The identity, on paper. The judge is Teresa L. Cataldo, Judge of Elkhart Superior Court 3, Elkhart County, Indiana — court code 20D03, Courtroom 3D at the Elkhart County Judicial Center, 1905 Reliance Road, Goshen. The identification does not rest on the reader’s tip: the Indiana Supreme Court’s own caption names her — “The Honorable Teresa L. Cataldo, Judge” — over the four causes at the spine of this file; Court of Appeals captions across a decade uniformly style appeals from her courtroom the same way; and Elkhart County’s court directory and the Indiana Office of Court Services list her in the seat.
| When | Role | The paper |
|---|---|---|
| Before 2015 | Defense attorney; deputy prosecuting attorney (Elkhart County); judge pro tempore | Rose v. State, 36 N.E.3d 1055 (Ind. Ct. App. 2015); the Supreme Court’s 2024 opinion independently describes her as “a former Elkhart County deputy prosecutor” |
| May 2014 | Won a four-candidate Republican primary to succeed retiring Judge George W. Biddlecome, with nearly 33% of the vote (David Francisco 29%, Andrew M. Hicks 22%, Fay Schwartz 16%) | Indiana Lawyer primary-night report |
| November 4, 2014 | Elected — the sole candidate on the general-election ballot for Elkhart Superior Court 3 | Rose v. State, 36 N.E.3d 1055 |
| January 1, 2015 – present | Judge, Elkhart Superior Court 3 — terms 2015–2020 and 2021–2026; the only candidate who qualified for the November 3, 2026 ballot (Republican, unopposed), a third term to follow barring a write-in upset | Official directories; Indiana Secretary of State 2026 general-election candidate list |
Sources: Seabolt et al. v. State, Nos. 24S-PC-270/271/272/273 (Ind. Aug. 20, 2024) (caption); Elkhart County Court Locations page and Judicial System Contact Information sheet; IOCS listings; Rose v. State, 36 N.E.3d 1055 (Ind. Ct. App. 2015); Indiana Lawyer (May 2014 primary); Indiana Secretary of State, 2026 general-election candidate list. Each read for this file, November 9, 2026.
The juror. The record holds one episode that shows the lawyer she was before the robe. In August 2014 — already the Republican nominee, not yet elected — Cataldo sat as a juror, and foreman, in a child-molesting jury trial in the very court she was about to join (State v. Rose). The defendant challenged the verdict on that ground, and the Court of Appeals rejected the challenge: at the time “she had not been elected as judge; she was simply another citizen performing her civic duty.” The episode is printed here because it is part of her papered record and because the case that recorded it, Rose, is also the paper that settles her pre-bench career and her 2014 election.
The ordinary record. Beyond the recusal line that occupies §§02–04, her appellate trail is routine: post-conviction and criminal appeals from 20D03 affirmed on the merits in the ordinary course (e.g. Martin, Jan. 9, 2024; Howard, Sept. 4, 2025), and local news mentions that are ordinary court reporting, such as the Goshen News on a sentencing in her court. No other appellate criticism of her was found in the research behind this file. And the discipline check is stated separately, at full size, in §06: she does not appear on Indiana’s judicial-discipline list.
Where the sequence starts. Andrew Royer’s post-conviction case came before Judge Cataldo carrying allegations about the system that had convicted him. His attorney, Elliot Slosar, held a press conference alleging a “systemic failure and an epidemic in Elkhart County where people [were] wrongfully convicted because of police corruption, uninspiring defense counsel and an overzealous prosecutor.” Those are the attorney’s allegations, printed here because of what the court did with them — they are not this file’s findings, and §03 shows the fence this file keeps around every allegation the petitioners raised.
The injunction and the word. The State moved to enjoin further extrajudicial comment. Judge Cataldo agreed, and enjoined both sides from extrajudicial commentary, describing Slosar’s comments, in the words the Supreme Court’s opinion recites from the record, as:
“highly inflammatory, defamatory, inaccurately stat[ing] the law as it exist[ed] at th[e] time … and draw[ing] legal conclusions about matters not yet adjudicated.”
