The identity, on one piece of federal court paper. Leroy Witucki was an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka, Indiana. That is proven by a single Tier A document — the published order in Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind. 1986) — which states, in the court’s own summary of the complaint, that the plaintiff alleges “each defendant is an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka.” That paper is sufficient for this series’ identity standard on name, agency and officer status. It proves nothing else about the man, and this file does not pretend otherwise: his identity is settled exactly as far as that order settles it, and not one fact further.
| Item | What the paper shows | The paper |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Leroy Witucki — no middle name or initial is proven in any source found, and none is printed in this file | Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind. 1986), caption |
| Employer & role | Officer, Police Department of the City of Mishawaka, Indiana — no rank beyond “officer” is proven | Same order, court’s summary of the complaint |
| Proven as of | On or about March 19, 1983 (the alleged incident date); the suit was filed in 1985 | Same order; docket number S 85-182 |
| Date of birth, badge number, hire date, separation date, rank history, current status | NOT PROVEN — no source found. Whether he is living, retired or deceased appears in no source the research behind this file could reach, and this file states no present-day fact about him | — |
Source: Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind., South Bend Division, Jan. 13, 1986), No. S 85-182, Sharp, Chief Judge — read directly for this file, November 9, 2026 (Leagle, decision 19861182624fsupp55811056).
One collision, excluded in writing — at full size, because it is the natural misreading of this file. Mishawaka’s longtime Chief of Police was Ken Witkowski Jr., who served as Chief from 2004 to 2024. He is not this man. The first names differ (Ken, not Leroy); the surnames differ in spelling (Witkowski, not Witucki); and the chronology excludes him on its own — the City of Mishawaka states that Witkowski retired on August 20, 2024 after a 36-year career at the department, which places the start of his service around 1988, five years after the March 1983 incident alleged in Craig. Nothing in Witkowski’s long, documented tenure as Chief belongs in this file, nothing in Craig belongs in any account of him, and no photograph of Ken Witkowski is, or may ever be presented as, a photograph of Leroy Witucki.
The era fence. Everything proven about Witucki’s service sits in 1983–1986 paper. No source found shows when his service began, when it ended, or what became of him afterward. This file therefore carries no service timeline, no retirement claim, and no later-life claim of any kind — the gaps are carried openly in §05 rather than filled in.
The case, as the federal court’s own paper frames it. In 1985, Michael D. Craig filed suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 — the federal civil-rights statute. The published order in the case is the whole of the public paper in this file, and this section prints what it contains: a caption, an allegation, and counsel of record. Nothing more exists in any indexed source, and nothing more is claimed.
• Case: Michael D. Craig, Plaintiff, v. Leroy Witucki, Michael Samp, John Doe I and John Doe II, Defendants — 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind., South Bend Division), order of January 13, 1986, Sharp, Chief Judge.
• For the plaintiff: Douglas D. Seely, Jr., of Mishawaka.
• For the defense: John P. Gourley, Wilfred J. Mayette and James J. Olson, of Mishawaka.
• The court’s summary of the complaint: the plaintiff alleges that “each defendant is an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka.”
The allegation, printed as an allegation. Craig alleged that Witucki, co-defendant Michael Samp and two John Doe officers, acting in their official capacity, assaulted him on or about March 19, 1983, in violation of his Fourteenth Amendment rights to due process and equal protection. That is the complaint’s claim, stated in the published order’s summary of it. A complaint is a claim, not a finding: no court is recorded anywhere in the indexed sources as having weighed this allegation, believed it, or rejected it. Everywhere in this file, the alleged assault prints welded to the filing that contains it — alleged, by Craig, in a 1985 federal complaint — and nowhere as an established fact.
The co-defendant fence. Michael Samp is named in this file for one reason only: he stands in the caption of Craig, beside Witucki, as a fellow defendant and a fellow Mishawaka officer of the era. Nothing about Samp — his later career, his other cases, his record — is Witucki’s paper, none of it is imported into this file, and the allegation in Craig is Craig’s claim about a group of officers, printed at exactly that size.
Source: Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind. 1986) — caption block and the court’s summary of the complaint. Read for this file, November 9, 2026.
