Whose file this is — and whose it is not. The subject is Brody L. Brown, a Goshen Police Department officer whose name enters the public record in the title of the city’s own disciplinary resolution. He is not Coty Brown, a different Goshen officer, fired in 2017 over the shooting of Andrew Alcaraz — the same department, the same surname, a different man, and nothing in this file belongs to him. He is not the Brody Brown of Boyd and Rhome, Texas. No people-search listing was used for anything in this file.
The service record, on the city’s own state filings. Every public employee’s pay in Indiana is filed by the employer with the state and published through Indiana Gateway. The City of Goshen’s filings for Brody Brown run four years:
| Year | Title on the city’s filing | Wage as filed |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | Police Reserve Officer | $25,913 |
| 2017 | Patrol Officer | $52,066 |
| 2018 | Officer | $58,342 |
| 2019 | Probationary Patrol Officer | $32,537 |
Source: Indiana Gateway employee compensation records for the City of Goshen (Goshen Civil City), as rendered by GovSalaries; each year read for this file, November 9, 2026. Titles are printed exactly as filed; this file reads no rank history into payroll codes beyond the filings themselves. The 2019 figure is a partial year — his resignation came in October 2019 (§06). No Indiana public payroll record under his name was located for any year after 2019.
By December 2018 he was a serving patrol officer in his third year on the department’s filings. What happened next is the reason this file exists — and every step of it after this section is either the city’s own paper or reporting labeled with its source.
The City of Goshen’s own account of the night was published by its mayor, ten weeks later, in a statement to the community. It is the city’s words, and this file prints them as the city’s words:
“In the early morning hours of December 14, 2018 two off-duty Goshen Police officers were involved in a traffic stop. This stop resulted in one officer being arrested for OWI, Operating While Intoxicated, and started an investigation into possible shots fired. Elkhart County Sheriff’s Department was contacted shortly after to complete the investigation. After the Sheriff’s Department completed their investigation the case was turned over to the Elkhart County Prosecutors Office. During this time the Goshen Police Department has also completed an internal investigation.”
— Mayor Jeremy Stutsman, “To the Community of Goshen,” City of Goshen, published February 22, 2019.
The stop, as reported. The Goshen News’ year-end reviews of the case fill in the scene the mayor’s statement does not: Brown was driving. The truck was stopped on Elkhart Road at the C.R. 17 overpass — by another Goshen officer, who was investigating sounds of gunfire. Riding with Brown were Goshen Sergeant Kyle Kalb and Elkhart police officer Leonard Dolshenko. All three were off duty. (Reported: the Goshen News, December 27 and December 28, 2019.)
So the shape of the night, on the record: an officer out on gunfire calls stops a truck and finds three off-duty officers inside it — one of them a sergeant from his own department, one from the neighboring city’s — and the driver goes to jail for OWI while a second question opens beside the first: shots were heard, a gun was part of that night, and somebody fired it. That question is §03.
The Sheriff’s Department investigated the shots. The question at the center of that investigation — which of the three officers fired the gun? — was put to the three men who were there. The Associated Press carried their answer in its state brief:
— Associated Press state brief (Post-Tribune). The wire account is reporting, and it is printed here as reporting.
The prosecutor’s decision. The case went to Elkhart County Prosecutor Vicki Becker — File No. 3 in this series. She declined to file gun charges. The reason the wire account records is not the officers’ silence. It is the police work:
“insufficient police response”
— The prosecutor’s stated ground, as reported by the Associated Press — which specifies the failures: the responding officers did not secure the truck’s officer-passengers, and did not secure the vehicle.
Hold the two halves of that together, because the record holds them together. Three officers too intoxicated to remember who fired a gun — and a stop scene handled loosely enough that the prosecutor cited the response itself when she closed the gun case. No one was ever charged over the shots. Who fired the gun on December 14, 2018 is not established by any record this file has found, and this file does not guess at it. The companion file on the prosecutor who made that call is File No. 3, THE VICKI BECKER FILE.