The recusal she granted. Royer then moved for her recusal under Post-Conviction Rule 1 §4(B), on two grounds: (i) his witnesses would be law-enforcement officers, deputy prosecutors, and an elected prosecutor she had worked with as a deputy prosecutor — some still her social acquaintances — witnesses whose credibility she would have to judge, in a case alleging misconduct spanning her own time in that office; and (ii) her “defamatory” characterization showed she had rejected his systemic-misconduct allegations before hearing any evidence. She granted the motion. The case was reassigned to an out-of-county special judge. Hold on to what she decided there — that on these facts, recusal was mandatory — because §03 turns on it.
What the special judge found. The special judge in Royer granted relief and vacated Royer’s conviction, concluding — in the Supreme Court’s words — that “many of Royer’s allegations of misconduct were well founded”: a detective’s handling of a severely disabled suspect’s confession; a fingerprint identification the State had called its “most important piece of evidence” that was in fact a healthcare aide’s; the expert’s admitted lack of training; and the State’s failure to disclose the detective’s removal from the homicide unit over past misrepresentations. Those conclusions are the special judge’s findings in Royer’s case, recited by the Supreme Court from Royer, 166 N.E.3d 380, 389–97 (Ind. Ct. App. 2021) — and they are the disposition Royer’s allegations are welded to in this file: his conviction was vacated on them.
The footnote. A prosecutor later filed a disciplinary complaint against Slosar over the press conference — the same comments Judge Cataldo had called defamatory. The Disciplinary Commission dismissed it as not raising “a substantial question of misconduct that would warrant disciplinary action.” The Supreme Court’s opinion records the dismissal. The word that started this sequence was hers; the system’s own disciplinary arm declined to treat the speech as misconduct at all.
Source for this section: Seabolt et al. v. State, Nos. 24S-PC-270/271/272/273 (Ind. Aug. 20, 2024) (Molter, J.), reciting the Royer record (App. Vol. III at 57–59, 196–204; App. Vol. IV at 26) and citing Royer, 166 N.E.3d 380, 389–97 (Ind. Ct. App. 2021). Read for this file, November 9, 2026.
The same claims, the same grounds, a different answer. Four later petitioners — Iris Seabolt, Reginald Dillard, Leon Tyson and Pink Allen Robinson — raised the same species of systemic-misconduct claims before Judge Cataldo. They intended to call the same class of witnesses: her former colleagues and social acquaintances, whose credibility she would have to judge. They moved for her recusal on the same two grounds Royer had won on. This time, she denied all four motions, and certified the denials for interlocutory appeal. The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed her denials (Seabolt, memorandum decision Sept. 20, 2023; Dillard, 222 N.E.3d 338).
The Supreme Court takes all four. The petitioners sought transfer. On August 20, 2024, the Indiana Supreme Court granted transfer in all four cases, reversed, and held her disqualified — in an opinion by Justice Molter, joined by Chief Justice Rush and Justices Massa and Goff, with Justice Slaughter not participating. The Court’s holding, in its own words:
“We hold that the judge is disqualified from presiding over these cases because her determination that recusal was mandatory in Royer’s case would lead an objective observer to reasonably question her impartiality in these cases, where the petitioners raised the same concerns as Royer.”
The Court remanded with instructions to grant the change-of-judge motions. The four cases are Nos. 24S-PC-270, 24S-PC-271, 24S-PC-272 and 24S-PC-273; the underlying causes are 20D03-2106-PC-19 (Seabolt), 20D03-2207-PC-19 (Dillard), 20D03-1807-PC-37 (Tyson) and 20C01-2012-PC-41 (Robinson).