What the one published ruling in this case actually decided. The order at 624 F. Supp. 558–560 is short, and it is procedural. The question before Chief Judge Sharp was not whether an assault happened — it was whether Craig’s federal claim could proceed at all, given Indiana’s Tort Claims Act and its notice requirement. As later federal courts describe the holding when they cite it, Craig held two things:
| Point | What Craig held, as later courts state it |
|---|---|
| A federal remedy, independently enforceable | § 1983 “provides a federal remedy ‘independently enforceable whether or not it duplicates a parallel state remedy’” (624 F. Supp. at 559, quoting Wilson v. Garcia, 471 U.S. 261) |
| The notice defense fails | Failure to give timely notice under the Indiana Tort Claims Act does not bar a federal § 1983 claim (624 F. Supp. at 560) |
Sources: Estate of Conner v. Ambrose, 990 F. Supp. 606, 611–612 (N.D. Ind. 1997), citing Craig at 559; Musgrove v. Broglin, 651 F. Supp. 769, 776 (N.D. Ind. 1986) (“this court has had occasion to specifically rule on that question… See Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558”); the Vukadinovich litigation’s citation of Craig at 560 on the Tort Claims notice point. Each read for this file, November 9, 2026.
The plain meaning. The judge let the § 1983 claim proceed past a notice defense. That is all the order does, and this file states its limits at full size: it is not a ruling that an assault occurred, not a finding of liability against Witucki or any defendant, and not discipline of any kind. A reader who stopped at the citation — a case that bears this officer’s name in the federal reporter — could easily overread it. The order opened a door. What, if anything, walked through it is §04, and §04 is the shortest honest section in this file.
The afterlife of the order. The case did leave one durable mark: its procedural holding entered the working law of the district. Federal courts were still citing Craig v. Witucki for the notice point in 1986 and again in 1997 — the precedent outlived every public trace of the case that produced it. The name in the citation is the officer’s. The holding is about a filing deadline. Both of those things are true at once, and this file prints them at exactly that size.
What happened after January 13, 1986 is not in any indexed source. The research behind this file ran three independent passes — exact-name and news searches; court-record and reporter searches; official-list and collision searches — across the federal reporter, Leagle, Justia, CaseMine/vLex and the general web. The final outcome of Craig v. Witucki appears in none of them. There is no trial outcome, no verdict, no settlement, no dismissal and no damages figure in the public indexed record. The ruling was never found.
Why the record stops there. The case is a 1985 South Bend Division docket, No. S 85-182 — it predates electronic PACER coverage. The published order is the part of the case the Federal Supplement carried; the disposition, if any exists beyond that order, sits in the archival federal docket, which has not been pulled. §06 names that pull as the first outstanding lane, in the order it should be worked: the complete docket, the complaint, the answer, and the final disposition, whatever it turns out to be.
How this file holds the gap. Nothing in this file fills the silence in either direction. It does not say Witucki won, lost, settled, or was cleared — no source says any of those things. It does not say the allegation was proven — no source says that either. What the public record holds is a filed federal lawsuit alleging an on-duty assault by a named Mishawaka officer, a 1986 ruling that the claim could proceed, and then — across forty years of indexed paper — nothing: no accountability entered against the officer in any source searched, and no exoneration entered for him. Under the law of this series, that absence is not a reason to suppress the file. It is part of the file, printed here at full size.
The rest of the trail is the same silence. No second case naming Leroy Witucki — as defendant, plaintiff, officer-witness with findings, or criminal defendant — was found in any of the passes. No news coverage of Witucki, or of the Craig incident or lawsuit, was found in the indexed South Bend Tribune, WNDU or general news searches. One lawsuit, one allegation, one procedural order, and no ending: that is the whole documented trail, and §§01–03 are all of it.
A file in this series prints what the paper shows and names what it does not. For this subject, the open items are these — each one stated at its true size, with the lane that can close it.
