
This is the case file for United States v. James Benjamin Gosnell Jr. — the matter, whole: how a sitting Charleston County, South Carolina magistrate judge came to the attention of federal agents through his own payments; how he confessed at his own front door on September 16, 2025; how his state’s supreme court suspended him the same day; how the case moved through complaint, indictment, a denied suppression motion, and two guilty pleas — his own, on July 2, 2026, and his Florida co-conspirator’s, on May 28, 2026; and where the record stops. The man is File No. 142, THE JAMES GOSNELL FILE; the co-conspirator is File No. 144, THE JOHN THORPE FILE.
The verified spine is short and hard. A CyberTip about payments to a known vendor. A search warrant at the judge’s home, and a confession. A second warrant at his chambers. Thousands of files. Six counts. A guilty plea to possession and distribution, carrying five to forty years. Around that spine sits a second layer — the government’s detention-brief allegations drawn from the defendant’s own chat messages — which was never charged, is not in either plea, and which the defendant denied on the record at his plea hearing. This file keeps the two layers separate everywhere, grades the second on its face at §05, and prints at §06 what the record does not establish at all — including the fact that no state charge has ever been located, and that no official who worked this case committed any misconduct: the roster named across these files is the roster of the people who caught him.
Homeland Security Investigations received a CyberTip — the reporting channel run by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, fed here by PayPal’s reporting — showing payments from accounts of Charleston County Magistrate James Gosnell to a known vendor of child sexual abuse material: two payments on November 4, 2024 from an account created that day, annotated “vid”, and three more the same day from a second account (detention brief, Doc. 18, case 2:25-mj-00068, banked with this file’s build records; U.S. Attorney’s Office releases). The investigation that followed was HSI’s; HSI Carolinas Special Agent in Charge Mark M. Zito is the agency’s quoted official. The individual case agent who swore the complaint affidavit is not named in any material pulled — an open pull at §07.
On September 16, 2025, HSI executed a federal search warrant at Gosnell’s Charleston home. Per the detention brief, he met the agents at the door, asked if they “knew who he was,” led them to a USB drive plugged into his computer, told them it held hundreds of videos of child sexual abuse material, and — post-Miranda — confessed to possessing the material and attempting to purchase it, admitting Telegram conversations with “like-minded individuals.” Agents seized more than thirteen additional flash drives, an iPhone, computers, discs, and VHS tapes; forensic review found thousands of files, put at plea-hearing reporting at more than 3,700 images and videos. The next day, September 17, 2025, a second warrant was executed at his court chambers at the Charleston County Magistrate Court, where bank records were seized.
The same day as the home search, the Supreme Court of South Carolina suspended him (Appellate Case No. 2025-001884, Rule 17(b) RJDE, signed by Chief Justice John W. Kittredge), finding his continued service “a substantial threat of serious harm to the public and the administration of justice”; multiple outlets report he resigned September 17, 2025.
His custody ran through two jails: the Charleston County Jail (Al Cannon Detention Center) from September 16 to 26, 2025, then the Williamsburg County Detention Center, where he remains. His recorded jailhouse calls from the Charleston week were later obtained and aired by WCSC’s Live 5 Investigates in February 2026; in them he maintains the chats were fantasy while conceding the material was real, and sums up his own position in a recorded line: “I’m going to be their poster boy.”
The complaint. Gosnell was arrested September 16, 2025 on a criminal complaint charging possession of child pornography, 18 U.S.C. § 2252A (complaint case 2:25-mj-00068), appeared initially before U.S. Magistrate Judge Molly Cherry, and waived his detention hearing on September 22, 2025 — the hearing at which the government filed the detention brief carried at §05.
The indictment. Unsealed October 22, 2025: six counts — possession involving a prepubescent minor; three counts of receipt and attempted receipt; conspiracy to receive and distribute; and distribution. He pleaded not guilty; Judge Cherry presided over the indictment arraignment (October 23, 2025, per WCBD). The indicted case number was not established in any record pulled and stands open at §07.
The suppression fight. In March 2026, U.S. District Judge Richard M. Gergel denied Gosnell’s motion to suppress the search-warrant evidence (WCSC reporting).
The pleas. The co-conspirator went first: John Badger Thorpe, 69, of Fort Lauderdale, Florida — who had received Gosnell at his home in the summer of 2024 for the flash-drive exchange at the center of the distribution count, and mailed the drive back to Charleston by FedEx — pleaded guilty on May 28, 2026 to conspiracy to receive and distribute, and two counts of distribution (File No. 144). On July 2, 2026, Gosnell pleaded guilty to counts 1 and 6; the remaining four counts are to be dismissed at sentencing under his plea agreement. Judge Gergel accepted both pleas and will sentence both men after the U.S. Probation Office’s presentence reports. The prosecution of record: U.S. Attorney Bryan P. Stirling, with Assistant U.S. Attorneys Katherine Orville (who signed the detention brief), Emily Limehouse, and Whit Sowards. Prosecutors state they will seek Gosnell’s maximum — forty years.
No sentencing has occurred for either man as of this file’s build, November 14, 2026, and no sentencing date has been announced in any record pulled. Both files carry the watch, not a date.
