
John C. Goelz coached swimming at Carmel — Carmel Swim Club, where he was an employee and lead age-group coach, and Carmel High School, where from the 2015–16 school year he volunteered as an assistant coach with one of the most decorated high school swim programs in the country. The district’s own statement, issued the week of his arrest, is precise about what he was: a volunteer with the school team and a coach with the club. “He is not a teacher or otherwise employed by Carmel Clay Schools.”
From at least September 2017 through June 30, 2018, the United States Attorney’s office states, Goelz built the trust of a student-athlete he coached — first as coach and confidant, in the government’s words — and then enticed the student into sexual acts. On June 30, 2018, at a motel in Anderson, Indiana, he used his cellphone to record sexual activity with the student. Federal investigators later recovered the video and images from that phone.
A community tip reached the Carmel police on June 29, 2018. Goelz was arrested on July 3, 2018. The case was federal from the first day — opened on a federal complaint on July 3, 2018 — and on January 30, 2019, he was sentenced to 200 months in federal prison, with ten years of supervised release to follow, after pleading guilty to sexual exploitation of a minor and possession of child pornography. The U.S. Center for SafeSport had already banned him from the sport for life.
A civil suit followed — filed January 29, 2020, in the same federal court, against the school district, the head coach, Goelz, and the motel chain. Its claims stand in this file as allegations, at that grade and no higher. Its ending, which this file’s first draft carried as unverified, is now stated from the docket itself at §06: Goelz was dismissed from the suit without prejudice in May 2020, and the case ended in June 2021, dismissed with prejudice on the parties’ June 4, 2021 stipulation.
Everything in this file traces to the paper listed in the Sources. The student in this case is never named, described, or identified in this file — here, a student-athlete he coached, and that is all.
Goelz worked both sides of Carmel swimming. He was an employee of Carmel Swim Club — his own professional profile, published by WISH-TV with its sentencing coverage, carried the title Lead Age Group Coach, Carmel Swim Club — and from the 2015–16 school year he volunteered as an assistant coach with the Carmel High School swim team, inside the Carmel Clay Schools program.
That program is not an obscure one. Carmel’s swim teams are among the most successful in Indiana high school history, and the club feeds them. A volunteer assistant’s chair on that pool deck carried the full trust of the institution — parents hand their children to the program, and the program handed this man its athletes.
The joint statement of Carmel Clay Schools and Carmel Swim Club, released to families of student-athletes and printed in the Hamilton County Reporter on July 6, 2018, said: “Mr. Goelz served as a volunteer assistant coach for the Carmel High School swim team and was also a coach for the Carmel Swim Club. He is not a teacher or otherwise employed by Carmel Clay Schools. He is no longer affiliated with either organization.” The statement was signed by Dr. Michael Beresford, the district’s superintendent, and Kristin Sherman, president of Carmel Swim Club, and it closed: “We are shocked and deeply saddened this has occurred.”
Note what the district’s own framing establishes: the man who coached its swimmers was, on paper, nobody’s employee at the school at all.
Law enforcement learned of the possible relationship on June 29, 2018. Lt. Cameron Ellison later credited a community tip with starting the investigation. Ellison, of the Hamilton County Metro Child Exploitation Task Force, put it plainly at sentencing: “It was a community tip that led to the investigation, arrest and prosecution in this case.”
Investigators obtained search warrants, including for Goelz’s residence and his cellphone. On the phone, federal investigators recovered the video and images from June 30, 2018 — the recording he had made at the Anderson motel — and computer evidence showed the files were filmed with his phone.
The investigation belonged to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) and the Hamilton County Metro Child Exploitation Task Force. It moved fast: tip on June 29, arrest on July 3.
This file prints no message, no screenshot, and no description of anything recovered beyond the charge language above. The charges carry the facts, and they are enough.
Goelz was arrested on July 3, 2018, and held in the custody of the U.S. Marshals Service. The federal complaint case is 1:18-mj-00653-TAB. He was charged with sexual exploitation of a minor and possession of child pornography. At the charging stage, Assistant U.S. Attorney MaryAnn T. Mindrum noted he faced a minimum of fifteen years in prison if convicted.
His detention hearing was held July 10, 2018, and the court ordered him held pending trial — finding, as the order was reported, that no condition or combination of conditions would reasonably assure the safety of the community, and that the weight of the evidence against him was strong.
There was no trial. On October 29, 2018, the government filed an Information in the criminal case, 1:18-cr-00341-TWP-DLP, and Goelz’s plea agreement and stipulation of facts were filed the same day. He waived indictment on November 6, 2018. He pleaded guilty to sexual exploitation of a minor and possession of child pornography.