This file was built from public sources — one published federal court order, the later federal courts that cited it, and one state list read in full. The trail below separates the paper in hand from the paper still outstanding, so a reader can weigh every section by what stands behind it.
| Record | Custodian / source | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 — the caption, the court’s summary of the complaint (the Mishawaka officer allegation; the alleged March 19, 1983 assault), counsel of record, and the January 13, 1986 procedural holding; the proving document of this file | U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division, No. S 85-182 — as published in the Federal Supplement (read via Leagle) | IN HAND — read for this file, November 9, 2026 |
| The citing courts — Estate of Conner v. Ambrose, 990 F. Supp. 606, 611–612 (N.D. Ind. 1997), and Musgrove v. Broglin, 651 F. Supp. 769, 776 (N.D. Ind. 1986), stating Craig’s holding; the Vukadinovich litigation’s citation of Craig at 560 | Federal reporter (read via Justia / CaseMine) | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| ILEA Certificate Decertification List — read in full (October 19, 2026 version, 351 extracted lines); no Witucki | Indiana Law Enforcement Academy / LETB, secure.in.gov | READ IN FULL — negative with the era caveat of §05 |
| City of Mishawaka releases on Chief Ken Witkowski — the retirement announcement (August 20, 2024) and leadership-transition release (August 27, 2024) carrying the 36-year-career line behind the §01 exclusion | City of Mishawaka, mishawaka.in.gov | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| Full Craig docket and disposition — complete docket, complaint, answer, and final disposition (judgment, verdict, settlement or dismissal, with any findings) | N.D. Indiana clerk / PACER-archival, No. S 85-182 | OUTSTANDING — the decisive pull; first lane |
| Mishawaka personnel paper — hire date, rank history, separation date and reason; any discipline; Board of Public Works & Safety minutes 1982–1986 (appointment, promotions, any Board discipline action) | City of Mishawaka / Mishawaka Police Department (APRA) | OUTSTANDING |
| Live Indiana MyCase party search — “Witucki, Leroy,” all St. Joseph County courts, party and witness | Indiana MyCase portal (interactive; cannot be run by text fetch) | OUTSTANDING |
| Contemporaneous Tribune archive — March–June 1983 (incident), January 1986 (order), and any Craig outcome coverage 1986–1988 | South Bend Tribune archive (GenealogyBank / Mishawaka-Penn-Harris microfilm) | OUTSTANDING |
| Gateway earliest-years test — City of Mishawaka 100R reports for the earliest years Gateway holds, searched for Witucki | Indiana Gateway | OUTSTANDING |
When the outstanding paper is pulled, this file updates in place, at this same address — that is how every update in this series lands.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
THE CHECKS RUN FOR THIS FILE — NO DOCUMENTED ENTRY FOUND. No driving infraction, traffic arrest or license action naming Leroy Witucki was found in the sources searched for this file — the court-record, reporter and news sweeps behind §§01–05, and the Indiana Law Enforcement Training Board Certificate Decertification List, read in full. The limits stand at full size: his only proven service is in 1983, paper of that era is archival rather than online, and an Indiana MyCase party search has not been run live — a site search is not a MyCase clearance, in either direction. This section does not claim a certified clean driving record — it reports what the searches found, and where they cannot reach.
If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.
This file began with a reader’s tip — a comment left on this series’ open-call post of November 3, 2026: “look into the file of Officer Leroy Witucki, Mishawaka IN.” A tip is not paper, and this series does not build on one. So the first work was the paper — and for this subject, the paper is a single federal case, found whole and read whole. Everything this file can honestly say stands on it, and this file says nothing that does not.
The shape of the record is this. In 1985, Michael D. Craig sued Leroy Witucki and fellow officers in federal court under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that they assaulted him, on duty, on or about March 19, 1983. On January 13, 1986, the court issued a short order in the case — Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind. 1986) — holding that the suit could proceed despite a state notice defense. The order decided a question of procedure. It did not decide whether any assault happened, and it was not a finding against the officer.
And then the record stops. No verdict, settlement, dismissal or judgment in Craig v. Witucki appears in any indexed source — not in the federal reporter, not in the case databases, not anywhere the research behind this file could reach. The ruling was never found. The 1985 docket predates electronic court records, and whatever ending the case had sits in archival paper that has not been pulled. This file prints the stop-point plainly, at full size, because under the law of this series the missing outcome is part of the record: a man alleged an on-duty assault in federal court, a judge opened the door to his claim, and the public record contains no ending at all — no accountability found, and no exoneration found either. This file does not say the officer did it. It does not say he was cleared. It says what the record holds, and where the record stops (§04).
• Identity: Leroy Witucki — an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka, Indiana. Proven by one Tier A document, Craig v. Witucki itself: the published order states, in the court’s summary of the complaint, that each defendant “is an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka.” No middle name or initial is proven, and none is printed (§01).
