
For eight years, Jamey Noel held two chairs at once in Clark County, Indiana. One was elected: Sheriff of Clark County, from January 1, 2015 through December 31, 2022. The other was never on any ballot: president and chief executive of the Utica Township Volunteer Fire Fighters Association — the nonprofit that runs New Chapel EMS, the ambulance service for Clark and Floyd counties. The badge in one hand. The ambulance money in the other.
On August 26, 2024, in Clark Circuit Court, cause 10C01-2311-F5-000297, he pleaded guilty to 27 felonies — fifteen counts of theft, five of tax evasion, four of official misconduct, and one each of corrupt business influence, obstruction of justice and money laundering. On October 14, 2024, the court accepted the plea and sentenced him to fifteen years — twelve to serve, three suspended to probation — with $270,000 in fines and $3,140,515.44 in restitution ordered repaid. His wife and his daughter pleaded guilty off the same credit cards. Nearly two years into the sentence, the court’s own accounting, reported August 31, 2026, says he still owes nearly $2 million of it.
This file is built from the paper: the plea agreement itself, filed in his cause and read here line by line; the Indiana Court of Appeals decision in his case; the court’s own settlement and distribution order of January 2026; and the reporting of the Indiana Capital Chronicle, the Indianapolis Business Journal, IPM News and the Courier-Journal. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §10 lists every pull that would raise a grade further.
One rule governs the money in this file: what he was ordered to pay, what has actually been paid, and what he still owes are three different numbers, in three different sections of the record, and they are never merged here.
The career, as the record carries it. Before the badge in Clark County, Noel served as an Indiana State Police trooper for more than two decades — the Chronicle’s profile reporting — and his state police service was still being argued over at his sentencing, where Superintendent Doug Carter told reporters Noel had previously received only a “separation benefit” because he did not meet the agency’s pension requirements.
He rose through the volunteer fire service alongside the police career: a leadership role in the Utica Township association from 1993 and chief of the Utica Fire Department in 2002, by the Chronicle’s account. Politics ran on the same track — chairman of the Clark County Republican Party and of the Ninth District Republican Party, and, per the Chronicle, the man who led Governor Eric Holcomb’s 2016 campaign, sat on his transition team, and chaired his reelection bid. In August 2024, with the plea on the table, Holcomb said a pardon would not come from his administration.
In 2014 he ran for sheriff and won — the county’s first Republican sheriff in decades, per the Chronicle’s reporting — and on January 1, 2015 he took the office he would hold for two full terms, until December 31, 2022. Those dates are not a summary; they are the Indiana Court of Appeals’ own statement of his tenure, in his own case. For a time he also fronted the county jail on national television, as a star of the A&E series filmed inside it — WAVE’s description of him when the jail doors closed on him instead.
What the record does not leave room to soften is the overlap. Every year he wore the sheriff’s badge, he also ran the nonprofit that held the ambulance contracts — and it is the second chair, the unelected one, that this file is mostly about, because it is the one the money flowed through.
The Utica Township Volunteer Fire Fighters Association is a nonprofit. It does business as New Chapel EMS — New Chapel Fire & EMS — and it was paid with tax dollars from Clark and Floyd counties to run ambulances. Its money was public money in everything but the letterhead, and its president and chief executive was the county sheriff.
The pleaded record is that he treated the association’s accounts as his own. The spending the investigation documented and the plea answered for ran to vehicles, travel — planes among it — vacations, clothing, college tuition and child support: the personal life of one family, billed to an ambulance service. Court documents further point to at least $33,000 of public funds contributed to Republican candidates and campaigns between 2020 and 2023. The tax counts frame the scale the State charged: $3.5 million in income run through association credit cards between 2018 and 2022 and never reported — the charge’s frame, printed as the News and Tribune reported it.
The cars became the case’s public face. When investigators executed their warrants they confiscated at least forty vehicles, including two 1970 Plymouth Superbirds, a 1959 Corvette, and 1966 and 1968 Chargers, according to the search-warrant returns; a July 2023 registration search counted about 133 vehicles registered across the fire department and New Chapel EMS in all. Separately, according to a search warrant, association funds paid $25,000 for a Cessna airplane in February 2022, first registered in Noel’s own name — its registration changed to the association in October 2023, after the first searches.
