
Jan Cahill came to the State Police from the Greenbrier County Sheriff’s Office, where he had been sheriff, and from service as a United States Marine. When Jim Justice became governor, he appointed Cahill superintendent of the West Virginia State Police, and Cahill led the agency from 2017 until March 20, 2023.
His fall took one morning, and it was not caused by a charge, a lawsuit or a vote. It was caused by a letter, an investigation he did not control, and a governor saying on camera what the letter had alleged. The full situation — the academy camera, the two letters, the seizure directive, the women’s litigation and its $9.1 million end — is File No. 129, THE WEST VIRGINIA STATE POLICE FILE.
Two years after the fall, Cahill answered in court: that he had been forced out not for the scandal but for raising fraud concerns inside the government. His suit never reached a hearing on that claim. This file prints both halves of his record — the fall and the answer — and smooths neither.
Two anonymous letters frame Cahill’s superintendency, and this file keeps them apart. The first, in July 2022, alleged among other things that a camera had been placed in the women’s locker room at the State Police Academy, and named a since-deceased trooper as the man who placed it; it was investigated inside the agency Cahill led, and no public findings from that investigation have been located.
The second, dated February 16, 2023 and later claimed by Cpl. Joseph Comer, alleged a hidden camera system at the academy, a “ghost account” in an overtime scheme, falsified overtime and three unreported crashes.
On March 2, 2023, the governor’s chief of staff directed the Homeland Security secretary in writing to seize the daily activity logs, duty logs, all emails and all text messages of thirteen named State Police employees for February 13–28, 2023. Cahill’s name stood on that list. The governor’s investigation was, by design, an investigation of the agency by the government above it — and its first name was the superintendent’s.
On the morning of March 20, 2023, Gov. Justice told Cahill there was “no pathway” for him to continue, and Cahill handed over his resignation at 9:30 a.m. The governor announced it the same day and confirmed, on the record, the allegation at the center of the scandal: “Our state police did stuff that was really bad. A video camera was put in the women’s locker room at the academy.”
Justice also said the man reported to have placed the camera had died years earlier, and indicated the camera itself may have dated to roughly 2014 or 2016 — before Cahill ever held the office. Both halves of that record belong in this file: the superintendent fell over a scandal his governor confirmed, and the worst act in it may have predated him. No source located accuses Cahill of placing, using or knowing of the camera, and he has never been charged with anything arising from it.
Cahill’s answer came two years later, in court. After giving the pre-suit notice West Virginia law requires — his intention to sue was reported in February 2025 — he filed suit on April 7, 2025 in Kanawha County Circuit Court against the State of West Virginia and the Department of Homeland Security, represented by attorney Stephen New. His allegation: that he was forced to resign in retaliation for raising concerns about potential fraud involving CARES Act funding — that the scandal was the occasion of his removal, not its cause.
The suit did not reach that question. In September 2025 — reported September 18, 2025 — Judge Richard Lindsay dismissed it, because the pre-suit notice to the Department of Homeland Security had not been correctly sent. Cahill appealed the dismissal; the appeal’s outcome, and whether the suit is refiled, stand as open pulls in this file (§05).
His retaliation claim has therefore never been tested on its merits, in either direction — a fact this file states plainly, because it cuts both ways: the dismissal proves a defective notice, and nothing else.
It does not claim Cahill knew about the academy camera; no source located says he did. It does not claim his retaliation account is true; it is his allegation, untested. It does not claim the July 2022 investigation he oversaw was mishandled; its findings were never made public, and this file prints that absence rather than filling it.
What the record does establish is narrow and complete: a superintendent of six years was directed against by name in his own governor’s seizure order, resigned within the month, and two years later lost his retaliation suit on a notice defect before any court reached what he said.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
Cahill appealed Judge Lindsay’s September 2025 dismissal of his retaliation suit. The appeal’s outcome has not been located.
Whether the retaliation suit is refiled on a corrected pre-suit notice — which would put his CARES Act allegation before a court for the first time — is not established in any source located.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
“Gov. Justice announces resignation of Jan Cahill; appoints Interim Superintendent of the West Virginia State Police” — the state’s own announcement of the resignation and of Maj. Jack Chambers’s appointment. Named in: Intro, §02.
“Superintendent of WVSP Jan Cahill resigns amid investigation” — the “no pathway” meeting, the 9:30 a.m. resignation, and the governor’s on-record confirmation of the academy camera, including his indication that it may have dated to roughly 2014 or 2016, before Cahill’s tenure. Read in full. Named in: §02.
“Former WVSP superintendent plans to sue state” — Cahill’s background (Greenbrier County sheriff; U.S. Marine; appointed by Gov. Justice), his announced retaliation theory — forced out after raising potential CARES Act fraud — and attorney Stephen New. Read in full. Named in: Intro, §03.
Judge Richard Lindsay’s dismissal of the April 7, 2025 suit against the State of West Virginia and the Department of Homeland Security, on the ground that the required pre-suit notice to the Department was not correctly sent — as reported by WOWK 13 News on September 18, 2025, with WCHS courtroom coverage the same day; WOWK reported the appeal that followed. Named in: §03, §05.
The written seizure directive naming Cahill among thirteen employees, as displayed in the post of record; the frame is banked with the File No. 129 build. Named in: §01.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
NONE DOCUMENTED YET. If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.