
On the Fourth of July, 2026, an eighteen-year-old from Ocean Springs, Mississippi rode a boat to Horn Island with his friends and did not come home. His body was found on the island’s shoreline two days later. In the weeks that followed, his death became one of the most argued-about stories in America — and the argument ran far ahead of the record.
This file is the record. What it establishes is narrower than the argument, and it matters more: Nolan Xavier Wells, 18, was last recorded on a boat at 2:23 p.m. on July 4 and last seen at about 3 p.m. The boat that carried his friends off the island left at 4:31 p.m. without him. He was reported missing that night and found on the morning of July 6, identified by his dental records. The Mississippi State Medical Examiner left his cause and manner of death undetermined. So did the pathologist his own family hired. And in September 2026, a Jackson County grand jury that heard 43 witnesses under 132 subpoenas — GPS data, phone extractions, photographs, video, including material the family’s own legal team turned over — unanimously returned no true bill: the death was consistent with drowning, there was no credible evidence that anyone on the boats committed a crime, and there was no credible evidence of racial motivation.
The claims that filled the silence — that he was beaten to death, that he was held at a judge’s house, that a sitting judge was “in on it” — are printed in this file the only way they will ever be printed here: attributed to the people who made them, and answered by the record in the same breath (§07). The one official act in this story that drew a formal public challenge — a judge’s own public statement about the active investigation — has its own file: File No. 121, the Ashlee Cole File.
One rule governs every line: the young people who were on those boats are referred to in this file by role only — no names, no initials, no detail that could point to any of them. Their ages are not established by any primary source in the record, and one of them is reported to be seventeen. They are not the subjects of this file, and they will not be made subjects by a caption. The subjects are the paper: what happened, what two autopsies could not determine, and what a grand jury found.
Nolan Xavier Wells was born August 19, 2007. He was eighteen years old, a member of the Ocean Springs High School class of 2025, and a wide receiver wearing number 16 for the Southwest Mississippi Community College Bears in Summit, Mississippi. The photograph at the top of this file is his college’s own picture of him in that uniform, published by Our Mississippi Home in its remembrance of “the young man behind the jersey.”
He went to Horn Island on July 4, 2026 with a group of friends from home, to a barrier island off the Mississippi Gulf Coast where hundreds of people gather on the holiday. Nothing in the verified record of that day begins with anything but an ordinary trip: boats, friends, a summer afternoon. What the record holds after that is §02.
His parents, Christine Wells-Wonsley and Elmore Wonsley of Ocean Springs, have spoken publicly throughout this case, and their own account of their son — and their refusal to accept the official outcome — runs through §05 on their own words as reported. They are named here because they made themselves public advocates in this matter on the record. Their son’s friends did not, and the difference is the rule stated in the introduction.
The documented timeline of July 4, 2026, as the reporting and the grand jury’s record establish it, is this. Wells traveled by boat with friends to Horn Island, a barrier island in the Gulf off the Mississippi coast, for an Independence Day gathering attended by hundreds of people. He was last recorded on a boat at 2:23 p.m. and last seen at about 3 p.m.
The friends’ boat took on water — a bilge pump failure. They called Sea Tow at about 4 p.m.; another boater towed the boat 2.75 miles, per the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources’ account carried in the reporting, and the friends’ boat departed the island at 4:31 p.m. — the GPS record fixes that time — without Wells.
Why he was not on it is the point on which the two public accounts divide, and this file prints both as accounts. The friends’ account — given publicly by the stepmother of one of them in her July 7 statement (§07 and File No. 121), and by that friend himself in on-record interviews afterward — is that Wells chose to stay on the island, with a young woman he had met there, and planned to return inland later with another group of friends. Wells’s parents, and another friend who was present, have said that separating from the group would have been out of character for him. Neither account is a finding. The grand jury that heard the witnesses under subpoena made its findings in September; they are §06.
That night, at about 11 p.m., one of the friends called Wells’s parents. His parents reported him missing that night. Using a tracking application, they located his phone and his car keys with a friend on the mainland — a fact that matters later in this file, because a viral version of it grew into a claim about a phone held “hostage.” The record version is in §05.
The search for Nolan Wells ran two days, coordinated by the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office with the U.S. Coast Guard, the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources, the National Park Service, and the United Cajun Navy. On the morning of July 6, 2026, a park ranger found his body on the island’s shoreline. He was identified by dental records — one detail of the viral telling that the record confirms exactly.