And the people. The State charged — in four counts of ghost employment — that public employees were put to his personal work: the probable-cause affidavits describe jail and New Chapel maintenance employees assigned to his rental buildings and properties, and firefighters at his sentencing described being tasked with driving his personal “limousines” while stations ran short. Those four counts were dismissed under his plea, and no guilty plea ever covered those four counts. The twenty-seven counts he did admit are §05.
It came out from inside the office he had just left. In June 2023, Noel’s successor as sheriff, Scottie Maples, carried criminal allegations about his predecessor to the Indiana State Police. On June 13, 2023, the State Police assigned the investigation — Lieutenant Jeffrey C. Hearon’s affidavit opens the paper trail — and it grew into what Superintendent Doug Carter called the largest case in the agency’s history.
The State Board of Accounts did the arithmetic in parallel: audits of the sheriff’s commissary fund and of New Chapel’s finances, the commissary audit filed in February 2024, which the Attorney General’s later civil suit would cite for more than $900,000 in jail commissary money “misappropriated, diverted, or misapplied.”
Through the fall of 2023 the warrants ran — dozens of them, against his homes, his buildings, his barn. Investigators found at least forty vehicles to seize. In March 2024, authorities disclosed finding approximately twenty-six shipping containers in Deputy, Indiana; investigators said some appeared to contain government-surplus equipment, as Louisville Public Media and WAVE reported. On November 8, 2023, the State filed the first fifteen felony counts, and the former sheriff was arrested and charged in the county he had policed for eight years.
What followed was not a quiet fall. It was a year of courtrooms — a contempt jailing, a bond multiplied twenty-fold, a charge sheet that more than doubled — before he stood up in August 2024 and pleaded guilty to twenty-seven felonies. The counts are next.
The case is State of Indiana v. Jamey Noel, cause 10C01-2311-F5-000297, in the Clark Circuit Court — heard not by a Clark County judge but by Special Judge Larry W. Medlock of Washington County, with Ripley County’s Richard J. Hertel as special prosecutor. On November 8, 2023, the State charged fifteen felonies. The Indiana Court of Appeals, in Noel’s own pretrial appeal, sets out the sheet as filed: one count of corrupt business influence, two counts of theft as Level 5 felonies, three counts of theft as Level 6 felonies, one count of obstruction of justice, four counts of ghost employment, and four counts of official misconduct.
His first bond was $75,000, posted the day of his initial hearing, on conditions that included surrendering his firearms. He did not keep them all surrendered. On April 9, 2024, after investigators found two guns he was not permitted to have, Medlock found the former sheriff in contempt of court and jailed him for sixty days on the spot — WAVE covered the hearing the day it happened. Then, on June 4, 2024, with the shipping containers and further purchases in front of him, the judge raised the bond to $1.5 million. Noel sat in the Scott County Jail from April onward, and his eventual sentence credit runs from June 8, 2024.
The hearing, on video. The April 9, 2024 contempt hearing is on YouTube: Special Judge Larry Medlock finds Noel in contempt for keeping two guns past his bond’s surrender order, slams the gavel so hard the sounding block breaks, and imposes the sixty days on the spot — the hearing WAVE covered the day it happened, and the broken sounding block the Indiana Capital Chronicle recorded. youtube.com
Meanwhile the sheet grew. Through 2024 the State filed the additional counts — theft, tax evasion and money laundering among them — until the case carried thirty-one felonies. Read the number the way this file reads every number: fifteen charged in November 2023 is the appellate record; thirty-one at the plea is the plea agreement’s own inventory. What he admitted, and what was dismissed, is §05 — from the agreement itself.
There was no trial. On August 26, 2024, Noel and the State filed their negotiated plea in cause 10C01-2311-F5-000297 — a conditional tender, subject to the court’s approval, and this file quotes it from the filed document itself. He pleaded guilty to twenty-seven counts:
• Count I — corrupt business influence
• Counts II–VI, XVI–XX and XXVII–XXXI — theft, fifteen counts in all
• Count VII — obstruction of justice
• Counts XII–XV — official misconduct
• Counts XXI–XXV — tax evasion
• Count XXVI — money laundering
• Dismissed under the agreement: Counts VIII, IX, X and XI — the four ghost-employment counts
The agreement fixed the rest in the same document: an aggregate of fifteen years in the Indiana Department of Correction with three years suspended to probation; credit for time served beginning June 8, 2024; and restitution in four lines — $2,870,924.00 to the Utica Volunteer Firefighters Association, $61,190.77 to the Clark County Sheriff’s Department, $173,155.07 to the Indiana Department of Revenue, owed jointly and severally with his wife Misty, and $35,245.60 to the Indiana State Police for the cost of storing the evidence. The fine was left for the court to set.
