
Eric Mentz’s documented record starts in 2012 — with a warrantless entry into a family’s home in the middle of the night, a teenager punched, tased and arrested for being the wrong man, a federal jury’s finding that his constitutional rights were violated, an internal investigation that found excessive force and unlawful entry, a second federal suit over a prank played on a 7-Eleven clerk, a one-day suspension, and a wrongful-death caption carrying Mentz’s name. Every one of those items is documented in public sources. (§02–§04)
The recent paper is real too: a detective’s affidavit filed October 5, 2022 in a multiple-murder case, and the department’s own summary when it promoted him to Sergeant in October 2026 — “spent several years in … the Violent Crimes Unit.” Both documents are verified in this file. One detail in the affidavit is worth printing exactly as it stands: it signs its author a detective of the “Violent Crimes Division” inside a unit the department calls a Unit. But a search that starts in 2022 will never find 2012 — and on this officer, 2012 is the story. (§02, §05)
The jury findings in this file are printed as findings, because that is what a verdict is. The allegations are printed as allegations, with the pleading named, because that is all they ever became. The dollar figures are printed only where a document carries them — including the one place where two documents carry two different totals, which this file shows side by side instead of blending. (§02) And where the paper runs out — a case number no source reached, a docket this desk could not pull — the file prints the gap as a gap. (§06–§08)
• Identity: Eric Mentz — South Bend Police Department; joined 2010 on the department’s own summary; Detective, Violent Crimes; promoted Sergeant, October 2026. (§01, §05)
• The verdict: Franklin v. Civil City of South Bend, 3:13-cv-207 (N.D. Ind.) — a federal jury in July 2016 found Mentz and two fellow officers violated the Franklin family’s Fourth Amendment rights by entering their home without a warrant and seizing a teenager who was not the man they sought. Nominal damages. (§02)
• The internal finding: the department’s own investigation found excessive force and unlawful entry in the same incident, and the officers were disciplined, including written reprimands — as the city itself told the press. (§02)
• The second suit: Ferguson v. Civil City of South Bend (N.D. Ind., filed May 2013) — the 7-Eleven “cinnamon challenge” case; settled for $8,000 on city records reported in the press; the conduct was alleged, never adjudicated. (§03)
• The discipline: a one-day suspension in January 2013 over the 7-Eleven prank — reported, WSBT/Police1. (§03)
• The caption: named defendant in Anderson, 71D05-1407-CT-000258, the in-custody-death suit — a name on a defendant list, with no personal act documented in any source this file reached. (§04)
• The later career: Special Victims Unit and Violent Crimes years on the department’s own summary; the October 5, 2022 Pence multiple-murder affidavit; a commendation acknowledgement in the December 21, 2022 Board agenda; Sergeant in October 2026. (§05)
• The photo: the department itself published a named portrait of Sergeant Mentz at his October 2026 promotion. This file needs no other picture of him. (§05)
• The open paper: his complete personnel file and disciplinary records were filed through the city portal November 10, 2026 and are pending production; this file updates in place when the productions land. (§07)
The identity, on paper. The man in this file is Eric Mentz of the South Bend Police Department. The department’s own summary, published at his promotion on October 6, 2026, gives the arc in its own words: he joined the department in 2010, after serving in the Army National Guard with a deployment to Iraq; he worked primarily in Patrol, on the 3rd Detail — midnights; he served in the Special Victims Unit and the Violent Crimes Unit; and he is part of the Uniform Crime Scene Technician program and the Honor Guard. In October 2026 the department promoted him to Sergeant. (§05)
| Item | The paper |
|---|---|
| Joined | 2010 — South Bend Police Department’s promotion summary, October 6, 2026 |
| Before | Army National Guard, with a deployment to Iraq — same department summary |
| Payroll arc | Second Class Patrolman (2012) → Patrolman First Class (2013–2018) → PO-Investigator, Special Victims Unit (2019–2022) → Patrolman 1st Class, 3rd Detail (2023–2024) → Patrolman First Class (2025) — Indiana Gateway payroll data, as mirrored |
| Detective years | Violent Crimes — his own sworn affidavit of October 5, 2022 signs him a Detective with the Violent Crimes Division, Investigative Bureau (§05) |
| Rank today | Sergeant, promoted October 2026 — the department’s own announcement (§05) |
One piece of arithmetic this file will not paper over. His sworn affidavit of October 5, 2022 states he had then been employed by the department for thirteen (13) years — which counts back to 2009, a year before the department’s own 2010 join date. Both documents are printed here as they stand; the file resolves neither against the other. The same tension runs through the payroll titles, which carry him as a Special Victims investigator through 2022 and a 3rd-Detail patrolman in 2023–24, while his affidavit of October 5, 2022 signs him in Violent Crimes. Paper in this city does not always line up with paper. This file shows the seams instead of sewing them shut.
