
Michael Douce was the assistant director of choirs at Noblesville High School — a man the Noblesville Schools put in front of other people’s children, in a room built on trust, in a Hamilton County suburb that sells itself on its schools.
On January 8, 2015, the State of Indiana filed thirteen criminal counts against him in the Hamilton Superior Court — eleven of them felonies, eight of them child seduction. The charges said he had carried on sexual relationships with two of his students in 2013 and 2014. He turned himself in the same day. The district had already removed him from student contact in December 2014, when it learned of the allegations; it announced his termination with the charges in January 2015.
That was not the end of it. Out on bond under a court’s no-contact order, he contacted a student again in May 2015. Four more counts followed, his bond was revoked, and on August 6, 2015 he pleaded guilty. The docket of the Hamilton County case (cause 29D01-1501-F4-000242, pulled November 11, 2026) records the plea on two counts of Class C felony child seduction, with every other count in that case dismissed; the Court of Appeals’ record additionally recites one count of Class A misdemeanor invasion of privacy in the plea. He was sentenced the next month and sent to the Indiana Department of Correction.
One thing about that sentence this file will not do is pretend. The docket now in hand shows two eight-year executed terms — one on each seduction count — and does not state whether they run consecutively or concurrently to each other. The Indiana Court of Appeals recites an aggregate sentence of sixteen years. Those two records are printed side by side, as the tension they are, in §10: this file does not add the docket’s silence into a settled sixteen, and it does not subtract the opinion’s aggregate down to one term. The paper that fixes the relationship between the two terms — the sentencing order — is still on this file’s pull list.
The case did not stay in 2015. In March 2023, the Indiana Court of Appeals decided a case that required it to recite this entire criminal history again — which is why a school case from 2015 carries fresh appellate paper, and why it is in this library now. And Douce was not Noblesville High School’s last case: a year after his plea, another of its teachers was charged (§09).
Everything in this file traces to the paper listed in the Sources. The students in this case are never named, described, or identified in this file — here, they are students, and that is all.
The job, first, because the job is the charge. Indiana’s child-seduction law is not a law about strangers. It is a law about position — it makes it a felony for a person who holds a position of trust over a child, a teacher, a coach, a counselor, to engage in sexual conduct with that child. The offense exists because the authority exists.
Michael Douce held that authority at Noblesville High School, in Noblesville, Hamilton County, Indiana. The Court of Appeals record describes him as a choir teacher there; the Hamilton County Reporter called him “the Noblesville school teacher and choir director”; the Indianapolis Star identified him as the school’s assistant director of choirs. A choir room runs on after-school hours, on trips, on one adult’s judgment about whose talent gets nurtured. It is one of the most trusted posts in a school building.
The Hamilton County Reporter’s front page of March 26, 2015 — the page this file’s photograph comes from — grouped his booking photo with two other men’s under a headline about high-profile cases. His was the face in the middle, captioned with his name. A school district’s choir director, on the front page, between two other defendants.
That is the whole of his public biography that this file prints: the post he held, and what the record says he did with it. The record begins on one date.
On January 8, 2015, the State of Indiana charged Michael Douce in the Hamilton Superior Court — cause 29D01-1501-F4-000242, Hamilton Superior Court 1, on the case summary pulled November 11, 2026. The charging record, as the Indiana Court of Appeals later recited it, ran to thirteen counts:
• One count of Level 4 felony burglary.
• Eight counts of child seduction — two as Class C felonies, two as Level 5 felonies, two as Class D felonies, and two as Level 6 felonies.
• One count of Level 5 felony child exploitation.
• One count of Level 6 felony dissemination of matter harmful to minors.
• Two counts of Class A misdemeanor contributing to the delinquency of a minor.
Eleven of the thirteen counts were felonies — the number the Hamilton County Reporter put on its front page. The charges, as the probable-cause record laid them out, concerned sexual conduct with two of his students during 2013 and 2014. The classifications above are printed exactly as the Court of Appeals’ recitation states them.
He turned himself in the day the charges were filed. A jury trial was set for May 11, 2015. No jury ever heard this case — the reason is in §04 and §05.