Judge Medlock did not accept it that day. He took the plea under advisement — he wanted to hear from the victims first. For seven weeks the former sheriff waited in the Scott County Jail to learn whether his own deal would hold. It held, in a courtroom full of the people it had hurt, and that hearing is §06.
On October 14, 2024, in a Clark County Circuit Court hearing in Jeffersonville, Judge Medlock officially accepted the plea — after two hours of victim testimony. Twenty-one statements were given, the Chronicle reported: former subordinates, firefighters, and Clark County residents whose lives had been, in the coverage’s word, upended. Roger Montgomery Jr., a first responder who had worked for Noel from 2005 to 2011 — before Noel became sheriff — told the court that firefighters lacked proper equipment under his command while emergency personnel were tasked with driving his personal “limousines,” sometimes leaving a single firefighter on duty. That testimony describes the years before the sheriff’s office; it does not establish the dismissed ghost-employment counts.
Noel read a prepared statement of his own. “It’s all my fault. … (My family) were victims of my deceit, like everyone else, and I hope they can forgive me,” he said, before reciting a Catholic prayer. Superintendent Carter addressed the court too: Noel, he said, had searched for power, control and money — “Politics should never be the number one priority … but it was for Jamey.”
Then the sentence, and the judge’s own summary of the man in front of him: “You’ve tarnished the badge and failed everyone in law enforcement,” Medlock told him — adding that he would have preferred a harsher sentence, but worried a heavier hand could make the case ripe for an appeal. The sentence imposed: fifteen years in the Indiana Department of Correction, three of them suspended to probation — twelve years to serve — with credit from June 8, 2024, and fines of $270,000: $10,000 for each of the twenty-seven counts he had admitted.
He is serving the term at the New Castle Correctional Annex — the Department of Correction’s own offender record carries him there as DOC #301710, his sentence dated October 14, 2024 out of Clark County, and IPM reported the same placement in November 2025. The civil court’s October 2025 order records June 5, 2033 as his earliest possible release date, as the Department’s records then projected it. The sentence itself is the fifteen years above.
He did not fall alone, and this file does not pretend otherwise — but his then-wife and his daughter stand here on their own records, in their own causes, at their own grades. They are in his file because the same credit cards run through all three cases.
Misty Noel — cause 10C01-2401-F5-000029. Charged in early 2024 with ten felonies, five counts of theft and five of tax evasion, for more than $660,000 in personal items charged to an association card. She pleaded guilty in May 2025 to the ten counts. On July 3, 2025, Medlock sentenced her to six years in total: eighteen months in prison, then four and a half years of probation — with restitution of $660,806.64 to New Chapel EMS and $29,547 to the Indiana Department of Revenue, and an agreement calling for the return of nine vehicles to the association. She had given WLKY an interview maintaining her innocence, and after sentencing the judge ordered her to show cause why her plea should not be set aside over those statements; in August he affirmed the plea and canceled the hearing. She served her time at the Madison Correctional Facility and was released on April 27, 2026 — a day ahead of the April 28 date the notification system had scheduled — the Courier-Journal reported from the state’s victim-notification system. She had filed for divorce the previous fall.
Kasey Noel — cause 10C01-2403-F6-000230. Their daughter was charged with nine felonies, five counts of theft and four of tax evasion, over more than $100,000 charged to the association and New Chapel. On January 13, 2025, she pleaded guilty to the nine counts and was sentenced the same day to sixty months — nine months in custody and fifty-one months of probation. Her restitution was $108,660.59 to New Chapel EMS and $5,049 to the Indiana Department of Revenue — the exact figure the contemporaneous January coverage and the court’s mediation exhibit both carry; the $108,661 in later accounting coverage is that figure rounded to the nearest dollar. Her $5,049 in tax restitution to the Department of Revenue was paid in full in the January 2026 distribution.
