
Nicholas Cauley’s is the smallest record in this wave of Indianapolis files — and the plainest. No camera network, no thousands of searches. One registration lookup, on his own department laptop, for one address: his ex-wife’s new home, which the court documents say she believed he did not have.
The paper runs like this. The divorce was final in December 2024. She blocked his number and his email. He reached her anyway — through his department-issued email, through a dating app, and on March 24, 2025, in person, driving his police car to her workplace when he was not on a call. The next day he ran her plate on his IMPD laptop and had her new address. She complained to his own department on June 24, 2025. He was arrested on July 18, 2025, and charged with three counts. On July 20, 2026, he pleaded guilty to one count of misdemeanor official misconduct; the felony and the harassment count were dismissed; the court put him on 356 days of probation. Five weeks before the plea, the State of Indiana’s own certification list had already recorded the end of his police powers — surrendered, it says, voluntarily.
This file is built from the paper: the Indianapolis Star’s reporting from the court documents, the Indiana Law Enforcement Academy’s certificate decertification list — the state’s own record, read firsthand — and the court’s own case summary, pulled November 11, 2026: State v. Nicholas Cauley, cause 49D36-2507-F6-021925, Marion Superior Court 36. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §09 keeps the register of the pulls that remain open.
One rule governs every line: the woman at the center of this case is a private person. She is his ex-wife — that role, and no name, no address, and no detail that could point to her, appears in this file. The subject of this file is the officer, and the use he made of the tools of the office.
What the verified record establishes is spare, and this section prints it no larger than it is. Nicholas A. Cauley — the full name is the state certification list’s — was an officer of the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department. He was 39 years old when he stood in court in July 2026 (the Star). He was a serving officer when the conduct in this file took place, a serving officer when his ex-wife complained to the department about him, and a serving officer when he was arrested on July 18, 2025.
No service length and no district assignment are printed here, because none was verified for this file. Figures for both circulate in summaries of his case; they are not in the court reporting this file stands on, and this file does not repeat what it cannot stand behind. His personnel file — the department’s own paper on the career — is listed in §09 among the records that would complete this section.
What the record does establish is the shape of the ending, and it comes in three separate pieces that this file never merges. The criminal case closed with his plea (§05). The certification ended by his own hand, on the state’s list, five weeks before that plea (§06). And the job itself was still formally undecided when the plea coverage ran — suspended without pay, awaiting the Merit Board (§07). A badge, a certificate, and a job are three different papers, and his file keeps them separate.
The court documents, as the Star reports them, carry her account. When the couple agreed to split in August 2024, she said, his behavior changed: he would prevent her from accessing her own property unless she agreed to speak with him, and over time, in her words, it became “crueler and stranger.” She did all that she could to cut off contact. The divorce was finalized in December 2024.
She blocked his personal email address and his phone number. The contact continued anyway — through other platforms, and through the channel that turns a private refusal into a public record: his department-issued email account. And according to police and court documents, he messaged her through the dating app Hinge as well.
One of his messages survives in the court documents as a screenshot, sent from his personal account. It is printed here exactly as the paper carries it, because it is his own words and the case is about what he did with the reaching: “…I am fully confident you will die alone because no one would want to deal with you.”
Her account is printed as her account — the framing the court documents give it. What followed it, in §03, is not account but record: the department’s own internal paper on where its car went, and its own laptop’s search.
On March 24, 2025, Cauley drove his police car to his ex-wife’s workplace. He was not responding to any call at the location — the department’s internal records showed that, investigators found — and he left only when dispatchers assigned him to respond to a nearby vandalism report. Investigators believe he left a letter on her windshield that morning; that detail is printed at the grade the paper gives it, an investigators’ belief, not a finding.
The next day, March 25, 2025, he looked up her car registration information on his IMPD-issued laptop. The results of the search showed her new address — in the court documents’ words, an address “which she believed he did not previously have.” That is the act at the center of this file: a police database, built for police work, spent on a blocked man’s need to know where his ex-wife lived.
It did not end with the address. In the months that followed, detectives wrote, he continued to contact her and her coworkers, “[threatening] to show up uninvited to her work event(s).” The uniform, the car, the email, the laptop: each one a tool of the office, each one turned to the same private purpose. The charges that followed are §04; what he admitted is §05.