The OWI arrest of December 14, 2018 became a criminal case — and this file now prints it from the court’s own paper. State of Indiana v. Brody Lin Brown, opened in Goshen City Court (No. 20H02-1812-CM-928) and received on transfer by Elkhart City Court on December 21, 2018, where it was decided as No. 20H01-1812-CM-010358 — a CM, criminal misdemeanor, case. Judge Charles H. Grodnik entered the judgments. Filed December 14, 2018; decided February 5, 2019.
This file launched with the docket named as its one outstanding record. The docket — the chronological case summary, pulled from Indiana MyCase — was read the same day, and this section was rewritten from it, in place, at the same address. What follows is the docket’s record. MyCase carries its own notice that it is not the official court record; the entries below are printed as the summary shows them, and where the summary does not say a thing in words, this file does not say it either.
The charges. Three counts, every one with an offense date of December 14, 2018:
| Count | Charge, as the docket states it | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| 01 | Operating while intoxicated in a manner that endangers a person | IC 9-30-5-2(b) |
| 02 | Operating while intoxicated, BAC .08 but less than .15 | IC 9-30-5-1(a) |
| 03 | Disregard automatic signal | IC 9-21-3-7 |
MyCase shows the degree for these counts as “CNV” and prints no Class A or Class C level for them in this view. A class this file has not read is a class this file does not print.
The course of the case. A $1,500 corporate surety bond was posted the day of the arrest. On January 2, 2019, attorney Mike J. Yoder appeared for Brown. On January 3, the summary records, in its own capitals, a “PROBABLE CAUSE SUSPENSION TO BMV (.177)” — the .177 figure is the docket’s, printed here because the docket prints it, at the scope of that entry. A PB setting — the docket’s abbreviation for its pretrial / plea / bench setting — was set for January 17, 2019 and continued to February 21, 2019.
The ending, in the docket’s words. The word the Goshen News used in 2019 was a plea. The docket does not use that word anywhere. Its entries for January 22, 2019 are three: two read “CASE DISMISSED BY STATE”, and one reads:
“1/22/19 DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY, JUDGMENT FOR THE STATE. FINES/COSTS OF $100 & $385.50. 30 DAY D.L. SUSP. 60 DAYS JAIL SUSP. 12 MOS RP, PUF NO D & D RAND TEST, EVAL/FOLL-UP H.V. ACT., VIP. TO PAY BY 4/19/19.”
Read plainly, the parts that read plainly: a $100 fine; a thirty-day driver’s license suspension; sixty days in jail, suspended; and twelve months of RP — probation. The remaining conditions stand in the docket’s own abbreviations, exactly as it prints them; this file does not expand an abbreviation it cannot source. Payment was due by April 19, 2019. The twelve months matches the year of probation the Goshen News reported — on the term, the docket and the reporting agree. On the mechanism, this file prints the docket’s words: found guilty.
The money — both figures, as the record shows them. The judgment entry above states fines and costs of $100 and $385.50. The summary’s own financial section states court costs and fees of $705.50 and a fine of $100.00 — $805.50 assessed — with a counter payment of $805.50 on February 5, 2019 and a balance due of $0.00; a February 6, 2019 entry reads “FINES/COSTS PAID.” The two costs figures do not match. This file prints both, exactly as the record shows them, and reconciles neither.
After the judgment. The summary’s last entry is February 8, 2019: Brown called the court because the BMV suspension had not been lifted, and a new SR16 was sent to the BMV. No later entry appears in this view — no probation-violation filing, and no discharge entry, is shown in the chronological summary as pulled. That absence is printed at exactly that scope.
One search result is not this case. The same party search returned a second item — No. 20D01-1812-MC-004759, an Elkhart Superior Court 1 probable-cause shell from the arrest, “No Charge Applicable,” decided December 17, 2018. It is the arrest’s paper shadow, not a second prosecution, and it is named here so no reader mistakes it for one.
While the court case ran, the city’s case ran on its own track — in the open, before the Board of Public Works and Safety, the board that disciplines Goshen’s officers. The mayor framed what was coming in his February 22, 2019 statement:
“The disciplinary actions recommended by Chief Miller include a reduction in rank, a long-term suspension, and a resignation.”
