
James Benjamin Gosnell Jr., 68 at his arrest and 69 at his plea, of Charleston, South Carolina, sat on the Charleston County magistrate bench for some 29 years — appointed in 1996 and still in office on the morning of September 16, 2025, when agents of Homeland Security Investigations executed a federal search warrant at his home. He met them at the door, asked whether they knew who he was, led them to a USB drive plugged into his computer, told them it held hundreds of videos of child sexual abuse material, and — after his Miranda warnings — confessed to possessing the material and to attempting to purchase it (U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of South Carolina, arrest release, September 16, 2025; the government’s detention brief, Doc. 18, case 2:25-mj-00068, banked with this file’s build records).
That same day, the Supreme Court of South Carolina suspended him from judicial duties, finding that his continued service posed “a substantial threat of serious harm to the public and the administration of justice” (suspension order, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884, signed by Chief Justice John W. Kittredge, September 16, 2025 — the signed order is banked with this file’s records). Multiple outlets report that he resigned the following day, September 17, 2025; the resignation instrument itself is an open pull, carried at §08.
An indictment unsealed October 22, 2025 charged him on six federal counts. On July 2, 2026, he pleaded guilty to two of them — possession of child sexual abuse material involving a prepubescent minor, and distribution — before U.S. District Judge Richard M. Gergel (U.S. Attorney’s Office plea release, July 2, 2026). He faces a mandatory minimum of five years and a maximum of forty, and prosecutors state they will seek the maximum. He is detained at the Williamsburg County Detention Center awaiting a sentence that has not been imposed and a sentencing date that has not been announced in any record pulled for this file. This file prints the watch, not a date.
One grading fence governs everything below, and it is stated here on the face of the file. The government’s pretrial detention brief quotes Gosnell’s own Telegram messages claiming contact abuse of infants. Those offenses were never charged. They are not in the indictment and they are not in his plea. At his plea hearing he said on the record: “I just want the court to know, I never touched a child or had the intentions of touching a child” (as reported by WCSC). In this file that layer prints only at its grade — alleged in a federal filing, never charged, and denied by him in open court — and it is carried at §06 with his denial in the same section. The case as a situation — how he was caught, the two jails, the public victim appeal, and what the record does not establish — is File No. 143, THE CHARLESTON FILE. The Florida co-conspirator is File No. 144, THE JOHN THORPE FILE.
The case began as a payment trail. Homeland Security Investigations received a CyberTip — routed through the reporting pipeline of PayPal and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children — showing payments from accounts of Gosnell’s to a known vendor of child sexual abuse material: two payments on November 4, 2024, from an account created that same day and carrying the note “vid”, and three more the same day from a second account (detention brief, Doc. 18, 2:25-mj-00068; U.S. Attorney’s Office releases). A sitting judge’s own purchases, made from accounts in his own name, are what brought federal agents to his door. Every step of that pipeline is institutional and documented; no misconduct by any official who touched this case appears anywhere in the record, and the prosecutors, agents, and judges named in this file are named as the roster of the people who caught and convicted him — as context, in this file only.
On September 16, 2025, HSI executed a federal search warrant at Gosnell’s Charleston home. Per the government’s detention brief, he met the agents at the door and asked if they “knew who he was.” He then led them to a USB drive plugged into his computer and told them it held hundreds of videos of child sexual abuse material. Agents seized more than thirteen additional flash drives, an iPhone, computers, discs, and VHS tapes. After Miranda warnings, he confessed — to possessing child sexual abuse material, to attempting to purchase it, and to Telegram conversations with what he called “like-minded individuals” (detention brief; U.S. Attorney’s Office arrest release).
The next day, September 17, 2025, agents executed a second search warrant at his court chambers at the Charleston County Magistrate Court, where bank records were seized (detention brief). Forensic review of the seized media found thousands of files; plea-hearing reporting put the seizure at more than 3,700 images and videos across the flash drives, discs, and tapes (U.S. Attorney’s Office plea release, “thousands”; plea-hearing reporting for the 3,700 figure).
He was arrested September 16, 2025 on a criminal complaint charging possession of child pornography, 18 U.S.C. § 2252A, and appeared initially before U.S. Magistrate Judge Molly Cherry. A detention hearing was waived on September 22, 2025. He was held at the Charleston County Jail from September 16 to 26, 2025, and has been held since at the Williamsburg County Detention Center, where he remains (detention brief; DOJ releases; WCSC reporting of his custody and jailhouse calls).
