
Torrie Lemon taught kindergarten at Colonial Christian School, a private Christian school on the north side of Indianapolis. In the spring of 2025, the school learned — and then police learned — that she was carrying on a sexual relationship with a student. When officers interviewed her, the probable-cause affidavit records her own words: “I was having an inappropriate relationship with a student from our school.”
Two counties charged her with child seduction. In May 2026 she pleaded guilty in Hamilton County, and the court’s own sentencing order is the center of this file: a four-year sentence, with forty days executed and the remaining 1,420 days handed back as probation — and the forty days were already satisfied by the thirty actual days she had served plus good-time credit. Eight days later she pleaded guilty by agreement in Marion County too, on identical terms running concurrent with the first sentence — and in each county, the second count was dismissed. A case summary also reports her probation was transferred out of Indiana.
This file is built from the paper: the affidavit as reported from the court record, the school’s own statements, the sentencing order itself, and both counties’ case summaries (MyCase/CCS), pulled November 11, 2026. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §07 lists every pull that would raise a grade.
One rule governs every line: the student in this case is a student. No name, no age, no detail that could point to a child appears in this file, and none ever will. The subject of this file is the teacher — and the answer the system gave.
Torrie Lemon was a kindergarten teacher at Colonial Christian School in Indianapolis — a private Christian school on the city’s north side. The classrooms she stood in front of held the youngest children in the building. She was 23 years old when the charges were filed in June 2025 and 24 when she pleaded guilty and was sentenced in May 2026.
She had come to Indiana from New Hampshire. That fact is on the paper because of how the case ended its first week: when detectives reached her by phone in April 2025, she told them she had moved back to New Hampshire and would not answer questions without an attorney. The state she left for is the state her probation was later reported to follow her to (§05).
The record in hand does not carry her hiring date, her training, or how she came to the school, and this file does not invent them. What the paper holds is the position she held, the trust that came with it, and what she admitted doing inside it. Under Indiana law, child seduction is the charge the State brings when a professional or a child care worker uses that position over a student — it is a Level 5 felony (IC 35-42-4-7), and it is the charge both counties filed against her.
It came to light on April 10, 2025. A member of the school’s staff became aware of the relationship and alerted police the same day; the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department opened its investigation from there. The school’s own account, given in its statement of May 14, 2026, is that after staff became aware of “misconduct involving a teacher” on April 10, 2025, the school “took immediate action, placed the teacher on leave, and contacted the Indiana Department of Child Services, and the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department.”
Her own account is shorter. Interviewed by police, she said it plainly, in the words the probable-cause affidavit carries: “I was having an inappropriate relationship with a student from our school.” There was no denial for the courts to weigh later; the plea that ended the Hamilton County case (§04) was built on an admission made at the front of it.
The paper trail then runs the way these cases run. Detectives reached her by phone on April 16, 2025; she told them she had moved back to New Hampshire and would not answer questions without a lawyer. The probable-cause affidavit for her arrest was filed on June 12, 2025. By then she was already out of the classroom and out of the school (§03) — what remained was for two counties to write the charges.
The school moved first. Colonial Christian’s principal, Andrew Fry, told FOX59/CBS4 that Lemon “was terminated soon after the allegations came to light,” adding: “We are committed to the safety and well-being of every student, and we are cooperating fully with the authorities.” The exact date of the termination is not in the records this file holds; what is certain is that she was out before any charge was filed.
Hamilton County filed first. On June 30, 2025, in Hamilton Superior Court 3 (cause 29D03-2506-F5-005476), prosecutors charged her with two counts of child seduction — Count 1 a Level 5 felony and Count 2 a Level 6 felony on the docket, framed in the charging paper as child seduction by a child care worker. A warrant for her arrest followed on July 1, 2025, with bond set at $15,000, according to the court records reported at the time.
Marion County filed two more, on November 3, 2025, in Marion Superior Court 32 (cause 49D32-2511-F5-033640). Prosecutors there were explicit that their two child-seduction counts were additional and separate charges from the same investigation — not copies of Hamilton County’s sheet. So the case she carried into 2026 was four counts in two counties, every one of them arising out of one admitted relationship with a student at the school that had employed her.