The first official words about the death were the sheriff’s and the coroner’s, and they were narrow. Jackson County Sheriff John Ledbetter said there were no signs of foul play and that drowning was suspected. Jackson County Coroner Bruce Lynd noted no obvious signs of physical injury, and the dangerous currents in the waters around the island.
Suspected is not determined. What the medical record could and could not say is §04 — and it is the honest center of this whole file: on the paper that exists, how Nolan Wells died is a question two autopsies left open.
Two separate autopsies examined Nolan Wells. They reached the same bottom line, and it was not drowning, and it was not homicide. It was undetermined — twice.
The Mississippi State Medical Examiner listed both the cause and the manner of death as undetermined. The body bore two bruises, one of them on the back of the head — and, in the grand jury findings as reported, neither bruise was deemed fatal.
The family’s independent pathologist, Dr. Roger A. Mitchell Jr. of Howard University Hospital, likewise found the manner of death undetermined. His examination found no bone fractures and no deep-tissue injuries, and he assessed the body’s position and condition as consistent with drowning. The family released the state autopsy on September 24, 2026, pointing to details they read as unanswered questions — no fluid or debris in the airways, and an empty stomach.
That is the whole of the medical paper, and this file does not widen it in either direction. The bruises are real and documented. Their meaning is disputed. The official medical answer, from the State’s examiner and the family’s own expert alike, is that the cause and manner of this death are undetermined — and every claim in §07 is measured against that sentence.
The Wells family did not accept the first official account, and they built an inquiry of their own. On July 7, 2026 they retained civil-rights attorney Benjamin Crump, with Mississippi co-counsel Gary Bufkin of Carroll Bufkin PLLC; the NAACP joined the family’s team in August. Their work produced the case’s sharpest public disputes — and this file carries those disputes as disputes, each side in its own words as reported.
The island video. Crump’s team circulated a video from the island and read a shouting voice on it as Wells’s — “Give me my freaking phone.” A friend who was there answered on the record in Rolling Stone (Lorena O’Neil, July 12, 2026): the voice is his, not Wells’s — “Get me off this f–king boat” — the argument was his own dispute, and Wells was not involved in it. His girlfriend and his uncle corroborated him; another friend told TMZ a fight happened on the island but did not involve Wells. The readings stand opposed on the record; no official finding adopts either.
The pool photograph. A group pool photograph that circulated widely as an image of the July events was, according to the friend with Wells in it — speaking to Rolling Stone and ABC News — taken on June 27, 2026, a week before Wells died. A photograph from a different day is not evidence about July 4, and this file does not use it.
The phone. The family’s digital-forensics expert, Andrew Garrett of Garrett Discovery, reported at the family’s September 24–25, 2026 news conference that he recovered nearly 300 Snaps from Wells’s phone and found that certain messages sent to Wells had been unsent or deleted by their senders, with interactions on the account before and after Wells’s death until the family retrieved the phone. District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath answered that the activity Garrett described came from other Snapchat users’ accounts, not from Wells’s phone; the friends’ attorney Edward Paltzik stated the friends never had the phone. The documented fact underneath the dispute is §02’s: the family retrieved the phone the night of July 4 from a friend on the mainland, located by a tracking app. Nothing in the reporting supports a taking by force, and the word “hostage” belongs to the claim stream answered in §07.
The family has called for a federal investigation of the death, a call publicly supported by U.S. Representatives Maxine Waters and Frederica Wilson and pressed at an October 5, 2026 Crump event. As of this file’s last check, no federal investigation of the death itself has been announced. What federal court has taken up is the threats — §08.
The question the public argument could not settle went to the body built to settle it. From September 14 to September 18, 2026, a Jackson County grand jury heard this case: 43 witnesses, testifying under 132 subpoenas. The panel reviewed GPS data, cellphone extractions, photographs and video — including material the family’s own legal team turned over to it.
On September 21, 2026, District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath announced the result: the grand jury unanimously returned no true bill. Its findings, as reported from its report, were these: the death was consistent with drowning; there was no credible evidence that anyone on the boats committed a crime; and there was no credible evidence of racial motivation. The report leaves the door open: if credible new evidence emerges, the matter can return to a grand jury — and the reporting on the report notes there is no statute of limitations on a homicide case, should one ever be made.
McIlrath defended the investigation that produced the case. The family rejects the outcome, and continues to press for federal review (§05). Both of those facts are printed here because both are on the record.
What the no-bill is, exactly: it is not a medical finding — the medical finding remains undetermined (§04) — and it is not a ruling that nothing happened on Horn Island. It is a grand jury’s unanimous judgment, after hearing everyone, that the evidence does not credibly show a crime by anyone who was on those boats. Every claim in the next section is measured against it.