— Mayor Jeremy Stutsman, February 22, 2019. “These types of actions cannot be tolerated,” the mayor wrote in the same statement, “especially by those we trust to protect us.”
Three days later the Board acted. Resolution 2019-04, adopted February 25, 2019, records that notices of disciplinary action were issued to Brown on December 17, 2018 and February 6, 2019, over the conduct of December 14, 2018; that Brown waived his right to a hearing; and that he agreed to the discipline recommended by Police Chief Jose’ Miller. The Board imposed:
• Suspension without pay for fifty (50) work days, or four hundred fifty (450) work hours.
• His driver’s license must be reinstated before he returns to work.
• He shall attend an alcohol education program offered by the Center for Problem Resolution in Elkhart — at his own cost, on his own scheduling — and must complete all class hours and provide proof of completion to the Police Chief by August 15, 2019.
— City of Goshen, Board of Public Works and Safety minutes, February 25, 2019. The resolution passed unanimously. One item in the mayor’s package is not itemized in the Board’s paper in hand: the Board’s resolutions assign the long suspension to Brown and the resignation (next section) to Sergeant Kalb; which officer the recommended reduction in rank attached to, the record in hand does not say, and this file does not assign it (§07).
The sergeant. The Board’s second resolution that day, Resolution 2019-05, took up Sergeant Kyle Kalb — the senior officer in the truck. A notice of disciplinary action had been issued to Kalb on February 12, 2019, over the same December 14 conduct. Kalb waived his hearing and resigned. The Board accepted the resignation effective May 8, 2019; Kalb was relieved of police duties immediately, with his accrued pay running through May 3, 2019, his last day of employment.
— City of Goshen, Board of Public Works and Safety minutes, February 25, 2019.
The officer. Brown served under the discipline — the city’s 2019 payroll filing shows a partial year — and then, in October 2019, he resigned. The Goshen News states the reason: he failed to complete disciplinary steps ordered.
Two facts stand side by side in the record, and this file prints them side by side without welding them into one. The News does not name which step failed. The Board’s resolution set exactly one dated completion requirement: the proof of the alcohol program’s completion, due to the Chief by August 15, 2019 (§05). Six weeks past that deadline, give or take, the resignation came. A reader can see the shape of it; the paper in hand does not say the words, so neither does this file.
That is the end of Brody Brown’s public record as a Goshen officer: hired onto the filings as a reserve officer in 2016, a patrolman by 2017, arrested by his own department in December 2018, suspended in February 2019, gone by October 2019. No Indiana public payroll record under his name has been located for any year since (§01, §07).
A file in this series prints what the paper shows and names what it does not. For this subject, the open items are these — each one stated at its true size, with the lane that can close it.
This file was built in one day, November 9, 2026, from public sources — no records request was needed to identify the officer or to document the discipline, because the City of Goshen published both itself. The trail below separates the paper in hand from the paper still outstanding, so a reader can weigh every section by what stands behind it.
| Record | Custodian / source | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Board of Public Works & Safety minutes, February 25, 2019 — Resolutions 2019-04 (Brown discipline) and 2019-05 (Kalb resignation) | City of Goshen (official minutes PDF) | IN HAND — read in full, November 9, 2026 |
| Mayor’s statement, “To the Community of Goshen” | City of Goshen, goshen.in.gov — published February 22, 2019 | IN HAND — read in full, November 9, 2026 |
| Compensation filings, 2016–2019 | Indiana Gateway (City of Goshen filings), via GovSalaries | READ — each year, November 9, 2026 |
| Certificate Decertification List | Indiana Law Enforcement Training Board / ILEA — current through October 19, 2026 | READ IN FULL — no Brown, November 9, 2026 |
| Year-end case reviews (the stop, the reported plea and probation, the October 2019 resignation) | The Goshen News, December 27 & 28, 2019 | IN HAND — read in full text, November 9, 2026 |
| State wire brief (the officers’ answer on the gun; the prosecutor’s stated ground) | Associated Press, carried by the Post-Tribune | IN HAND — November 9, 2026 |
| The OWI docket (chronological case summary) — State v. Brody Lin Brown, Elkhart City Court No. 20H01-1812-CM-010358, transferred from Goshen City Court No. 20H02-1812-CM-928 | Indiana MyCase (Elkhart County) | IN HAND — pulled November 9, 2026, the day this file launched; §04 rewritten from it the same day. MyCase states it is not the official court record |
| Personnel-file slice — the factual basis of the final discipline, under IC 5-14-3-4(b)(8) | City of Goshen | AVAILABLE LANE — the Board’s published resolution already carries the terms; the underlying personnel paper has not been requested |
The docket landed the same day this file launched — November 9, 2026 — and this file updated in place, at this same address, with §04 rewritten from the court’s own entries. That is how every update in this series lands: in place, dated, at the link already published.
