
This is Plymouth, Massachusetts — the town and the county on the South Shore of the Commonwealth. In the spring of 2026, a young man who had lived for years in the home of a Plymouth police officer walked into a State Police barracks and reported that he had been sexually assaulted across those years — first by the officer’s husband, the man who held legal guardianship over him, and then by both of them together. Six months later, on September 18, 2026, a Plymouth County grand jury indicted them both: the officer, Samantha Pelrine, on five counts, and her husband, Daniel Forand, on nineteen.
The charges are allegations in a pending case. Both defendants pleaded not guilty at the district-court stage; both are presumed innocent unless proven otherwise; no plea has been entered on the indictments, because the Superior Court arraignment was still to come at the last reporting. Their files are File No. 139, THE SAMANTHA PELRINE FILE, and File No. 140, THE DANIEL FORAND FILE.
This file is about the institutions around the case, and about a paper record that does not depend on the verdict. Within twelve days of the report, the Plymouth Police Department had placed its officer on leave, the State Police had arrested both defendants, a district court had set bail and impounded the case documents, and the Commonwealth’s POST Commission had suspended the officer’s certification. And behind the case sits a decade of paper that two police departments — Carver’s and Plymouth’s own — had already written about the husband: unsuitability reports, seized guns, and firearm-permit reinstatements refused again and again, one refusal signed by the man who is now Plymouth’s police chief. What the institutions documented, and what they did with it: that is this file, printed from the record.
The complainant was a minor during the alleged offences. He is referred to here by role only — never named, never pictured — and no image of him appears in this file or ever will. The same fence covers the husband’s minor daughter and his former wife, who appear by role only.
The prosecution’s account, as the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office states it: a boy came into the couple’s home in 2018; Daniel Forand became his legal guardian in 2019; the abuse the office alleges ran, in its written summary, “from 2018–2025” — beginning, on Assistant District Attorney James Duffy’s in-court account, when the boy was 14, with Forand first and Pelrine later joining, until 2025. The complainant left the home in February 2026 and reported to the Massachusetts State Police on March 15, 2026.
The case has run in two stages, and this file keeps them separate, because the coverage does not. Stage one, district court (March 2026): an abuse-prevention order and paid administrative leave on March 17; arrest and Plymouth District Court arraignment on March 26 — Forand on 20 counts, Pelrine on 4; not-guilty pleas; bail of $25,000 and $10,000 cash imposed and posted, against the Commonwealth’s request of $250,000 each; the case documents impounded; and the POST Commission’s certification suspension on March 27. Stage two, grand jury and Superior Court (September 2026): the complainant’s testimony on September 10, and indictments on September 18 — Forand on 19 counts (nine aggravated rape of a child, two rape, seven indecent assault and battery, one assault and battery), Pelrine on 5 (three aggravated rape of a child, two rape of a child) — carrying the case to Plymouth Superior Court, where arraignment was outstanding at the last report (Patriot Ledger, September 21, 2026). The pleas and the bail belong to March; nothing in the indictment coverage shows a new plea or a new bail event, and this file prints none.
Everything in the criminal case is an allegation until a court says otherwise. This file’s institutional record — the leave, the suspension, the permit history — is documented fact about the institutions, printed at that strength, separately.
March 15. The complainant, by then an adult, reported to the Massachusetts State Police in Middleborough that he had been sexually assaulted “first by Forand and then by Forand and Pelrine together, on numerous occasions from 2018–2025” (Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office statement, March 26, 2026). The State Police investigated and obtained arrest warrants.
March 17. He filed for an abuse-prevention order; it issued the same day — stay away, and surrender all guns, ammunition and gun licences. The same day, told by the State Police that its officer was the subject of a criminal investigation, the Plymouth Police Department placed Pelrine on paid administrative leave (Patriot Ledger).
March 26. State Police arrested both defendants at their home at 6 a.m., without incident; that afternoon both were arraigned in Plymouth District Court before Judge Kristen A. Stone — the counts, pleas and bail printed at §01 — and the court extended the protective order and impounded the case documents. The department issued its statement the same day (§03).
March 27. The Massachusetts POST Commission suspended Pelrine’s law-enforcement certification, Case No. 2026-017 (§05). Twelve days, report to suspension — every institution in the chain moved on its own paper, and every step of it is dated in the record. What the record also shows is the longer paper that preceded it, at §04.
The Plymouth Police Department’s public answer came on the day of the arrest, in its own words: “We are appalled and deeply disturbed by the allegations. We hold our officers to the highest of standards and expect them to uphold their sworn duty both on duty and off… The conduct alleged is in violation of our values and of our basic principals [sic] as police officers to serve and protect.” The department said Pelrine’s duty status was under review and that it was committed to a timely internal investigation (statement posted to the department’s Facebook page; text carried by PEOPLE, The Sun and Law&Crime).
The department’s chief is Dana Flynn. He stands in this record twice. As the chief, his department placed Pelrine on leave the day the State Police investigation surfaced and issued the statement above. As a captain, years before, he was the Plymouth officer who refused to reinstate Daniel Forand’s firearm permit — one of three refusals, across two departments, documented at §04. The department that employed the wife had already refused the husband his firearm permit back — in writing, on suitability grounds — years before it employed her. Both facts are the departments’ own paper; this file prints them side by side because the record does.
Pelrine’s status since: paid leave on March 17, 2026; certification suspended March 27; described by the Patriot Ledger in September 2026 as “suspended from the police department.” Any later change is an open pull (141-04).
