
Julious Johnican was a first-year teacher in an Indianapolis Public Schools elementary school. In the fall of 2023, according to the court documents in his criminal case, he took out his phone in his own classroom, recorded a fight between two of his students — and did not intervene.
What happened next is the second half of this file, and in its way the larger half. The state agency that investigated the case confirmed the neglect in writing — and, as WFYI’s investigation found, never told the police. The school district did not tell the police either. Prosecutors learned what had happened in that classroom the way the public did: from the news. The teacher was charged in May 2024, pleaded guilty on August 4, 2026, and on September 24, 2026 was sentenced to two years in the Indiana Department of Correction for neglect of a dependent.
This file is built from the paper: the court documents as reported from the criminal case, the federal court record of the civil suits, the agencies’ own statements, and WFYI’s investigation of the silence around the case. Every claim stands at the grade its evidence earns, and §08 lists every pull that would raise a grade.
One rule governs every line: the students in this case are students. No name, no initials, no age, no detail that could point to a child appears in this file, and none ever will. The subjects of this file are the teacher — and the system that knew before the police did, and said nothing.
Julious Johnican came to Indianapolis Public Schools as a first-year teacher, and the fall of 2023 was his first semester in an elementary classroom. An IPS lawyer later said he had been hired during the pandemic as an emergency-permitted teacher — not a fully certified educator — a statement reported by the Indianapolis Star and carried here as the district’s own account of how he came to be in front of a classroom.
The record of his time in the building is short. The events in the court documents date to the first weeks of that school year. Once school officials learned of the video at the center of the case, Johnican was removed from the building and placed on administrative leave, and, in the district’s words as reported at the time, he never returned to the classroom. IPS personnel records list his resignation as effective in November 2023.
He resigned before any charge existed. The criminal case was still half a year away, and the two state agencies about to handle what he had done were about to handle it quietly (§03). What this file can say about the teacher himself is what the paper holds: a first-year, emergency-permitted hire; a classroom in the fall of 2023; a phone; and a resignation in November. The rest of the record belongs to the courts and the agencies.
The criminal case against Julious Johnican rests on a narrow, documented core, and this file prints it in exactly the terms the court documents support — no wider.
According to the court documents, between September 20 and October 1, 2023, Johnican recorded cellphone video of a fight between two students in his classroom and did not intervene. That is the conduct the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office charged, and it is the conduct described the same way in the prosecutor’s announcement and in the Indianapolis Star’s reporting from the court record. This file does not describe the fight, and it does not describe the video beyond those words. Nothing in the criminal case requires it, and the children in that room are not this file’s material.
The family of a student learned of the video that fall, at a parent-teacher conference — on the family’s account, as reported in coverage of their lawsuit, a clip was shown in error for another. However it surfaced, it surfaced outside every official channel: not through the teacher, not through the school’s own reporting chain, and — as the next section shows — not through the state agency that investigated it next.
The civil lawsuits filed afterward describe far more than the criminal case ever charged, including a pattern the families’ lawyers call a “fight club” style of discipline. Those are allegations in civil complaints, and this file carries them as allegations, in §05 — never as findings, and never as part of what Johnican admitted or was convicted of. What he was convicted of is in §04 and §07, and it is a single count with a single name: neglect of a dependent.
The Indiana Department of Child Services opened its investigation in November 2023. It finished in February 2024, and its conclusion was not ambiguous: the department substantiated neglect against the teacher. A state agency had examined what happened in that classroom and put its finding in writing.
Then, as WFYI’s investigation established, the finding went nowhere. DCS did not notify the police — although, as WFYI reported, the department’s own policy requires staff to notify police of abuse and neglect reports and to notify prosecutors of substantiated claims. DCS also did not notify the Indiana Department of Education, the office that licenses teachers. When WFYI asked the education department about the case, a spokesperson said officials there first learned of it from news reports, in mid-April 2024 — five months after the school’s report and two months after DCS’s own finding.
The district’s part, in its own words: IPS says it reported the matter to DCS in November 2023 in accordance with district policy. Superintendent Aleesia Johnson acknowledged that the district “fell short” in informing parents. What the district did not do is tell the police. The Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department’s investigation, when it finally began, began at the request of the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office — after prosecutors learned of the case from reporting, not from either agency that had handled it.