Officers write tickets for every one of these. This section keeps the same record on the officer in this file.
THE DOCUMENTED ENTRY — DECEMBER 14, 2018. Arrested for operating while intoxicated, off duty, at the wheel of a truck stopped by his own department (§02); the case it produced — Elkhart City Court No. 20H01-1812-CM-010358 — carried three counts, one of them disregarding an automatic signal; the State dismissed two of the counts, and on the one that remained Brown was found guilty: sixty days in jail suspended, twelve months of probation, and a thirty-day license suspension, all on the court’s own paper (§04). The Board’s discipline carried its own road term: his driver’s license had to be reinstated before he could return to work (§05). No other driving matter naming him was found in the sources searched for this file — the searches and their scopes are in §07 and §08.
If you photograph or film this officer speeding with no lights on, driving with a light out, rolling through without a signal, parked across a sidewalk or a crosswalk, parked in a handicap space, or breaking any road law you would be ticketed for, send the photo or the video in. Date, time, and place required. Verified submissions run here, dated, with the picture or the footage itself.
This file began with a reader’s tip — a comment left on this series’ page: “Officer brown of Goshen PD 2018, check that story out.” A surname, a department, and a year are not an identification, and this series does not build on one. So the first work was the paper: the name, when it came, came out of the City of Goshen’s own minutes. The officer is Brody L. Brown, and the 2018 story is written in his own city’s official record — Resolution 2019-04 of the Goshen Board of Public Works and Safety, titled, in the city’s own words, “DISCIPLINARY ACTION AGAINST BRODY L. BROWN.”
The story that paper tells is short and it is not small. In the early morning of December 14, 2018, Brown — off duty, driving, with a Goshen sergeant and an Elkhart officer riding with him — was stopped by a fellow Goshen officer who was out investigating sounds of gunfire. Brown was arrested for operating while intoxicated. An investigation into shots fired followed. All three officers told investigators they could not remember who fired the gun. The county prosecutor declined to charge anyone over the shooting, and said the police response itself was part of the reason why. The State dismissed two of the three counts the stop produced; on the one that remained, the court found Brown guilty — sixty days in jail, suspended, and a year of probation. The Board of Works suspended him for fifty working days without pay. The sergeant resigned. And in October 2019, Brown resigned too — reported, in the Goshen News’ words, because he failed to complete the disciplinary steps the Board had ordered.
This file grades its own paper as it goes. What comes from the city’s documents is printed as the city’s documents. What comes from reporting is printed as reporting, with the reporter named. One document was not in hand when this file launched — the court’s own docket in Brown’s OWI case — and the file said so at full size wherever the court case was discussed. It was pulled the same day, November 9, 2026, and §04 now prints the case from the court’s own entries, case number and all. This file updates in place, at this same address — that is what happened here.
• Identity: Brody L. Brown — named in the City of Goshen’s Resolution 2019-04 (Board of Public Works and Safety, February 25, 2019). Not Coty Brown, a different Goshen officer (§01).
• Service: Goshen Police Department, on the city’s Indiana Gateway filings: Police Reserve Officer 2016 → Patrol Officer 2017 → Officer 2018 → Probationary Patrol Officer 2019 (partial year). No Indiana public payroll record under his name located after 2019.