On the day of the arrest — September 16, 2025 — the Supreme Court of South Carolina suspended Gosnell from judicial duties under Rule 17(b) of the Rules for Judicial Disciplinary Enforcement, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884. The signed order, by Chief Justice John W. Kittredge, found that his continued service as a magistrate posed “a substantial threat of serious harm to the public and the administration of justice.” The order itself is banked with this file’s build records; its disposition, and the reported September 17, 2025 resignation, stand as open pulls at §08. Twenty-nine years on the bench ended between a morning arrest and a same-day order from his own state’s highest court.
The indictment, unsealed October 22, 2025, charged six counts (the count list as carried verbatim in the U.S. Attorney’s Office release of May 28, 2026):
Count 1 — possession of child sexual abuse material involving a prepubescent minor. Counts 2, 3 and 4 — three counts of receipt and attempted receipt. Count 5 — conspiracy to receive and distribute. Count 6 — distribution.
He pleaded not guilty, and reporting at the time put his combined exposure at roughly 100 years. In March 2026, Judge Gergel denied his motion to suppress the search-warrant evidence (WCSC reporting). The indicted case number (2:25-cr-_____) was not established in any record pulled for this file and is carried as an open pull at §08; the complaint case number, 2:25-mj-00068, is established and is the number this file cites for the early record.
On July 2, 2026, Gosnell pleaded guilty to count 1 (possession involving a prepubescent minor) and count 6 (distribution). Under the plea agreement, the remaining four counts are to be dismissed at sentencing. U.S. District Judge Richard M. Gergel accepted the plea (U.S. Attorney’s Office plea release, July 2, 2026).
The distribution he admitted is the Florida exchange: from December 2023 he communicated with John Thorpe of Florida by text message and encrypted applications; in the summer of 2024 he traveled to Thorpe’s Florida home, they viewed child sexual abuse material together from a flash drive he brought, he left the drive there, and Thorpe later mailed it back to Charleston by FedEx (plea release). Thorpe’s own guilty plea is File No. 144.
His exposure on the plea: a mandatory minimum of five years and a maximum of forty years in federal prison, a fine of up to $250,000, restitution, up to lifetime supervised release, and lifetime sex-offender registration — registration the court ordered at the plea (plea release; SC Public Radio plea coverage). U.S. Attorney Bryan P. Stirling — quoted in both of his office’s releases, including the line that Gosnell was “a man entrusted with carrying out justice in the Charleston community yet was doing exactly the opposite” — has stated through his office that prosecutors will seek the maximum, forty years (WCSC). The prosecution team of record is Stirling with Assistant U.S. Attorneys Katherine Orville (who signed the detention brief), Emily Limehouse, and Whit Sowards; HSI Carolinas Special Agent in Charge Mark M. Zito is the investigating agency’s quoted official. His defense counsel of record in coverage from the arrest through the plea is Lionel Lofton; the spelling is carried as coverage prints it, with docket confirmation an open pull at §08.
Sentencing has not occurred. As of this file’s build (November 14, 2026), no sentencing date has been announced in any record pulled; he awaits the U.S. Probation Office’s presentence report and remains detained at Williamsburg County. When a date is set or a sentence imposed, this file updates at this same address.
This section exists because the viral post this file answers built its headline on it — and because the record supports exactly one honest way to print it. The government’s pretrial detention brief (Doc. 18, filed September 22, 2025, banked in full with this file’s records) quoted Gosnell’s own Telegram messages to argue that he was a danger. Per that filing, his messages claimed contact abuse of infants in his care and in his neighborhood — children described as three months old, five months old, and two weeks old — a trip account from Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, and a planned future trip to Florida with his co-conspirator. The brief’s graphic descriptions are characterized here, not reproduced.
The grade, stated plainly: ALLEGED IN A FEDERAL FILING. Every item in the paragraph above is the prosecution’s characterization of the defendant’s own chat statements, offered at a detention hearing. None of it was ever charged. None of it is in the indictment. None of it is in the guilty plea. And at his plea hearing on July 2, 2026, Gosnell said on the record: “I just want the court to know, I never touched a child or had the intentions of touching a child” (as reported by WCSC). His recorded jailhouse calls, aired by WCSC in February 2026, hold the same line — that the chats were fantasy while the material was real — and carry his own summary of his position: “I’m going to be their poster boy.”
Two corrections belong to this section, because the post got both wrong. First: the post says the two men “went to Texas” to reach a baby. That claim is FAILED as stated. The filing describes a plan discussed in chats for a future trip to Florida — a plan, never a trip taken — and the state in the filing is Florida, not the one the post named; the underlying plan allegation itself carries the grade of this whole section. Second: versions of this story circulating in the same chain call him a “North Carolina judge.” FAILED. He is a South Carolina magistrate, of Charleston County, and he sat in Charleston for 29 years.
