United States v. Cory Newland and Joshua Titus, Cause No. 2:19-cr-23, U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana (Hammond). One count: deprivation of rights under color of law, 18 U.S.C. § 242, and aiding and abetting, 18 U.S.C. § 2 — unreasonable force against a detainee, alleging bodily injury. Status: DECIDED — guilty plea; 12 months and one day in federal prison, plus 1 year of supervised release.
The indictment. A federal grand jury indicted Titus and Newland in March 2019; the indictment was filed March 21, 2019, and the Justice Department announced it March 22, 2019. The charge carried a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. The FBI's Indianapolis Field Office investigated.
The plea. Titus had been scheduled to stand trial the following week; instead, in March 2023, he pleaded guilty to the civil-rights charge (ProPublica and Associated Press reporting; the exact day, March 30, 2023, rests on a single compilation and is printed at that grade). No Justice Department release on the plea was located.
The sentence. U.S. District Judge Phillip P. Simon sentenced Titus, then 34, to 12 months and one day in federal prison, followed by 1 year of supervised release (U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Indiana — release, October 12, 2023). The Department's release is dated October 12, 2023 and says Titus was "sentenced today"; this file prints October 12, 2023 as the sentencing date on that basis — the release's own date. The Associated Press reported the sentencing on a Thursday, and October 12, 2023 was a Thursday, which corroborates the date; it is not printed as a docket-verified fact.
"When officers abuse their power by assaulting handcuffed and defenseless arrestees, it erodes the public trust and tarnishes the reputation police officers everywhere. No one is above the law, and the Justice Department will continue to ensure that officers who violate the rights of individuals in their custody are held accountable."
— Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke, Civil Rights Division, U.S. Department of Justice sentencing release.
This is the Justice Department's account, from its sentencing release, of what the court documents establish. On January 12, 2018, while on duty, fellow officer Cory Newland assisted in the arrest of a detainee and transported him to the booking area at the Elkhart Police Department. The detainee was placed in a chair with his hands handcuffed behind his back, with both arms behind the back of the chair.
While seated, the detainee spat in the direction of Newland — at which point both Titus and Newland began punching him in the face, causing him to fall backwards onto the concrete floor. Titus and Newland then hunched over him and punched him approximately 10 more times in the face and body. The count matters and this file prints it the Department's way: the approximately ten punches came after the fall, in addition to the punches that caused it.
"Both former officers have acknowledged that they knew at the time of the assault that their use of force on M.L. was unjustified and unlawful under the circumstances." (U.S. Department of Justice, verbatim.)
The detainee's name. The Justice Department's releases identify him by initials only — "M.L." The name Mario Guerrero-Ledesma runs on the State's charging record and the South Bend Tribune and ProPublica reporting. Passages in this file that quote the Department keep the Department's initials; elsewhere he is named on that attribution. His own case arising from that day's arrest — a guilty plea in July 2018, reported by the Tribune and ProPublica — is context only. It mitigates nothing, and this file does not use it to.
How the public saw it. The beating was captured on the station's detention-area video. The Tribune obtained the video by records request — filed after a reporter noticed discrepancies between what the chief told the Police Merit Commission and what personnel records said — and the Tribune and ProPublica published it in November 2018 (Tribune/ProPublica reporting).
State of Indiana v. Joshua Titus, filed as Cause No. 20H01-1811-CM-009139, later carried as 20D05-1901-CM-000111. Charged November 2018: Class A misdemeanor Battery Resulting in Bodily Injury. Status: DISMISSED BY THE STATE, May 9, 2019 — "without prejudice" (the docket's own words).
Reported context for the timing — attributed, and kept separate from the docket fact. The Associated Press reported in May 2019 that the Elkhart County prosecutor's office announced the state charges were being dismissed following a request from federal prosecutors, so the federal case could proceed. The dismissal and the federal conviction sit side by side in this file — neither swallows the other.
The rank. Through the 2018–2019 coverage, Titus was a Corporal (Tribune/ProPublica reporting). State compensation data, as compiled by a salary database, lists him as Corporal in 2017 and as Investigator-Acting in 2018 — a single-source compilation of the official dataset, printed at that grade; the personnel production now running (§07) supersedes it.
His hire year is not in this file, because it was not found. Searched November 6, 2026: the Justice Department's releases give ages only, and the coverage in hand gives no hire year for Titus. The "hired in 2008" line in that coverage belongs to his co-defendant, Cory Newland. It is not borrowed here.
June 2018 — written reprimand for the January 12, 2018 beating, alongside Newland's; no suspension, no demotion (Tribune/ProPublica). Chief Ed Windbigler, explaining the reprimands to the Police Merit Commission, said Titus "had no previous complaints" — printed as the chief's stated rationale at the time, not as a verified statement of Titus's complete disciplinary history, which the production in §07 will establish.
Leave. Administrative leave when the state charges were announced in November 2018 — paid, per NPR's account of the Tribune reporting — and unpaid administrative leave in early April 2019, after the federal indictment (Board of Public Safety, as reported).
Separation. The Associated Press's sentencing coverage states, of both men, that they "later resigned from the Elkhart Police Department after being placed on unpaid administrative leave." That single formulation, at reported grade, is all the record in hand holds for Titus: his separation date was not found (searched November 6, 2026). One date is fenced off plainly: the well-documented resignation of August 30, 2022 — the day of the plea, confirmed by the department's spokesperson — is Newland's resignation. It is not Titus's, and this file never carries it as his.