• What is not proven about him: no rank beyond “officer,” no badge number, no hire date, no separation date, no rank history — and whether he is living, retired or deceased appears in no source found. This file makes no present-day claim about him (§01, §05).
• The suit: Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558 (N.D. Ind., South Bend Division), No. S 85-182, Chief Judge Sharp — filed 1985, order issued January 13, 1986 (§02).
• The allegation: Craig alleged that Witucki, co-defendant Michael Samp and two John Doe officers, acting in their official capacity, assaulted him on or about March 19, 1983, violating his Fourteenth Amendment due-process and equal-protection rights. An allegation in a filed complaint — printed as one everywhere in this file, never as a finding (§02).
• The order: procedural only — a § 1983 claim is independently enforceable in federal court, and failure to give timely Indiana Tort Claims Act notice does not bar it. The judge let the claim proceed past a notice defense; he did not rule that an assault occurred (§03).
• The disposition: none in any indexed source. No trial outcome, verdict, settlement, dismissal or damages figure was found in the federal reporter, Leagle, Justia, CaseMine/vLex or general-web searches. The case’s ending, if one exists beyond the published order, sits in the archival federal docket (§04).
• Discipline / decertification: no discipline record was found. Witucki is not on the Indiana Law Enforcement Training Board’s Certificate Decertification List (current version read in full) — a negative whose era limits are printed at full size in §05, because the modern list reaches back only to about 2007–2009.
• Photo: none. No photo of Leroy Witucki was found in any source; this file carries the NO VERIFIED PHOTO form.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Official records and official publications are linked where they live; items named but not linked are identified by their custodian and their status, so a reader can pull the same paper. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 9, 2026.
The published order of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division, No. S 85-182, Sharp, Chief Judge, January 13, 1986 — Michael D. Craig v. Leroy Witucki, Michael Samp, John Doe I and John Doe II. Plaintiff’s counsel: Douglas D. Seely, Jr., Mishawaka; defense counsel: John P. Gourley, Wilfred J. Mayette, James J. Olson, Mishawaka. The order’s summary of the complaint states the allegation that each defendant “is an officer on the Police Department of the City of Mishawaka” and that the defendants, acting in their official capacity, assaulted Craig on or about March 19, 1983 — an allegation, printed as one throughout this file. The order itself (at 558–560) is procedural. Read directly for this file. Leagle — Craig v. Witucki · Last checked November 9, 2026
Estate of Conner v. Ambrose, 990 F. Supp. 606, 611–612 (N.D. Ind. 1997) (Justia full text) — citing Craig at 559 for the proposition that § 1983 provides a federal remedy “independently enforceable whether or not it duplicates a parallel state remedy” (quoting Wilson v. Garcia, 471 U.S. 261); Musgrove v. Broglin, 651 F. Supp. 769, 776 (N.D. Ind. 1986) — “this court has had occasion to specifically rule on that question… See Craig v. Witucki, 624 F. Supp. 558”; and the Vukadinovich litigation (CaseMine summary) citing Craig at 560 for the Tort Claims notice point (§03). · Last checked November 9, 2026
The LETB Certificate Decertification List, current version dated October 19, 2026 (secure.in.gov/ilea), was read in full for this file — all 351 extracted lines. The complete W–Y tail reads: Weaver, Webster, Whitright, Wike, Williams, Wilson (Todd W.), Wilson (Ty’Ray A.), Winkle, Worley, Wuestefeld, Yagelski. No Witucki; no Witkowski. The caveat of §05 travels with this negative: the modern decertification regime (IC 5-2-1-12.5) and this list reach back only to about 2007–2009 entries. · Last checked November 9, 2026
City of Mishawaka releases, mishawaka.in.gov — “Mayor Wood Announces the Retirement and Reassignment of MPD Chief Ken Witkowski” (August 20, 2024) and the leadership-transition release (August 27, 2024) — carrying the statement that Witkowski retired after a 36-year career at the department. Registered here for one purpose: so a reader can check the §01 exclusion — Ken Witkowski Jr. is a different man from Leroy Witucki (different first name, different surname spelling, and a career beginning around 1988, five years after the incident alleged in Craig). No fact from Witkowski’s tenure is attributed to Witucki anywhere in this file. · Last checked November 9, 2026