• The night: December 14, 2018 — off-duty, driving; stopped on Elkhart Road at the C.R. 17 overpass by an officer investigating gunfire sounds; arrested for OWI. Passengers: Goshen Sgt. Kyle Kalb and Elkhart officer Leonard Dolshenko.
• The gunfire: no one charged. All three officers told police they could not recall who shot, due to their level of intoxication; Prosecutor Vicki Becker declined gun charges citing “insufficient police response” (Associated Press).
• The court case: State v. Brody Lin Brown, Elkhart City Court No. 20H01-1812-CM-010358 (transferred from Goshen City Court No. 20H02-1812-CM-928) — three counts from December 14, 2018; two dismissed by the State; found guilty on one (the docket’s entry order points to the .08-to-.15 OWI count — §04 labels that attribution as inferred from entry order; the docket does not label it). Sixty days in jail suspended, 12 months of probation, fines and costs paid in full. Docket pulled from Indiana MyCase, November 9, 2026.
• The discipline: suspension without pay for 50 work days / 450 work hours; license to be reinstated before return to work; alcohol education program at his own cost, proof of completion due to the Chief by August 15, 2019 (Resolution 2019-04).
• The end: Kalb resigned effective May 8, 2019 (Resolution 2019-05). Brown resigned in October 2019, reported as for failure to complete the disciplinary steps ordered.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Official publications and state data are linked where they live; items named but not linked are identified by their custodian and their status, so a reader can pull the same paper. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 9, 2026.
Resolutions 2019-04 (“DISCIPLINARY ACTION AGAINST BRODY L. BROWN” — the notices of December 17, 2018 and February 6, 2019, the waived hearing, the 50-day / 450-hour unpaid suspension, the license-reinstatement term, and the alcohol-education term with its August 15, 2019 proof deadline) and 2019-05 (acceptance of Sgt. Kyle Kalb’s resignation, effective May 8, 2019) (§01, §05, §06). Read in full for this file. Official minutes (PDF) · Last checked November 9, 2026
“To the Community of Goshen,” published February 22, 2019 — the December 14, 2018 stop and OWI arrest, the shots-fired investigation, the Sheriff’s Department’s role, the case’s referral to the prosecutor, and Chief Miller’s recommended discipline package (§02, §05). goshen.in.gov · Last checked November 9, 2026
Employee compensation filings for the City of Goshen (Goshen Civil City), Brody Brown, reporting years 2016–2019, as rendered by GovSalaries — the title and wage ledger in §01. Each year read directly for this file, November 9, 2026. · Last checked November 9, 2026
Certificate Decertification List, current through October 19, 2026, read in full for this file: no Brody Brown, and no Brown of any first name, appears on it (§07). · Last checked November 9, 2026
The paper’s year-end reviews of the case — the stop on Elkhart Road at the C.R. 17 overpass, the passengers, its report of a January 2019 guilty plea and a year of probation (the plea is the News’ word; the docket, pulled November 9, 2026, records a finding of guilty and twelve months of probation — §04), and the October 2019 resignation and its stated reason (§02, §04, §06). Read in full text through InsuranceNewsNet. · Last checked November 9, 2026
The wire account carried by the Post-Tribune — the three officers’ statement that they could not recall who fired, and Prosecutor Becker’s “insufficient police response” ground for declining gun charges (§03). · Last checked November 9, 2026
State of Indiana v. Brody Lin Brown, Elkhart City Court No. 20H01-1812-CM-010358, transferred from Goshen City Court No. 20H02-1812-CM-928 — the three counts and their statutes, the January 22, 2019 entries (two counts “CASE DISMISSED BY STATE”; one “DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY” with its sentence, quoted in full in §04), the February 5, 2019 judgments, and the financial section, paid in full (§04). Pulled in an interactive Party Search (“Brown, Brody L.,” Elkhart County), November 9, 2026. MyCase states that it is not the official court record; the guilty count’s attribution in §04 rests on the order of the docket’s entries and is labeled there as inferred from entry order.