On May 14, 2026, in Hamilton County (cause 29D03-2506-F5-005476), Torrie Lemon pleaded guilty to Count 1, child seduction as a Level 5 felony, and the court sentenced her the same day. The docket records Count 2, the Level 6 felony count, dismissed at the plea. The sentencing order — obtained and quoted in the reporting this file relies on, and now matched by the county’s case summary — reads like this:
Four years imposed — a four-year IDOC term on Count 1. Forty days executed. The remaining 1,420 days suspended to probation. The arithmetic closes exactly: forty plus 1,420 is 1,460 days — the whole four years, accounted for on paper, with one day in forty to be spent in custody.
And even the forty were already gone. The docket carries 40 days of jail credit: 30 actual days served — one day on July 4, 2025, and the rest across April 16 to May 14, 2026, per the docket’s own comment — plus 10 days of good-time credit. Thirty and ten make the forty. On the day the sentence was read, she owed the jail nothing further. Reporting drawn from the court records states the sentence also carries sex-offender registration and treatment, on probation conditions that include no unsupervised contact with minors.
Set the sentence against the statute. A Level 5 felony in Indiana carries one to six years. The court imposed four — a number inside the range, on paper indistinguishable from a serious sentence — and then suspended all of it but forty days that had already been served waiting for the case to end. That is the whole of the Hamilton County answer to an admitted sexual relationship between a kindergarten teacher and a student: the punishment was the wait.
Marion County’s two counts took the longer road. The case (cause 49D32-2511-F5-033640, Marion Superior Court 32) was filed on November 3, 2025. The online court records show a plea agreement filed on February 24, 2026; a jury trial that had been set to begin on March 11, 2026 did not go forward, and the case was set for a change-of-plea hearing on May 22, 2026 — eight days after Hamilton County sentenced her.
The Marion County case summary is now in hand, pulled November 11, 2026, and this section is written from the docket. On May 22, 2026 she pleaded guilty by agreement to Count 1, child seduction as a Level 5 felony. The sentence: 1,460 days imposed, 40 days executed, 1,420 days suspended to probation, a probation term of 1,460 days, and the whole of it concurrent with the Hamilton County sentence — the same four years, the same forty days, running alongside rather than on top. Count 2, a Level 6 felony, was dismissed under the plea agreement (Order Granting Motion to Dismiss, May 26, 2026).
Two details of the Marion disposition remain carried as reported, because the docket entries pulled do not carry them: a published case summary of the disposition, dated May 23, 2026, reports sex-offender treatment and registration, and her probation transferred to New Hampshire, the state she had moved back to when the case began. Those two points stand at that grade until a record carrying them is in hand.
So the two counties’ answers are the same answer, and both are now on the docket. Four counts, two guilty pleas, two dismissals at the plea table — Hamilton County’s second count dismissed at its plea on May 14, 2026, Marion County’s dismissed under its plea agreement — and a total of forty days in custody, every one of them served before either sentence was read, with the years that remain to her spent on probation.
Each item below is printed as a search, with its scope — a gap named is worth more than a gap papered over. Two gaps that stood in this section at launch closed on November 11, 2026, when both counties’ case summaries were pulled: Hamilton County’s second count is dismissed on its docket (§04), and the Marion County disposition is on its docket (§05). What remains is below.
Her teaching license. No Indiana educator-license record or license action naming Torrie Lemon was located in the searches run for this file (web and reporting sweep, November 11, 2026). Colonial Christian is a private school, and the state’s educator-license lookup (IDOE LVIS) has not yet been pulled for her name — that pull is registered in §07. This file therefore prints nothing about a license: not that she held one, and not that she didn’t.
Her start at the school. No record in hand carries her hiring date or how she came to Colonial Christian. The file begins where the paper begins: with the position she held.
The public gap register for this file. Every pull below closes a named gap; when a pull lands, the file is updated in place, at this same address, with the date of the update.
1. Marion County — the chronological case summary (MyCase/CCS). IN HAND — pulled November 11, 2026. Cause 49D32-2511-F5-033640 (Marion Superior Court 32). The plea-by-agreement, dismissal, and sentencing entries lifted §05 to docket grade; the disposition is written from the docket there.