What he stands convicted of is the material — possession and distribution, confessed at his own door and admitted again in his plea. What the chats claimed stands exactly where the record leaves it: alleged in a federal filing, never charged, and denied by him in open court. This file prints both, at their grades, and blends neither into the other.
Gosnell was appointed to the Charleston County magistrate bench in 1996 (reported as an appointment by Governor David Beasley) and served some 29 years. South Carolina magistrates are not required to be lawyers, and he held no law degree — a fact about the office that the coverage of his fall returns to, and that this file prints as the record states it.
His name was national once before. In June 2015 he presided over the bond hearing for the Emanuel AME church shooter and drew national criticism for describing the shooter’s family as “victims” too. Earlier in his tenure, he was reprimanded by the Supreme Court of South Carolina for using a racial slur from the bench — the reprimand’s existence is corroborated by named outlets reporting it since 2015; the reprimand order itself, and with it any year, is an open pull at §08, and no year is printed here until the order is in hand.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
No sentencing date has been announced in any record pulled as of November 14, 2026. The U.S. Probation Office’s presentence report precedes it; prosecutors state they will seek the maximum, forty years. The moment a date is set or a sentence imposed, §05 and this card update in place.
The indicted case number (2:25-cr-_____) and the complaint affidavit (Doc. 1, 2:25-mj-00068) — the affidavit would name the individual HSI case agent, who is not named in any material pulled. PACER/RECAP pull.
September 2025 reporting said state charges were expected, and the detention brief mentioned possible state Criminal Sexual Conduct with a Minor, First Degree. No state charge has been located in any record or coverage through this file’s build. This file does not state or imply that he was charged by the state with anything; if a Charleston County or Ninth Circuit Solicitor filing ever lands, it prints here.
Multiple outlets report he resigned on September 17, 2025; the resignation instrument has not been pulled. The disposition of the judicial-discipline matter, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884, is likewise open.
The Supreme Court of South Carolina’s reprimand of Gosnell for a racial slur from the bench — existence corroborated by named outlets since 2015; the order and its year (reported as 2003) are not in hand. No year prints in §07 until the order is pulled.
Coverage carries his defense attorney as Lionel Lofton from the arrest through the plea; one early item renders the name “Loften.” Docket-appearance confirmation closes this item; the coverage spelling governs meanwhile and is flagged as such at §05.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
“Former Charleston County Magistrate Pleads Guilty to Possessing, Distributing Child Sexual Abuse Material” — the governing record for the guilty plea: counts 1 and 6, the four counts to be dismissed at sentencing, the Florida flash-drive exchange, the five-to-forty-year exposure, and the “thousands” of files. Named in: Intro, §02, §05.
“Charleston County Magistrate Charged with Possessing Child Sexual Abuse Material” — the complaint charge (18 U.S.C. § 2252A), the arrest, and the initial appearance before U.S. Magistrate Judge Molly Cherry. Named in: Intro, §02.
“Gosnell Co-Conspirator Pleads Guilty to Conspiracy and Distribution of Child Sexual Abuse Material” — carries the verbatim six-count list of Gosnell’s indictment relied on at §04, and the whole of File No. 144’s plea record. Named in: §04.
The government’s pretrial detention brief, banked in full with this file’s build records (SHA-256 on file) — the CyberTip and the November 4, 2024 payments, the home search and the confession, the chambers warrant, and, at its grade, the Telegram-message allegations printed at §06. A party’s filing: what it alleges is printed as allegation, never as finding. Named in: Intro, §01, §02, §06, §08.
The signed order suspending Gosnell under Rule 17(b) RJDE, Appellate Case No. 2025-001884, signed by Chief Justice John W. Kittredge — banked with this file’s build records (SHA-256 on file). Named in: Intro, §03.
“Federal Investigators Seek Public’s Help Identifying Possible Victims in Charleston County Magistrate Case” — the public appeal and its tip line. No victim has been publicly identified, and no contact-offense charge has followed; File No. 143 carries the appeal in full. Named in: §08.
The Charleston station’s continuing coverage — the suppression ruling (March 2026), the plea hearing and Gosnell’s on-record denial (July 2, 2026), the prosecutors’ maximum-sentence position, and the February 2026 airing of his recorded jailhouse calls. Named in: Intro, §02, §04, §05, §06.
Plea coverage carrying the registration order and exposure detail — and the publisher of this file’s mugshot half (see the photo record). Named in: §05.
The reaction video this file answers — built over an original video by creator Ebonique Luxe, posted March 31, 2026, before the guilty plea. Its verified core is the arrest; its headline layer is graded at §06, and its two flat errors are corrected there. The post itself is banked with this file’s build records. Named in: Intro, §06.