In October 2025, HSI and the U.S. Attorney publicly appealed for potential victims to come forward, publishing a dedicated tip line (Charleston_exploitationtips@hsi.dhs.gov) under the heading “Federal Investigators Seek Public’s Help Identifying Possible Victims in Charleston County Magistrate Case” (U.S. Attorney’s Office release, October 2025). The appeal is part of this case’s public record and prints here in full context: no victim has been publicly identified, and no contact-offense charge has followed it — not in the indictment, not in either plea, and not in any coverage through this file’s build. The appeal’s existence is a fact; what it has produced, on the public record, is nothing the government has charged.
The government’s detention brief (Doc. 18, September 22, 2025) quoted Gosnell’s own Telegram messages to argue dangerousness. Per that filing, his messages claimed contact abuse of infants — children described as three months, five months, and two weeks old — a trip account from Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, sessions teaching others, and a planned future trip to Florida with his co-conspirator. The brief’s graphic descriptions are characterized here, not reproduced. Grade for every item in this paragraph: ALLEGED IN A FEDERAL FILING — a party’s characterization of the defendant’s own chat statements, offered at a detention hearing.
What stands against that layer, in the same breath, is also a matter of record. None of it was charged — the indictment’s six counts concern the material alone. None of it is in either guilty plea. And at his plea hearing, Gosnell stated: “I just want the court to know, I never touched a child or had the intentions of touching a child” (as reported by WCSC). The viral post that carried this story built its headline out of the first paragraph of this section and printed it as accomplished fact; the headline is, at the record’s grade, overstated — and its claim that the two men traveled to Texas is FAILED: the filing describes a plan discussed in chats for a future Florida trip that was never taken, and Florida is the state the filing names.
One piece of public adjacency belongs here, at its grade, because it cannot be understood out of the case’s public life: Rep. Nancy Mace publicly praised a Gosnell bond-hearing ruling on August 20, 2025 — twenty-seven days before the arrest — condemned him after it, and in a September 1, 2026 clip publicly insinuated the same uncharged contact abuse graded above. She holds no role in this case; her statements are context for the case’s public weather, and the insinuation carries the identical grade as the filing it echoes — alleged, uncharged, and denied.
No state charge. September 2025 reporting said South Carolina charges were expected, and the detention brief mentioned possible state Criminal Sexual Conduct with a Minor, First Degree. No state charge has been located in any record or coverage through this file’s build. Neither this file nor File No. 142 states or implies that Gosnell was charged by the state with anything.
No identified victim of a contact offense. The October 2025 public appeal stands; no victim has been publicly identified, and no contact-offense charge exists in the record pulled.
No sentence. Neither man has been sentenced; no sentencing date has been announced in any record pulled. Any date printed anywhere for either sentencing is not from this record.
No misconduct by the case’s officials. The U.S. Attorney, his assistants, the HSI leadership, and the judges named in these files — Stirling, Orville, Limehouse, Sowards, Zito, Gergel, Cherry, Kittredge — appear in this record doing the work of catching, charging, and convicting a sitting judge. They are named as the case’s roster, in context, and no file is proposed or warranted for any of them.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
Gosnell (five-to-forty exposure; prosecutors seek forty) and Thorpe (five-year minimum; up to twenty years per count) both await sentencing after the U.S. Probation Office’s reports. No date has been announced for either in any record pulled as of November 14, 2026.
The indicted case number (2:25-cr-_____) and the full docket — PACER/RECAP — together with the complaint affidavit (Doc. 1, 2:25-mj-00068), which would name the individual HSI affiant.
Whether Charleston County / Ninth Circuit Solicitor CSC-with-minor charges were ever filed after the September 2025 “expected” reporting. Nothing located through November 14, 2026 (§06).
The resignation instrument (reported September 17, 2025) and the disposition of the judicial-discipline matter, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
The government’s pretrial detention brief, banked in full with this file’s build records (SHA-256 on file) — the CyberTip, the searches, the confession, the chambers warrant, and the allegation layer graded at §05. Named in: §01, §02, §05, §06.
Gosnell plea release, July 2, 2026 and Thorpe plea release, May 28, 2026 — the pleas, the count structure, the exchange, the exposure. Named in: Intro, §03.
“Charleston County Magistrate Charged with Possessing Child Sexual Abuse Material” — the complaint, the arrest, the initial appearance. Named in: §03.
The signed Rule 17(b) suspension order, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884, signed by Chief Justice John W. Kittredge — banked with this file’s build records (SHA-256 on file). Named in: §02.
“Federal Investigators Seek Public’s Help Identifying Possible Victims in Charleston County Magistrate Case” — the appeal and tip line carried at §04, with its outcome on the public record. Named in: §04.
WCSC — the suppression ruling, the plea hearing and denial, the maximum-sentence position, and the February 2026 Live 5 Investigates airing of the jailhouse calls. WCBD — the October 23, 2025 indictment arraignment before Judge Cherry. Named in: §02, §03, §05.
The reaction video these files answer — over an original video by creator Ebonique Luxe; banked with the build records. Its verified core (the arrest) and its graded and failed layers are carried at §05. Named in: §05.