2. Hamilton County — the chronological case summary (Superior Court 3, MyCase/CCS). IN HAND — pulled November 11, 2026. Cause 29D03-2506-F5-005476. It carries the cause number and the formal disposition of the second count — dismissed at the plea (§04) — and matches the sentencing order already corroborated from the order as obtained and quoted in the reporting.
3. IDOE educator-license lookup (LVIS). OPEN. Whether an Indiana educator license stands in her name and whether any action has been taken on it. Closes the license gap in §06.
4. Indiana sex-offender registry listing. OPEN. The registration condition of her sentences, checked against the registry itself — including whether the listing followed the reported transfer of her probation to New Hampshire.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 11, 2026.
The sentencing order in the Hamilton County case, obtained and quoted in the reporting relied on here: guilty plea to one count of child seduction as a Level 5 felony; four years imposed, 40 days executed, 1,420 days suspended to probation; 40 days of jail credit — 30 actual days served (July 4, 2025, and April 16–May 14, 2026) and 10 days of good-time credit. Named in: Intro, §04.
The chronological case summaries for Hamilton County cause 29D03-2506-F5-005476 (Hamilton Superior Court 3, filed June 30, 2025, decided May 14, 2026) and Marion County cause 49D32-2511-F5-033640 (Marion Superior Court 32, filed November 3, 2025, decided May 22, 2026), pulled from Indiana MyCase on November 11, 2026. They carry: both cause numbers; Hamilton Count 2 dismissed at the May 14, 2026 plea and the Count 1 sentence terms (four-year IDOC term, 40 days executed, 1,420 days suspended, 40 days jail credit); the Marion plea by agreement of May 22, 2026, its sentence (1,460 days imposed, 40 executed, 1,420 suspended to probation, probation term 1,460 days, concurrent with the Hamilton sentence), and Marion Count 2 dismissed per the plea agreement (Order Granting Motion to Dismiss, May 26, 2026). One Hamilton sentence comment is truncated in the public display; the truncation is noted where the comment is used. Named in: Intro, §03, §04, §05, §07.
Independent review of the court records of both counties: the Hamilton County plea and sentence terms in full; charges in both counties; the admission in the police interview. Named in: Intro, §02, §03, §04.
The probable-cause affidavit as reported: the April 10, 2025 discovery and the staff alert to police; her recorded admission (“I was having an inappropriate relationship with a student from our school”); the April 16, 2025 phone contact and the New Hampshire statement; the affidavit’s filing on June 12, 2025; charges filed June 30, 2025 in Hamilton Superior Court 3. Named in: Intro, §01, §02, §03.
Two felony counts of child seduction filed by the Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office on June 30, 2025; arrest warrant issued July 1, 2025; bond set at $15,000. Named in: §03.
The school’s May 14, 2026 statement: staff awareness on April 10, 2025; immediate action; the teacher placed on leave; the Indiana Department of Child Services and IMPD contacted. Principal Fry’s statement: the teacher “was terminated soon after the allegations came to light”; the school’s commitment to student safety and full cooperation. Named in: §02, §03.
The Marion County procedural record as shown online: plea agreement filed February 24, 2026; the March 11, 2026 jury-trial setting lost; the change-of-plea hearing set for May 22, 2026; the two Marion counts described by prosecutors as additional and separate. Also the publisher of the booking photograph used at the head of this file, credited to the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office. Named in: §03, §05.
The Hamilton County plea and sentence; the sentence conditions as reported from the court records — sex-offender registration and treatment. Named in: §04.
Its core account — guilty plea to one of the two Marion County counts, the second count dismissed, an identical sentence concurrent with Hamilton County’s — is now confirmed by the Marion County docket (see the DOCKET card above) and is no longer carried on this source. Two details rest on this summary alone and remain carried as reported in §05: sex-offender treatment and registration in the Marion disposition, and probation transferred to New Hampshire. Named in: §05.
IC 35-42-4-7 (child seduction — a professional or child care worker and a student; Level 5 felony) and IC 35-50-2-6 (Level 5 felony sentencing range: one to six years, advisory three). Named in: §01, §04.