
In December 2023, employees of the City of South Bend signed non-disclosure agreements with Amazon Web Services. The signatures were the city's own public-works staff. The subject was the largest economic project in state history — the Amazon data center rising between South Bend and New Carlisle, and the city wastewater service that would run to it. The agreements were secret. The public whose works department signed them was not told.
Signed in December 2023, the agreements were not disclosed to the public. They surfaced in the fall of 2026 because a council member heard whispers and started asking. On September 8, 2026, the Director of Public Works, Eric Horvath, stood up in a council committee and said it himself: “I’m the one that signed an NDA, so you guys need to hear from me.” The mayor, by his own statement to the South Bend Tribune a week later, “wasn’t aware city employees signed NDAs with Amazon until very recently.”
What Mayor James Mueller did next is the spine of this file. He signed an executive order — No. 01-2026, September 16, 2026 — barring the employees under his own supervision from signing the next secret data-center agreement. The order binds his branch only. It is prospective only. It does not touch the Amazon NDA his government already signed, which runs to December 2026. And when the Common Council tried to write the ban across the whole city government — Bill 67-26, filed September 9, 2026 — the mayor’s office answered that the council had no legal authority to do it, the mayor called the bill’s early draft an AI product carrying “citations of precedents that don’t exist,” and he said on the record that if it passed unfixed, he would veto it. On November 9, 2026, the council’s Personnel and Finance Committee tabled the bill indefinitely, 4–1. Its sponsor says he will bring it back. (§04)
One thing this file states at the top, because it governs everything below. James Mueller is the chief executive of this city — over 1,000 employees and a budget his own office puts at over $380 million. He is not a bystander in his own administration’s paper. Where the record ties a decision to him personally, this file says so and shows the paper. Where the record ties it only to the City Administration he heads, this file says exactly that and no more. And where the paper has not been produced — and in this city, in 2026, a great deal of paper has not been produced — this file prints the request, the acknowledgment, and the silence, with dates. (§08)
He came up through the office he now holds. He was Pete Buttigieg’s chief of staff from 2015, then the city’s Executive Director of Community Investment from April 2017 — the office that courts business and cuts the development deals. He won the mayor’s office in 2019 with 63.41% of the general-election vote and kept it in 2023 with 72.83%, on the St. Joseph County election reports. This file is his whole public record as the record stands: the man, the office, the money, the secrecy fight, the police-oversight posture his administration inherited and carried, the courts, the campaign — and the searches that came back empty, printed as searches, with their scope. (§01–§11)
• Identity: James Mueller — 33rd Mayor of South Bend, Indiana; sworn in January 1, 2020. (§01)
• Before: Buttigieg’s Chief of Staff from 2015; Executive Director of Community Investment from April 24, 2017. He was never the city’s Chief Innovation Officer — that title belongs to another official, and this file corrects the record where it is misstated. (§02)
• Elections: 2019 general — 9,437 votes, 63.41%, over Sean M. Haas. 2023 general — 7,878 votes, 72.83%, over Desmont Upchurch. County election reports. (§02)
• Pay: the mayor’s salary for 2024 was set at $122,990 by Bill No. 63-23, adopted 7–2 on October 9, 2023. (§03)
• The secrecy fight: city staff signed Amazon NDAs in December 2023; the mayor says he learned of them “very recently” (September 2026); his Executive Order 01-2026 (Sept. 16, 2026) bars the next one — his branch only, going forward only; the council’s government-wide ban, Bill 67-26, was tabled indefinitely on November 9, 2026, after the mayor threatened a veto. (§04)
• The money: the city’s adopted 2025 budget book totals $447,119,391 in revenue including the Redevelopment Commission; property-tax revenue rose from $88,670,960 (2022 actual) to $108,764,709 (2025 adopted) in the city’s own books. (§05)
• The tapes: the police-tapes case his administration inherited ended its trial phase on May 28, 2026, when a judge ruled the recordings violated the Indiana and Federal Wiretap Acts and ordered them destroyed — stayed until every appeal is exhausted. The Common Council, not the mayor, is appealing. (§06)
• The transparency record: eight acknowledged records requests from this desk sat with no production date on November 3, 2026, when the city answered with no date for any of them; the fight is now in front of Indiana’s Public Access Counselor, on a letter sent November 10, 2026. (§08)
• The campaign: “Mueller for South Bend” reported 2023 receipts of $393,342.90 and expenditures of $610,625.36 on its annual CFA-4. (§09)
The identity, on paper. The man in this file is James Mueller, Mayor of the City of South Bend, Indiana. The city’s own page for him states the office plainly: “Mayor Mueller is the chief executive of the City of South Bend. The city’s thirty-third mayor, he was sworn into office on January 1, 2020. As mayor, Mueller is responsible for the city workforce of over 1,000 employees and an annual budget over $380 million.” His office sits at 215 S. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd, Suite 600, South Bend, IN 46601 — the sixth floor of County-City Building, where the Mayor’s Office has sat through every administration this series covers.
| Item | The paper |
|---|---|
| Office | Mayor of South Bend (33rd), sworn in January 1, 2020 — City of South Bend, official mayor page |
| Predecessor | Pete Buttigieg (mayor 2012–2019), in whose administration Mueller served as chief of staff from 2015 |
| Education | St. Joseph’s High School, South Bend; University of Notre Dame; PhD studies at the University of Delaware — City of South Bend official bio. Reporting adds: Notre Dame bachelor’s 2004 (philosophy, history, math) and a Delaware PhD in oceanography — reported by Notre Dame Magazine and the Saint Joseph High School alumni publication |
| Before South Bend | George Washington University Solar Institute, Washington, DC; office of U.S. Senator Maria Cantwell (D-WA), nearly four years, first as a John A. Knauss Legislative Fellow, then as a policy adviser on energy and natural resources — City of South Bend official bio |
| Home ground | Born and raised in South Bend (Sunnymede neighborhood) — reported, Notre Dame Magazine / Saint Joseph Square |
Source for the office facts: City of South Bend, “Mayor James Mueller,” southbendin.gov (page last updated December 5, 2025; read for this file November 10, 2026). Education detail beyond the city bio is marked reported where it stands on magazine and alumni-publication sourcing; a birth date of June 29, 1982 circulates in secondary references and is printed nowhere in this file as verified — no primary record for it is in this file’s hands.
What kind of mayor the paper shows. Mueller is a technocrat out of the Buttigieg school — an energy-policy man, a PhD, who came home in 2015 to run the mayor’s office from the chief of staff’s desk and then ran the department that sells the city to business. He kept most of Buttigieg’s department heads when he took the office himself. Nothing in the record searched for this file shows a criminal case, an audit finding, or an ethics action naming James Mueller personally — those searches, and their exact scope, are printed in §10 so the reader can weigh the silence himself.
The apprenticeship. Mueller returned to South Bend in 2015 to become Mayor Pete Buttigieg’s Chief of Staff. The city’s own bio credits that tenure with the establishment of the first Diversity and Inclusion Office in Indiana and the creation of the Departments of Innovation & Technology and Venues Parks & Arts. A Princeton case study of the era, “Rebooting a Rust Belt City,” independently describes “James Mueller, the mayor’s chief of staff from 2015 to 2017.” On April 24, 2017, he moved to Executive Director of Community Investment — the department “responsible for attracting businesses to South Bend and investing in the neighborhoods,” where he established the Engagement & Economic Empowerment Division. That desk — development, incentives, deals — is the desk he held when he ran for mayor, and it is the desk whose work runs through §05 of this file.
A correction this file makes in the open. Mueller is sometimes described, in summaries of his résumé, as a former chief innovation officer. The record does not support it. No source located in the search behind this file attributes that title to him: in the Buttigieg era the innovation office was built by Santiago Garces, and in Mueller’s own administration the Chief Innovation Officer was Denise Linn Riedl, retained in January 2020. The title is theirs. It is not printed as his anywhere in this file.