What the holding is — and what it is not. Read the standard the Court used: an objective observer, reasonably questioning impartiality, because of her own earlier determination that the same facts made recusal mandatory in Royer. That is an appearance-of-impartiality holding. The Court did not find that Judge Cataldo was actually biased in any of the four cases; it did not find corruption; it made no misconduct finding against her at all. This file prints the holding at exactly that size — the state’s highest court ordered a sitting judge off four cases because her own Royer ruling made her impartiality reasonably questionable in theirs — and it does not print one ounce more than that.
Source: Seabolt / Dillard / Tyson / Robinson v. State, Nos. 24S-PC-270, 24S-PC-271, 24S-PC-272, 24S-PC-273 (Ind. Aug. 20, 2024) (Molter, J.). The opinion’s caption styles the appeals as from the Elkhart Circuit Court [sic]; the cause numbers are Elkhart Superior Court 3 (20D03) causes, with Robinson’s in the 20C01 series. Read for this file, November 9, 2026.
Seabolt’s road to the remand. Iris Seabolt’s change-of-judge fight in front of Judge Cataldo had already run for years before the Supreme Court ended it: the judge denied Seabolt’s change-of-judge motion on October 5, 2021, certified it for appeal on January 10, 2022, and denied a renewed motion on May 4, 2022. After the Supreme Court’s remand, the docket records the ending in one line, recited in the replacement judge’s later order: “On September 11, 2024, Judge Cataldo recused herself from the case.” On October 31, 2024, Judge Christopher J. Spataro of Elkhart Superior Court 5 was appointed in her place.
Seabolt: a new trial. Before Judge Spataro, Seabolt’s case went to evidentiary hearings in January and February 2026. Judge Spataro granted post-conviction relief — the granting order, in cause 20D03-2106-PC-000019, was filed April 6, 2026 — and Seabolt was granted a new trial (the granting order is dated April 22, 2026, per the National Registry of Exonerations).
Seabolt: case dismissed — fully exonerated. The new trial never took place: on September 2, 2026, Judge Spataro granted the special prosecutor’s motion to dismiss, and Iris Seabolt was fully exonerated (Notre Dame News, September 2, 2026).
Dillard: conviction vacated, case dismissed. Reginald Dillard’s case took its own course after the removal. In June 2025 the Elkhart County Prosecutor’s Office was itself disqualified in Dillard and a Marshall County special prosecutor was appointed. After hearings on February 18–19, 2026, Judge Spataro vacated Dillard’s conviction, and on February 23, 2026 he granted the prosecution’s motion to dismiss. Dillard was released.
Whose orders these are. Every disposition in this section is Judge Spataro’s, in cases Judge Cataldo was ordered removed from. They are printed here as what they are — the documented downstream of the disqualification: of the four cases the Supreme Court took out of her courtroom, the two whose post-remand paper is in hand ended with a dismissal and full exoneration for one petitioner and a vacated conviction and dismissal for the other. The petitioners’ allegations were the reason those cases existed; the dispositions above are what the courts did with them, and in this file the allegations never appear without them.
Sources: Order Granting Petition for Post-Conviction Relief, Seabolt, cause 20D03-2106-PC-000019 (filed Apr. 6, 2026) (Spataro, Special Judge), reciting the procedural history; National Registry of Exonerations case records for Seabolt and Dillard. Read for this file, November 9, 2026.
A smaller episode, printed at its true size. In 2017, South Bend Tribune reporter Christian Sheckler filed a formal complaint with Indiana’s Public Access Counselor, alleging that the Elkhart Superior and Circuit Courts had violated the Access to Public Records Act by denying copies of court records. The courts responded through “the Hon. Judge Teresa L. Cataldo.” The Counselor’s advisory opinion, Formal Complaint 18-FC-5, concluded that the Elkhart Courts:
“… have not acted in compliance with the Access to Public Records Act by withholding certain records upon request.”