This file states what the charges were, because the charges are the public record of what the State alleged. What he admitted, under oath, by plea, is stated in §05 — and this file keeps the two apart the way the record does.
Noblesville Schools moved the same month the charges landed. The district’s own sequence came in two steps. It removed Douce from student contact in December 2014, as soon as it became aware of the allegations — the school notified investigators on December 17, 2014 — and in its statement issued with the January 8, 2015 charges, reported by the Indianapolis Star, it said his employment had “officially been terminated for inappropriate conduct.”
That sentence is the district’s whole public account of its own part in this, and this file prints it at exactly that weight — a termination, stated by the employer, in the month of the arrest. The charges alleged conduct reaching back into 2013. What the district knew, when it knew it, and what it did before January 2015 are questions the record in this file’s hands does not answer, and this file does not invent answers for them. The records that would speak to them are registered in §11.
What the record does show is the sequence: charges on January 8, 2015, and a choir director out of the building within the month. The court case was just beginning.
Douce was released on bond after the January charges, and the bond came with the order that governs every case like this one: no contact. The Court of Appeals’ record is blunt about what happened next. In May 2015 — while the thirteen counts were pending, with a jury trial on the calendar — he contacted a student, by telephone and by a handwritten letter.
On June 23, 2015, the State filed a second case: four counts of Class A misdemeanor invasion of privacy, the charge Indiana law provides for violating a no-contact order. His bond was revoked. The man who had walked into the Hamilton County Jail to surrender in January went back into custody, and this time he stayed there.
This is the fact in the file that no mitigation reaches. Whatever was still allegation in the first case, the second case was about conduct after arrest, after charge, after a judge’s written order — and it is the case that supplied one of the three counts he ultimately pleaded guilty to (§05).
There was no trial. On August 6, 2015, Michael Douce pleaded guilty. What the docket of the Hamilton County case — cause 29D01-1501-F4-000242, case summary pulled November 11, 2026 — records is exact:
• Count 2, Class C felony child seduction — plea by agreement.
• Count 8, Class C felony child seduction — plea by agreement.
• Every other count in the cause — dismissed: the Level 4 felony burglary count, the remaining child-seduction counts (Level 5, Class D, and Level 6), the Level 5 felony child-exploitation count, the Level 6 felony dissemination count, and both Class A misdemeanor contributing counts. Eleven counts dismissed; two counts of conviction.
The Court of Appeals’ record recites the August 6, 2015 plea one count wider: two counts of Class C felony child seduction and one count of Class A misdemeanor invasion of privacy — the no-contact case filed in June 2015 (§04). That third count does not live in the cause above; its own case summary has not been pulled, so this file prints it exactly as what it is — the appellate court’s recitation, attributed — and registers the June 2015 cause on the pull list (§11) rather than folding it into the docket’s count.
A guilty plea is not an accusation. It is an admission, made in court, that ends the presumption the law started with. So this is the settled core of the file: a Noblesville High School choir director admitted, by plea, to felony child seduction — twice, on the docket — and, on the Court of Appeals’ record, to violating the no-contact order that was supposed to keep him away from a student while the first case was pending. Everything else in this file is context around those admissions — and none of them is disputed by anyone, anywhere in the record.
Douce was sentenced in September 2015, one month after the plea — the cause stands decided September 8, 2015 on its case summary. He was committed to the Indiana Department of Correction, and the Court of Appeals’ record states that he began serving his sentence at the New Castle Correctional Facility.
The case summary pulled November 11, 2026 states the sentence count by count, and this section prints exactly what it states:
• Count 2 (Class C felony child seduction): 8 years in the Department of Correction — 8 years executed, 0 suspended — with 64 days of jail credit.
• Count 8 (Class C felony child seduction): 8 years in the Department of Correction — 8 years executed, none suspended — with no jail credit.
Each entry adds one line about another case: “Consecutive with Prior Sentence: 29D03-1506-CM-5604.” Neither entry states whether Counts 2 and 8 run consecutively or concurrently to each other, and the docket states no aggregate. Against that silence stands the Court of Appeals’ recital of “an aggregate sentence of sixteen years.” This file prints the two records as the tension they are (§10): two eight-year executed terms whose relationship to each other the docket does not state, beside an appellate aggregate of sixteen. It does not print sixteen as a settled total, and it does not print eight as the whole sentence.