2019 — the first election. Buttigieg, running for president, did not seek a third term. Mueller won a nine-candidate Democratic primary on May 7, 2019 — reported at 4,447 votes (37.37%), ahead of Jason Critchlow (3,081) and Lynn Coleman (2,701), per the South Bend Tribune’s reporting of the county totals; the certified county primary report itself is a registered pull for this file (§11). Buttigieg endorsed him, appeared in his ads, and donated to his campaign. In the general election on November 5, 2019, the St. Joseph County Election Summary Report records:
| 2019 general — Mayor of South Bend | Votes | Share |
|---|---|---|
| James Mueller (DEM) | 9,437 | 63.41% |
| Sean M. Haas (REP) | 5,445 | 36.59% |
| Total | 14,882 | — |
Source: St. Joseph County, Election Summary Report, General Election, November 5, 2019 (county report dated November 6, 2019; marked unofficial/absentee-and-election-day results — the certified canvass is registered as a pull in §11).
2023 — the second election. Mueller announced his re-election bid on November 15, 2022. In the May 2, 2023 Democratic primary he defeated Henry Davis Jr. — reported at 4,880 votes (67.50%) to Davis’s 2,350 (32.50%). In the general election on November 7, 2023, the county’s Official Results record 7,878 votes for Mueller, 72.83%, of 10,817 cast in the race, over Republican nominee Desmont Upchurch. Secondary tables print 7,877 of 10,815; the one-vote and two-vote differences are unresolved in the sources in hand, so this file prints the county’s own set — 7,878 and 10,817 — and no other. As of the Tribune’s October 5, 2026 reporting, Mueller had not announced whether he will seek a third term in 2027.
The office today. The Mayor’s Office is the city’s executive suite — chief of staff, legal, communications, and the directors who run community investment, innovation, and venues. The city’s current staff listing (southbendin.gov/mayors-staff, updated October 8, 2026) and the public record put these names in the office’s senior chairs as this file opens:
| Chair | Holder (current) | The paper |
|---|---|---|
| Chief of Staff | Troy Warner (from June 1, 2026) | City staff listing. The office’s first holder under Mueller was Kacey Gergely (2020–2024); the Deputy Chief of Staff chair was held by Jordan Gathers until 2023 and shows no successor on today’s staff page, though the post was still budgeted in 2025 — a gap this series has registered, not filled (§10) |
| Corporation Counsel | Sandra Kennedy | City listing. Tenure-era holders: Stephanie Steele (to May 2021, when she took a Superior Court seat), Charles Leone (interim, 2021) |
| City Attorney | Jenna Throw | City listing. Prior holder Aladean M. DeRose retired July 2023 |
| Director of Communications | Allison Zeithammer | City listing; her statements carry §04. Prior holder Caleb Bauer left the office in February 2026 |
| Exec. Director, Community Investment | Darryl Scott | City listing. The chair Mueller himself held 2017–2019; Santiago Garces held it before leaving for Boston’s CIO office in 2022 |
| Chief Innovation Officer | Madi Rogers | City listing. Denise Linn Riedl held the chair from January 2020 to November 2025 |
| Chief Community Officer, Venues Parks & Arts | Maurice Scott | City listing. Aaron Perri ran VPA until May 2023; Jordan Gathers held the executive-director chair until May 1, 2026 |
Roster source: City of South Bend staff pages and the appointment/departure reporting compiled in this file’s research record, November 10, 2026. Every person named in a senior chair in this table is a public official in a public role; each carries or will carry a file of their own in this series, built from their own paper.
The mayor’s pay. The mayor’s salary is set by ordinance each year. For calendar 2024, Bill No. 63-23 set it at $122,990 — adopted October 9, 2023, by 7 ayes to 2 nays; the council minutes record that the mayor took no increase in 2021 and took increases in 2022 and 2023. Reporting on the following cycle puts the 2025 figure at $126,681 and a proposed 2026 figure of $130,481 (Bill 61-25) — printed here at reporting weight only: the 2025 ordinance and the adopted 2026 ordinance were not in this file’s hands when it opened, and both are registered pulls (§11). Payroll-aggregator “earnings” figures (one reports $123,968 for 2023) measure something different from ordinance salary and are never substituted for it in this file.
The office’s budget line. In the city’s own budget presentations, the Mayor’s Office department line reads: 2021 actual $1,716,896; 2022 actual $2,132,797; 2023 adopted $1,036,452; 2024 proposed $1,109,306; 2025 budget $1,180,862; 2026 proposed $1,170,660. The drop from $2.13 million actually spent in 2022 to a $1.04 million adopted line in 2023 is unexplained in the documents located — functions may have been reclassified out of the line. This file prints the figures as the city prints them and characterizes the change not at all until the adopted budget books’ Mayor’s Office pages are pulled (registered, §11).
December 2023 — the signatures. According to a document the city itself provided to the South Bend Tribune, multiple South Bend public-works employees signed non-disclosure agreements with Amazon Web Services in December 2023. The subject was the Amazon data center between South Bend and New Carlisle — the largest economic project in state history — and South Bend’s part in it: wastewater service, approved in public by the Board of Public Works in December 2024, with permits following in early 2025. The project was public. The signatures were not. (Tribune, September 17, 2026, reporting the city-provided document.)
September 8, 2026 — the admission. The NDAs surfaced because Council Member Oliver Davis heard, in his words, whispers, and pressed. At a joint committee meeting on September 8, 2026, the Executive Director of Public Works, Eric Horvath, told the council on the record: “I’m the one that signed an NDA, so you guys need to hear from me.” Horvath — who carries his own file in this series, No. 48 — added that he had not felt comfortable sending anyone else in his place. The city’s count, as Council President Canneth Lee put it on September 28, is one active NDA, with Amazon, expiring in December 2026. No dollar figure attaches to the NDAs in any source in hand; they are not payments. They are promises of silence, signed by public employees, about public business. (Tribune, September 16 & 30, 2026; the “one active NDA” count as reported by Rackline, October 22, 2026, attributed to the council president.)
September 9, 2026 — the council’s answer. Davis and Council Member Sherry Bolden-Simpson filed an ordinance — Bill 67-26, per the sponsor’s own posting — to bar city officials and employees across the executive branch, the legislative branch, and the clerk’s office from signing or enforcing NDAs over data-center development, construction, zoning and tax abatement, and over the capacity, operations, pricing and infrastructure of the city’s Water Works. Its purpose clause, as quoted by the Tribune, reads: “The purpose of non-disclosure or similar agreements by municipal officials or employees relating to the operation and affairs of municipal governments is to shield information from the public through private arrangements… Such arrangements cannot be tolerated in the South Bend City government.” The bill would also have audited past agreements — a review by the city attorney with monthly reports to the council’s attorney. Council attorney Bob Palmer helped the sponsors draft it. (Tribune, September 16 & 30, 2026.)
The mayor’s answer, in three moves. First, the statement. On September 11, 2026, Communications Director Allison Zeithammer answered for the administration: “An NDA cannot legally prohibit or hide publicly disclosable information from being disclosed through the state’s Access to Public Records Act or federal reporting requirements” — and then the counter-attack: “Under state law, the Common Council does not have the legal authority to restrict what legal agreements boards, commissions and the administration can enter, so long as they are within the confines of the law,” and the bill’s proposed fines “fall outside of those bounds.” Second, the order. On September 16, 2026, Mueller signed Executive Order No. 01-2026, the Data Center Transparency & Accountability Order, filed that day in the City Clerk’s office. Its operative sentence, from the order itself: “No City department, employee, or appointee subject to the Mayor’s supervision and control shall enter into, approve, amend, renew, or extend an Agreement concerning a Data Center if the Agreement would prohibit or restrict Data Center transparency or public disclosure of the Agreement or any of its terms beyond the extent required by applicable law.” Read the order’s own limits, because the order prints them itself: it binds only those under the mayor’s supervision — it does not reach the council; it preserves APRA, trade-secret, security and privilege protections; and it is prospective only. The Amazon NDA already signed is untouched by it. Third, the mayor himself. Mueller told the Tribune he “wasn’t aware city employees signed NDAs with Amazon until very recently.” He guessed at why they signed — the city was not the lead on the project, and “you didn’t want the city of South Bend to accidentally or intentionally release the details of this project before the governor had the chance to announce it.” He called the council bill’s early draft “clearly” created using artificial intelligence, with “citations of precedents that don’t exist.” And he put a veto on the table: if the bill passed in its filed state, “It would go back to the council that would have to get a super majority to override the veto.” (Tribune, September 16 & 17, 2026. The mayor’s account of when he learned of the NDAs is printed as his statement; no document in hand fixes the date the Mayor’s Office first knew.)