This file exists in part because of a claim stream. Its specimen is a 108-second commentary reel posted July 13, 2026 by the page TyC, titled on screen “NOLAN WELLS UPDATE / THE JUDGE WAS IN ON IT” — one video among thousands, chosen here because it states the stream’s claims in their plainest form. Each claim below is printed as its maker’s claim, and answered by the record in the same breath. None of them is printed as fact anywhere in this file, and none belongs in a headline.
The claim: “The judge was in on it” — that Chancery Judge Ashlee Cole was involved in Wells’s death. The record: the grand jury, after 43 witnesses, found no credible evidence of criminal conduct by anyone on the boats (§06). No reporting pulled for this file contains any evidence placing the judge in the events of July 4 at all; her documented connection to the day is that a member of her family was in the friend group — and her own public statement about it, which is File No. 121’s subject.
The claim: “They didn’t let Nolan leave the judge’s house.” The record: no reporting places Wells at the judge’s house at any point. The documented timeline places him on Horn Island — last recorded on a boat at 2:23 p.m., last seen about 3 p.m., the friends’ boat departing at 4:31 p.m. (§02).
The claim: the judge “was drinking with these kids and doing drugs.” The record: no news report contains any such allegation from any named source. The judge stated that she and her husband were not on Horn Island that weekend.
The claim: Wells was beaten to death. The record: both autopsies — the State’s and the family’s own — left the cause and manner of death undetermined; the family’s pathologist found no fractures or deep-tissue injuries and assessed the body’s condition as consistent with drowning; the two documented bruises were deemed non-fatal (§04).
The claim, by presentation: that the circulated pool photograph shows the July events. The record: a participant in the photograph dates it to June 27, 2026, a week before the death (§05).
The claim: an “initiation” — a hazing. The record: no reporting and no official statement supports any hazing theory, and the grand jury’s findings stand against it (§06).
The summary of the case written by Wikipedia’s editors, indexing the reporting, is the fair one: this death “has also been subject to misinformation, conspiracy theories, harassment, and threats.” The harassment and threats were not abstractions. They produced federal criminal cases, and those are real paper — §08.
The online frenzy around this death did not stay online. Judge Cole reported threats to her home and to her court — including a mail-bomb threat — by July 9, 2026. Her husband told the New York Post the family received thousands of “credible” death threats. Witnesses were threatened. Wells’s own mother was harassed — a flood of bad reviews aimed at her job, hateful messages mailed to her home, as the Clarion Ledger reported. Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch and Department of Public Safety Commissioner Sean Tindell both warned publicly that threatening officials and witnesses is a crime.
Four out-of-state defendants now face federal charges arising out of those threats. Each case below is printed as the record stands: charges are allegations, each defendant is presumed innocent, and no outcome is printed for any of them — the outcomes are open docket items (§09, NW-01), and this file prints none.
| Defendant | Charge as reported | The allegation | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joseph Alfredo Vasquez Dumarce, 27, of Sacramento, California | Interstate transmission of a threatening communication (18 U.S.C. § 875(c)) — up to five years and a $250,000 fine, per the Clarion Ledger | Facebook Messenger threats to Judge Cole from an account with the username “yaeyae962,” including a threat that a package containing a bomb would be sent to her office and threats against her children; the FBI tied the account to him. The charging papers identify the judge by the initials “A.C.” The Clarion Ledger, via the Sun Herald, also reports his prior California convictions in 2019 and 2020 on sex-related offenses involving minors. | Indicted; a trial setting of November 2, 2026 was reported. Outcome: OPEN. |
| Edward James Porter, 32, of Berwyn, Illinois | Interstate transmission of a threatening communication (18 U.S.C. § 875(c)), per federal criminal complaint 1:26-mj-00669-RPM | On July 31, 2026, repeated calls and texts to two witnesses — a member of the friend group and his father — threatening to kill them and their families, sending one witness his own home address and claiming to be outside the home. The witnesses are referred to here by role only, under this file’s rule. | Indicted in August 2026; a trial setting of October 5, 2026 was reported. Outcome: OPEN. |
| Michelle Francine Edwards, 41, of Cincinnati, Ohio | Transmitting a threatening communication in interstate commerce (18 U.S.C. § 844(e)), per federal criminal complaint 1:26-mj-00657-RPM — a charge carrying up to ten years, per the Cincinnati Enquirer | On July 23, 2026, more than twenty blocked-number calls in about eight minutes to the George County Chancery Clerk’s Office and about eight more to the Jackson County Sheriff’s Department — “Do not go outside,” “the clock is ticking,” “die,” and a claim of a bomb outside the sheriff’s office. | Charged by complaint, July 2026. Outcome: OPEN. |
