
Paul Humphrey wore an Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department badge for twenty-four years. He also ran a second business — a lawn-care company — and it was the second job, not the first, that put a minor in his power: one of his own employees.
In January 2024, Marion County prosecutors filed his case in Marion Superior Court 21 — cause 49D21-2401-F4-002559 — and its docket carries 18 counts. In July 2025 he pleaded guilty to six counts of sexual misconduct with a minor — the counts stated in this file exactly as the court states them — and the remaining 12 counts were dismissed. On August 8, 2025, he was sentenced to twenty years in prison. Three months later his name appeared on the State of Indiana’s own decertification list, marked Voluntary: Paul S. Humphrey had surrendered his law-enforcement certification himself.
This file is built from the paper: the court’s own docket for the cause, pulled from Indiana MyCase on November 11, 2026; the Indianapolis Star’s reporting from the court documents; and the Indiana Law Enforcement Academy’s certificate decertification list — the state’s own record. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §09 lists every pull that would raise a grade further.
One rule governs every line: the employee at the center of this case was a minor. No name, no age, and no detail that could point to a child appears in this file, and none ever will. The subject of this file is the officer — and the record he made.
Twenty-four years. That is the whole of the verified career record this file can print: the Indianapolis Star, which covered his case from the court documents, fixes his service with the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department at twenty-four years before his arrest — nearly a quarter-century in the uniform of the city he was sworn to police.
No assignment history is printed here, because none was verified for this file. Accounts of where he served circulate in low-grade summaries of his case; they are not in the court reporting, and this file does not repeat what it cannot stand behind. His personnel file — the department’s own paper on those twenty-four years — is listed in §09 among the records that would complete this section.
What the record does establish is the shape of the ending. He was a serving IMPD officer when the charges were filed in January 2024. By the time he stood for sentencing in August 2025, the Star’s court reporting counts him what he had become: a former officer. The badge was already gone. What remained of it — the state certification behind it — he surrendered himself, and §07 takes that from the state’s own list.
Humphrey’s second job was a lawn-care business — his own company, run alongside the badge. One of the people who worked for that business was a minor.
This file describes what passed between them in the court’s words and no others. The charge the State of Indiana brought, six times over, is called sexual misconduct with a minor. That is the language of the statute and of the case caption, and it is as far as this file goes: no act is described here and no detail is retailed, because every detail belongs to a child’s privacy, and none of it is needed to weigh the officer’s record.
What the chronology establishes, from the court documents as reported: the charging papers reach back to January 2022 — two full years before prosecutors filed the criminal case in January 2024. For those two years, the man with the badge and the man with the business were the same man, and it was the second job that made the record.
It came out through the agency built to hear it first. Reporting from the court documents records that the Indiana Department of Child Services opened an investigation into the allegations — and that once Humphrey learned of it, events moved fast.
Police were called to his lawn-care business on a report that he had attempted to take his own life. Officers found him unconscious in a small room filled with carbon monoxide. He was treated at a hospital — and then he was arrested. That is the Star’s account, drawn from the court documents, and it is printed here at exactly that weight.
The department he had served for twenty-four years confirmed the arrest of its own officer. The career that ends this file ended there, in January 2024 — everything after it is court paper.
On January 26, 2024, the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office filed the case in Marion Superior Court 21: cause 49D21-2401-F4-002559, against a sitting Indianapolis police officer. The docket for the cause carries 18 counts.
The sheet, as the charging coverage reported it, ran wider than the conduct at its center. Alongside the sexual-misconduct counts stood counts of child seduction, attempted obstruction of justice, official misconduct and voyeurism — the State charging not only what it said he did to a minor employee, but what it said he did with the badge, and against the investigation itself.
Read this section for exactly what it is: a charge sheet is an accusation, printed here because the filing is a public act and part of his record. What became of the sheet is a matter of docket record, and it is printed without varnish: six of the 18 counts ended in his guilty plea (§05), and the other 12 counts — Counts 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 16, 17 and 18 — were dismissed. What Humphrey actually admitted is narrower than what he was charged with, and it is in §05. The two are never merged in this file.
There was no trial. In July 2025 — a year and a half after the charges were filed — Paul Humphrey pleaded guilty, by agreement, to six counts of sexual misconduct with a minor: Counts 1, 4, 12, 13, 14 and 15 of cause 49D21-2401-F4-002559, per the amended information (Count 15 standing in place of Count 11, which was dismissed).
A guilty plea is the defendant’s own word in the court’s record: not an accusation, not a headline — an admission, entered in open court, that the State could prove what the counts charge. On those six counts, the twenty-four-year officer admitted the counts that named his conduct toward the minor who worked for him.
The plea answered the case on those six counts, and the docket answers the rest of it: the remaining 12 counts — Counts 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 16, 17 and 18 — were dismissed. This file does not dress the ending up or down: the sheet as filed is §04, the conviction as entered is these six counts, the dismissals are printed with them — no more, and no less.
