
This is the case file for what happened inside the Methuen Police Department between 2015 and 2020, and for everything it set in motion: a forged police academy certificate carried by a sitting city councilor working as an officer; six full-time hires made outside the civil service law; a state commission’s audit; three separate state investigations; two indictments; two guilty pleas — and a letter from a mayor and eight councilors asking the United States Attorney to reopen a federal case the city says was shut down in 2024 with a grand jury presentation ready to go.
Six intermittent officers were converted to full-time civil service roles outside the process the law requires — the conduct Police Chief Joseph Solomon admitted by guilty plea on September 18, 2026 (Attorney General’s release, September 18, 2026). Sean Fountain served as an officer from 2017 to 2020 on the forged certificate, and pleaded guilty on December 17, 2025 (Attorney General; Eagle-Tribune). The Civil Service Commission found the city paid more than $1.5 million to seven individuals who should not have been hired (Commission report, January 2023). And on October 5, 2026, the Mayor and City Council wrote to U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley asking her to reopen the federal investigation, or direct a fresh and independent review (City of Methuen letter, October 5, 2026).
The individual files: No. 124, THE JOSEPH SOLOMON FILE — the chief who ran the scheme and swore to it in writing — and No. 126, THE SEAN FOUNTAIN FILE — the councilor who wore the badge the certificate bought.
One document sits at the center of the whole case: a police academy certificate that Sean Fountain never earned. His employment application claimed he had graduated from the Northeast Regional Police Institute in 1996 (Attorney General’s release, September 28, 2023).
Questioned on that claim, he produced a certificate documenting graduation in May 1995 — dated May 13, 1995. The Attorney General states Fountain created the certificate; the STIRM Group’s investigation concluded it was a forgery (Attorney General, September 28, 2023; STIRM report).
Per the Civil Service Commission, Fountain never attended or completed a full-time police academy, was never certified by the Municipal Police Training Committee for full-time service, had no evidence of a completed physical or medical examination, and was over the city’s age limit for new officers (Civil Service Commission report, January 2023, as reported). His misrepresentations about his training ran through his employment application and a search warrant affidavit (Attorney General, September 28, 2023).
“Solomon knew Fountain’s certificate was forged yet acted as if it was a real document” (Attorney General’s release, September 28, 2023).
The State Ethics Commission’s Enforcement Division separately alleged that Solomon presented a fabricated training certificate and a fabricated letter to the city’s Human Resources Director so Fountain could continue to be paid (Ethics Commission, July 6, 2023 — allegations in a civil proceeding, printed as allegations).
In January 2023, the Massachusetts Civil Service Commission issued a 43-page report on Methuen’s hiring (Civil Service Commission; WBZ NewsRadio).
City records showed more than $1.5 million paid to seven individuals who were working full-time positions they were not qualified or trained to hold (Civil Service Commission report, January 2023).
The Commission called Fountain “the most brazen example of abuse, which occurred (in plain sight) over a period of years” (Civil Service Commission, as quoted in coverage of the report), and it recommended the city explore legal action against Joseph Solomon and Sean Fountain (Civil Service Commission report, January 2023).
Two counts run through this case and they are not the same count: the criminal case charged six conversions; the Commission counted seven individuals paid. Both are printed in their own lanes throughout this file, and never blended.
December 2020 — the Massachusetts Inspector General’s report on the 2017 police contracts found Chief Solomon “abandoned his duties” by remaining silent while unapproved language that indirectly increased his own pay was slipped into the contracts (Office of the Inspector General, as reported by The Boston Globe).
April 2023 — a city-funded investigation concluded Solomon ran the department “like the don of an organized crime family,” relying on “humiliation, fear, intimidation and retaliation” (the investigation’s report, as reported by The Boston Globe).
The STIRM Group’s investigative report — commissioned by the City of Methuen and public on the city’s own website — documented the falsified police credentials at the center of the case (City of Methuen; STIRM report).
July 6, 2023 — the State Ethics Commission’s Enforcement Division issued an Order to Show Cause alleging conflict-of-interest violations by Solomon, including the fabricated certificate and letter presented to the Human Resources Director (State Ethics Commission, July 6, 2023).
Essex County District Attorney Paul F. Tucker contacted the Attorney General’s Office in January 2023, after reviewing the Inspector General’s and the Commission’s reports; the joint investigation that produced the indictments followed (The Boston Globe’s indictment coverage, September 2023).
