State of Indiana v. Donald Shafer, Cause No. 20D03-2602-F4-000014, Elkhart Superior Court 3. Filed February 13, 2026. Status: PENDING.
These are the charges as filed — the State's allegations, sworn to in an Information, not findings by any court. All three counts carry an offense date of February 11, 2026.
| Count | Charge as filed | What the paper says |
|---|---|---|
| 01 | Sexual Misconduct with a Minor, Level 4 felony | The lead count of the Information, graded a Level 4 felony as filed. The State must prove the allegation at trial or resolve it at sentencing. |
| 02 | Child Solicitation, Level 4 felony | The second count, graded a Level 4 felony as filed. |
| 03 | Possession of Child Sexual Abuse Material, Level 6 felony | The possession count, graded a Level 6 felony as filed. |
What is not in the case. The charges announced at his arrest (§02) included two more — child seduction and child exploitation. Neither appears in the case as filed. Booking charges are a police department's preliminary paper; filed counts are a prosecutor's. This file prints the two sets separately and never blends them.
The plea filing — printed at exactly its weight. On October 8, 2026, a plea agreement was filed in this case, and the jury trial that had been set was cancelled. Sentencing is set for January 7, 2027, at 1:30 PM. A plea agreement is a document the parties file: it is not a conviction. A judge must still accept it, its terms — which counts it covers, what sentence it proposes — are not in the public record this file holds, and no sentence exists until the court imposes one at that January hearing. Claims circulating online about what he "pleaded to" are not in any record this file can cite, and they are not printed here. When the court acts, this file prints the ending from the docket — whichever way it cuts.
Whether the court has accepted the agreement is not stated in the docket entries this file holds; that question stays open on this page until the docket answers it.
The arrest paper is the Goshen Police Department's — case 26GOS00530. In the early morning of Wednesday, February 11, 2026, Goshen officers were on routine patrol inside Shanklin Park, which is closed after dark. At 3:06 AM, near the park's basketball courts, they located a vehicle parked in the lot. The sworn affidavit of the arresting officer, Derek Weldy of the Goshen Police Department, sets out the probable cause on which Shafer was arrested without a warrant, and he was booked into the Elkhart County Jail.
The department's press release, signed by Chief Jose' D. Miller, announced the arrest on preliminary charges of child seduction, sexual misconduct with a minor, child solicitation, and child exploitation; stated that the investigation remained active and ongoing; and carried the department's own reminder that a person arrested is innocent until proven guilty. Preliminary charges are the arresting paper — the charges the State actually filed, two days later, are the three counts in §01.
The first court paper. On February 12, 2026, an Elkhart Superior Court magistrate reviewed the affidavit, found probable cause, and — because the prosecutor required more time to evaluate whether charges should be filed — ordered Shafer held without bond. His initial hearing was set for Tuesday, February 17, 2026, at 1:00 PM, in the courtroom at the Elkhart County Correctional Complex, and was reported held as set. The State filed its Information the day after the probable-cause order, on February 13 (§01).
WNDU has reported contents of the probable-cause affidavit, including statements the affidavit attributes to Shafer and accounts attributed to the other party. That is a television station's report of one officer's sworn affidavit — allegations, not testimony, not evidence tested in court, and not findings. This file has read the affidavit as the court filing made it public, and prints its arrest account in this section at that weight. It does not print the affidavit's descriptions involving the minor, here or anywhere.
Every line of the career below is reporting, attributed — his personnel file, which would state his assignments and dates in the district's own hand, has been requested and has not been produced (§07).
| Date | Record — as reported |
|---|---|
| October 2022 | Shafer's employment at West Side Middle School begins, as a social studies teacher (WSBT; WNDU/Gray, citing the school's website and Elkhart Community Schools documents: teaching social studies at West Side since 2022). |
| 2024–25 school year | Head track coach (WNDU/Gray: "records show"). |
| Through February 2026 | Also a football coach at West Side Middle School (Elkhart Truth; WSBT confirms he was coaching middle school students alongside teaching). |
What the reporting does not state, and this file does not guess: where he taught before Elkhart, or anything about his education and training. Under Indiana law, a school employee's education and training background and previous work experience are public personnel-file components (IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8)). They are in the request now prepared for the district (§07), and when the district produces them, this section is updated from the document.