September 28 – October 2, 2026 — the ground moves. The full council voted unanimously to support the mayor’s executive order and to give Bill 67-26 a favorable recommendation toward committee (the Tribune’s own dating of the two actions wobbles between September 28 and 29; this file prints the range). Council President Lee, presenting: the bill “reflects a principle this council should stand behind.” On October 2, Amazon’s AWS chief executive announced the company would no longer use NDAs with government agencies at all. (Tribune, September 30 & October 2, 2026.)
November 9, 2026 — the halt. The Personnel and Finance Committee tabled Bill 67-26 indefinitely, 4–1: Rachel Tomas Morgan, Ophelia Gooden-Rogers, Sheila Niezgodski and citizen member Caz Margenau to table; Karen White alone against. The Tribune reports that opponents cited vague, broad language and questioned the bill’s legality and scope — a collective paraphrase in the Tribune’s own words; no member, attorney, or mayor’s-office voice is quoted in the record in hand calling the bill “too vague,” and this file attributes those words to no one. Two more facts the record requires beside the vote: sponsor Davis himself asked the committee to pause the bill to explore its legality further; and council attorney Palmer — the council’s lawyer, who helped draft the bill; the Tribune’s November 10 story mislabels him “City Attorney” — said his own research found the ordinance “meets all the legal requirements,” while stressing that was not an opinion that it should pass. The Mayor’s Office made no statement on the November 9 tabling in the Tribune’s report. Davis says he will bring the bill back “during one of the last two meetings of the year, or… even in January if need be.” (Tribune, November 10, 2026 — single source for the committee detail until the committee’s minutes are pulled; registered, §11.)
The law underneath, in one paragraph. Indiana’s Public Access Counselor has held — most recently in Opinion 25-FC-069 (December 31, 2025), a case against Purdue, not South Bend — that “the parties to an agreement cannot deem information confidential in abrogation of the Access to Public Records Act,” that “a public agency has no authority to declare or agree to maintain a public record as ‘confidential,’” and that where a settlement agreement carries financial terms, those terms “must be disclosed.” That is the state’s own referee stating the principle the council’s bill reached for. This file’s own records lane reached for the paper a year of news cycles earlier: my request for the city’s data-center NDA records was acknowledged by the City on October 3, 2026 as AR26-2211 — and as this file opens, no NDA has been produced under it. (§08; the request and its follow-ups are registered in §11.)
The budget as the city prints it. The city’s adopted 2025 budget book — issued over the mayor’s own transmittal — estimates total 2025 revenue at $447,119,391 including the Redevelopment Commission, down 6% from amended 2024 estimates of $477,541,421. Inside the same book: property-tax revenue of $88,670,960 (2022 actual), $98,454,891 (2023 actual), and $108,764,709 adopted for 2025; local income tax adopted at $43,460,144 for 2025. The trend in the city’s own paper is upward on both taxes across the mayor’s tenure, and this file prints the figures without adjectives. (City of South Bend, 2025 Adopted Budget book.)
SEA 1 and the squeeze ahead. Indiana’s 2025 property-tax law (Senate Enrolled Act 1) is the largest external fact in the city’s finances. In his March 25, 2025 State of the City address, Mueller opposed the bill as not “targeted relief”: “We fully support targeted property tax relief that protects seniors, disabled veterans and other vulnerable homeowners… SB 1 is not targeted relief.” Presenting the 2026 budget on September 22, 2025, he warned the law creates substantial uncertainty for property- and income-tax revenue; for 2027, the Tribune reports, his administration proposed an across-the-board 5% departmental reduction in response — Venues Parks & Arts alone proposing 15 position cuts saving about $780,000. (Reported: State Affairs/Howey Politics reporting of the March 2025 address; South Bend Tribune, September 23, 2026.)
TIF. The Redevelopment Commission’s 2024 TIF management report, presented to the council on April 14, 2025 by Community Investment Executive Director Caleb Bauer, put combined TIF fund balances at $70.8 million at the end of 2024, with TIF revenue rising from about $40 million (2023) to about $55 million (2024); the River West area is the largest. (Reported from the council presentation; the Commission’s own report is a registered pull, §11.) In February 2026 the Commission adopted a downtown Innovation Development District — eight new TIF allocation areas capturing state sales and income tax — around the Colfax Corner project. (Tribune, August 15, 2026.)
Four Winds Field — two figures, never blended. The city owns the stadium. A Board of Public Works professional-services agreement of July 11, 2023 ($849,525 for Phase I design) states an owner’s budget for the cost of the work of $40,000,000. At the September 10, 2024 groundbreaking, the project was publicly announced as a $48 million improvement, funded through a Professional Sports and Convention Development Area mechanism. Both figures stand in this file as their documents state them, fourteen months apart; the financing paper that reconciles them is a registered pull (§11).
Colfax Corner. The downtown tech hub reusing the former Tribune building, with Notre Dame as anchor tenant and a $30 million Lilly Endowment grant, is reported at $130–135 million total, with city financial support stated at $30.8 million (Notre Dame Magazine, 2026; Tribune, August 15, 2026). Groundbreaking was August 13, 2026; completion is projected for summer 2028. The development agreement that would fix the city’s commitment in the instrument itself is a registered pull (§11); until it is in hand the $30.8 million prints at reporting weight.
Data centers — the framework. On October 6, 2026 — in the middle of the NDA fight in §04 — the city released a draft Neighborhoods-First Framework for hyperscale data centers: full property taxes with no abatements, developers paying the full cost of utility upgrades, and 100% of data-center tax revenue committed to neighborhood improvements. A separately reported in-city concept (~300 acres, 750 MW, Western Hospitality Partners) was called “speculative at best currently” by the mayor’s spokesperson and is not a city deal; a November 5, 2026 NextNRG announcement ($22 million term sheet, Lone Wolf Energy Center site) is an announcement, not an approval. Both print here so the file’s reader can tell a deal from a headline. (City of South Bend framework page; Tribune, October 6 & December 18, 2025, November 9, 2026.)
Streets. On February 2, 2021, Mueller announced a three-year, $25 million “Rebuilding Our Streets” plan for neighborhood streets, with a condition dashboard presented by Chief Innovation Officer Denise Linn Riedl. (Tribune, February 2, 2021.)
The case he inherited. The South Bend police-tapes fight began in 2012, eight years before Mueller took office: the Common Council subpoenaed recordings of an SBPD phone line; the City Administration resisted disclosure on wiretap grounds; the recorded officers intervened to block it. On January 1, 2020, the defendant’s chair — captioned “South Bend City Administration” in St. Joseph Superior Court, Cause No. 71D06-1209-MI-000159 — became his administration’s chair. Mueller is not a named party in the state case in any document located for this file, and no document in hand ties a tapes-litigation decision to him personally; what follows is therefore printed as the record of the City Administration under Mueller, which is what the paper supports. (The gap is registered, §11.)
The case on his watch, from the court paper. May 10, 2021: the trial court ordered the subpoena enforced (reported; Tribune timeline). 2022: the Indiana Court of Appeals, in Young v. South Bend Common Council, 192 N.E.3d 176, affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded — reinstating the intervening officers’ wiretap claims for trial. The intervenors include Tim Corbett, the former Metro Homicide commander who carries File No. 7 in this series. January 12, 2023: the Indiana Supreme Court declined transfer (reported). December 9, 2025: bench trial. May 28, 2026: Judge Jamie C. Woods ruled for the intervenors — the recordings “were obtained unlawfully and in violation of state and federal” wiretap law; all recordings, cassette tapes, copies and derivative materials must be suppressed and destroyed — and, in the same order’s §5, preserved and not released, published, erased, disseminated or destroyed until all appeals have been exhausted. What is alleged to be on the tapes remains allegation in every source, including the 2026 order, which decided legality, not content; this file prints no content claim as fact. In June 2026 the Common Council — announced by at-large member Oliver Davis on June 24 — appealed the destruction ruling. The appeal is the council’s, not the mayor’s; its appellate docket and briefing status were not yet verified when this file opened (registered, §11). A figure of “more than three million taxpayer dollars” for the fight’s cost circulates from a single source (Redress South Bend, June 2026) and prints here at that weight and no higher.