The document that fixes the relationship between the two terms is the sentencing order. It has not been pulled, and until it is in hand this section stands as written — the docket’s terms, the docket’s silence, and the opinion’s aggregate, each at its own weight.
The record of the years that followed is thin, and this file keeps it at the record’s weight. Douce remained in the Department of Correction’s custody for years after the September 2015 sentencing. He was still incarcerated on April 1, 2020, when — from custody — he filed his objection in the family case that later produced the 2023 appeal (§08).
By the time that case was heard in December 2021, he had been released. The Court of Appeals’ record states that he was living with family, working full-time, and serving the remainder of his time on parole — and that, in the trial court’s words, “He has served his incarcerated time and continues to serve his time on parole.” The appeal record further states that his parole supervisor confirmed he was in full compliance with the conditions of his parole.
The records pulled November 11, 2026 carry the end of the custody story. The case record shows a Community Transition Program eligibility notice on February 3, 2021 and a Findings/Order for CTP on March 23, 2021. The Department of Correction’s offender record — Douce is DOC #257048 — shows the earliest possible release date as June 3, 2021 and his status as discharged: he is not in custody, and this file does not print him as a man currently inside. The DOC record states no usable term length and no aggregate. Its duplicate rows for the Hamilton County cause reflect, by the record’s own comments, re-commitment for probation and community-corrections violations — not multiple convictions.
No exact release date is stated in the records this file holds, and none is printed: the appeal record brackets it (in custody in April 2020, released by December 2021), and the DOC record shows the earliest possible date, which is a different thing. This file prints both records as they stand and does not merge them into a date neither one states.
The reason a 2015 case carries 2023 paper is a family courtroom, and this file states the connection exactly. In 2020, a petition was filed in the Hamilton Superior Court to adopt Douce’s children; because he was their father, the adoption could not proceed over his objection unless the petitioners proved, by clear and convincing evidence, that he was unfit and that adoption was in the children’s best interests. His criminal record — the charges, the bond violation, the plea, the sentence — became the petitioners’ evidence of unfitness.
The trial court heard the case in December 2021 and ruled on April 29, 2022: the petitioners had not carried their burden, his consent was required, and the adoption was denied. The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed on March 20, 2023, in a published memorandum decision, M.H. v. M.D., cause number 22A-AD-1245. This file prints that outcome straight: the courts that heard the full evidence declined to find him unfit, and his children were not adopted over his objection. A record file prints what the courts did, all of it.
The decision does not print his name — adoption appeals are anonymized, and he appears in it as “Father.” The identification of that decision as his case is made the way this file makes every identification: on the facts. The decision recites a choir teacher at Noblesville High School, charged in Hamilton Superior Court on January 8, 2015, pleading guilty on August 6, 2015 to the same three counts, beginning his sentence at New Castle Correctional Facility. The Indianapolis Star’s named reporting of this case carries the same school, the same dates, and the same plea, under the name Michael Douce. The match is one-to-one, and the method is printed here and in the Sources so any reader can test it.
It is that decision — a court’s own recitation, published in 2023 — that carries the controlling account of the criminal case in this file: the charge list in §02, the bond violation in §04, the plea in §05. And it is that decision that carries one side of the sentence conflict this file refuses to smooth (§10).
One year after Douce’s plea, the Indianapolis Star’s August 17, 2016 report on this case noted, in passing, why it was asking about him again: Noblesville High School had another teacher in the criminal courts.
Nicholas McKinney, a health teacher at the same school, was charged in 2016 with two counts of child seduction and one count of criminal deviate conduct, over an incident alleged to have occurred in 2012. That is the whole of what this file states about McKinney — charges, attributed to the Star’s reporting. No outcome for his case is on the record this file holds, and this file states none. A charge is an allegation; it is printed here as one, because the pattern it establishes is a fact about the school, not a conclusion about the man: within two school years, two teachers in one Hamilton County high school stood charged with seducing students.