Three defendants, three causes, one set of cards. What the three of them still owe, together and separately, is the ledger in §08.
A sentence ends. A restitution order does not — it follows a man out of the courtroom and waits. This is the ledger, in the record’s own three columns, every figure carrying its source and its date.
• $2,870,924.00 to the Utica Volunteer Firefighters Association
• $61,190.77 to the Clark County Sheriff’s Department
• $173,155.07 to the Indiana Department of Revenue (jointly with Misty Noel)
• $35,245.60 to the Indiana State Police, for evidence storage
• Total restitution ordered against Jamey Noel: $3,140,515.44 — plus $270,000 in fines. Misty Noel was separately ordered to pay $660,806.64 and $29,547; Kasey Noel, $108,660.59 and $5,049.
What has been raised and paid. The courts sold his life off in lots — the classic cars, the firearms, the properties — and by November 2025 auctions and forced sales had generated more than $2.7 million gross, before mortgages, liens and commissions took their cut. Under a combined settlement the three Noels reached with the association and the State, approved by the court’s distribution order in his own cause, the escrow was paid out on January 30, 2026 — the date and amounts the Chronicle reported from the clerk’s records: $977,836 to the firefighters association — $885,393 of it from Jamey Noel’s case proceeds — and $286,413.20 to the Attorney General’s office, which satisfied the State Police and Department of Revenue lines in full and put $43,416.53 against the Sheriff’s Department line. In all, more than $1.26 million moved that day. Separately, the Utica Township fire district that replaced New Chapel received a $650,000 civil-settlement allocation; in November 2026 its chief credited that settlement for the department’s recovery, as WDRB and WAVE reported.
• The three Noels collectively still owed the association more than $2.66 million
• Nearly $2 million of it is Jamey Noel’s alone
• Misty Noel owes the association $586,424; Kasey Noel owes $90,600
• Jamey Noel also still owes $17,774 on the Sheriff’s Department line — what remains of the $61,190.77 after the January distribution, to the dollar
And a separate column entirely: the civil judgments, which are not restitution and are never merged with it here. In October 2025, in the Attorney General’s suit over the jail commissary fund, Special Judge Roger Duvall entered summary judgment for the State: $918,416.53 in compensatory damages and audit costs on the commissary counts, plus $122,500 in additional damages under the Crime Victims Relief Act — a total judgment of $1,040,916.53, with post-judgment interest of eight percent a year. The judgment directs that applicable criminal restitution and civil recoveries be offset against it. The court declined to add punitive or treble damages. (Order of Summary Judgment, October 14, 2025.) The next month the same judge approved a $122,000 mediated settlement of the suit by his late brother’s children, who said he had mishandled their inheritance from the estate he administered. From his cell, Noel has answered the only way left to him: handwritten federal lawsuits against the superintendent, the detective and the sheriff who investigated him — his own allegations, unproven, filed in October 2026 and reported by WDRB. A separate jail-treatment complaint of his was dismissed by a federal judge in September 2026, with leave to file an amended complaint by October 12 (Louisville Public Media). The courts will grade those. This file grades only what the record has already settled.
Every officer file in this library carries the same check: the subject’s record on the road — impaired-driving arrests, license actions, any driving history the paper carries.
For Jamey Noel, the check came back empty. Searches run for this file on November 11, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news and court coverage, and through the full coverage of his case — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in his name.
That is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere. The vehicles in this record were not a road offense; they were bought with an ambulance service’s money, and they are weighed where they belong, at §02.
This file stands on court documents read firsthand — the plea agreement, the appellate decision, the distribution order — and on named reporting for everything those documents do not reach. The pulls still open are listed here, each one a public record, each one named so this file’s grades can be raised in the open:
1. The case summaries (CCS) for all three causes — 10C01-2311-F5-000297, 10C01-2401-F5-000029 and 10C01-2403-F6-000230, from Indiana MyCase: the dockets themselves, to confirm no post-judgment filing — no appeal, no modification — stands behind the endings printed here.
2. His Department of Correction record — pulled November 11, 2026: the Department carries him as DOC #301710 at the New Castle Correctional Annex, his sentence dated October 14, 2024 out of Clark County, and §06 now prints the custodian’s own line. Still open under this item: the projected release date as the Department itself carries it, to replace the reported estimates at §06.