The reform paper. The city’s own November 16, 2023 update on the 21st Century Policing process records two structural steps taken on Mueller’s watch: a Discipline Matrix adopted by the Board of Public Safety in July 2020 and a new Use of Force policy approved in June 2021 — the February 17, 2021 board vote on the revised guidelines (4–1, formally banning chokeholds and requiring de-escalation and reporting of excessive force, with further revisions demanded within two months) is reported by the Tribune. (City of South Bend, 21CP Update, November 16, 2023; Tribune, February 17, 2021.)
The Review Office fight. The council created the Community Police Review Office by Ordinance No. 10721-20 in 2020. Its first director, Joshua Reynolds — hired by City Clerk Dawn Jones in May 2021 at $65,000 — became a governance controversy when his Indianapolis suspension record surfaced; Mueller publicly said Reynolds should resign or be fired, and Reynolds resigned on August 20, 2021. The council then moved the office from the Clerk to the Mayor (August–September 2021), and the office’s director today is the Rev. Charles L. King III (the office’s Q1 2026 quarterly report). The fight is not finished: on December 18, 2025, BLM South Bend and former council member Henry Davis Jr. charged the Review Board was not adhering to its ordinance — quorum failures, a canceled meeting — and an activist, Jordan Giger, alleged that “the mayor’s office and certain members of the common council have tried to delay and disrupt the board’s work.” That sentence is an allegation, attributed to the man who made it; this file prints it as one. (Tribune, August–September 2021, March 22, 2023, December 18, 2025; City of South Bend CPRO Quarterly Report Q1 2026.)
Reparatory justice. On October 26, 2026, Mueller said 32 of the Reparatory Justice Commission’s 62 recommendations are in place or underway, six months after the commission’s report was filed; BLM South Bend rejected his premise. (Reported, Tribune via syndication summary, October 26, 2026; the commission’s report and the original article are registered pulls, §11.)
United States v. City of South Bend, N.D. Ind. No. 3:24-cv-00830. On October 11, 2024, the U.S. Department of Justice sued the city under Title VII, alleging the police department’s written test and physical-fitness test disproportionately excluded Black and female applicants, on allegations reaching back to at least 2016 — predating and spanning Mueller’s tenure. The ending, in the words the docket supports: on the parties’ joint stipulation (filed February 26, 2025), Judge Damon R. Leichty dismissed the case with prejudice on February 28, 2025. A joint stipulation after a change of federal administration is not a merits ruling for the city, and this file does not call it one. (Docket via CourtListener/RECAP as presented by the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse.)
Nichols v. South Bend Police Department et al., N.D. Ind. No. 3:25-CV-597. Ronald Nichols, suing pro se as a prisoner plaintiff, named among others Mayor James Mueller — in his official capacity — over an August 23, 2023 arrest whose charges were later dismissed. In an Opinion and Order of August 3, 2026, Chief Judge Holly A. Brady found the amended complaint stated no plausible claim against Mueller — the allegations amounted to appointing and retaining the police chief, and §1983 carries no respondeat superior — and gave Nichols until August 31, 2026 to amend, cautioning the case would be dismissed if he did not. Whether an amended complaint was filed, and the case’s current status, were not yet verified from the docket when this file opened (registered, §11); the order’s contents above are from the filed order itself.
The opioid settlements — the city as plaintiff. By resolution in March 2022 (Bill No. 22-16), the city opted back into Indiana’s opioid settlement structure — reversing its 2021 opt-out after state law raised local governments’ share from 15% to 50% — while holding its own suit against retail defendants and claims in the Purdue Pharma and Mallinckrodt bankruptcies. The amounts the city has actually received were not found in the record searched (registered, §11). (City Department of Law transmittal, March 23, 2022.)
The honest limit of this section. No comprehensive docket sweep of every suit naming the City of South Bend from 2020 to 2026 was completed before this file opened; the CourtListener and Indiana MyCase party searches are registered pulls (§11), and this section will grow in place as they land. What prints today is what the dockets and filed orders in hand support — nothing carried from news memory.
This section is different from the rest of the file, and the difference is printed on its face: it is built from this operation’s own records log — requests I filed with the City of South Bend under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act during Mayor Mueller’s tenure, the city’s written answers, and the dates. The log is the source; every entry below is in it.
The eight stalled files. By the fall of 2026 I held eight acknowledged city requests with no production: the SBPD Flock/ALPR records (AR26-2112, acknowledged via the city’s October 8 identification, sixty-plus days old by November); the Linden Avenue encounter records (AR26-2113); the data-center NDA records (AR26-2211, acknowledged October 3, 2026 — the same secrecy this file’s §04 documents); SBPD policy records (AR26-2213); three intake/Corby/Heartwood matters (AR26-2259, AR26-2260, AR26-2274); and the SBPD ID-policy records (AR26-2344, which the city on November 2 described as “waiting on department records, no timeframe”). On November 2, 2026 I followed up on production across the set. On November 3, 2026, the city answered: no production date for any of the eight — no fixed deadline, a citation to the Public Access Counselor’s Opinion 19-FC-133, a note that the city fields some 2,500 requests against my 28, and a warning about reasonable particularity that identified no specific category in any of my requests.
The portal wall. A second pattern runs beside the first. Requests I filed by email on November 4–5, 2026 — the Corbett-lane set, the Knepper litigation set, the Eddy Street set, the McBride city set — were answered on November 5 with a single form position: file through the city’s portal; email filings receive no AR number. My consolidated response went back on November 9, 2026, preserving the November 4–5 filing dates and demanding AR-number assignment or itemized per-request portal instructions. A third pattern is stranger: two requests I filed through the city’s own portal on October 24, 2026 — the SBPD roster and the factual basis for final officer discipline, the two most basic accountability records a police department keeps — were never numbered at all; the city’s November 3 answer described an email-submission scenario for submissions that had been made in its own portal, with on-screen confirmations. I restated both through the portal on November 9, 2026, preserving the October 24 date; the city numbered the restatements the same morning — AR26-2532 (roster) and AR26-2533 (final discipline) — without saying whether the originals were ever located or whether the October 24 date governs.
The referee. On November 10, 2026 — the day this file opened — I sent Indiana’s Public Access Counselor an informal-opinion request covering all three fronts: the eight acknowledged requests stalled without dates; the October 24 portal originals and whether their date governs; and the November 4–5 email batch answered with the portal-only form. The counselor’s office owes an opinion. It will land in this file, at this address, whatever it says.
How to weigh this section. None of it, standing alone, proves a decision by James Mueller about any single request — records in this city are processed by the Legal Department, and no document in hand ties a delay to the mayor’s desk. What it proves is the operating condition of public access in the city he has run since January 1, 2020, measured in his own government’s written answers: acknowledged requests aging without dates, a portal that loses what it confirms, and a form letter standing where productions should be. The mayor campaigned as a transparency modernizer and signed an executive order in September 2026 reciting that his city “operates transparently.” This section is the other exhibit.
The mayor’s campaign committee is “Mueller for South Bend” (abbreviated “Mueller for Mayor”), filing CFA-4 reports with St. Joseph County. Aggregator sites call the payee “James Mueller Campaign”; that is not the committee’s filed name, and this file uses the filed name only.