On June 24, 2025 — about seven months after the divorce was finalized — his ex-wife complained to his employer. Her email to the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department is in the court documents, and it is printed here in her own words: “I would simply like his attempts to contact me to stop” — and: “If he had not been an officer I would have moved forward in some sort of legal way much sooner.” The second sentence is the whole case in one line: the badge that was supposed to protect her was, on her account, the reason she waited.
The department investigated its own officer, and on July 18, 2025, Cauley was arrested. The Marion County Prosecutor’s Office charged him with three counts: one count of misdemeanor harassment, one count of felony official misconduct, and one count of misdemeanor official misconduct. The case is State v. Nicholas Cauley, cause 49D36-2507-F6-021925, Marion Superior Court 36, filed July 18, 2025.
A charge sheet is an accusation, and this file keeps it labeled that way. Which of those counts he stands convicted of — and which the State gave up — is §05, and the two are never merged here.
One year and two days after the arrest, on July 20, 2026, Nicholas Cauley pleaded guilty by agreement to Count 1, misdemeanor official misconduct — the lesser of the two misconduct counts on the sheet. No trial, no jury: his own admission, in open court. On the docket, the felony official-misconduct count (Count 2) and the harassment count (Count 3) stand Dismissed. Those counts are closed as dismissed — this file does not carry them as if they stand, and the conviction is exactly one count wide.
The court’s Sentencing Order of July 20, 2026 fixes the sentence exactly, and this file prints it exactly: on Count 1, a county jail term of 360 days, with 356 days suspended and 2 days of jail credit — and, in the order’s own words on conditions, “Probation, 356 days probation.” His probation term is 356 days.
The plea agreement reached past the courtroom. As the Star’s report of the plea begins: he relinquished his police powers under the terms of the recently-approved plea agreement. The state’s own list of that surrender — its date, and the word it uses for how it happened — is §06.
For the record: his defense attorney did not immediately return the Star’s request for comment on the plea.
One piece of paper predates the sentencing. An Indiana police officer’s authority runs on a state certification, and the Indiana Law Enforcement Academy keeps the public list of the officers whose certification has ended — the Certificate Decertification List.
His line on that list reads, in full: “Nicholas A. Cauley — 06/15/2026 — Voluntary.”
June 15, 2026 — five weeks before he stood in court and pleaded guilty, the certification behind the career was already surrendered. By Cauley himself, the list records: not stripped by the board, not revoked after a hearing — given back. The two dates stand in this file exactly as their records state them, in the order the records give: the surrender on the state’s list in June, the plea in court in July, the plea agreement that the reporting says joined them. It is the last official act in this file, and it comes from the state’s own record, which is listed in the sources below.
The criminal case is closed. The employment case, on the last paper this file could find, is not.
After the arrest, the department put Cauley on administrative leave and collected his police gear. A year later, at the plea’s publication on July 20, 2026, he remained on unpaid suspension pending termination — an officer convicted of nothing yet at the time the suspension began, and by then an officer who had surrendered the certification the job runs on.
The department’s public information office put the last known state of it in writing: “His status with the IMPD has been referred to the IMPD Merit Board for final decision.” No Merit Board decision was located for this file — not in the plea coverage, and not in any later reporting the searches behind this file could reach. So this section prints the referral as the standing state of the record and registers the decision itself in §09. The word for what the Board decides is the Board’s to write; until it does, this file does not write his ending for him — not a termination, and not a resignation.
Every officer file in this library carries the same check: the subject’s record on the road — impaired-driving arrests, license actions, any driving history the paper carries.
For Nicholas Cauley, the check came back empty. Searches run for this file on November 11–12, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news record, against the Indianapolis Star’s roster of charged officers, and against the state’s own certification records — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in his name. The returns were other officers’ driving cases, and his own.
One documented misuse of a police vehicle does stand in his record — the March 24, 2025 drive to his ex-wife’s workplace, in his police car, when he was not on a call. It is told in §03, where it belongs, as conduct in the criminal case; this section does not dress it up as a road infraction.
The empty result is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere. If the court’s case summary (§09) or the personnel file carries one, this section will be the first thing updated.
This file stands on reporting from the court documents and on the state’s own certification list. What follows is the register of the originals — each one a public record, each one named so this file’s grades can be raised in the open:
1. The Marion County case summary (CCS) and cause number (NC-01) — CLOSED November 11, 2026. The docket was pulled: State v. Nicholas Cauley, cause 49D36-2507-F6-021925, Marion Superior Court 36, filed July 18, 2025, decided July 20, 2026 — Count 1, misdemeanor official misconduct, plea by agreement; Count 2, felony official misconduct, Dismissed; Count 3, harassment, Dismissed. At build, the courts’ online portal ran its search inside a browser application this build’s route could not execute, and no cause number appeared in any coverage retrieved — so none was printed and none was guessed. The live pull closed the gap, and the cause number now prints.