How to hold this section. This is an advisory opinion of the Public Access Counselor — a compliance finding about the Elkhart courts’ handling of records requests, in a complaint the courts answered through Judge Cataldo as their respondent. It is not a court judgment, and it is not a personal misconduct finding against her; this file prints it as what it is, a documented second episode in which a state reviewer found the courts she spoke for out of compliance with the public-records law this series exists to use. It stands in this file at Tier B, behind the Tier A Supreme Court paper of §§02–04, and at exactly that weight.
Source: Opinion of the Public Access Counselor, Formal Complaint 18-FC-5 (in.gov/pac/files/advisory/18-FC-5.pdf). Read for this file, November 9, 2026.
A file in this series prints what the paper shows and names what it does not. For this subject, the open and negative items are these — each stated at its true size.
This file was built from public sources — the Indiana Supreme Court’s own published opinion, the Court of Appeals decisions it cites, the replacement judge’s post-conviction order, an official registry’s case records, the Public Access Counselor’s advisory opinion, and the state’s and county’s official directories and lists. The trail below separates the paper in hand from the paper still outstanding, so a reader can weigh every section by what stands behind it.
| Record | Custodian / source | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Seabolt / Dillard / Tyson / Robinson v. State — the August 20, 2024 opinion: the Royer sequence as recited, the four denials, the reversal and the disqualification holding | Indiana Supreme Court, Nos. 24S-PC-270/271/272/273 (Molter, J.) | IN HAND — read for this file, November 9, 2026 |
| Royer, 166 N.E.3d 380, 389–97 — the special judge’s findings and the vacatur of Royer’s conviction, as cited by the Supreme Court | Indiana Court of Appeals (2021) | IN HAND as cited in the Supreme Court’s opinion |
| The affirmances of her denials — Dillard, 222 N.E.3d 338; Seabolt, memorandum decision, September 20, 2023 | Indiana Court of Appeals | IN HAND as cited in the Supreme Court’s opinion |
| Order Granting Petition for Post-Conviction Relief, Seabolt — the procedural history, her September 11, 2024 recusal, Judge Spataro’s appointment, and relief | Elkhart Superior Court, cause 20D03-2106-PC-000019 (filed April 6, 2026) (Spataro, Special Judge) | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| Case records for Seabolt and Dillard — the downstream narrative: hearings, the new-trial grant, the vacatur, the dismissal, the release | National Registry of Exonerations | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| Advisory opinion, Formal Complaint 18-FC-5 — the Elkhart courts’ APRA compliance, answered through Judge Cataldo | Indiana Public Access Counselor | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| Rose v. State, 36 N.E.3d 1055 — her pre-bench roles, the 2014 election, the juror episode | Indiana Court of Appeals (2015) | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| Directories, candidate lists, discipline list — her seat and courtroom; the 2026 candidacy; the discipline negative | Elkhart County; IOCS; Indiana Secretary of State; OJAR | READ IN FULL — November 9, 2026 |
| The four underlying Court of Appeals recusal decisions (22A-PC-208, 23A-PC-261, 22A-PC-143, 22A-PC-1102); the 2014 general-election vote total (Clerk’s SOVC); her Roll of Attorneys entry | Indiana Court of Appeals; Elkhart County Clerk; Roll of Attorneys | OUTSTANDING — the lanes that can widen, not create, this file |
When the outstanding paper is pulled, this file updates in place, at this same address — that is how every update in this series lands.
This file began with a reader’s comment left on this series’ page on November 8, 2026 — a bare nomination, asking that everything findable on Teresa Cataldo, a judge in Elkhart, be dug up. The comment alleged nothing. A nomination is not paper, and this series does not build on one. So the first work was the paper — and for this subject, the paper is the strongest paper an Indiana court produces: a published opinion of the Indiana Supreme Court, holding a sitting judge disqualified in four cases.