The 2023 annual report, as filed. For calendar 2023 — the re-election year — the committee’s annual CFA-4 reports: beginning cash January 1, 2023, $262,508.60; receipts year-to-date $393,342.90 (itemized $383,787.90 + unitemized $9,555.00); expenditures year-to-date $610,625.36 (itemized $610,117.82 + unitemized $507.54); closing cash December 31, 2023, $45,226.14. The committee spent roughly three dollars for every two it raised in the year it won with 72.83% — printed as the filing prints it, without characterization. (CFA-4, “Mueller 2023 Annual,” St. Joseph County DocumentCenter — read for this file November 10, 2026.)
What is not in hand. The committee’s 2019-cycle totals and any 2024–2026 annual filings were not located in the search behind this file (county DocumentCenter and web, November 10, 2026) — an incumbent committee ordinarily files annual reports in off-years, so the gap is a search limit, not evidence of non-filing. The full CFA-4 run, 2019–2026, is a registered pull (§11), and donor-level claims will print in this file only against the filed schedules, never against aggregator pages.
Under this series’ law, a search that returns nothing is a finding, and it prints with its scope. These are this file’s, as of November 10, 2026:
No State Board of Accounts finding names James Mueller personally. Scope: searches of SBOA reports and coverage, November 10, 2026, for City of South Bend audits and the mayor’s name. Located material concerned the South Bend Community School Corporation — a separate unit, whose findings are not the city’s and not his — and a 2017 city report, from the Buttigieg era, listing him only as a department contact for a corrective action. A direct pull of the SBOA index for city audit periods 2020–2025 is registered (§11); until it lands, this stands as a scoped negative, not a lifetime clearance.
No criminal case, and no personal-capacity civil case, naming James Mueller was found. Scope: web and docket-adjacent searches for his name as a defendant, November 10, 2026. The searches surface other men — a Marion County Jamie Mueller from a 2004–05 case, an Indianapolis car-dealership manager named James Mueller in a 2009–10 federal employment case, a James Mueller who was a TCPA plaintiff in New York in 2020. None of them is the mayor, and none of their records appears anywhere in this file as his. A direct Indiana MyCase name search is the registered closing pull (§11). The one suit naming the mayor himself, Nichols, names him in his official capacity and stands in §07.
No documented city NDA outside the Amazon/data-center matter was found. Scope: searches, November 10, 2026, for South Bend non-disclosure and confidentiality agreements — employee separation agreements, litigation settlements, Board of Public Works settlements — across 2020–present. Nothing documented a personnel or settlement NDA, and no source ties Bill 67-26 to employment settlements; the bill’s fight was over developer NDAs, and §04 prints it as exactly that. If a settlement NDA exists in this administration’s paper, it is not in the public record searched; the drafted APRA in §11 asks for the category outright.
No successor was found for two chairs. The Deputy Chief of Staff post — held by Jordan Gathers until 2023 — was still budgeted in 2025 but names no holder on today’s staff page; and no Venues Parks & Arts successor after May 1, 2026, and no Community Investment holder between February and May 2026, appears in the record searched. The gaps print as gaps (§03).
Not yet verified when this file opened (each with its closing pull in §11): the tapes appeal’s appellate docket and briefing status; the Nichols docket after August 31, 2026; the IURC’s final order in the water-rate case, Cause No. 45719 (the filings show the city seeking 7.7% phased and the OUCC recommending 1.58% — the approved figure is not in hand); the 2025 and adopted-2026 salary ordinances; the certified election canvasses for 2019 and 2023; the adopted budget books’ Mayor’s Office pages; and a comprehensive litigation sweep, 2020–2026.
This file’s public gap register. Every item names the pull that closes it.
| Item | Status | What it settles |
|---|---|---|
| Data-center NDA records (City of South Bend) | FILED — acknowledged as AR26-2211, October 3, 2026; no production as this file opens | The Amazon NDAs themselves and the city’s NDA paper (§04) |
| PAC informal-opinion request (three fronts) | SENT — November 10, 2026, to the Indiana Public Access Counselor | The eight stalled ARs, the October 24 portal originals, the portal-only deflection (§08) |
| Whole-file APRA set — the Mayor’s Office (MU-01 to MU-06) | DRAFTED — November 10, 2026; filed on the dated-batch approval, as every send in this operation is | Office roster + salary records 2020–present; every NDA and confidentiality-bearing separation/settlement agreement executed by the city 2020–present, including the Amazon instruments and the signer list; the mayor’s calendars; all correspondence on Bill 67-26 among the Mayor’s Office, the City Attorney and the Council; Mayor’s Office expenses; the mayor’s city personnel file from the Buttigieg administration |
| Bill 67-26 filed text + November 9 committee minutes | PREPARED — clerk/Laserfiche pull | The bill’s full text, fine schedule, and the tabling motion’s exact words (§04) |
| Certified election canvasses, 2019 + 2023 (primary + general) | PREPARED — St. Joseph County pull | The 7,878/10,817 vs 7,877/10,815 conflict and the primary totals at certified weight (§02) |
| Salary ordinance series 2020–2026 | PREPARED — city docs pull | The mayor’s pay for every year of the tenure (§03) |
| Adopted budget books — Mayor’s Office pages, 2020–2026 | PREPARED | The office line’s 2022→2023 change, explained or printed unexplained (§03, §05) |
| Tapes case — official order copy + Council’s appeal docket | PREPARED — MyCase / clerk / Court of Appeals | The May 28, 2026 order at official-copy weight and the appeal’s posture (§06) |
| Litigation sweep, 2020–2026 | PREPARED — CourtListener/RECAP + Indiana MyCase party searches, incl. the current Nichols docket | Every suit naming the city or the mayor, with docket-true endings (§07, §10) |
| SBOA city audit index, 2020–2025 | PREPARED | The scoped negative in §10, closed or corrected |
| IURC Cause No. 45719 final order | PREPARED — IURC portal | The approved water rate (§10) |
| Campaign finance — full CFA-4 run, 2019–2026 | PREPARED — county DocumentCenter | The committee’s whole history, donor schedules included (§09) |
| Four Winds Field financing instruments; TIF management report; Colfax Corner development agreement | PREPARED — Redevelopment Commission / Board of Public Works | The $40M/$48M reconciliation, the TIF figures at instrument weight, the city’s Colfax commitment (§05) |
| Encampment-removal records, 2020–present (MU-07) | DRAFTED — November 10, 2026, in the Mayor’s Office APRA set | Every City clearing’s orders, notices, after-action and property-disposition records — the May 26, 2020 sweep and the May 2023 shutdown at document weight (§12) |
| Mayor’s Office communications on the clearings (MU-08) | DRAFTED — November 10, 2026, in the Mayor’s Office APRA set | Who decided the Michigan Street clearings, and what was said inside the office before and after (§12) |
| Homelessness program contracts and spend (MU-09) | DRAFTED — November 10, 2026, in the Mayor’s Office APRA set | The EDIT $650,000 accounting; the Motels4Now city grants/contracts incl. the Knights Inn purchase grant; the New Day funding instruments and site records (§12) |
| Mueller’s original May 26, 2020 post-sweep statement | PREPARED — city communications pull | The “proud” statement at full-text weight, not as quoted by others (§12) |
| What ended the Doulos Chapel camp (July 31, 2020) | PREPARED — city/code-enforcement pull | Whether the city ordered the church grounds closed (§12) |
| Tribune full text — May 2023 encampment shutdown | PREPARED — archive pull | The May 2023 camp’s location, notice, arrests, offers and property handling (§12) |
| Leliaert docket ending (3:22-cv-359) | PREPARED — PACER, when search privileges activate | The case’s ending, stated only from the docket (§12) |
| SBPD enforcement under Indiana SEA 285 | PREPARED — SBPD annual report due March 1, 2027; interim records pull | Any citation, arrest or clearing under the street-camping law since July 1, 2026 (§12) |
When the paper lands, this file updates in place, at this same address — that is how every file in this series works.
Mayor James Mueller took office in a city with no low-barrier shelter. Six years on, this is his record on homelessness — the clearings, the promises, and what each promise became — printed as a dated chronology, with promises and outcomes kept separate, and every claim carrying its source. Where a search found nothing, the search prints, with its scope.