3. The sentencing order of October 14, 2024 — the original document behind the fines and the sentence structure.
4. The State Board of Accounts audit reports — the commissary-fund audit of February 2024 and the New Chapel audit: the auditors’ own figures, to raise §03 from reported to primary.
When a pull lands, this file is updated at this same address, in place, with the date of the update shown — the way every file in this library is kept.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
The plea agreement. State of Indiana v. Jamey Noel, Clark Circuit Court, cause 10C01-2311-F5-000297 — the Conditional Joint Motion / Negotiated Plea, filed August 26, 2024, read in full: the twenty-seven pleaded counts by number, the four dismissed ghost-employment counts, the fifteen-year aggregate, the credit date of June 8, 2024, and the four restitution lines totaling $3,140,515.44. Establishes §05 and the ordered column of §08. indianacapitalchronicle.com
The appellate decision. Jamey Noel v. State of Indiana, 23A-CR-2924 (Ind. Ct. App. June 20, 2024), memorandum decision, read in full: his tenure (January 1, 2015 – December 31, 2022), the fifteen counts as charged on November 8, 2023 with their levels, and the $75,000 bond. Establishes §01 and §04. law.justia.com
The distribution order. State of Indiana v. Jamey Noel, cause 10C01-2311-F5-000297 — the Amended Order Granting Motion to Approve Settlement and Distribute Funds (Combined Settlement Agreement of August 27, 2025, with the December 22, 2025 addendum), read in full: the three causes, the $286,413.20 itemization to the Attorney General’s office, and the escrow distribution completed January 30, 2026. Establishes the paid column of §08 and the cause numbers at §07. indianacapitalchronicle.com
The sentencing coverage. Indiana Capital Chronicle (Casey Smith) and the Indianapolis Business Journal, October 14–15, 2024, read in full: the plea’s acceptance after twenty-one victim statements, the verbatim quotes printed at §06, the fifteen-year sentence, the $270,000 fine at $10,000 per count, the restitution lines, and the scheme’s documented spending. indianacapitalchronicle.com
The plea coverage. The Associated Press report of August 26–27, 2024 (via EMS1, Firehouse and Police1): the plea’s terms, the dismissed ghost-employment counts, the advisement, and his custody at the Scott County Jail on the $1.5 million bond.
The family cases. IPM News, July 3, 2025 (Misty Noel’s acceptance and sentencing) and November 24, 2025 (the commissary judgment, the estate settlement, the escrow balances, the New Castle placement); the Courier-Journal, March 30, 2026 (Misty Noel’s April 28, 2026 release; Kasey Noel’s nine months in custody and fifty-one months of probation). Establishes §07 at its grades.
The still-owed ledger. Indiana Capital Chronicle, Indiana Lawyer and IPM News, August 31, 2026, each reporting the Washington County court accounting records: the $2.66 million collective balance, the per-person shares, the $17,774 remainder, and the January 30, 2026 distribution figures. Establishes the owed column of §08.
The contempt and bond. WAVE, April 9, 2024 (the contempt finding and sixty days); Prison Legal News, July 2024, sourcing Louisville Public Media and WAVE (the June 4, 2024 bond increase). Establishes §04’s custody line. The contempt hearing itself is on video: youtube.com
The photograph. Jamey Noel, in an orange jail jumpsuit, listening to victim-impact statements at his sentencing, October 14, 2024 — a courtroom photograph by Casey Smith for the Indiana Capital Chronicle, cropped to Noel alone from the Chronicle’s published frame (a news photograph, not a booking photo). Face-verified November 11, 2026 against a second captioned news photograph of the same man (Ripley Publishing / Versailles Republican, October 24, 2024), and corroborated by the Department of Correction’s offender record for DOC #301710 (see the package’s photo record).
The rule of this file. Claims above the grade of the paper behind them are not printed. Attributions ride with the claims they support, and §10 lists every original that would raise a grade.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
THE CHECKS RUN FOR THIS FILE — NO DOCUMENTED ENTRY FOUND. Searches run for this file on November 11, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news and court coverage, and through the full coverage of his case — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in Jamey Noel’s name. That is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere. The vehicles in this record were not a road offense; they were bought with an ambulance service’s money, and they are weighed where they belong, at §02.
If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.