The full treatment of this record — attributed item by item — is File No. 140. Its shape belongs here, because it is the institutional backdrop of the whole case. The Plymouth Independent’s investigation (Andrea Estes, September 18, 2026) of Carver and Plymouth police records documents: roughly 20 calls involving Forand logged by Carver police between 2012 and 2016 alone; a 2016 eight-page unsuitability report by Carver Police Sergeant Sheri Sarmento, written after Forand’s then-wife came to the station saying she did not feel safe, concluding that his “angry, threatening and intimidating behavior has shown that he would be a danger to public safety if his firearm’s license were to be reinstated”; his nine guns seized; reinstatement refused in 2016, 2017 and 2019 by both departments — in Plymouth by Captain Dana Flynn; standing stay-away orders covering government offices in both towns and Plymouth police headquarters; and further accusations carried in the reports, printed in File No. 140 at the grade the Independent gives them — accusations, never charges.
Two fences ride with this history wherever it prints. The first: Forand was never criminally charged in that history — it is a record of assessments and refusals, not of criminal cases, and no copy in this set inflates it into one. The second is the 2026 collateral, printed in full in File No. 140: after the March arrest a probate judge refused to suspend Forand’s visits with his young daughter, and on June 1, 2026 Middleborough Patrol Officer Terry Meleski reported intervening at her school as Forand carried her, crying and kicking, and being cursed at and threatened with suit — the officer’s written report of the defendant’s conduct, attributed as such, with the child role-only throughout.
The Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) Commission — the body that certifies every officer in the Commonwealth — suspended Pelrine’s certification in Case No. 2026-017, Suspension Order issued March 27, 2026 (the Commission’s own archive listing). The order requires surrender of her agency-issued identification and equipment; NBC10 Boston reports the order itself is redacted, so its stated grounds are not public (open pull 141-03). A date in wide circulation is wrong and is corrected here once: aggregator copy dates the suspension to March 30 — that is the issue date of the adjacent case in the Commission’s archive, Case No. 2026-018, a different officer’s case. Pelrine’s order is the March 27 one.
The courts: Plymouth District Court held the March stage — arraignment before Judge Kristen A. Stone, bail set, documents impounded, a June 8 date that the indictments superseded. The case now sits in Plymouth Superior Court on the September 18 indictments; arraignment there was set for a later date at the last reporting, and no plea on the indictments appears in any source pulled (open pull 141-02). Both courts sit in the building at this file’s head — the Plymouth Trial Court, 52 Obery Street.
At the center of the case is a home, and a legal status the record states exactly. The complainant came into the couple’s home in 2018, when his parents and other relatives could not care for him. In 2019, Daniel Forand became his legal guardian — in the court papers, Forand described the boy’s parents as “close friends” (Plymouth Independent, from the court papers). He lived in the home until February 2026. The prosecution alleges the abuse ran across most of that residence; the defendants have pleaded not guilty at the only stage where pleas exist, and the case is pending.
A correction belongs here, because the wrong word is everywhere in the coverage. Tabloid accounts call the complainant the couple’s “adopted son” or “foster child.” No adoption appears in any record source pulled for this set of files; the court-papers account documents guardianship. The distinction is not a nicety — it is the legal fact of the case, the status that put the boy in the home and under Forand’s authority — and the wrong words appear in this set only inside their corrections, this one included.
This file prints its open items in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
The Plymouth Police Department’s March 26, 2026 statement as originally posted to the department’s Facebook page (shared with File No. 139’s pull 139-05). Its text is confirmed verbatim through three outlets and quoted at §03; the original post completes the pack.
Shared with pull 139-01: the Plymouth Superior Court docket — docket numbers, the arraignment date and any pleas on the indictments, counsel at this stage, and next dates. Outstanding at the last report, September 21, 2026.
Shared with pull 139-02: the Commission’s redacted order document itself. Attempted again at this build through the Commission’s own site; the March entry’s document link was not reached by the text route, and no address was guessed at. A live-browser pull closes it.
Shared with pull 139-03: any Plymouth Police Department action on Pelrine’s employment after September 2026 — termination, resignation, hearing, pay status. The documented status stands at §03 until a record changes it.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall and Allen in Indiana; Berrien and Cass in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Reporting is credited to the outlet that did it. Where a source could not be reached in full, the file says so on its face. Last checked November 14, 2026.
“Plymouth couple indicted in alleged child rape” — the spine of this file: the only outlet that investigated the husband’s documented history in Carver and Plymouth police records, and the grand-jury path from the lost May date to the September 10 testimony. Read in full for the intake. Named in: Intro, §01, §04, §06.
“Suspended Plymouth cop, husband indicted on child rape, other charges” (Jessica Trufant, September 21, 2026) and “State commission comes after Plymouth cop facing child rape charges” (Hannah Morse, March 30, 2026) — the indictment counts from the District Attorney’s office, the arrest and arraignment record, the paid leave, the POST order and its surrender terms. Both read in full. Named in: Intro, §01–§03, §05.
The Commission’s archive listing — Pelrine, Samantha (Plymouth Police), Case No. 2026-017, Suspension Order issued March 27, 2026 — the primary record for the suspension; the adjacent Case No. 2026-018 (March 30) is a different case, and the distinction is printed at §05. Named in: §02, §05.
The office’s statement of the report, the warrants, the district-court counts, and its summary of the allegations, quoted at §01 and §02. Named in: §01, §02.
“Plymouth Trial Court” — the courthouse at 52 Obery Street, Plymouth, photographed by Ktr101 (Kevin Rutherford), CC BY-SA 4.0; the building’s identity is lettered on its face in frame and matches the Massachusetts Trial Court’s own courthouse listing for the Plymouth campus (District Court and Superior Court at 52 Obery Street). Full record in this file’s PHOTO.md. Named in: the lead.
The reel this set of files answers — a 21-second update on the indictments, unusually accurate in its particulars; its two compressions (March pleas and bail presented inside an indictment update) are corrected at §01. Banked with this build’s records (SHA-256 445cf008…2c4). Named in: Intro, §01.