph alone. The 2016 photograph it replaced is preserved in the file’s build record.
The state file is closed and the federal file is open, and this page will be updated at this same address as the paper moves — the docket first, the license record with it.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 11, 2026.
The state case from the court documents: the ten possession counts and the cocaine count; the cryptocurrency transactions of August 2024–February 2025, almost $900 to wallets associated with child sex abuse websites; the background check he passed and the September 2024 start at Invent Learning Hub; the plea agreement’s open ceiling, in the prosecutor’s office’s words, of up to 10 years; the September 9, 2026 sentence — six years of probation, treatment, five days’ credit, ten years on the registry, early termination possible after four years; the prosecution’s request for no specific sentence; the Community Corrections exchange; Judge Marchal’s words from the bench; the prosecutor’s office’s later statement; and the public outcry the sentence drew, including criticism of that office. Named in: Intro, §03, §04, §05, §06.
The federal indictment of October 21, 2026 — four counts of receipt of child pornography and one count of possession of material containing child pornography, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana — reported from the court records; the custody of the U.S. Marshals Service; the initial appearance of October 22, 2026; the absence of a listed attorney at publication; and the maximum penalty the court documents state, up to 20 years. WTHR’s account carries the October 22 custody, from a source. Named in: Intro, §07. The indictment’s allegations are carried as allegations throughout this file.
The plea of July 15, 2026 — five counts of possession of child sex abuse material and the cocaine count, the remaining counts dismissed, the appeal waived — and the sentencing order’s terms: nearly six years of probation as NPR hedges it (the sentencing documents, via the Star, state six years), registration, and five days’ credit. Carries the IMPD charging documents’ report of the August 20, 2025 interview, via WRTV, and the school’s statement, given to NPR. Named in: §04, §06.
The investigation’s August 2025 start; the not-guilty plea and the $15,000 bond; the Trinity Wall Street tenure and the March 2022 termination; and the New York matter’s endings — no criminal charges brought in it, and the defamation suit’s dismissal by the New York Supreme Court in June 2023. Named in: §01, §02, §04, §05.
The August 20, 2025 booking into the Marion County Jail on the preliminary charges, from the booking record as reported at the time; the plea and the six-year probation sentence as the classical-music press carried them; and the prosecutor’s office’s statement after sentencing. Named in: §04, §06.
The career spine — Boston University doctorate, Trinity Wall Street 2011–2022, The Washington Chorus, the General Theological Seminary professorship, the Grammy-nominated Israel in Egypt — and the case chronology it assembles from its cited coverage: the February–March 2022 allegation and firing, the state case number as published in coverage of the court’s trial settings (49D31-2508-F4-026083), the trial’s five settings, the July 15, 2026 plea agreement, the school’s statement as given to NPR, and the December 2025 Indianapolis Symphony engagement that ended with the charges. A tertiary source, used for the spine and flagged wherever it stands alone; the direct case-summary pull that would raise its case-number grade is registered in §08. Named in: §01, §02, §03, §05.
The lead photograph is Wachner’s August 2025 Marion County booking photograph, published by WRTV on October 22, 2026 under the caption “Julian Wachner. (Provided photo/Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department)” and carried by FOX59 as “Julian Wachner mugshot (Marion County Jail)” — two station captions for one photograph. Before the swap (JW-05), the face was checked against the verified 2016 BRIC festival photograph of him conducting (the file’s original lead image, preserved in the build record). It is cropped from the WRTV broadcast graphic to the booking photograph alone; the photograph itself is unaltered.