The sequence, in the courts’ own paper, is this. In Andrew Royer’s post-conviction case, Judge Cataldo called his attorney’s public allegations of systemic misconduct “defamatory” and enjoined both sides from speaking — then granted Royer’s motion to remove her from his case, because her own determination said recusal was mandatory on those facts. A special judge took the case and vacated Royer’s conviction, concluding that many of the allegations were well founded. Four later petitioners — Iris Seabolt, Reginald Dillard, Leon Tyson and Pink Allen Robinson — raised the same species of claims before her, called for the same class of witnesses, and moved for her recusal on the same two grounds. She denied all four. The Court of Appeals affirmed her denials. On August 20, 2024, the Indiana Supreme Court reversed and held her disqualified in all four cases (§03 prints the holding in the Court’s own words). Under the judge who replaced her, Seabolt won a new trial and Dillard’s conviction was vacated and his case dismissed (§04).
Three fences stand on this file at full size. First: the Supreme Court’s holding is about the appearance of impartiality — whether her own earlier recusal determination would lead an objective observer to reasonably question her impartiality. The Court did not find that she was actually biased, and it made no finding of corruption or misconduct by her; this file does not upgrade the holding into one. Second: the petitioners’ underlying allegations print in this file only as allegations they raised, each welded to what the courts did with the case it was raised in — never as this file’s findings against any officer, prosecutor or judge. Third, the counterweight: Judge Cataldo’s name appears nowhere on Indiana’s published judicial-discipline list, which was read in full for this file — no disciplinary case, no public reprimand, no private reprimand names her (§06).
• Identity: Teresa L. Cataldo — Judge, Elkhart Superior Court 3 (court code 20D03), Elkhart County Judicial Center, Goshen, Indiana. Settled on the Supreme Court’s own caption, appellate captions across a decade, and the county’s and IOCS’s directories.
• Before the bench: defense attorney; deputy prosecuting attorney, Elkhart County; judge pro tempore — as the Court of Appeals recorded in Rose v. State (2015).
• Election: won a four-candidate Republican primary in May 2014 (nearly 33%) to succeed retiring Judge George W. Biddlecome; sole candidate on the November 2014 ballot; took the bench January 1, 2015. Terms 2015–2020 and 2021–2026; the only candidate who qualified for the November 3, 2026 ballot, unopposed.
• The Royer case: she characterized attorney Elliot Slosar’s systemic-misconduct allegations as “defamatory,” enjoined both sides’ extrajudicial comment, then granted Royer’s recusal motion. The special judge vacated Royer’s conviction, concluding many of the allegations were well founded (§02).
• The four cases: Seabolt, Dillard, Tyson and Robinson raised the same claims on the same grounds; she denied all four recusal motions; the Court of Appeals affirmed (§03).
• The holding: August 20, 2024 — the Indiana Supreme Court granted transfer in all four cases, reversed, and held her disqualified, in an opinion by Justice Molter; Chief Justice Rush and Justices Massa and Goff concurred; Justice Slaughter did not participate (§03).
• After the removal: her recusal in Seabolt is docketed September 11, 2024; Judge Christopher J. Spataro replaced her. Seabolt was granted a new trial (April 2026); Dillard’s conviction was vacated and the case dismissed (February 2026) (§04).
• The open-records opinion: in Formal Complaint 18-FC-5, Indiana’s Public Access Counselor concluded the Elkhart courts — which answered the complaint through Judge Cataldo — had not acted in compliance with the Access to Public Records Act (§05).
• The counterweight: she is not on Indiana’s judicial-discipline list, and her ordinary appellate record is routine (§01, §06).
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Official records and official publications are linked where they live; items named but not linked are identified by their custodian and their status, so a reader can pull the same paper. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as an allegation or as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 9, 2026.