2. The plea agreement and the sentencing order (NC-02) — CLOSED November 11, 2026. The Sentencing Order of July 20, 2026 is in hand through the docket: on Count 1, a county jail term of 360 days, 356 days suspended, 2 days of jail credit, and conditions stating “Probation, 356 days probation.” The exact probation term — carried at build as the reporting’s approximation — is now exact everywhere in this file: 356 days.
3. The Civilian Police Merit Board’s final decision (NC-03) on his separation from the department — the decision the department’s own statement left pending in July 2026.
4. The probation record (NC-04). The term imposed in July 2026 is 356 days, running to about July 2027; its completion, or any violation, closes the criminal file’s last open line.
5. His IMPD personnel file (NC-05). Service length, assignments and any discipline, under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act — the paper that would complete §01.
One conflict is left standing on the record rather than smoothed: the Star’s own roster of charged officers still describes this case, in its current text, as “pending.” The plea report of July 20, 2026 — contemporaneous and drawn from the court documents — governs this file; the roster is a living document whose entries update unevenly, and the discrepancy is named here so it can be checked, not hidden.
When a pull lands, this file is updated at this same address, in place, with the date of the update shown — the way every file in this library is kept.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
The state’s own record. Indiana Law Enforcement Academy, Certificate Decertification List (the Law Enforcement Training Board’s public list, edition dated October 19, 2026): the entry “Nicholas A. Cauley — 06/15/2026 — Voluntary.” Establishes §06 in full, and his full name in §01. in.gov/ilea
The court’s own record. Indiana MyCase (Marion Superior Court 36), public case summary and Sentencing Order pulled November 11, 2026 — State v. Nicholas Cauley, cause 49D36-2507-F6-021925, filed July 18, 2025, decided July 20, 2026: Count 1 official misconduct (Class A misdemeanor), plea by agreement; Count 2 official misconduct (Level 6 felony), Dismissed; Count 3 harassment (Class B misdemeanor), Dismissed; Sentencing Order July 20, 2026 on Count 1 — county jail term 360 days, 356 days suspended, 2 days jail credit, conditions stating “Probation, 356 days probation.” Establishes the cause number, the per-count dispositions, and the exact probation term at §04, §05 and §09 (pulls NC-01 and NC-02, closed).
The court reporting. The Indianapolis Star — Ryan Murphy — IMPD officer gets probation, loses police powers over official misconduct (July 20, 2026): the plea and the probation sentence; the three counts as filed and the two dismissed under the plea; the arrest; and the conduct record — the workplace visit, the laptop search and the address, the department email and the dating app, the complaint of June 24, 2025 — all drawn from the court documents and the police investigation, including the quoted words of both parties as the documents carry them. indystar.com
The department’s statement. IMPD’s public information office, in writing, as carried in the Star’s plea report: administrative leave and gear collected after the arrest; unpaid suspension pending termination; the Merit Board referral quoted in §07.
The roster, with its limit named. The Indianapolis Star — These IMPD officers have been charged with crimes since 2024 (roster, crawled October 20, 2026): corroborates the arrest and the charges’ substance — and still describes the case as “pending” in its current text, a stale line this file names in §09 rather than repeats.
The photograph. His booking photograph, as aired in WISH-TV 8’s coverage of his case (broadcast frame carried via indynewsdaily.com), cropped by this file to the booking photograph alone — gray backdrop, no station graphics, the photograph untouched. Booking photographs are taken at arrest; this is the arrest-era image from the July 2025 case coverage, printed as the record carries it, and never described as anything else.
The rule of this file. Claims above the grade of the paper behind them are not printed. Attributions ride with the claims they support, and §09 lists every original that would raise a grade.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
THE CHECKS RUN FOR THIS FILE — NO DOCUMENTED ENTRY FOUND. Searches run for this file on November 11–12, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news record, against the Indianapolis Star’s roster of charged officers, and against the state’s own certification records — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in Nicholas Cauley’s name. One documented misuse of a police vehicle does stand in his record — the March 24, 2025 drive to his ex-wife’s workplace, in his police car, when he was not on a call. It is told in §03, where it belongs, as conduct in the criminal case; this section does not dress it up as a road infraction. The empty result is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere.
If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.