Sources for this section: SBPD promotion post, October 6, 2026; supplemental affidavit in State v. Pence, Cause No. 71D03-2210-MR-000017 (filed October 5, 2022); Indiana Gateway payroll data via public mirrors. The personnel file that would settle the seams was filed through the city portal November 10, 2026 and is pending production. (§07)
Franklin et al v. Civil City of South Bend et al, No. 3:13-cv-207 (U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana). This is the center of Eric Mentz’s documented record.
How the night started — from Mentz’s own report. On July 7, 2012, at 2:23 AM, Officer Mentz responded to a domestic-violence complaint. The victim told him her boyfriend, Dan Jones, had bitten her — what Mentz’s report called “ghastly bite marks.” Jones was the older brother of DeShawn Franklin. Mentz relayed the information to Officer Aaron Knepper, who went looking for Jones; Jones had already left the scene, and the victim said he might have gone to his mother’s house. Officer Knepper glimpsed a man he believed was Jones jog across a street toward the 1000 block of Bowman, and lost sight of him. A K-9 tracked the trail from the alley to the back of a house about two blocks away — 910 Bowman Street. That house was the Franklin home at 910 Bowman Street — Jones’s mother’s house, and, on the Franklins’ account, not Jones’s own residence. (ECF 43)
The entry. The officers went in — without a warrant, and without asking permission, as the department’s internal-affairs report put it in the press accounts of it. Inside, asleep, was DeShawn Franklin, a high-school student — reported as 17 by the Associated Press and in his own lawyers’ filing as quoted by the court; the Washington Post reported 18. Mistaking the sleeping DeShawn for Jones, the officers seized him: punched, tased, handcuffed, detained. Only after he was subdued did they realize he was not the man they were looking for. They detained him further, then decided he should not be charged with resisting arrest or battery, and released him. Jones was not in the house. (ECF 43; Indianapolis Star)
The department’s own investigation. The internal-affairs investigation found that the officers used excessive force and unlawfully entered the Franklins’ home. They were disciplined, including written reprimands; the department retrained the officers on Fourth Amendment rights and built new classes on ethics and diversity. That is the city’s own account, given by its spokesman to the Indianapolis Star — printed here at that weight, as reporting of the city’s statement. One courtroom note belongs beside it: at the summary-judgment stage the federal court held the internal-affairs report itself unauthenticated and inadmissible as an exhibit. The finding stands in this file as the city’s stated position, not as a court exhibit. (Indianapolis Star, via the city spokesman; ECF 43)
The lawsuit and the road to a jury. The Franklins — Dan, Vivian and DeShawn — filed a twelve-count complaint on February 26, 2013, in St. Joseph Circuit Court, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and state law; the case was removed to federal court as 3:13-cv-207. On September 3, 2015, Judge Theresa L. Springmann ruled on summary judgment (ECF 43). Judge Springmann refused to find exigency as a matter of law, held the warrantless-entry rule clearly established and “not a close case,” denied qualified immunity, and sent the entry and seizure claims to a jury — which then found the entry unlawful. The federal excessive-force claim did not reach the jury: the court granted qualified immunity on that claim because circuit law on pre-seizure conduct was unclear and DeShawn’s active resistance was undisputed. A jury never heard the excessive-force claim; the internal investigation (§02, above) is where that question was answered, and it answered against the officers.
The verdict. From July 26 to 29, 2016, a federal jury in Fort Wayne tried the remaining claims. The jury found for the Franklins on the Fourth Amendment claims: Mentz, Stuk and Knepper violated the family’s constitutional rights by the unlawful entry of their home and the unlawful seizure of DeShawn. The jury found for the officers on the state-law false arrest, false imprisonment and battery claims. Those findings are findings. This file states them as such.
The damages — nominal, and printed with their paper showing. The jury found for the Franklins on both Fourth Amendment claims — unlawful entry and unlawful seizure — and awarded $1 to each of the three plaintiffs for each violation. The court recorded the total judgment as $6 in nominal damages (ECF 99). Contemporaneous reporting by the Associated Press, the Indianapolis Star and the Washington Post multiplied the same $1 awards by the three officers and reported an $18 total; the court’s own order states the recovery as $6, and $6 is the judgment figure. What no document supports is any larger number. The family had asked for more than a million dollars; the court record puts the trial ask at $1,275,000 to $1,950,000. The damages were nominal. That is the point of them, and it cuts the way the jury cut it: the rights were violated, and the violation was priced at a dollar a time.