Nos. 24S-PC-270, 24S-PC-271, 24S-PC-272, 24S-PC-273 (Ind. Aug. 20, 2024) (Molter, J.) — the spine of this file: the Royer sequence as recited from the record (the press conference, the injunction and her “defamatory” characterization, App. Vol. III at 57–59; the recusal motion and its grant, App. Vol. III at 196–204; the Disciplinary Commission’s dismissal of the complaint against Royer’s attorney, App. Vol. IV at 26); the four petitioners’ identical motions and her denials; the Court of Appeals’ affirmances; and the disqualification holding quoted verbatim in §03, with remand instructions to grant the change-of-judge motions. Chief Justice Rush and Justices Massa and Goff concurred; Justice Slaughter did not participate. The caption styles the appeals as from the Elkhart Circuit Court [sic]; the causes are 20D03-2106-PC-19, 20D03-2207-PC-19, 20D03-1807-PC-37 and 20C01-2012-PC-41. · Last checked November 9, 2026
The special judge’s decision in Andrew Royer’s case, at 389–97 as cited by the Supreme Court: relief granted, Royer’s conviction vacated, and the conclusion that “many of Royer’s allegations of misconduct were well founded” — the findings on the disabled suspect’s confession, the fingerprint identification, the expert’s training, and the non-disclosure of the detective’s removal from the homicide unit (§02). · Last checked November 9, 2026
Judge Christopher J. Spataro, Special Judge, Elkhart Superior Court, cause 20D03-2106-PC-000019 — recites the procedural history this file prints in §04: her denials of October 5, 2021 and May 4, 2022 and the January 10, 2022 certification; “On September 11, 2024, Judge Cataldo recused herself from the case”; Spataro’s appointment October 31, 2024; and the grant of relief after the January–February 2026 evidentiary hearings. · Last checked November 9, 2026
The Registry’s case records for Iris Seabolt and Reginald Dillard — the downstream narrative in §04: Seabolt’s new trial (granting order dated April 22, 2026, per the Registry); in Dillard, the June 2025 disqualification of the Elkhart County Prosecutor’s Office and the Marshall County special prosecutor’s appointment, the February 18–19, 2026 hearings, Judge Spataro’s vacatur of the conviction, the February 23, 2026 dismissal, and Dillard’s release. · Last checked November 9, 2026
Advisory opinion on Tribune reporter Christian Sheckler’s 2017 formal complaint — the Elkhart Superior and Circuit Courts, responding through “the Hon. Judge Teresa L. Cataldo,” were concluded to have “not acted in compliance with the Access to Public Records Act by withholding certain records upon request” (§05). An advisory compliance finding about the courts, printed at Tier B. Advisory opinion 18-FC-5 (PDF) · Last checked November 9, 2026
The paper for her pre-bench career and election: she had worked as a defense attorney, a deputy prosecuting attorney and a judge pro tempore; in August 2014 she sat as juror and foreman in State v. Rose in the court she was about to join, and the Court of Appeals rejected the fundamental-error challenge (“she was simply another citizen performing her civic duty”); and she was “the sole candidate on the November ballot for judge of Elkhart Superior Court 3” in 2014 — “Cataldo is now Judge of Elkhart Superior Court 3” (§01). · Last checked November 9, 2026
Elkhart County Court Locations page and Judicial System Contact Information sheet (“Superior Court 3 — Courtroom 3D — Hon. Teresa L. Cataldo, Judge,” Elkhart County Judicial Center, Goshen); IOCS listings (Jury Committee; Judges Speakers Bureau); Indiana Secretary of State 2026 general-election candidate list (Teresa L. Cataldo, Republican, Elkhart Superior Court Judge No. 3 — the only candidate who qualified); Indiana Lawyer primary-night report, May 2014 (four-candidate primary, nearly 33%). Counterweight: the OJAR Judicial Disciplinary Opinions list was read in full — every entry from 26S-JD-312 (2026) back to Matter of Alsip (1986) — and Teresa L. Cataldo does not appear on it (§06). · Last checked November 9, 2026