April 30, 2020 — Winter Weather Amnesty closed. Advocates’ petition of the period states no local shelter was then accepting new houseless guests. [Advocates’ petition — single source, attributed.]
Early May 2020 — A tent camp formed on a private vacant lot in the 500 block of Michigan Street, with the lot owner’s permission and donated portable toilets. On May 14, 2020, Mueller declined, on the record, to break it up: “It’s my understanding it has remained clean and sanitary, and as safe as other places that could be outside without permanent shelter. Being pragmatic, as long as this remains safe and sanitary and healthy, and doesn’t generate its own safety or health concerns, then, while not ideal, this may be the best option we have in the near term.” [South Bend Tribune, Jeff Parrott, May 14, 2020.] Days later the owner, after his name appeared in an article, rescinded permission; the toilets were removed, and on May 20, 2020 the camp moved across the street onto a city-owned lot. Advocates state they had told city officials, the police and the Mayor’s office of the planned move, and that no alternative location was offered. [Petition — single source, attributed; Tribune, May 21, 2020.]
May 26, 2020 — the clearing. The federal court record states the City “decided to clear” the encampment, citing criminal activity and COVID-19 liability; gave three days’ notice to move by 10:00 a.m. on May 26, with signs posted; and that, when notice alone did not work, Chief Scott Ruszkowski dispatched officers “with orders to clear the property,” telling residents they risked arrest if they stayed. [Leliaert v. City of South Bend, 3:22-cv-359, Doc. 49 (N.D. Ind., Aug. 20, 2024) — verified.] Two pastors on the scene describe more police than residents, a bulldozer ready, officers with apparent less-lethal guns drawn, and a megaphone threat of pepper spray; they state they heard no alternative location offered. [Eyewitness account, Patheos, June 6, 2020 — attributed.] The advocates’ petition puts the police presence at “over 70 officers.” [Petition figure — single source, attributed.] Three people were arrested for trespassing: Tracy Leliaert, a housed protester; William Binion, an occupant; and one other. [Docs. 49–50 — verified as to three arrests and the two named.] That night, Pastor Mario Sims of Doulos Chapel took the displaced onto church grounds. [Doc. 49; reporting.] Mueller afterward issued a statement declaring himself “proud” of how Code Enforcement and the Police Department handled the task. [As quoted in Patheos, June 6, 2020; the statement itself is a registered pull, §11.]
The camp stayed on the Doulos grounds until the advocates’ program there ended July 31, 2020 — the occupants’ third displacement since April 30. Whether the city ordered the church grounds closed: not found in the sources searched. [Petition update — single source; open question, §11.]
The lawsuit. Leliaert v. City of South Bend, filed May 4, 2022, reached summary judgment on August 20, 2024: the court ruled for the defendants on the First Amendment and failure-to-intervene counts, and one claim survived for a jury — excessive force against Officer Morgan, limited to his use of his left knee. The case’s ending is not verified: later docket entries sit behind PACER, and no ending is stated here until the docket is pulled. [Docs. 49, 50, 73 — verified to that point.]
The city-run shelter that never opened. In May 2020 Mueller proposed that the city itself run a homeless shelter. The Associated Press reported he “hasn’t developed details of his plans,” and his spokesman Caleb Bauer said: “This is the early planning stages and we aren’t going to have all the answers right now.” [AP, May 24, 2020.] By July 9, 2020, Mueller said no entity had expressed interest in operating such a shelter year-round. [Tribune, July 9, 2020.] Outcome: “When the council gave the idea a chilly reception, Mueller scrapped it and appointed the working group.” No city-run shelter ever opened under that proposal. [Tribune, Feb. 16, 2021.]
July 13, 2020 — The Common Council passed Bill No. 20-22, a resolution addressing the emerging homelessness crisis, strongly encouraging the mayor to promptly present an emergency temporary aid and shelter program and to prepare an ordinance declaring a state of emergency on the homeless crisis. Passed 5–4. [Resolution text, July 13, 2020 council agenda packet — verified.]
July 16, 2020 — Mueller vetoed it. His veto letter: “Chief among them were the calls in the resolution to exceed my legal authority as Mayor, in addition to inappropriate encroachments on our respective roles. Approving the language in this resolution forces a choice between supporting an overreach of legal authorities or ignoring the text contained within the resolution. Neither choice is acceptable. We must meet a higher standard for legislation, even non-binding resolutions. I cannot approve legislation based on intent over the actual text.” And: “While I fully support acting as swiftly as possible and working together as a community toward sustainable solutions for our homeless neighbors, I am vetoing Bill 20-22 for the reasons stated above.” [Veto letter, July 27, 2020 agenda packet — verified.] The council’s override attempt failed on July 27, 2020. [ABC57 / WNDU, July 27, 2020.]
The task force, and the group that actually met. Advocates state a Houseless Task Force meeting was promised at the May 26 council meeting and that, more than a month later, the re-formed task force had yet to meet. No minutes, membership list or product under that name was found in the city documents searched. [Petition and public comment, July 13, 2020 — single source, attributed.] What Mueller created instead, in early August 2020, was his own 31-member Homelessness Implementation Group, which met through December 2020 and delivered final recommendations in February 2021 — Housing First, a low-barrier intake center, and more permanent supportive housing. [Implementation Group Final Recommendations, Feb. 2021 — verified; HOME-ARP Allocation Plan.]
The old Salvation Army building. The city had bought the former Salvation Army building on South Main Street in 2019 for $299,000, for winter weather amnesty — designed for 60–70 people overnight, run by Hope Ministries. [Board of Public Works agreement, Nov. 12, 2019 — verified.] On the night of the sweep, Mueller proposed using it again for that winter’s amnesty; in July 2020, council members pressing him to open it at once for emergency shelter were told the idea lacked downtown-business support. It served four winters as seasonal amnesty, 50–60 beds in use — never as a year-round shelter. [Tribune, July 9, 2020; Redevelopment Commission minutes, Jan. 26, 2023 — verified.]
August 17, 2020 — Motels4Now began: advocates under Our Lady of the Road began moving 42 people from tents into motel rooms. St. Joseph County contracted for the program with CARES Act money (October 1, 2020–March 31, 2021); the city funded Oaklawn’s wrap-around services for the same period. More than 100 people were housed by December 2020; 150 residents, including 41 children, by January 2021. [Notre Dame Institute for Social Concerns, Jan. 21, 2022; Today’s Catholic.]
The $650,000. In late October 2020 Mueller pledged $650,000 of the city’s Economic Development Income Tax funds in 2021 for homelessness, and named Deputy Chief of Staff Jordan Gathers his homelessness lead. [Tribune, Feb. 23, 2021.] The pledge was budgeted: the city’s February 22, 2021 presentation breaks the $650,000 down — weather amnesty $272,000; new center scoping and planning $133,000; an implementation contractor $75,000; a countywide coordinator match $25,000; an education campaign $15,000; bus passes $30,000; supportive-housing leasing $100,000. [City Council presentation, Feb. 22, 2021 — verified.] Whether the full $650,000 was actually spent, and on what, is not found in the sources searched — the accounting is a registered pull (§11).
The coordinator. The Implementation Group recommended a jointly funded countywide coordinator. The city instead hired a contractor — Housing Matters LLC, headed by Anne Mannix, a one-year, $75,000 facilitator contract — in early August 2021, six months after the recommendation. A salaried city coordinator, Carl Hetler, does not appear in the record until late 2023 / early 2024 — roughly three years later. He remains in the role in 2026. A joint city–county coordinator position is not documented as ever having been created. [Tribune, Aug. 17, 2021 and Dec. 19, 2023; DCI minutes, Sept. 12, 2024 — verified; city homelessness page, updated Oct. 21, 2026.]