What the case cost, on the court’s own order. The Franklins’ counsel asked for $168,430.79 in attorney’s fees. The court denied fees entirely: where only nominal damages are awarded, “the only reasonable fee is … no fee at all.” The court awarded the plaintiffs’ counsel $1,065.30 in costs, and awarded the defendants’ counsel $97.52 in costs under Rule 68 — the officers had offered the family $15,000 on March 16, 2016, the family declined, and the judgment came in lower. No document found in the record searched for this file shows any city payment in Franklin beyond the verdict and those taxed costs, and this file prints no other figure. (ECF 99)
The district-court record read for this file ends with the December 7, 2016 fees-and-costs order (ECF 99), after the July 2016 verdict. No appeal to the Seventh Circuit was located in any opinion or index searched for this file, and the full docket sheet was not pulled — this desk’s federal docket access is not yet active. The ending past ECF 99 is therefore written here as NOT VERIFIED, not as silence and not as a guess. If a later docket entry exists, this section updates in place when the docket is in hand. (§07)
Ferguson v. Civil City of South Bend (U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana, filed May 2013). The same summer as the Franklin entry, the same three officers — Mentz, Knepper and Stuk — were regulars at a South Bend 7-Eleven on their shift. What happened there became the second federal suit in this file.
What was alleged — alleged, and printed as such. Jonathan Ferguson, the store clerk, a man reported to have a learning disability, filed suit in May 2013 against the Civil City of South Bend, Interim Chief Charles Hurley, and Officers Mentz, Stuk and Knepper. As the complaint was reported, he alleged the officers bullied him, slashed his tire, and paid him to perform stunts on duty: $30 and an Applebee’s gift card to swallow a spoonful of cinnamon — the “cinnamon challenge” — after which he vomited for hours; and a challenge to eat ten crackers in one minute, which he started and did not finish. The complaint, as the Washington Post reported it, said the officers took a video of the cinnamon challenge and posted it on YouTube. The pleading was collective: no source reached for this file assigns Mentz a specific individual act inside the episode, and this file does not invent one. A filed allegation is not proven conduct — here, it was never adjudicated at all.
The discipline — reported, and dated before the suit. In January 2013, after an internal investigation, Interim Chief Hurley suspended Eric Mentz for one day and Aaron Knepper for two days for pulling the prank. The Tribune later reported the suspensions were without pay. (WSBT, via Police1, January 17, 2013; South Bend Tribune.) This is discipline on the public record, reported at the time it was imposed — in 2013, in the local press, carrying his name and a suspension.
The ending — a settlement, reported from the city’s own records. The Ferguson suit settled. The South Bend Tribune reported the figure from the paper itself: the clerk “settled the lawsuit with the city for $8,000, according to documents provided by the city in response to a public records request.” The $8,000 is printed here on exactly that basis — city records, as reported. The Washington Post’s account confirms the parties reached a settlement without stating the amount.
No case number for Ferguson was located in any source searched — not in the federal dockets and filings indexed by Justia, not in CourtListener-indexed results, not in news archives, and not in the Senate Commerce Committee questionnaire that documents the filing (it lists the case by month, court and parties, with no number). Without the docket, the formal ending — the dismissal’s date and form — is written here as NOT VERIFIED. The filing is documented; the settlement is reported from city records; the docket is a gap, printed as a gap. (§06, §07)
Anderson v. Civil City of South Bend, Cause No. 71D05-1407-CT-000258 (St. Joseph Superior Court, filed July 2014). The Anderson family’s suit over the in-custody death of Michael Anderson named a long list of defendants — the city, its officials, and a roster of officers. Eric Mentz is one of the names on that list. The filing is documented, among other places, in the Senate Commerce Committee questionnaire that catalogues the city’s litigation, which reproduces the defendant list with Mentz on it.
And that is where this file stops, because that is where the record stops. No source reached for this file — not the questionnaire, not the news and court indexes searched — describes any personal act by Eric Mentz in the Anderson incident. No report places him at a scene, assigns him a decision, or pleads a specific act by him. A defendant list is not a scene roster, and a name on a caption is not a finding. What the caption proves is only that a wrongful-death complaint naming him exists — not that it proves anything about his conduct in that case. It does not, on this record, and this file says so in the same breath that prints the caption.