On September 28, 2023, a statewide grand jury indicted Joseph Solomon on 17 charges and Sean Fountain on five, in a joint investigation by the Attorney General’s Office and the Essex County District Attorney’s Office (Attorney General’s release, September 28, 2023).
| Defendant | Charges |
|---|---|
| Joseph Solomon | Perjury by Written Affidavit (2) · Obtaining Unwarranted Privileges (7) · Civil Service Law Violations (6) · Uttering a Forged Document (1) · Procurement Fraud (1) |
| Sean Fountain | Forgery · Uttering a Forged Document · Perjury · Procurement Fraud · Conflict of Interest Law Violation |
Before the statewide indictment, Fountain had been arraigned in Lawrence District Court on April 6, 2023, on eight counts including conspiracy and forgery — in a case whose paperwork named a co-conspirator a judge ordered impounded (Eagle-Tribune, as reported). Both men were arraigned in Essex Superior Court at Salem on November 10, 2023, and released without bail (CNHI / Eagle-Tribune).
The 2023 prosecution was assigned to Assistant Attorney General Douglas Sheehan of the White Collar and Public Integrity Division and Essex County Assistant District Attorney Marina Moriarty (Attorney General, September 28, 2023).
December 17, 2025 — Sean Fountain pleaded guilty. Judge Thomas Dreschler sentenced him to three years of probation, under terms barring him from possessing firearms and from law-enforcement employment (Eagle-Tribune, December 18, 2025). While serving without lawful qualification, Fountain made more than 40 arrests and earned roughly $427,000 (Eagle-Tribune).
September 18, 2026 — Joseph Solomon pleaded guilty to all 17 counts: 2.5 years in the House of Correction with 30 days to serve and the balance suspended for three years, probation on the felony counts, and his rights to appeal waived (Attorney General; Office of the Mayor).
The only negotiation documented before Solomon’s plea was a proposed resolution with no jail time at all — which the mayor of Methuen appeared in court to reject (mayor’s statement, September 18, 2026; the full account is File No. 124, §07).
With both pleas entered, the state criminal case is closed. What the pleas cost, what the city still has to collect, and what Washington has been asked to reopen are at §06, §07 and §08.
The state case ended in two courtrooms in Salem. The federal case never reached one — and Methuen’s elected government has now said so, in writing, to the United States Attorney:
The letter, dated October 5, 2026, from Mayor D.J. Beauregard and the City Council to U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley, asks her to “reopen the federal investigation into corruption involving the former leadership of the Methuen Police Department, or direct a fresh and independent review of the evidence gathered in that investigation” (City of Methuen letter, October 5, 2026).
Per the letter, city officials were informed by the Justice Department under Attorney General Merrick Garland that the federal investigation and prosecution “had been abruptly shut down,” and that the case, “though fully ready to be presented to the grand jury, was closed and the presentation was stopped.” The city learned of the abandonment during the week between Mayor Neil Perry’s death and his funeral in September 2024 (City of Methuen letter, October 5, 2026).
The letter asks the U.S. Attorney to examine Solomon, Fountain, former Captain Gregory Gallant and former Municipal Police Training Committee Executive Director Robert Ferullo, and cites the whistleblower lawsuit Baker v. Municipal Police Training Committee (Suffolk Superior Court, Case No. 2584CV00937), the STIRM report, and Boston Globe reporting that a federal grand jury had been investigating the police contracts (City of Methuen letter, October 5, 2026).
The letter also puts the city’s own exposure in writing: Fountain arrested more than 40 people while impersonating an officer — conduct the city equates to kidnapping and a source of potential civil liability (City of Methuen letter, October 5, 2026, as published by the city).
Neither Gallant nor Ferullo has been charged in any record pulled for this file. The letter is the City of Methuen’s request and the city’s characterizations — printed here as the city’s position, not as findings against any person.
The letter was adopted at the City Council’s October 5, 2026 meeting and transmitted by the city, signed by the mayor and eight councilors (City of Methuen, October 9, 2026). No response from the U.S. Attorney’s Office, and no reopening, had been publicly reported as of November 14, 2026.
Every figure in this case belongs to a document. They are printed here in their lanes, each with its source — and never added together into a total no document states:
More than $1.5 million — paid by the City of Methuen to seven individuals who should not have been hired (Massachusetts Civil Service Commission report, January 2023).
Roughly $427,000 — earned by Sean Fountain across his years as an officer (Eagle-Tribune).
$326,707 — Joseph Solomon’s salary in 2019, among the highest of any police chief in the nation (The Boston Globe, 2020).
$183,858 a year — Solomon’s city pension, forfeited as a result of his plea (amount: Boston Herald; forfeiture: Attorney General’s release, September 18, 2026).