Elkhart Community Schools answered on the day of the arrest, in a published statement and a letter to families. The statement, as published by WSBT and the Elkhart Truth, said the district was contacted by the Goshen Police Department on February 11, and:
"Immediately after we were contacted, we placed the teacher in question on paid administrative leave … and are now cooperating with the police department in its investigation. Obviously, this is an extremely disturbing matter – one that involves the safety and security of our students."
What the record does not show after that day: whether the leave's terms ever changed, and whether it ended in resignation, termination, or non-renewal — or whether it stands today. No later district action is documented in any public record this file holds, as of November 6, 2026. Under Indiana law, the factual basis for final discipline that suspends a public employee without pay, demotes him, or discharges him is a public record (IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8)(C)), and the basic personnel components of his file are public as well. Both are in the request prepared for the district (§07). When the district answers, this section is updated with the document, whichever way it cuts.
A public-school teacher in Indiana teaches on a state license, issued by the Indiana Department of Education. The license file is the state's own paper on the same questions this file asks the district: what credentials he holds, whether the license stands, and whether the state has ever acted on it — suspension, revocation, or surrender are final actions, and final license discipline is public record.
What this file can see today: the state's public license lookup (LVIS360) runs behind an account sign-in, and no public license status for Donald Shafer could be pulled from the open web for this file. That is a limit of the lane, printed as a limit — it is not a finding about his license, in either direction, and this file prints no license status it cannot verify. The records request for his educator license file is written and ready (§07). When the Department produces it, this section prints the document.
A file is also defined by what it refuses to print. These are the open spaces in this one, stated plainly so that nobody builds a claim on them:
The photograph. This file leads with Shafer's booking photo from his February 2026 arrest, as published by WNDU 16 News Now — the Goshen Police Department booking photograph, carried here with its credit. The official booking-record copy remains inside the pending Goshen production (§07); when it is produced, the official copy swaps in. No personal or social-media image has been used at any point.
The plea's terms. A plea agreement was filed on October 8, 2026 (§01). Its terms are not in the public record this file holds, and claims circulating online about what counts it covers or what he "pleaded to" are unverified and not printed. The agreement itself, and the court's action at the January 7, 2027 sentencing, settle it.
The affidavit's detail. The probable-cause affidavit contains allegations involving a minor beyond the arrest account printed in §02. They are not printed — here, the minor appears only in the language of the charges themselves.
The ending of the job question. His final employment disposition — leave terms, any further action, any separation — is not documented yet (§04).
A prior record. No earlier criminal case for Donald Shafer surfaced in this file's docket pull or in its reporting searches, as of November 6, 2026. That is a dated negative, printed as one — not a claim about what no search could miss.
Everything else. Claims about this man circulating in comment sections and social media — about his family, his history, his character — are not in this file, because none of them are in any record this file can cite. If paper surfaces, the file grows. If it doesn't, the silence stays labeled as silence.
This file is a living file, and these are the pulls now running to complete it. Each answer lands here as a dated update at this same address — including the answers that help him.
