
This is the situation file for the West Virginia State Police scandal: the hidden camera in the women’s locker room at the State Police Academy in Institute, the whistleblower letter that forced it into the open, the governor-ordered seizure of the agency’s own leadership’s communications, the fall of a superintendent, and the class litigation that ended, three and a half years later, in a $9.1 million settlement. The individual files are File No. 130, THE JAN CAHILL FILE — the superintendent who resigned — and File No. 131, THE JOSEPH COMER FILE — the trooper whose letter started it.
One thing about dates, stated once and plainly: the post that raised this file, published November 4, 2026, is a March 9, 2023 video presented without its date, as if the events were breaking. They were not. Everything in this file is dated to when it actually happened — February and March 2023 for the scandal itself, and September 16, 2026 for the settlement that closed the women’s cases. The attorney who published the whistleblower’s letter, and whose video the post reposted, was a participant in the events he covered; this file treats him as exactly that — the record’s publisher, never a neutral narrator, and not the whistleblower’s lawyer.
Two anonymous letters drive this story, and this file keeps them separate, because they are different documents, eight months apart, with different authors and different allegations. Blending them is the first error in most tellings of this case.
In July 2022, an anonymous letter reached state officials alleging, among other things, that a camera had been placed in the women’s locker room at the State Police Academy. The letter named a trooper — Joseph Portaro — as the man who placed it.
Trooper Portaro is deceased; he died of a heart attack, and no proceeding ever adjudicated the allegation against him. He is named in this file only as the man the letter named, and nowhere as a man found to have done what it said.
The 2022 letter was investigated inside the agency. No public findings from that investigation have been located; what it concluded, and what was done with the camera allegation in 2022, remains an open pull in this file (§07, 129-02).
On February 16, 2023, a second, five-page anonymous letter reached the governor and state lawmakers. Its author — who identified himself two months later as Cpl. Joseph Comer — alleged a system, not an incident: a hidden camera system in the academy women’s locker room whose footage, he wrote, had been shared among troopers for years; a “ghost account” used in an overtime-fraud scheme; falsified overtime at headquarters; and three vehicle crashes involving the agency that were never reported.
WCHS-TV reported the letter first. Its full text was published on February 17, 2023 by the attorney who later posted the video this file answers — the letter’s publisher, graded in this file as a participant-advocate, the man who put the document into public view.
The governor’s answer came on paper. On March 2, 2023, Chief of Staff Brian Abraham wrote to Homeland Security Secretary Jeff Sandy directing the seizure of records for thirteen named State Police employees — Superintendent Jan Cahill first among them: their daily activity logs, their duty-log entries, all of their email messages, and all of their text messages, for the period February 13 through February 28, 2023. The directive’s scope page is this file’s lead image.
According to the whistleblower’s published account, troopers also searched headquarters itself for documents and video. One supervisor put his objection in writing at the time: Sgt. Brent Kieffer’s February 23, 2023 duty log questioned how the search of Cpl. Comer’s office had been handled — a contemporaneous document, written inside the agency while it happened. (The name is spelled as the March 2 directive itself spells it: Kieffer. The video that raised this file spells it “Keefer”; that is the video’s error, not this file’s.)
On the morning of March 20, 2023, Gov. Jim Justice told Col. Jan Cahill there was “no pathway” forward for him, and Cahill handed over his resignation at 9:30 a.m. That afternoon, the governor confirmed the core of the scandal on the record, in his own words: “Our state police did stuff that was really bad. A video camera was put in the women’s locker room at the academy.”
Justice said three troopers had found the thumb drive holding the camera’s video, pulled it out, threw it on the floor and stomped on it. He said the man reported to have placed the camera had died of a massive heart attack running on the academy track, and indicated the camera may have dated to roughly 2014 or 2016 — years before Cahill’s superintendency, a fact this file prints with the same prominence as the fall itself.