Read the sequence as the record gives it: a school reports to the child-welfare agency in November. The agency substantiates neglect in February. Police hear about it from prosecutors, who heard about it from journalists, in the spring. And in May 2025, the Indiana legislature passed House Enrolled Act 1412 — signed May 1, 2025, as Public Law 168 — requiring police to investigate whether a school or another institution knew about abuse by a staff member and failed to report it, according to the legislature’s bill digest as reported in coverage of this case. The gap this file documents is the gap that law now names.
This file makes no claim that any agency broke the law; no court or agency finding in this record says that. What the record supports is what WFYI found and the agencies’ own statements confirm: the finding existed, the policy existed, and the phone call did not happen.
In late May 2024 — roughly seven months after the school’s report to DCS, and weeks after the case became public — the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office charged Julious Johnican with neglect of a dependent, a Level 6 felony under Indiana law. One count. The case is State of Indiana v. Julious Johnican, Marion Superior Court, cause 49D25-2405-F6-015121.
The name of the charge matters, and this file keeps it exact. Johnican was not charged with abuse, and he was never convicted of abuse. The State’s theory, on the court documents, is neglect: a teacher who stood in a classroom, recorded one of his students striking another, and — on the State’s charge and the civil complaint alike — encouraged it instead of intervening — a failure of the duty his position carried, charged as a felony because of who he was in that room. The far wider conduct described in the civil complaints (§05) was never charged, and none of it forms part of his conviction.
He pleaded not guilty at the outset, and the case moved slowly — more than two years between the charge and its end, while the civil suits ran on their own track in another courthouse. How it ended is in §07.
Everything in this section is allegation — claims made in civil complaints, denied or unanswered in the ways the record shows, and never adjudicated in either case. This file states them because they are part of the public record of this case, and it states their endings with the same care.
The first suit. In April 2024, a parent filed suit in federal court against Johnican, the Indianapolis Public Schools Board, the superintendent, and school staff, alleging that Johnican encouraged and recorded the abuse of a student by other students and that officials failed to act — the complaint its lawyers framed as a “fight club” style of discipline. One year later, in April 2025, the parties agreed to dismiss the lawsuit. Whether any out-of-court settlement accompanied that dismissal is not stated in the record: the district did not comment, and the family’s attorneys said they could not comment on the resolution. Any figure attached to that ending anywhere else is not supported by the paper in this file, and this file prints none.
The second suit. On May 2, 2025, a second parent sued in Marion Superior Court — naming the IPS Board, the school’s principal and assistant principal, and Johnican — alleging gross negligence, failure to report suspected abuse, and deliberate indifference. The defendants removed the case to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana on May 16, 2025, where it is No. 1:25-cv-00959-TWP-MG. At the last docket-level reporting on the case — September 24, 2026, the day of the criminal sentencing — proceedings were ongoing. This file claims no ending for it (§08, pull JN-03).
Neither plaintiff parent is named in this file, and no student is identified in either suit’s description here, for the reason stated in the File’s opening rule: naming a parent would point at a child.
While the agencies were not calling each other, the state’s licensing office held a live credential with Julious Johnican’s name on it. As of the spring and early summer of 2024 — after the substantiated neglect finding and after the felony charge — his Indiana teaching license was still listed active and valid in the state educator licensing database, as WFYI reported from that database at the time.
The Indiana Department of Education’s own position, given to WFYI by its spokesperson, had two parts. First: felony neglect is not among the offenses that trigger automatic revocation of a teaching license under state law. Second: the department had filed a complaint against his license with the Office of Administrative Law Proceedings, seeking revocation — a proceeding that was pending when the statement was made.
What became of that proceeding is not in the record this file could reach. No 2026 coverage of the plea or the sentencing located in this build’s searches states whether the license was revoked, surrendered, or still stands. This file therefore claims nothing about the license after 2024, and the question is registered as an open pull (§08, JN-02). A man sentenced to prison for neglecting a student in his classroom may or may not still hold the State of Indiana’s license to teach. The paper should answer that question, and until it does, this file leaves it standing in the open — where it belongs.
On August 4, 2026, more than two years after he was charged, Julious Johnican stood in Marion Superior Court and pleaded guilty to the one count against him: neglect of a dependent, a Level 6 felony. The plea came under an agreement, and it came with a request — that the court enter the conviction as a misdemeanor instead of a felony.