At his sentencing hearing in Hammond, as reported by ProPublica (Ken Armstrong, October 30, 2023), Titus expressed gratitude for the video being made public by the Tribune and ProPublica. He said he had been dealing with severe post-traumatic stress disorder from his service in the Air Force. "I was in denial of my psychological issues," he said, adding that the video's release "opened my eyes and gave me a renewing of my soul," and that publication "helped change the culture at the Elkhart Police Department."
His attorney, Mike Allen of Cincinnati, a former police officer, told ProPublica: "He's a good man that served his country, and served his country well and honorably, who made a mistake and is now paying for it."
These are Titus's and his counsel's own statements, as reported from the hearing — printed attributed, in their mouths. They are not a medical finding, and this file does not carry them as mitigation in its own voice. The Air Force service itself is established only through these reported statements; no service record is in hand. Reached by phone by ProPublica in April 2023, after his plea, Titus said: "You'll have to speak with my attorney about that, bud." His attorney declined to comment (ProPublica).
His photograph. The portrait at the top of this file is his Elkhart Police Department portrait, published by ProPublica on October 30, 2023 in its sentencing story, captioned "Elkhart, Indiana, police officer Joshua Titus (Obtained from Elkhart Police Department)" — a police-provided department photo, published and captioned as him, the first-choice class of photograph under this file's standard. His official portrait is also expected inside the City of Elkhart production now running (§07); when it lands, it is checked against the published one.
Also not found (searched November 6, 2026): his hire year or appointment date; his separation date or any Board action fixing it (§04); any discipline, assignment, or commendation detail beyond the June 2018 reprimand and the chief's statement about it; and any Justice Department release on his plea. The gaps are named here so the production in §07 can close them one by one.
This file is a living file, and these are the pulls now running to complete it. Each answer lands here as a dated update at this same address — including the answers that help him.
| Filed | Request | Status |
|---|---|---|
| November 6, 2026 | City of Elkhart (city portal) — whole-file APRA: his complete personnel, discipline and internal-affairs file, including the January 12, 2018 incident file; his official portrait and certification record ride in this production | Filed — portal filing Id 45974ad8-59d1-41f5-a621-b4fb64d5ddc0 |
| Read November 6, 2026 | Court records: Indiana MyCase dockets 20H01-1811-CM-009139 / 20D05-1901-CM-000111 (state charge and dismissal); U.S. Department of Justice releases and the federal indictment in 2:19-cr-23 (plea and sentence) | Read — §01, §03 |
The City's production — the personnel file, the separation paper, and the portrait — is the next paper this file is watching for.
Joshua Titus was an Elkhart police officer — a corporal, by the reporting that covered his case. On January 12, 2018, in the booking area of his own station, he and a fellow officer punched a handcuffed detainee in the face until the man fell backward onto the concrete floor, then punched him approximately ten more times. The station video recorded it. Both officers have acknowledged, in the Justice Department's words, that they knew at the time that their use of force was unjustified and unlawful.
Two governments prosecuted him, and this file prints both endings at the same size. The State of Indiana charged him with battery in November 2018 — and dismissed its own case on May 9, 2019, "without prejudice," in the docket's own words. The federal government indicted him in March 2019, and the civil-rights charge he pleaded guilty to in March 2023 put him in federal prison for 12 months and a day. Neither outcome erases the other. Where the record is a newsroom's account rather than a document in hand, this file says so. Where a claim cannot be verified, it does not run.
STATE CASE DISMISSED: State of Indiana v. Joshua Titus, 20H01-1811-CM-009139, carried as 20D05-1901-CM-000111 — Class A misdemeanor Battery Resulting in Bodily Injury, charged November 2018, DISMISSED BY THE STATE on May 9, 2019, "without prejudice" (the docket's words). FEDERAL CASE DECIDED: United States v. Newland and Titus, 2:19-cr-23 — deprivation of rights under color of law (18 U.S.C. § 242) and aiding and abetting (§ 2); guilty plea March 2023; sentenced to 12 months and one day in federal prison, followed by 1 year of supervised release (U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Indiana — release, October 12, 2023). Records now running: his complete EPD file, requested November 6, 2026.
Every file in this series is built the same way: public records, exhibited in full, and nothing in them that the paper does not say. Finish one file, and the next is waiting — the loop does not close.
Every document this file names, where it lives, and what state it is in — in one place. Hosted means the paper itself is on this page. A docket entry means this file read the court's own chronological case summary and cites it; the docket lives at the court's portal, not here. Reporting is labeled reporting — it is never dressed up as a primary document. Anything missing is labeled missing, in plain words. Register checked November 7, 2026.
Full-size copy hosted on this page — in hand.
Hosted in this file · Named in: File home · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
At the official source — linked from this file. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
U.S. Department of Justice · Named in: §01 — The Federal Case — Decided · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the public docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it at the official MyCase portal: search the case number. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
Indiana Judicial Branch — MyCase · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the public docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it at the official MyCase portal: search the case number. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
Indiana Judicial Branch — MyCase · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the federal docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it through PACER: search the case number. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana — PACER · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
November 6, 2026 — City of Elkhart (city portal) — whole-file APRA: his complete personnel, discipline and internal-affairs file, including the January 12, 2018 incident file; his official portrait and certification record ride in this production — Filed — portal filing Id 45974ad8-59d1-41f5-a621-b4fb64d5ddc0
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Read November 6, 2026 — Court records : Indiana MyCase dockets 20H01-1811-CM-009139 / 20D05-1901-CM-000111 (state charge and dismissal); U.S. Department of Justice releases and the federal indictment in 2:19-cr-23 (plea and sentence) — Read — §01, §03
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Anything else this file names in its text that does not appear in this register is not hosted here yet — it stands in the file as reporting or as a records request until the paper itself is in hand, and this register is updated when it lands.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
NONE DOCUMENTED YET. If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.