Justice appointed Maj. Jack Chambers interim superintendent the same day and ordered him to run an “all-out investigation” of the agency and to reopen a second matter: casino money a trooper was reported to have picked up from an envelope a patron dropped, and walked away with. The death of Trooper Edmond Exline, who died February 12, 2023 during a traffic stop on Interstate 81 near Martinsburg, was folded into the wider investigation as well.
On April 21, 2023, attorney Teresa Toriseva announced that 42 women — including 10 minors who had attended the Junior Trooper Academy — intended to sue. More than 80 women ultimately filed. The defendants’ insurer was ruled potentially liable for up to $1 million per victim.
On September 16, 2026, Judge Kenneth Ballard approved a $9.1 million class settlement of the locker-room cases — the figure as reported by WV MetroNews, WBOY and WV News from the September 16, 2026 hearing — a settlement that also requires security upgrades at the academy.
One variance in the record is printed as a variance, not smoothed: Toriseva has said the taping ended in 2020, when the Junior Trooper Program was discontinued; a September 2026 summary of the litigation describes the camera as operating from about 2015 to 2023. The women and girls in this litigation are never named in this file; the minors among them are counted, and nothing more.
The man who wrote the February letter was placed on leave on February 23, 2023 and arrested the next day on domestic-violence complaints from December 2022 — the day before a corruption hearing at which, his attorney said, he was to testify. His charges, his attorney’s denial, and the visible track of his case are File No. 131.
Its most important line is this one, which this file repeats rather than improves: the final disposition of Cpl. Comer’s charges is NOT VERIFIED as of this file’s build date, and the Ritchie County Circuit Court docket stands as a dated open pull.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
The final written report of the governor-ordered Homeland Security investigation, beyond the findings the governor presented on March 20, 2023, has not been located.
What the internal investigation of the July 2022 letter concluded — and what was done with its academy-camera allegation a year before the scandal broke — has not been located.
The State Police served Comer a notice of intent to terminate on September 12, 2023. Whether that termination became final is not established in any source located.
The outcome of the investigation folded around Trooper Edmond Exline’s February 12, 2023 death has not been located.
WCHS-TV reported the February 2023 letter first; the individual reporter on that first report is not established in the sources pulled for this file and is not named in it.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
“Superintendent of WVSP Jan Cahill resigns amid investigation” — the “no pathway” meeting and 9:30 a.m. resignation; the governor’s on-record confirmation of the academy camera; the thumb drive found and stomped by three troopers; the casino-money matter reopened; the Exline death folded into the wider investigation; the interim appointment of Jack Chambers with orders to investigate. Read in full. Named in: Intro, §04, §06.
“Gov. Justice announces resignation of Jan Cahill; appoints Interim Superintendent of the West Virginia State Police” — the state’s own announcement of the change at the top of the agency. Named in: §04.
The written directive from Chief of Staff Brian Abraham to Homeland Security Secretary Jeff Sandy — thirteen named employees; daily activity logs, duty logs, all emails, all texts; February 13–28, 2023 — as displayed in the post of record. The frame is banked with this build (SHA-256 in this file’s photo record), and its scope page is this file’s lead image. Named in: §03.
“Dozens of women, girls to sue over locker room recordings at West Virginia State Police Academy” — attorney Teresa Toriseva’s announcement for 42 women, including 10 minors of the Junior Trooper Academy (counted in this file, never named or described). Named in: §05.
Judge Kenneth Ballard’s approval of the $9.1 million class settlement on September 16, 2026 — the figure, the academy security upgrades, and the insurer’s ruled exposure of up to $1 million per victim — as reported from the hearing by WV MetroNews and carried by WBOY and WV News. Named in: §05.
The reel by the page “John H. Bryan, Attorney at Law” (reel 1066923659728799) — a repost, unchanged and undated, of the publisher’s March 9, 2023 video, presenting February–March 2023 events as breaking. Bryan published the February 16, 2023 letter on February 17, 2023 and is graded in this file as its publisher and a participant-advocate. Media and transcript banked with this build (SHA-256 bf46f0df…b093). Named in: Intro, §02, §03.