On September 24, 2026, Judge Clark Rogers refused. The conviction stands as a felony, and the sentence is two years in the Indiana Department of Correction. A Level 6 felony in Indiana carries six months to two and a half years; the term imposed sits near the top of the range the charge allows.
Marion County Prosecutor Ryan Mears, announcing the sentence, said the defendant “abused the trust placed in him as an educator.” It is the prosecutor’s characterization, and this file carries it as his — the conviction itself is neglect, and §04 keeps that line exact.
His lawyers said he had no further comment. The district did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the sentencing. And so the criminal case that began with a phone in a classroom — and reached a courtroom only after journalists found it — ended the way the record said it would have to: with the teacher in prison, and the questions about everyone who knew first still standing in §03 and §06, unanswered on the paper.
This file prints its gaps in the open. Each pull below closes one, and the file will be updated at this same address when the paper lands.
The chronological case summary in State of Indiana v. Julious Johnican, 49D25-2405-F6-015121 (Marion Superior Court), pulled directly from Indiana MyCase — confirming the cause number, the plea entry of August 4, 2026, and the sentencing entry of September 24, 2026 against the court’s own record. The outcome in this file rests on the prosecutor’s announcement and four concurring named outlets; this pull closes it at the highest grade.
The outcome of the Indiana Department of Education’s complaint against Johnican’s teaching license before the Office of Administrative Law Proceedings (filed 2024, seeking revocation): revoked, surrendered, or still listed. See §06.
A docket re-check of No. 1:25-cv-00959-TWP-MG (U.S. District Court, Southern District of Indiana): still pending, as the September 24, 2026 reporting states, or ended — in which case the ending will be printed in the words the docket supports, and only those words. See §05.
The Marion County Prosecutor’s May 2024 charging announcement, pulled directly from the office. This file relied on the Indianapolis Star’s reporting of that announcement and on the office’s September 2026 sentencing announcement; the original release closes the chain.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 11, 2026.
Defendants’ Notice of Initial Extension of Time, Doc. 3 in No. 1:25-cv-00959-TWP-MG, read directly from the RECAP archive: the second civil complaint was filed May 2, 2025 in Marion Superior Court and removed to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana on May 16, 2025; the defendants are the IPS Board of School Commissioners, the school’s principal and assistant principal, and Johnican. Named in: §05.
The charging announcement (the recorded fight and the failure to intervene, as reported from the court documents) and the sentencing announcement of September 24, 2026, carrying Prosecutor Ryan Mears’ statement that the defendant “abused the trust placed in him as an educator.” Named in: Intro, §02, §04, §07.
WFYI’s investigation of the case: the Department of Child Services opened its inquiry in November 2023, substantiated neglect in February 2024, and did not notify police or the Department of Education, against its own policy; the IDOE learned of the case from news reports in mid-April 2024; IMPD investigated at the prosecutor’s request; the license stood active in the state database and the IDOE’s revocation complaint was filed. WFYI’s September 2026 sentencing coverage carries the plea posture and Judge Rogers’ refusal of misdemeanor entry. Named in: Intro, §01, §03, §06, §07.
The charge and the court documents (the September 20–October 1, 2023 recording window); the district’s account of its November 2023 report to DCS; the emergency-permit statement of an IPS lawyer; the August 4, 2026 guilty plea and the two-year sentence. Named in: §01, §02, §03, §04, §07.
The civil suits’ filings and claims; the first suit’s agreed dismissal (April 18, 2025 report); the second suit’s state-court origin and federal removal; the criminal cause number, 49D25-2405-F6-015121; the plea agreement; and the statement, on September 24, 2026, that proceedings in the federal civil case are ongoing. Named in: §04, §05.
Chalkbeat: the first civil suit’s agreed dismissal and the parties’ silence on its terms. Mirror Indy: the IDOE was told by neither the district nor DCS, and Superintendent Johnson’s acknowledgment that the district “fell short” with parents. Named in: §03, §05.
The sentencing as carried on the television stations’ coverage: the plea, the refused misdemeanor entry, the two-year term, and the family’s account of learning of the video at a parent-teacher conference. Also the source of this file’s lead photograph — a courthouse still credited to WTHR and FOX59 (see the caption on the File page). Named in: §02, §07.