Two cases do not make a district’s culture, and this file does not call it one. They make a question — the question this series exists to ask of every building in this library: what did the institution know, and when did it know it? For Noblesville Schools, the record in hand answers that question for Douce’s termination (§03) and is silent on the rest. The silence is registered, not filled (§10, §11).
Each gap below is printed as what it is: a search, with its scope, that did not close. Nothing in this section is filled in by inference. Two gaps that stood here at launch closed on November 11, 2026, when the Hamilton County case summary and the DOC offender record were pulled: the January 2015 cause number and its count-by-count dispositions are in hand (§05, §06), and his custody posture is the DOC record’s own (§07). What remains is below.
How the two eight-year terms run against each other. The case summary states two terms: Count 2 — eight years, eight executed, none suspended, 64 days of jail credit; Count 8 — eight years, eight executed, none suspended, no credit. Each entry states only that the sentence is consecutive with a prior sentence in another cause (29D03-1506-CM-5604). Neither states whether Counts 2 and 8 are consecutive or concurrent to each other, and no aggregate is stated on the docket. Beside that silence, the Indiana Court of Appeals recites “an aggregate sentence of sixteen years,” and the Indianapolis Star reported in 2016 that he was “sentenced in September 2015 to eight years in the Indiana Department of Correction.” This file prints the tension exactly: if the two terms run consecutively, the opinion’s sixteen is their sum; if concurrently, the executed time is eight — and the docket in hand does not say which. The document that fixes it is the Hamilton Superior Court’s sentencing order, and that order has not been pulled. Until it is in hand, no aggregate is printed in this file as the sentence, and no single term is printed as the whole of it.
The June 2015 cause. The invasion-of-privacy case filed June 23, 2015 is recited in the Court of Appeals’ record, including the one count the opinion places in the August 6, 2015 plea (§05). Its case summary has not been pulled: its cause number and its count-by-count dispositions are not in hand, and the third plea count’s home rests on the opinion’s recitation alone.
The plea agreement. Not pulled. The plea’s terms are stated in this file from the docket’s dispositions and the Court of Appeals’ recitation; the agreement’s own written terms — including any sentence recommendation — are not in hand.
His educator’s license. Not pulled. No Indiana Department of Education license record for Douce was located in this build, and this file states nothing about the status of his teaching license.
His exact release date. Not stated in any record in hand. The appeal record brackets it — in custody in April 2020, released by December 2021 — and the DOC record shows an earliest possible release date of June 3, 2021 and a discharged status. Neither is an exact release date, and this file prints none.
The McKinney outcome. Not found (§09). The 2016 charges against the second Noblesville teacher are in hand; their ending is not, and none is stated.
The district’s foreknowledge. No record in hand states what Noblesville Schools knew about Douce before January 2015. The question is registered as open (§03, §11), not answered by implication.
The public gap register for this file. Every pull below closes a named gap in §10; when a record lands, the file updates at this same link and the register entry closes.
• Hamilton Superior Court — sentencing order, January 2015 cause (State v. Michael Andrew Douce, cause 29D01-1501-F4-000242, filed January 8, 2015). STILL OPEN — and it alone fixes the one question the case summary leaves open: whether the two eight-year executed terms on Counts 2 and 8 run consecutively or concurrently to each other (§06, §10). Route: Indiana MyCase / Hamilton County Clerk. (The cause’s case summary itself was pulled November 11, 2026 and is in hand; the cause number and count-by-count dispositions stand in §02, §05 and §06.)
• Hamilton County — CCS, June 2015 cause (invasion of privacy, filed June 23, 2015). Closes: the second case’s cause number and dispositions, and the docket home of the third plea count the Court of Appeals recites (§05, §10).
• The plea agreement of August 6, 2015, as filed. Closes: the plea’s written terms.
• Indiana Department of Education — educator license record, Michael Douce. Closes: the license question, one way or the other.
• Indiana Department of Correction — offender record. IN HAND — pulled November 11, 2026 (DOC #257048): discharged status, earliest possible release date June 3, 2021, no usable term length stated; the exact release date remains unstated in every record in hand (§07, §10).
• Hamilton County — the 2016 McKinney cause, docket in full. Closes: the outcome §09 does not state.
• Noblesville Schools — board and personnel records touching the January 2015 termination. Closes: what the district’s own paper says about its part, beyond the one public sentence quoted in §03.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 11, 2026.