More than $1 million — pension benefits paid to Solomon since his 2020 retirement, which the city states it will pursue recovering (Office of the Mayor, September 18, 2026).
Roughly $3.7 million — the projected reduction in the city’s unfunded pension liability over 20 years from the forfeiture, as the city states it (Office of the Mayor, September 9, 2026).
A figure of $1.1 million for the six officers circulates in social summaries of this case. It appears in neither the Attorney General’s releases nor the Commission’s findings as pulled for this file, and it is not printed here as a figure of record. The documented totals are the ones above.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
The U.S. Attorney’s response to the city’s October 5, 2026 letter — none publicly reported as of November 14, 2026.
The city’s pursuit of the more than $1 million in pension benefits paid since 2020 was announced on September 18, 2026; no filed recovery action had been publicly reported as of November 14, 2026.
No Methuen Retirement Board forfeiture determination has been publicly reported as of November 14, 2026.
The Enforcement Division’s 2023 Order to Show Cause against Solomon is a civil proceeding separate from the criminal case; no outcome appears in the record pulled for this file.
The judge who took Solomon’s plea is not named in the Attorney General’s release, the mayor’s statements, or the coverage pulled; the Essex Superior Court dockets — reported as Nos. 2377CR00451 (Solomon) and 2377CR00452 (Fountain) — have not been pulled for this file.
Baker v. Municipal Police Training Committee (No. 2584CV00937), cited by the city as a source of new information; its docket has not been pulled for this file.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
Mayor and City Council letter to U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley (published in full by the city, methuen.gov). The request to reopen the federal investigation; the city’s account of the 2024 shutdown; the names and records the city asks be examined. Named in: Intro, §06.
“AG Campbell Secures Guilty Plea From Former Methuen Police Chief” (Mass.gov). Solomon’s plea to all 17 charges, the sentence structure and the plea’s documented losses. Named in: Intro, §05, §07.
“Indictments Announced In Case Against Former Methuen Police Chief, Police Officer” (Mass.gov). The statewide grand jury indictments of both men; the certificate, the application and the search-warrant affidavit; the perjury stated in the Attorney General’s own words. Named in: §01, §04.
The city-commissioned investigative report (public on the city’s website) — the investigation that concluded the academy certificate was a forgery. Named in: §01, §03.
The 43-page report, as reported by WBZ NewsRadio — the more-than-$1.5 million paid to seven individuals; Fountain’s missing qualifications; the recommendation of legal action against Solomon and Fountain. Named in: Intro, §01, §02, §07.
Enforcement Division Order to Show Cause (Mass.gov). The conflict-of-interest allegations against Solomon, including the fabricated certificate and letter presented to the Human Resources Director. Allegations in a civil proceeding; no outcome in the record pulled. Named in: §01, §03, §08.
Statement following the guilty pleas, September 18, 2026 (methuen.gov) — the rejected no-jail resolution; the recovery of more than $1 million in pension benefits; the call on the U.S. Attorney. And the statement of September 9, 2026 (the city’s release, as reproduced by MethuenLife Magazine) — the agreed plea announced in advance; the roughly $3.7 million projected liability reduction. Named in: §05, §07.
Methuen coverage — Fountain’s December 17, 2025 plea and sentence before Judge Thomas Dreschler (front page, December 18, 2025); his 40-plus arrests and roughly $427,000 in earnings; the April 2023 Lawrence District Court arraignment. Named in: Intro, §04, §05, §07.
“Solomon, Fountain released without bail after arraignments” — the Salem arraignments and release of both men. Named in: §04.
Andrea Estes’s reporting on Methuen (the 2020 salary investigation; the April 2023 city-funded investigation; the September 2023 indictment coverage), and Inspector General Glenn Cunha’s December 2020 report on the 2017 police contracts, as reported by the Globe. The Globe’s site would not open to this library’s reader; its reporting is credited in the text wherever it is used. Named in: §03, §07.
The city’s official post transmitting the Foley letter — the letter’s adoption and transmission, signed by the mayor and eight councilors. Named in: §06.
The $183,858 annual pension figure. Printed in this file only as the figure’s source; the forfeiture itself is the Attorney General’s statement. Named in: §07.
“Methuen City Hall - 2006.jpg,” photograph by EraserGirl, Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 — cited the same way by the Commonwealth’s own Methuen profile (Mass.gov). Format-converted for this page without crop or content change; see this file’s PHOTO.md in the build record. Named in: Intro (lead photograph).
The narrated summary this case file answers. Its claims are carried in this file only where the record above supports them; the figure it circulated that no document supports is addressed at §07. Named in: Intro.