| Filed | Request | Status |
|---|---|---|
| November 6, 2026 | City of Goshen (public-records web form — the city's stated lane): the Goshen Police Department's complete records of the February 2026 arrest, case 26GOS00530 — the incident and arrest report and all supplements, CAD/dispatch records, body-worn and dash-camera video indexes, and all booking-related records the city holds | Filed — the form issues no reference number; the city acknowledges within 7 days, flagged November 13, 2026 |
| Prepared November 6, 2026 | Elkhart Community Schools (written request under the Access to Public Records Act and Board Policy 8310 — the district takes these by mail): his personnel-file components public under IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8), the factual basis for any discipline finally imposed, his complaint history in categorical form, and the employment-status paper arising from the February 2026 arrest — leave terms and any separation record | Prepared — not yet mailed |
| Prepared November 6, 2026 | Indiana Department of Education: his educator license file — licenses held, current status, and any license discipline | Request text prepared — not yet sent |
| — | Court documents (MyCase / Clerk of Elkhart Superior Court 3): the Information, the October 8, 2026 plea agreement, and the sentencing order in 20D03-2602-F4-000014 | Watch — sentencing January 7, 2027 |
The next court date this file is watching is his: January 7, 2027.
If you know anything or hear anything, you can always report it. Evidence is taken on the main page — tap below and hit SEND EVIDENCE in the bottom-right corner.
🏠 GO TO THE MAIN PAGEDonald Shafer is a social studies teacher at West Side Middle School in Elkhart. In the early morning of February 11, 2026, Goshen police arrested him in a city park, and the State of Indiana charged him in Elkhart Superior Court 3 with three felony counts. The case is pending. A plea agreement was filed on October 8, 2026, the jury trial was cancelled, and sentencing is set for January 7, 2027. The docket entries this file holds — the filing, the cancellation, and the sentencing date — do not state whether the court has accepted the agreement, and its terms are not in the public record this file holds. Acceptance status: unresolved on the present record. A filed plea agreement is not a conviction, and no sentence exists until the court imposes one. He is presumed innocent, and nothing in this file treats the charges as anything but allegations the State must prove or resolve. The charges below are printed exactly as filed, and everything a court has actually decided is labeled decided.
This file is the public record on the case and on the classroom career in front of it: the arrest on the arresting department's own paper — printed separately from the case as filed, because the charges announced at his booking and the counts the State actually filed are not the same set — the school district's answer, given the same day, and the state license file that no one has produced yet. Where the record has not been produced yet, this file says so and names the request that settles it. Where a claim cannot be verified, it does not run. The minor at the center of the charges appears in this file only in the language of the charges themselves — never named, never described.
Every file in this series is built the same way: public records, exhibited in full, and nothing in them that the paper does not say. Finish one file, and the next is waiting — the loop does not close.
Every document this file names, where it lives, and what state it is in — in one place. Hosted means the paper itself is on this page. A docket entry means this file read the court's own chronological case summary and cites it; the docket lives at the court's portal, not here. Reporting is labeled reporting — it is never dressed up as a primary document. Anything missing is labeled missing, in plain words. Register checked November 7, 2026.
Full-size copy hosted on this page — in hand.
Hosted in this file · Named in: File home · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the public docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it at the official MyCase portal: search the case number. Filed February 13, 2026. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
Elkhart Superior Court 3 · Indiana Judicial Branch — MyCase · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
November 6, 2026 — City of Goshen (public-records web form — the city’s stated lane): the Goshen Police Department’s complete records of the February 2026 arrest, case 26GOS00530 — the incident and arrest report and all supplements, CAD/dispatch records, body-worn and dash-camera video indexes, and all booking-related records the city holds — Filed — the form issues no reference number; the city acknowledges within 7 days, flagged November 13, 2026
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Prepared November 6, 2026 — Elkhart Community Schools (written request under the Access to Public Records Act and Board Policy 8310 — the district takes these by mail): his personnel-file components public under IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8), the factual basis for any discipline finally imposed, his complaint history in categorical form, and the employment-status paper arising from the February 2026 arrest — leave terms and any separation record — Prepared — not yet mailed
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Prepared November 6, 2026 — Indiana Department of Education : his educator license file — licenses held, current status, and any license discipline — Request text prepared — not yet sent
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Anything else this file names in its text that does not appear in this register is not hosted here yet — it stands in the file as reporting or as a records request until the paper itself is in hand, and this register is updated when it lands.