The ending — in two parts. The suit did end once, on paper: the trial court dismissed it — the City defendants’ motion was granted October 23, 2014, with judgment on the pleadings for the County defendants. The Indiana Court of Appeals then reversed and remanded on October 16, 2015 (Anderson v. Civil City of South Bend, 41 N.E.3d 307, memorandum decision No. 71A03-1502-CT-53), reinstating the suit. What happened after remand is a different question: the case’s docket sits in Indiana’s MyCase system, which was not directly queried for this file, and no post-remand order, settlement or news account of a final ending was located in the indexed sources searched. The final ending after remand is therefore written as NOT VERIFIED. (§06)
This section prints the detective years from the underlying paper.
The detective years. On the department’s own summary, Mentz served in the Special Victims Unit and in the Violent Crimes Unit — “spent several years in … the Violent Crimes Unit,” as the promotion summary puts it. The payroll record carries him as an SVU investigator from 2019 through 2022 (§01). Board of Public Safety paper puts his name on a list of officers for Acknowledgement of Commendations in the Board’s December 21, 2022 agenda; the agenda text reached for this file lists the names without stating the basis of each commendation, and the file prints it at exactly that weight.
The affidavit — verified here independently. On October 5, 2022, in State v. Rease Pence, Cause No. 71D03-2210-MR-000017, Detective Eric Mentz swore the supplemental probable-cause affidavit: “Your affiant, Detective Eric Mentz, is a sworn law enforcement officer with the South Bend Police Department … I am currently assigned to the Investigative Bureau of the South Bend Police Department as a Detective with the Violent Crimes Division.” The case was the June 18, 2022 double homicide at Laurel Woods Apartments, where Jamie Binns and Samantha Lawson were shot and killed; the Prosecutor charged Pence, then 17, with two counts of Murder and a firearm enhancement. In September 2023 a jury found Pence guilty of both murders, and the court found the firearm enhancement. Mentz appears the same way a working VCU detective appears across the unit’s paper — his name also sits on witness lists in other Violent Crimes prosecutions of the period, as a witness, not the affiant. (§01)
The promotion. In October 2026 the department promoted Eric Mentz to Sergeant and published its summary of the man it was promoting: joined 2010; Army National Guard, Iraq; Patrol, 3rd Detail midnights; Special Victims; Violent Crimes; Crime Scene Technician; Honor Guard. The department’s post also published his formal portrait — an agency-published photograph, captioned as him, and the only photograph this file needs. The copy reproduced here was supplied from that promotion post and confirmed as him; the department’s caption is the identification of record. Nothing in the promotion summary mentions 2012. Departments write summaries forward; files like this one exist to keep the whole record in one place.
Read together, the record is not two officers. It is one: the patrolman whose name is on a federal verdict for a warrantless home entry and a teenager’s seizure in 2012 (§02), disciplined by his own department for that entry and separately suspended over the 7-Eleven prank (§02–§03) — and the detective the same department trusted with a double-homicide affidavit in 2022 and promoted to Sergeant in 2026 (§05). This file prints both halves, at the weight the paper gives each. What it will not print is a summary that keeps one half and deletes the other.
Every claim in this section is a search result, printed with its scope. A search that finds nothing proves the search, not the world — and Indiana police personnel and internal-affairs files are not public, so no section of this file, this one included, reaches the inside of Eric Mentz’s personnel file. That file was filed through the city portal November 10, 2026 and is pending production. (§07) Last checked November 10, 2026.
No criminal charge, booking, or arrest report naming Eric Mentz as a defendant was found in any source searched — news archives, court opinions, or indexed dockets. That is a statement about the sources searched, printed as one.
Beyond the one-day suspension reported in January 2013 (§03) and the Franklin written reprimands reported by the city’s own spokesman (§02), no other discipline item naming Mentz was found in the public sources searched. Discipline in this state usually surfaces, if at all, through the personnel file — which is the paper filed November 10, 2026 and pending production in §07.
As §04 grades it: Mentz is a named defendant in the Anderson in-custody-death suit, and no source reached describes any personal act by him in that incident. The negative is part of his record too, and it is printed here so the caption is never made to carry more than it holds.