| Brandon Ephraim Washington, 30, of Jacksonville, Florida | Federal threat charges, as reported by the Sun Herald and the Enterprise-Journal | Threatening calls and messages to two witnesses — the boater who towed the friends’ boat and his father, per the family’s attorney — threatening to kidnap or injure. Arrested August 12, 2026. | Expected to face prosecution in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming, where the alleged conduct occurred. Outcome: OPEN. |
One further piece of paper belongs in this section because it disciplines everything around it: the announced civil litigation. The judge’s husband has said he intends to sue attorney Benjamin Crump for slandering his son; the friends’ attorney Tyler Cox has said he plans a defamation suit against Rev. Al Sharpton, who denies defaming anyone; and Crump’s team has sent the friends and some of their relatives letters directing them not to delete records and declaring an intent to sue. Suits announced are not suits filed, and this file prints them as announcements. But they are a standing instruction to anyone writing about this case — this file included — to print nothing the paper does not hold.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
A PACER docket check on each threat case in §08 — Dumarce, Porter, Edwards, and Washington. Trial settings of October 5 and November 2, 2026 were reported for the two indicted Mississippi cases; no outcome for any of the four stands in the reporting this file could reach, and §08 prints none. Any verdict, plea, or dismissal updates §08 at this address.
The Jackson County grand jury’s report as released — the document behind the findings quoted in §06. This file’s account of the findings rests on the District Attorney’s September 21, 2026 announcement and the reporting that carried the report’s language; the report itself raises every finding to its proper grade.
Whether the Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance has taken any action on the petition concerning Judge Cole’s July 7 statement. No action appears in any reporting through this file’s last check. The question is File No. 121’s spine and is tracked there (§07, AC-01).
The family’s call for a federal investigation of the death itself (§05). No such investigation has been announced in the reporting; if one opens — or is formally declined — this file updates §05 and §06.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. This file is built from the official outcome as announced and the reporting that carried the underlying documents; the open pulls that would raise its grades are listed in §09. Last checked November 14, 2026.
District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath’s announcement that the grand jury (September 14–18, 2026; 43 witnesses; 132 subpoenas) unanimously returned no true bill — death consistent with drowning; no credible evidence of criminal conduct by anyone on the boats; no credible evidence of racial motivation; the matter open to credible new evidence. Reported by Mississippi Today and the Clarion Ledger (Mina Corpuz’s reporting carried by the Enterprise-Journal), the Sun Herald (Elise Gregg and Madeline Halpert, September 22, 2026), and the BBC. Named in: Intro, §03, §06, §07.
“Judge gets threats over Wells case. Husband says Crump slanders his son.” The July 7 statement quoted verbatim; the petition and its roughly 3,500 signatures; the threats against the judge, the family, the witnesses, and Wells’s mother; the Attorney General’s and DPS Commissioner’s warnings; the Dumarce charge and its penalties; the announced defamation litigation. Read in full for this build. Named in: §05, §07, §08.
“What Really Happened in the Last Known Video of Nolan Wells.” The friend’s on-record account that the shouting voice in the island video is his, not Wells’s; the June 27, 2026 date of the circulated pool photograph, per a participant. Named in: §05, §07.
The Porter complaint (1:26-mj-00669-RPM) and the Edwards complaint (1:26-mj-00657-RPM), U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, as carried in published reporting and posted court documents; the Cincinnati Enquirer, August 1, 2026 (Edwards’s charge and its ten-year maximum); the Enterprise-Journal’s trial-dates report (Dumarce and Porter indicted; Washington’s Wyoming posture); AP reporting, August 2026, on the first three threat arrests. Outcomes unverified — see §09, NW-01. Named in: §08.
The July 4 timeline — last recorded on a boat 2:23 p.m.; last seen about 3 p.m.; the bilge-pump failure and tow; the 4:31 p.m. GPS departure; the two-day search and the July 6 recovery — as carried by WLOX (Gray) and the sourced chronology of the case. Wikipedia’s “Death of Nolan Wells” was used in this build as an index to the reporting above, not as a source of record, and is named as exactly that. Named in: §02, §03.
Wells in his Southwest Mississippi Community College uniform, number 16, published in Our Mississippi Home’s “Remembering the Young Man Behind the Jersey: Nolan Wells,” credited to the college. Saved from the published article; SHA-256 recorded in this build’s photo note. Named in: the File page caption, §01.