David C. Bonfiglio has sat on an Elkhart County bench for roughly forty years. He is the first judge of Elkhart Superior Court 6 — the county's family division, the court where Elkhart County's custody fights end — and in 2024 he was re-elected unopposed — the county's certified official summary records 55,883 votes, 100.00 percent. This file rests on the paper that record left behind: the appellate decisions reviewing his rulings, the election records, and the suits naming him, each with its disposition attached.
The spine of the file is his appellate record, and it is stated here exactly as the opinions opened support it. In the written appellate decisions this file opened — a sample, not a census of his roughly forty years — his rulings were reversed, vacated, or remanded in whole or in part in 11 matters and affirmed outright in 11; every split decision is counted once, on the reversal side, and described as split in its entry, and two of the eleven reversals turned on grounds outside his own rulings. The reversals cluster on procedure — hearings, evidence, counsel, and the statutory limits of his own orders — with the two exceptions named in that sentence: one conviction fell with a statute the Seventh Circuit had invalidated, and one reversal rested on ineffective assistance of counsel. The two most recent reversals are both family matters, both process failures, both in the division that is his: in Roush (2024), a mother's counsel was let out of the case in violation of the trial rule and the evidentiary hearing went on without her; in Dangerfield (2026), the Court of Appeals held, in its own words: “The trial court's procedures did not comport with due process.”
The file also prints, in full and with its disposition attached in the same breath, what litigants have alleged against him in court filings — and what the courts did with every one of those filings. On March 26, 2026, the federal court dismissed every claim against him and stated that no claims remain pending against him. The custody claims were dismissed on jurisdictional grounds and the disability claims on pleading grounds; every dismissal was without prejudice. It was not a finding that any allegation was true, and it was not a finding that any was false. Both halves print, or neither does.
Every claim in this file is graded against the record behind it. A claim marked verified rests on a primary record that was opened and read — an appellate opinion, a federal opinion, a county page, an election summary. A claim carried by one secondary source is printed as reported. Lawsuits are allegations by the people who filed them; an allegation in this file carries its disposition in the same entry, in the same breath, and never travels without it. No appellate opinion opened criticizes him personally beyond the legal error. Where a search found nothing, this file states the search and its scope — it never converts a blocked or unfinished search into a claim that no record exists. This file is a living file: if the appellate census or any later docket changes the tally or a printed status, the page updates in place at this same address, and the change is noted on the page. Status statements in this file are printed as of a records check run November 7, 2026.
Every file in this series is built the same way: public records, exhibited in full, and nothing in them that the paper does not say. Finish one file, and the next is waiting — the loop does not close.
Every source this file rests on, where it lives, and what state it is in — in one place. Court opinions and official pages are named as what they are. Reporting and aggregator data are labeled as what they are — never dressed up as primary documents. Anything missing is labeled missing, in plain words. Register checked November 7, 2026.
The full 15-page published opinion, read at the Indiana appellate decisions archive: appeal from Elkhart Superior Court, Hon. David C. Bonfiglio, Judge, cause 20D06-2501-MI-2; reversed and remanded, the remand including a full evidentiary hearing; the due-process holding at ¶¶32 and 34, the disposition at ¶35.
Indiana appellate decisions archive (public.courts.in.gov) · Named in: §§03, 04 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The published opinion: abuse of discretion to grant counsel's withdrawal in violation of Trial Rule 3.1(H) and hold the evidentiary hearing without her; the contempt judgment and its sanctions (180 days, $8,876.70 in fees, a $1,000-per-day fine) reversed; a new hearing ordered on remand. Cause 20D06-1709-DC-681.
Justia (cases.justia.com) · Named in: §§03, 04 · Last checked November 7, 2026 OPEN →
Judge Leichty's Opinion and Order: every claim against Bonfiglio dismissed; no claims remain pending against him; the custody-related claims dismissed for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, the disability and Monell claims resolved on pleading grounds; every dismissal without prejudice; the sole surviving claim an IIED claim against attorney Thomas Stipp. Read the opinion →
Justia (law.justia.com) · Named in: §06 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The public docket copy: Doc. 90–93, ending April 15, 2026 with the amended-complaint deadline extended to May 11, 2026 and Stipp's response due May 25, 2026. Stale at April 15, 2026 — the live PACER pull is on the records list (§08).
Justia dockets · Named in: §06 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The written decisions behind the tally in §03: the eleven reversed/vacated/remanded matters (including S.T., 764 N.E.2d 632 (Ind. 2002); Sapen; Hawkins; Harris; Fritz), the eleven affirmed outright (including In re M.M., 733 N.E.2d 6 (2000), and the April 22, 2024 affirmance at 23A-JP-2416), the Rodriguez sequence ending in the Indiana Supreme Court's affirmance (129 N.E.3d 789 (2019)), and the party suits McCrum (806 F. Supp. 203), Culbreath, and Breaston (20A03-0609-CV-427).
Indiana appellate archive / Justia · Named in: §§03, 05 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The county's own pages fixing his court, courtroom, address, and telephone — the identity concordance for this file. The Court Locations page is text-only: no portrait.
Elkhart County (elkhartcounty.com) · Named in: §§01, 07 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The local rule making Superior Court 6 the county's family division court.
Indiana judiciary (in.gov) · Named in: §02 · Last checked November 7, 2026
His introduction as judge of Elkhart Superior Court VI with sixteen years on the bench — referee, then magistrate, then judge — and his own testimony on his juvenile-court years; plus his March 22, 2002 House testimony (“about 14 years”). The two accounts are why this file prints a range, not a start year.
govinfo · Named in: §01 · Last checked November 7, 2026
His January 10, 2024 Republican filing, and the county's certified official summary: 55,883 votes, 100.00 percent, unopposed in the primary and the general. (The county's earlier unofficial summary recorded 55,401; the certified figure controls and is used throughout this file.) Term records (GoodParty / BallotReady) state in office until December 31, 2030.
Indiana SOS / Elkhart County · Named in: §01 · Last checked November 7, 2026
GovSalaries lists “David Bonfiglio C,” Superior Court Judge: $140,135 in 2015; $187,996 in 2025 (+34.2% since 2015, computed from those two figures). OpenGovPay lists $175,545 in 2023. The underlying Gateway record was not opened; the figures print at reported grade.
GovSalaries / OpenGovPay · Named in: §01 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The Public Access Counselor's advisory on an APRA complaint against Superior Court 6 over hearing transcripts, and the court's April 20, 2009 answer through his letter. Not discipline.
Indiana Public Access Counselor · Named in: §05 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The South Bend Tribune's 2000 candidacy coverage (“A magistrate since 1987”; the newly created Superior Court VI) via the ProQuest archive; the Elkhart Truth headline on the four-person race via the Elkhart Public Library Local History Index; and the Indiana Court Times item (Feb. 7, 2014) on the 2013 NASW Indiana “Community Partner of the Year” award — the item that published his formal portrait, a 2013 portrait, which runs as this file’s lead photo.
South Bend Tribune / Elkhart Truth index / Indiana Court Times · Named in: §01 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The live PACER pull on 3:25-cv-937 after April 15, 2026. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The Indiana Gateway compensation record. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
His Election Board campaign-finance file. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
Certified Clerk copies (including the Roberson order). Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The JQC public-filings check. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The appellate census. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
The Truth's 2000/2001 items. Each is on the records list at §08, with the state of its lane printed there.
Named in: §§01, 03, 06–08 · Last checked November 7, 2026
Anything else this file names in its text that does not appear in this register is not hosted here yet — it stands in the file as reporting or as a records request until the paper itself is in hand, and this register is updated when it lands.