(1) Franklin: no Seventh Circuit appeal was located and the full docket sheet was not pulled; the record verified here ends at the December 7, 2016 order (ECF 99). (§02) (2) Ferguson: no case number and no docket was located in any source searched; the settlement stands as reported from city records. (§03) (3) Anderson: dismissed October 23, 2014 and reinstated on appeal October 16, 2015; the final ending after remand was not verified — the MyCase docket was not directly queried and no post-remand ending was located in indexed sources. (§04) Each gap is an open pull, not a conclusion.
No source searched documents any city payment in Franklin beyond the nominal verdict and the costs taxed in ECF 99 (§02), or any Ferguson amount beyond the reported $8,000 (§03). Figures larger than the documented ones circulate in cases like these; none is printed here, because none is on paper this desk has seen.
The public record in §§01–§06 is what could be built from courts, boards, payroll and press. The rest of Eric Mentz’s file — the part that would settle the seams in §01 and complete the discipline picture in §06 — sits in records the department holds. Those records have been requested. This section is the register of the requests; when a production lands, this file updates in place at this same address, and the updated sections will say what the paper changed.
This is a different request from the portal pair below: a standing request in this operation’s records queue, filed by email November 4, 2026, deflected to the portal, with a Public Access Counselor opinion sought. It seeks, for Officer Eric Mentz: his complete personnel file, including hiring, assignments, promotions, discipline and employment status; all internal-affairs investigations naming him, with findings and dispositions, 2008 to present — expressly including the internal investigation arising from the July 7, 2012 Franklin incident and the 2012 7-Eleven incident, and the record of the one-day suspension reported as imposed in January 2013; all citizen complaints naming him, with dispositions; all use-of-force reports naming him; and a complete index of incidents naming him as a responding, assisting or arresting officer. Status: pending. No production has been received as of November 10, 2026.
Two further requests for this officer were filed through the City of South Bend portal in the November 10, 2026 batch: Batch #11 — his complete personnel file; Batch #12 — his disciplinary records as a standalone request (formal charges, findings, the factual basis for final discipline, internal-affairs dispositions, suspensions, demotions, reprimands, and any separation or settlement terms). Status: filed through the City portal November 10, 2026 (discipline confirmed 11:59 AM ET with receipt on file; file force-confirmed from the city’s confirmation page); awaiting acknowledgment/production.
What the productions could change. The personnel file can fix the join-date arithmetic in §01, confirm or correct the reported suspension and reprimand record in §§02–§03, and show whether any discipline exists beyond what the public sources carried (§06). The internal-affairs file can put the Franklin finding on primary paper instead of the city’s press statement (§02). Until then, every claim in this file stands at the grade its section gives it — no higher.
Officers in this library get a road-infractions section for a simple reason: they are the ones who pull people over. The search below was run on Eric Mentz on November 10, 2026.
No traffic or infraction case naming Eric Mentz as a defendant was found. Scope of the search: general web and news indexes, and Indiana court-record material indexed on the open web, searched under his name with traffic, infraction, speeding, citation and court-record terms, together with name-only court searches. Stated limit: Indiana’s MyCase portal (public.mycase.in.gov) is an interactive system and was not directly queried in this pass, so this negative covers the web-indexed record only. It is printed as a scoped negative — searched, and not found in the sources named — never as proof that no such case exists anywhere. If a MyCase pull or a production in §07 surfaces one, this section updates in place.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 10, 2026.
Opinion and Order (Springmann, J., September 19, 2013): the July 7, 2012 incident as pleaded — the warrantless entry, DeShawn Franklin assaulted and arrested through use of a taser, the search for his older brother — and the twelve-count complaint’s removal to federal court. Named in: §02.
Opinion and Order (January 27, 2015): summary judgment denied without prejudice; the parties ordered to state the discrete claims they intended to take to trial. Named in: §02.
Opinion and Order (September 3, 2015), read in full for this file: facts drawn from the officers’ own case reports, including Mentz’s dispatch to the domestic call and his report of “ghastly bite marks”; the exigency and hot-pursuit analysis; qualified immunity denied on the entry and seizure claims and granted on the federal excessive-force claim; the internal-affairs report held unauthenticated as an exhibit. Named in: Intro, §01, §02.
Opinion and Order (December 7, 2016), read in full for this file: the July 26–29, 2016 jury trial; the verdict for the plaintiffs on the Fourth Amendment claims and for the defendants on the state-law claims (citing the verdict forms, ECF 87); the fee request of $168,430.79 denied in full; $1,065.30 in costs to the plaintiffs’ counsel and $97.52 in costs to the defendants’ counsel under Rule 68, after the rejected $15,000 offer of March 16, 2016. The order’s summary line for the verdict — “$1.00 to each Plaintiff for a total of $6.00” — is the judgment figure §02 leads with; the contemporaneously reported $18 total is printed beside it as attributed reporting. Named in: Intro, §02, §06.