Motels4Now’s county funding survived a fight — county commissioners vetoed a $1.65 million extension in February 2022 and the County Council unanimously re-approved it — before county officials elected in November 2022 declined further support; a request for more than $875,000 was denied in spring 2023. The county had given the program $3.3 million of relief money by then. [Tribune, Feb.–Mar. 2023.] On March 28, 2023, the city stepped in with $1.5 million of its own federal relief money for Motels4Now and $1 million for the Center for the Homeless; most of the Motels4Now money bought the former Knights Inn, where the program still operates, for $1.25 million, closing March 31, 2023. Mueller’s statement that day: “These shelter services are critical to our housing-first approach, which provides dignity and needed support to our neighbors experiencing homelessness. We cannot go back to large tent encampments in South Bend.” [Tribune, Mar. 28–30, 2023.] In his State of the City remarks three days later he put the county’s exit this way: “When the County abandoned its Motels4Now program a few weeks ago without any plan or transition, we stepped up to keep it going.” [State of the City, Mar. 31, 2023 — verified.]
Weather amnesty moved. The Salvation Army building’s last winter was 2022–23. The city’s $1 million to the Center for the Homeless was announced as expanding amnesty to about 75 beds as the main site from fall 2023; the first winter there was described as 50 beds for men, 16 for women and two family rooms. By the 2025–26 winter plan the capacity stands at 74 beds for men, 19 for women and two rooms for mothers and children, running November 1 to April 30 regardless of temperature, with turn-away counts to be recorded. No named report of a specific night on which people were turned away was found. [Redevelopment Commission minutes, 2022–23 — verified; Tribune, Dec. 19, 2023; 2025–26 winter plan — verified.]
May 2023 — the one news-documented shutdown of 2021–2026. “South Bend homeless camp shut down by police, code enforcement,” the Tribune headlined on May 22, 2023; the shutdown “renewed calls to extend the city’s weather amnesty program. Nearly all of the residents had been sheltered there until it closed May 1.” The camp’s location, its size, the notice given, any arrests, what was offered to the people displaced, and what happened to their property are not found — the Tribune’s full text was not retrievable in this sweep, and no other outlet’s account was located. The pulls that would close it are registered (§11). [Tribune, May 22, 2023; corroborated as an event by TV News Check, June 20, 2023.]
Portage Woods is not a city sweep. A large encampment on county land at Portage Manor scattered after a 2021 explosion — Commissioner Derek Dieter’s two tellings of its cause differ, and both print in the research record, not blended. County and community cleanups removed debris there through 2023, with no-trespass signs and trail cameras reported in September 2023. No document found shows an ordered removal of people from Portage Woods. It is recorded here so the record is complete — and not inflated. [Tribune; St. Joseph County minutes, Feb. 14, 2023; ABC57 via digest — single source for the signs/cameras.]
Scoped negatives. Year-by-year, outlet-by-outlet searches found no news-documented encampment clearing in South Bend in 2022, in 2024, or from January 2025 through June 2026. Two October 2026 social-media posts describing cleared or noticed campsites, and an undated zine claim of a breakup near Sample Street, are uncorroborated reports only — no location, completion or official record could be confirmed — and they are not counted as clearings here. An April 2025 camp at Our Lady of the Road was a documented non-removal: a negotiated stay. [Sweep searches, Nov. 10, 2026.]
In his State of the City remarks in both 2023 and 2025 — the second time in identical words — Mueller said: “We have already secured over 100 permanent supportive housing units and are working to add more in the coming years.” [State of the City 2023 and 2025 — verified as his claim.] No city document found in this sweep breaks that figure down unit by unit. The new supportive housing clearly documented as opened and occupied on his watch is Hope Avenue Homes — 22 units for people previously homeless, fully occupied in 2022 — plus an 8-unit Oaklawn development, Turnock House, listed in the city’s 2025 report. The 32-unit Oliver Apartments opened in 2017, before his tenure. “Secured” is not “opened”: the 100-plus figure appears to aggregate existing units, leasing, scattered-site commitments and pipeline projects, and until the city publishes the breakdown, it prints here as a claim, not a count. [City CAPERs — verified; HOME-ARP Allocation Plan.] The city’s own homelessness page (updated October 21, 2026) puts the community’s total supportive-housing stock at 391 units and its 2026 count at 596 people experiencing homelessness, 18 of them unsheltered, with 452 shelter beds, mostly full, with waiting lists. [southbendin.gov — the city’s figures, printed as such.]
The permanent low-barrier intake center was a 2017 goal, a Mueller campaign plank, and the Implementation Group’s central recommendation; the city budgeted $133,000 to scope it in 2021. By January 2024 the design stood at 80 beds and $12–16 million. That month the Redevelopment Commission put off buying the proposed Bendix Drive site after county officials and nearby businesses objected. Mueller answered the county on the record: “To those who say we need these critical services in this community but this site is not the right one, show us which site is better. Give us the site that’s better. We’ve been working on this for years.” And: “Motels4Now is not a permanent solution. That can’t go on indefinitely. But we also can’t go back to large encampments in our city.” [Tribune, Jan. 29, 2024; RDC minutes, Jan. 25, 2024 — verified.] Bendix was bought and then set aside for other redevelopment after the project moved. The site that held — 4022 Old Cleveland Road, 15 acres, $825,000, approved October 10, 2024 — was at least the fourth documented site, after an Ivy Tech / southeast-side site that fell apart in 2019, a Portage Manor site and an airport site the county rejected. [RDC records, 2024 — verified.]
By 2025 the design had grown to 120 beds and at least $18 million. The Redevelopment Commission approved a $4 million forgivable loan; the council backed it on September 22, 2025, and the 2026 budget carries $500,000 for operations — matching the city’s earlier pledge of $4 million in capital and $500,000 a year. The New Day Intake Center broke ground on September 22, 2025. It is under construction — a foundation permit appears in the city’s September 2026 report — and it is not open: its opening is projected for 2027, early in one account and late in another, a discrepancy the record carries rather than resolves. Motels4Now, which has served more than 900 guests by its operator’s count, still operates at the Knights Inn as the interim site. [WVPE, Sept. 22, 2025; Tribune, 2025; city permit report, Sept. 2026; Community Foundation grant summaries — provider-reported guest figures, attributed.]
No comprehensive South Bend ordinance banning public camping was found in this sweep; enforcement against camps in this record ran through trespass, property and code enforcement against specific encampments. The United States Supreme Court’s Grants Pass v. Johnson decision (June 28, 2024) held that cities may enforce camping bans even when shelter is unavailable — but no South Bend ordinance change, and no statement by the mayor tying local enforcement to Grants Pass, was found. The change that did arrive is state law: Indiana’s SEA 285 (Public Law 138-2026), signed March 5, 2026 and effective July 1, 2026, makes “street camping” on public land a Class C misdemeanor — with a warning and shelter information first, a charge only if the person remains within 300 feet after 48 hours, and a defense if no shelter or treatment bed is available within five miles; cities are barred from discouraging enforcement, and the South Bend Police Department must report its citations and arrests under the law starting March 1, 2027. Any South Bend enforcement under SEA 285 between July and November 2026: not found in news searches. [Grants Pass v. Johnson, 603 U.S. 520 — verified; SEA 285 — Indiana legislative record, verified.]
The shape of the record. One documented mass clearing, in the pandemic’s first spring, defended by the mayor as a job proudly done, and litigated for four years over one officer’s knee. One emergency resolution vetoed on its text. One city-run shelter proposed and scrapped within a season. One motel program the county built and abandoned and the city bought. One intake center promised since before he took office, on its fourth site, under construction at last — and a claim of “over 100” supportive homes that six years of city paper still does not itemize. That is the record as the paper carries it; the pulls registered in §11 are how every open line in it gets closed.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 10, 2026.
The city’s official mayor page (southbendin.gov, last updated December 5, 2025): 33rd mayor, sworn in January 1, 2020; workforce and budget figures; the bio — St. Joseph’s, Notre Dame, Delaware PhD; GWU Solar Institute; Senator Cantwell’s office; Chief of Staff from 2015; Community Investment thereafter. Named in: §01, §02, §03.
southbendin.gov/mayors-staff (updated October 8, 2026) — the current chief of staff listing; the office roster in §03 is built from this page and the appointment/departure record compiled with it. Named in: §03.