On August 8, 2025, the Marion Superior 21 court sentenced him. The twenty years this file has always carried now prints in the docket’s own structure, pulled from the court’s case summary on November 11, 2026:
• Count 1 (sexual misconduct with a minor, F4), plea by agreement: 10 years in the Indiana Department of Correction, 2 years of it suspended — 8 years executed — with 560 days of jail credit, and a two-year probation term; consecutive with Counts 4, 12, 13, 14 and 15
• Count 4 (F4), plea: 12 years, concurrent with Counts 12–15, consecutive with Count 1
• Counts 12, 13, 14 and 15 (F4/F3), plea: 12 years each, concurrent with each other, consecutive with Count 1
Eight executed years on Count 1, then twelve more running consecutive to it: 20 years executed in the Indiana Department of Correction, with the two years of probation on Count 1 standing as the docket states them. One later line stands on the docket after the sentence: on November 5, 2026, a motion for the guilty-plea transcripts and the clerk’s record was filed. This file prints the entry and claims nothing about its purpose or its outcome.
Twenty-four years in uniform. Twenty years in prison. The symmetry is the record’s, not this file’s invention — the two numbers sit in the paper, side by side, and they need no help.
One piece of paper outlasted the sentencing. An Indiana police officer’s authority runs on a state certification, and the Indiana Law Enforcement Academy keeps the public list of the officers whose certification has ended — the Certificate Decertification List.
His line on that list reads, in full: “Paul S. Humphrey — 11/03/2025 — Voluntary.”
November 3, 2025 — three months into a twenty-year prison sentence, the certification behind the twenty-four-year career was surrendered. By Humphrey himself, the list records: not stripped by the board, not revoked after a hearing — given back. It is the last official act in this file, and it comes from the state’s own record, which is listed in the sources below.
Every officer file in this library carries the same check: the subject’s record on the road — impaired-driving arrests, license actions, any driving history the paper carries.
For Paul Humphrey, the check came back empty. Searches run for this file on November 11, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news and court coverage of his case, and against the state’s own certification records — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in his name.
That is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere. If the personnel file (§09) or another record carries one, this section will be the first thing updated.
This file stands on the court’s own docket, on reporting from the court documents, and on the state’s own certification list. The first pull below is closed, and it is kept on the page, dated, so the reader can see what was asked and what the record answered. The rest are the originals still outstanding, each one named so this file’s grades can be raised in the open — and what is sought from them is their public portions: the dates of his IMPD employment, any public record of final discipline or separation, and the public portion of his Department of Correction sentence record:
Closed November 11, 2026 — the Marion County case summary (CCS). Pulled from Indiana MyCase: Marion Superior 21, cause 49D21-2401-F4-002559, filed January 26, 2024, decided August 8, 2025. The docket fixed the sentence’s structure count by count (§06), the formal disposition of every count outside the plea — 12 counts dismissed, listed at §04 and §05 — and the two-year probation term on Count 1, which this file previously carried as reported and now carries as docket fact.
1. His IMPD personnel file. Twenty-four years of assignments, evaluations and any discipline, under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act — the paper that would complete §01.
2. The Civilian Police Merit Board’s disposition of his separation from the department — the formal end of the employment the sentencing coverage already counts as former.
3. His Department of Correction record under the twenty-year sentence.
When a pull lands, this file is updated at this same address, in place, with the date of the update shown — the way every file in this library is kept.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
The state’s own record. Indiana Law Enforcement Academy, Certificate Decertification List (the Law Enforcement Training Board’s public list, dated October 19, 2026): the entry “Paul S. Humphrey — 11/03/2025 — Voluntary.” Establishes §07 in full. in.gov/ilea
The court’s own docket. Indiana MyCase, Marion Superior 21 — cause 49D21-2401-F4-002559, filed January 26, 2024, decided August 8, 2025 — pulled November 11, 2026: the 18-count inventory; the pleas by agreement on Counts 1, 4, 12, 13, 14 and 15; the dismissal of Counts 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 16, 17 and 18; the sentence structure count by count, including the two-year probation term on Count 1 (8 + 12 = 20 years executed); and the November 5, 2026 motion for the guilty-plea transcripts and the clerk’s record. Establishes the docket facts at §04, §05 and §06.
The court reporting. The Indianapolis Star — Ryan Murphy and Jade Jackson — These IMPD officers have been charged with crimes since 2024 (roster, updated 2026) and the Star’s IMPD crime coverage of March 13, 2026: the guilty plea and the August 8, 2025 sentencing to twenty years, the twenty-four years of service, and the Department of Child Services investigation and the circumstances of the arrest, all drawn from the court documents. indystar.com
The charging and plea coverage. Indianapolis charging coverage of January 2024 and plea and sentencing coverage of July–August 2025, as surveyed in this file’s research record: the charge families as filed (§04), the six counts of the plea (§05), and the conduct window the charging papers reach back to (§02). Where this file rests on that coverage, the text says so; the remaining originals are registered in §09.
The photograph. His booking photograph, published by LEO Ratings and matched in this file’s research against the same booking photograph carried in broadcast coverage of the case; printed at its true size, 275 by 344 pixels, never enlarged past the record.
The rule of this file. Claims above the grade of the paper behind them are not printed. Attributions ride with the claims they support, and §09 lists every original that would raise a grade.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
THE CHECKS RUN FOR THIS FILE — NO DOCUMENTED ENTRY FOUND. Searches run for this file on November 11, 2026 — his name against impaired-driving and traffic terms across the news and court coverage of his case, and against the state’s own certification records — surfaced no traffic arrest, no impaired-driving case, and no road infraction of any kind in Paul Humphrey’s name. That is printed as exactly what it is: none found in the records searched, with the search stated — not a claim that none exists anywhere. If the personnel file (§09) or another record carries one, this section will be the first thing updated.
If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.