Toby Manges kept two public jobs in Marshall County: custodian and maintenance man for Bremen Public Schools — the State of Indiana's own payroll carries him there from 2020 through 2025 — and volunteer firefighter for the Madison Township department. In May 2026 he was arrested, and every news account of that arrest reported two Level 6 felony charges. The Marshall County docket holds one count, graded Level 5 — and the second charge does not exist. A second case, in St. Joseph County, holds one count of the same charge — and that case is already decided: he pleaded guilty, and the court convicted him in September 2026. Those corrections are not footnotes in this file. They are the file.
What follows is the record at its weight: the Marshall case exactly as filed and the calendar it now runs on, the St. Joseph County case and the judgment it ended in, the arrest as the reporting itself conflicts over it, the two employers who both moved in the same week and neither of whose final answers is public, and four months in which the Marshall case sat under an unserved warrant. In Marshall County he is charged, not convicted, and presumed innocent. In St. Joseph County the case is decided, on his own plea.
Every file in this series is built the same way: public records, exhibited in full, and nothing in them that the paper does not say. Finish one file, and the next is waiting — the loop does not close.
Every document this file names, where it lives, and what state it is in — in one place. Hosted means the paper itself is on this page. A docket entry means this file read the court's own chronological case summary and cites it; the docket lives at the court's portal, not here. Reporting is labeled reporting — it is never dressed up as a primary document. Anything missing is labeled missing, in plain words. Register checked November 7, 2026.
Full-size copy hosted on this page — in hand.
Hosted in this file · Named in: File home · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the public docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it at the official MyCase portal: search the case number. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
St. Joseph Superior Court 8 · Indiana Judicial Branch — MyCase · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Cited in this file from the public docket — the docket itself is not hosted here. Read it at the official MyCase portal: search the case number. Filed May 21, 2026. Link checked November 7, 2026 — it resolves.
Marshall Superior Court 3 · Indiana Judicial Branch — MyCase · Named in: This file · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
November 6, 2026 — Madison Township Trustee, Marshall County (Trustee Scott Laidig, by email): his complete Madison Township Volunteer Fire Department record — membership and service history, the administrative leave and its terms, any department action, and his separation or current status — Filed — acknowledgment flagged November 13, 2026
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
November 6, 2026 — Bremen Public Schools (Superintendent's office, by email): his whole personnel file — the components public under IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8), the administrative leave, the factual basis for any discipline, and his separation or current employment status — Filed — acknowledgment flagged November 13, 2026
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Begun November 6, 2026 — Court documents (MyCase / Clerk of Marshall Superior Court 3): the Information, the chronological case summary, the warrant and its return in 50D03-2605-F5-000013 — Pull in progress
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Read November 7, 2026 — Court record (Indiana MyCase): the full chronological case summary and the September 25, 2026 judgment in 71D08-2605-F5-000142 (St. Joseph Superior Court 8) — In hand — printed at §01 as Case 2
Named in: §07 — The Paper Trail · Last checked November 7, 2026
Anything else this file names in its text that does not appear in this register is not hosted here yet — it stands in the file as reporting or as a records request until the paper itself is in hand, and this register is updated when it lands.