“Data Center Transparency & Accountability Order / Prohibiting Nondisclosure or Other Confidentiality Agreements,” signed by Mayor Mueller, filed in the City Clerk’s office September 16, 2026 (City Laserfiche, DocView 413663, linked from the city’s Data Center Framework page). Read in full; §2 quoted verbatim. Named in: Intro, §04.
Nelson v. Purdue University (December 31, 2025) — read in full (in.gov/pac). The confidentiality-clause holdings quoted in §04 are the PAC’s; the respondent was Purdue, and the opinion is cited as background law, not as a ruling on South Bend. Named in: §04.
Election Summary Report, General Election, November 5, 2019 (county, dated November 6, 2019, marked unofficial results); Election Summary Report, Municipal General Election, November 7, 2023, Official Results (county, dated November 17, 2023). The 2023 secondary-table conflict (7,877/10,815) is noted where the figures print. Named in: §02.
The 2024 mayoral salary ordinance ($122,990; adopted 7–2) and the minutes recording the 2021 no-increase / 2022–2023 increase history (docs.southbendin.gov). Named in: §03.
2025 Adopted Budget book (revenue table incl. Redevelopment Commission; property-tax and income-tax lines); Innovation & Technology budget presentations of September 26, 2023 and August 20, 2025 (citywide department table carrying the Mayor’s Office line). Named in: §03, §05.
Professional-services agreement, Jones Petrie Rafinski Corp. ($849,525, Phase I design, Four Winds Field), stating the owner’s budget for the cost of the work as $40,000,000 (docs.southbendin.gov). Named in: §05.
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Order and Judgment filed May 28, 2026 (Woods, J.) — the complete signed order as published (copy via redresssouthbend.com; the official-portal copy is a registered pull, §11). Holdings printed from the order’s text. Named in: §06.
The Court of Appeals’ opinion in the tapes case — affirmed in part, reversed in part, remanded (full text via CaseLaw/vLex). Caption variants exist across the record; the reporter cite and year are the stable reference. Named in: §06.
Docket as presented by the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse from CourtListener/RECAP (docket 69249424): filed October 11, 2024; joint stipulation February 26, 2025; order dismissing with prejudice February 28, 2025. Named in: §07.
Chief Judge Brady’s August 3, 2026 screening order (filed order via Justia docs): no plausible claim against the mayor; leave to amend to August 31, 2026. Post-deadline docket status not yet verified. Named in: §07, §10.
City’s water-rate case: petitioner testimony of Eric Horvath (Ex. 1, May 6, 2022) and Alex D. Hilt (Ex. 2; settlement testimony November 2022); OUCC testimony of Carla F. Sullivan (August 12, 2022). The Commission’s final order was not pulled. Named in: §10.
The committee’s annual report (St. Joseph County DocumentCenter, View/60870): receipts $393,342.90; expenditures $610,625.36; closing cash $45,226.14. Named in: §09.
The city’s statement of its policing-reform record: Discipline Matrix (July 2020), Use of Force policy (June 2021) (southbendin.gov). Named in: §06.
Community Police Review Office report (City of South Bend): Ordinance No. 10721-20; the Rev. Charles L. King III as current director. Named in: §06.
Jessica Velez, September 16 & 17, 2026 (the proposal; the executive order; the mayor’s statements); Rayleigh Deaton, September 30, 2026 (the bill’s quoted purpose clause; the council’s votes); Velez, October 2, 2026 (Amazon’s national NDA announcement); Juliane Balog, November 10, 2026 (the November 9 tabling, 4–1, member by member). Committee detail stands at single-source weight until the minutes are pulled. Named in: Intro, §04.
February 2, 2021 (streets plan); February 17, 2021 (Board of Public Safety vote); August–September 2021 and March 22, 2023 (Review Office); January 29, 2024 (New Day Intake Center); November 15, 2022 (re-election bid); September 23, 2026 (SEA 1 / 2027 cuts); October 5, 2026 (2019 primary totals recited; third-term status); October 6, 2026 (data-center framework); December 18, 2025 (Review Board criticism; Western Hospitality concept); August 15, 2026 (Colfax Corner); November 9, 2026 (NextNRG). Named in: §02, §05, §06.
May 29, 2026 (the Woods ruling) and June 26, 2026 (the council’s appeal, announced by Oliver Davis June 24). Named in: §06.
MiLB.com, September 10, 2024 (Four Winds Field groundbreaking; the $48 million announced figure). Notre Dame Magazine, “The New Mayor” (2020) and “Civic Collaboration” (2026) (bio detail; Colfax $135M / city support $30.8M). Princeton Successful Societies case study (2018) (chief-of-staff tenure). Saint Joseph Square, August 17, 2021 (alumni profile; the April 24, 2017 transition date). Named in: §01, §02, §05.
Docs. 49, 50 and 73 (Leichty, J., 2024, via Justia): the May 26, 2020 clearing as the court record recites it — the decision, the three days’ notice, the clearing order, the three arrests, the church shelter that night — and the August 20, 2024 summary-judgment rulings. The case’s ending was not verified; later docket entries sit behind PACER. Named in: §12.
The resolution’s full title and text, Mueller’s July 16, 2020 veto letter, and the July 27, 2020 agenda carrying the veto (docs.southbendin.gov) — read in full. Named in: §12.
Board of Public Works agreement, November 12, 2019 (Salvation Army building; Hope Ministries); Homelessness Implementation Group Final Recommendations, February 2021, with the February 22, 2021 council presentation breaking down the $650,000 EDIT budget; Redevelopment Commission minutes of October 27, 2022, January 26, 2023, May 11, 2023, January 25, 2024 and October 2024 (amnesty site, Bendix, Old Cleveland Road); the HOME-ARP Allocation Plan; city CAPERs (Hope Avenue occupancy); DCI minutes, September 12, 2024 (coordinator); the 2025–26 weather-amnesty winter plan; and the city’s homelessness page as updated October 21, 2026 (point-in-time figures, beds, the coordinator listing). Named in: §12.
Full texts at southbendin.gov (March 31, 2023; March 25, 2025): the housing-first pillars, the “over 100 permanent supportive housing units” claim in identical words both years, the Motels4Now passage, and “We cannot go back to large tent encampments in South Bend.” No homelessness passage was quoted from the 2021, 2022, 2024 or 2026 addresses — no text was located for 2021 or 2026, and the located 2022 and 2024 texts were not opened for this section. Named in: §12.
The Supreme Court’s camping-ban holding (June 28, 2024) and Indiana’s street-camping act — signed March 5, 2026, effective July 1, 2026, with its warning, 300-foot / 48-hour, five-mile-bed-defense and SBPD reporting provisions — from the opinions and the Indiana legislative record. No South Bend ordinance change or mayoral statement tying local enforcement to Grants Pass was found. Named in: §12.
South Bend Tribune: Parrott, May 14 and July 9, 2020, February 16 and 23, 2021, August 17, 2021; the Motels4Now and county-funding sequence, February 2022–March 2023; May 22, 2023 (the encampment shutdown); December 19, 2023; Smith, January 29, 2024 (Bendix; the mayor’s “show us which site is better”). AP, May 2020 (the city-run shelter proposal), via Indiana Public Media. WNDU / ABC57, July 27, 2020 (the failed override). WVPE, September 22, 2025 (the New Day groundbreaking). Notre Dame Institute for Social Concerns, January 21, 2022 (Motels4Now’s history). Today’s Catholic, April 2023; National Catholic Reporter, August 11, 2023. Eyewitness account: Cramer & Badertscher, Patheos, June 6, 2020 — attributed where used. Advocates’ petition documents are cited as single-source claims of their authors, never as fact. Named in: §12.
The requests, acknowledgments and answers logged in §08: AR26-2112, AR26-2113, AR26-2211, AR26-2213, AR26-2259, AR26-2260, AR26-2274, AR26-2344 (the city’s November 2–3, 2026 answers); the November 5, 2026 portal-only replies to the November 4–5 email filings; the consolidated response of November 9, 2026; the October 24 portal originals and the November 9 restatements numbered AR26-2532 and AR26-2533; and the informal-opinion request sent to the Indiana Public Access Counselor on November 10, 2026. The log is the source; productions, when they land, update this file in place.