M.H. v. M.D., memorandum decision, cause 22A-AD-1245, decided March 20, 2023 (Hamilton Superior Court causes 29D05-2003-AD-436 and -437 below), read in full. Carries: the January 8, 2015 charge list as the court recites it; the May 2015 bond violation and the June 23, 2015 invasion-of-privacy charges; the August 6, 2015 guilty plea to two counts of Class C felony child seduction and one count of Class A misdemeanor invasion of privacy; the commitment to the Department of Correction at New Castle Correctional Facility; the aggregate-sentence recital (see the sentence card below); his custody status in April 2020 and his release to parole by December 2021; and the affirmance of the order denying the adoption. The decision anonymizes him as “Father”; the identification of the decision as this subject’s case rests on its own recited facts — Noblesville High School choir teacher, charged January 8, 2015, the same plea on the same date — matched against the named contemporaneous reporting below, and is printed as a method, not an assumption (§08). Named in: Intro, §01–§08, §10.
Contemporaneous named coverage of the filing: Michael Douce, Noblesville High School assistant director of choirs, charged with child seduction and the companion counts (summarized by the paper as eight counts of child seduction, one count of burglary, one count of child exploitation, one count of dissemination of matter harmful to minors, and two misdemeanor counts of contributing to the delinquency of a minor); his surrender at the Hamilton County Jail the day the charges were filed; and the Noblesville Schools statement that he had “officially been terminated for inappropriate conduct.” Named in: Intro, §01–§03, §08.
The Star’s report of the 2016 charges against Noblesville High School health teacher Nicholas McKinney (two counts of child seduction, one count of criminal deviate conduct, over an incident alleged from 2012) — charges only; no outcome is stated in this file. The same report carries the paper’s account of Douce’s sentence (“sentenced in September 2015 to eight years in the Indiana Department of Correction on two counts of child seduction”) — see the sentence card below. Named in: §09, §10.
Vol. 2, No. 61, front page, read directly from the published issue. Carries: this file’s photograph — the Hamilton County booking photograph of Michael Douce, the center of three captioned booking photos, captioned “Douce”; the statement that he faced “11 felonies” (the eleven felony counts of the thirteen filed); the May 11, 2015 jury-trial setting; and his counsel’s name. Named in: Intro, §01, §02.
The chronological case summary for State v. Michael Andrew Douce, cause 29D01-1501-F4-000242 (Hamilton Superior Court 1, filed January 8, 2015, decided September 8, 2015, thirteen counts), pulled from Indiana MyCase on November 11, 2026. It carries: the cause number and court; Count 2 (Class C felony child seduction) — plea by agreement, 8 years IDOC, 8 executed, 0 suspended, 64 days jail credit; Count 8 (Class C felony child seduction) — plea by agreement, 8 years IDOC, 8 executed, none suspended, no credit; every other count in the cause dismissed; each sentence entry stating only “Consecutive with Prior Sentence: 29D03-1506-CM-5604” — neither states whether Counts 2 and 8 run consecutively or concurrently to each other, and no aggregate is stated; and the 2021 Community Transition Program entries (eligibility notice February 3, 2021; Findings/Order for CTP March 23, 2021). The Indiana DOC offender record pulled the same day (DOC #257048) carries: status discharged; earliest possible release date June 3, 2021; no usable term length and no aggregate; and, in its own comments, that duplicate rows for one cause reflect re-commitment for probation/community-corrections violations, not multiple convictions. Named in: Intro, §02, §05, §06, §07, §10, §11.
The docket (see the card above) states two eight-year executed terms and does not state how they run against each other. Two older records frame that silence. The Court of Appeals (22A-AD-1245, at ¶5) recites “an aggregate sentence of sixteen years.” The Indianapolis Star (August 17, 2016) reported “eight years in the Indiana Department of Correction.” This file prints neither sixteen as a settled total nor eight as the whole sentence: the document that fixes the inter-count relationship — the Hamilton Superior Court sentencing order — has not been pulled, and its pull stays registered in §11. §10 is the tension’s home in the text; this card is its home in the register. Named in: Intro, §06, §10.