St. Joseph County Prosecutor release of October 5, 2022, with Det. Mentz’s supplemental probable-cause affidavit (“Detective with the Violent Crimes Division”; thirteen years’ service); the June 18, 2022 Laurel Woods double homicide; two Murder counts and the firearm enhancement. Followed by the Prosecutor’s September 21, 2023 release: jury guilty on both murders. Named in: §01, §05.
City of South Bend (docs.southbendin.gov): Eric Mentz listed under Acknowledgement of Commendations. The agenda text states the listing, not the commendation’s basis. Named in: §05.
The May 2013 entry documenting Ferguson v. Civil City of South Bend (plaintiff Jonathan Ferguson; defendants incl. Hurley, Mentz, Stuk, Knepper; U.S. District Court, Northern District of Indiana) and the July 2014 entry documenting Anderson, 71D05-1407-CT-000258 (St. Joseph Superior Court), with Mentz on the reproduced defendant list. The catalogue gives no Ferguson case number. Named in: §03, §04.
Memorandum decision No. 71A03-1502-CT-53 (Crone, J.), in this file’s Anderson case (trial cause 71D05-1407-CT-258): the trial court dismissed the suit October 23, 2014 (City defendants’ motion granted; judgment on the pleadings for the County defendants); the Court of Appeals reversed and remanded October 16, 2015, reinstating it. No post-remand ending was located in indexed sources; the final ending after remand is NOT VERIFIED. Named in: §04, §06.
The department’s own post promoting Eric Mentz to Sergeant: joined 2010 after Army National Guard service with an Iraq deployment; primarily Patrol, 3rd Detail; Special Victims Unit and Violent Crimes Unit service; Uniform Crime Scene Technician program; Honor Guard; the named formal portrait published with the announcement. Named in: Intro, §01, §05.
Gateway employee records for Eric Mentz J, South Bend Civil City, as mirrored by GovSalaries and OpenGovPay: Second Class Patrolman, 2012 ($51,011); Patrolman First Class, 2013–2018 (2018: $72,358); PO-Investigator-SVU, 2019–2022; PO Patrolman 1st Class, 3rd Detail, 2023–2024; Patrolman First Class, 2025. Mirror data; Gateway itself is the authoritative source. Named in: §01.
The verdict reporting: the jury’s finding of constitutional violations in the warrantless entry and seizure; the nominal-damages total as the court’s order records it ($6 — ECF 99), and as contemporaneously reported ($18 — AP/Star/WaPo); the internal-affairs finding of excessive force and unlawful entry and the written reprimands, as stated by the city’s spokesman to the Star; the department’s retraining response. Carried in full by Indiana Lawyer, September 6, 2016. Named in: Intro, §02, §06.
“2 cops suspended for prank, third may be fired”: after an internal investigation, Interim Chief Hurley suspended Eric Mentz for one day and Aaron Knepper for two days for the 7-Eleven prank — paying the cashier for tasks such as eating a spoonful of cinnamon or a quantity of saltine crackers. Named in: Intro, §03.
The complaint’s allegations as reported (bullying; the slashed tire; $30 and an Applebee’s gift card; the cinnamon spoonful and the hours of vomiting; the ten-cracker challenge) — the detail that a video of the cinnamon challenge was posted to YouTube is the Washington Post’s reporting of the complaint, and is registered to that account, not the Tribune’s — and the settlement: $8,000, “according to documents provided by the city in response to a public records request”; the suspensions later reported as without pay; the 2017 Gannett account repeats the jury finding, the written reprimands and the $8,000 figure. Named in: Intro, §03.
The standing personnel/internal-affairs request held in this operation’s Knepper-pack queue (personnel file; IA investigations 2008–present, expressly including the Franklin and 7-Eleven investigations and the record of the reported January 2013 suspension; citizen complaints; use-of-force reports; incident index) — pending (a separate request: filed by email November 4, 2026, portal-deflected, Public Access Counselor opinion sought); and the November 10, 2026 portal pair, Batch #11 (complete personnel file) and Batch #12 (standalone disciplinary records) — filed through the City portal November 10, 2026; awaiting acknowledgment/production. The log is the source; productions, when they land, update this file in place. Named in: §06, §07.