Every document this file names, where it lives, and what state it is in — in one place. Hosted means the paper itself is on this page. A docket entry means this file read the court's own chronological case summary and cites it; the docket lives at the court's portal, not here. Reporting is labeled reporting — it is never dressed up as a primary document. Anything missing is labeled missing, in plain words. Register checked November 7, 2026.
Full-size copy hosted on this page — in hand.
Hosted in this file · Named in: File home · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the federal docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Federal dockets are read through PACER, the courts' official portal.
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Scott R. Claybaugh is already a Sergeant with the Elkhart Police Department. The payroll record runs unbroken from there — same rank, no gap year, no separation (§02).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
Assigned to Professional Standards — the internal-affairs office that investigates other officers. Testifying in August 2023, he put his time there at "roughly four and a half years."
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
As the Professional Standards investigator, he opens the investigation of a female detective over accusations she was taking criminal-investigation records outside the department. He takes her laptop and her cell phone to cyber crimes for forensic analysis. His report runs 38 pages (§03).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
November 1, 2022 — He is in the room when the detective is placed on administrative leave — and, by his own testimony, he physically stops her from leaving it (§03).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
July 18, 2023 — The amended charges against the detective are signed. Specifications XIII and XIV rest substantially on Claybaugh's investigation; his report is in the hearing record as Chief's Exhibit 35.
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
August 16, 2023 — Claybaugh testifies as a city witness on day one of the Merit Commission hearing — and answers the cross-examination this file is built on (§§03–05).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
August 21, 2023 — The Merit Commission votes: misconduct found 4–1 (the commission's president dissenting), dismissal 5–0 , effective immediately. The written decision contains no findings of fact (§06).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
July 12, 2024 — The detective sues in federal court, naming Claybaugh among eleven individual defendants (§06).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
June 30, 2025 — The federal suit is dismissed — on the legal category of her speech, at the pleading stage, with her allegations taken as true for the ruling (§06).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
August 19, 2025 — Her appeal is dismissed — on her own motion . The matter ends in every forum (§06).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
Claybaugh is still a Sergeant with the Elkhart Police Department. No discipline, charge, or consequence for him appears anywhere in the public record (§02, §07).
Named in: §01 — The Record In Order · Last checked November 7, 2026
The investigation and finding behind the clearance Claybaugh described under oath: any report, memo, or closure document on the cell-phone accusation, and any record of whether a device of his was examined — Denied in full October 27, 2026 (IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8)) — reconsideration and narrowed follow-up in motion; Public Access Counselor route next
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
His complete personnel file in the public categories of IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8) — hiring and employment dates, the status of any formal charges, the factual basis for any discipline in which final action was taken, his complaint and investigation history, his assignment and its history since 2019, and his underlying Professional Standards investigation file — Prepared — filed on the whole-file order
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
His complete certification and training record — status and full status history, any Report of Cause, notice, order, or determination, and the Academy's correspondence with the Elkhart Police Department about him — Prepared — filed on the whole-file order
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
The office-incident file: internal reports and the Indiana State Police referral — Requested October 2026 — response pending
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Anything else this file names in its text that does not appear in this register is not hosted here yet — it stands in the file as reporting or as a records request until the paper itself is in hand, and this register is updated when it lands.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
NONE DOCUMENTED YET. If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.