The partial public docket capture in hand carries the case’s filings and its closing, but not the plea-entry or sentencing minutes themselves; the exact date the plea was entered is therefore not printed here, and the full docket is registered as a pull at §07. What the government’s own releases state — the guilty plea, and the sentence that followed — is printed at §04.
On January 30, 2019, John Goelz, age 30, was sentenced in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana to 200 months in federal prison — sixteen years and eight months — and must serve ten years of supervised release after the prison term. The criminal docket closed on February 5, 2019.
United States Attorney Josh Minkler, announcing the sentence: “Today’s sentence sends a strong message to those whom we put trust in to supervise and coach our children, that this behavior is illegal and those who take advantage of our children will face real consequences. Protecting our youth from sexual predators will always remain a top priority of this office.”
The case was prosecuted by Assistant United States Attorney MaryAnn T. Mindrum. The sentence the government’s releases state is an aggregate — 200 months in all. The per-count split lives in the written judgment, which has not been pulled; it is registered at §07 rather than reconstructed here.
Two hundred months is the number this case will be remembered by, and it was a federal number — a federal complaint on July 3, 2018, a federal plea, a federal sentence. The United States took a volunteer swim coach out of Carmel and put him in a federal prison for the better part of two decades.
The criminal case was not the sport’s only answer. The U.S. Center for SafeSport — the body that governs coach abuse and bans across Olympic sports — suspended Goelz on July 7, 2018, days after his arrest, and when his one-month appeal period expired on August 6, 2018, the ban became what it remains: permanent, for life.
SafeSport’s list is the sport’s memory. Whatever happens to the criminal sentence on appeal, on good time, or on any future docket, John Goelz does not coach again — not at Carmel, not anywhere the Center’s authority reaches.
It is worth holding the two timelines side by side. The sport’s own system closed its door on him in a month. The school system he volunteered inside held no employment relationship over him at all — on the district’s own statement, he was nobody’s employee there — and what ended it was not any system of theirs but a tip from the community. That is the gap the civil case, at §06, was filed into.
On January 29, 2020, a federal civil suit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana: 1:20-cv-00320-JMS-DML, a Title IX case. The defendants were Carmel Clay Schools, head coach Chris Plumb, John Goelz, and Red Roof Inn — the district that took his volunteering, the program’s head coach, the man himself, and the motel chain where the June 30, 2018 recording was made. The plaintiff is the student-athlete, who is not named here or anywhere in this file.
A filing is not a finding. The complaint claimed, as the case’s own papers summarize it: a Title IX claim against the district; sexual exploitation, battery, and invasion of privacy against Goelz; and negligence against Plumb, the district, and Red Roof Inn. Every one of those claims stands as allegation, and this file prints them at exactly that grade and no higher.
Goelz’s part in the suit ended first. On the plaintiff’s own motion, the court dismissed John Goelz from the case without prejudice on May 5, 2020 (an order under Rule 41(a)(2), signed by Judge Jane Magnus-Stinson). Chris Plumb was dismissed the same way, also without prejudice, on May 14, 2020, and his pending motion to dismiss was denied as moot. A dismissal without prejudice is not an exoneration and not a finding for anyone — it is the plaintiff letting the claims against those two men go, in a form that left them legally capable of being refiled.
One thread of the case runs under seal in everything but name. In June 2020 the district’s amended answer asserted payment, release, and set-off defenses built on a confidential settlement agreement with parties who were not defendants in the lawsuit; the court ordered the agreement produced under a protective order, and those other parties intervened in the case to protect its confidentiality. The public papers in hand do not name those parties, and no term or figure from that agreement is in hand. This file states its existence — the docket states it — and nothing more about it.
The motel defendant answered the complaint in June 2020, as Radhey Shyam, LLC doing business as Red Roof Inn (Doc. 56). The case then ran on against the district — through discovery, a settlement conference, and a jury trial setting that the June 2021 stipulation overtook. The ending: on June 4, 2021, the plaintiff and Carmel Clay Schools filed a joint stipulation dismissing all claims in the case with prejudice, each party to bear its own costs and attorneys’ fees, and on June 7, 2021, the court entered its Order of Dismissal with Prejudice. The case is over. No jury ever decided it, and no court ever found the district liable or not liable — a dismissal with prejudice on the parties’ own stipulation is an ending the parties chose, not a verdict.
This section’s ending is stated from the docket itself, pulled from the RECAP archive for this file’s pre-launch verification — the same archive the criminal dockets at §03 came from. The draft of this file written before that pull carried the ending as not yet verified; it is verified now, and the pull is closed at §07. What remains genuinely not in hand is narrower, and it is registered there in the open: the confidential settlement agreement’s parties and terms, and a separate order recording Red Roof Inn’s exit, which is not among the archived papers.
This file’s open items, in the open. Nothing on this list is guessed at anywhere in the file; each is a document that exists and can be pulled.
1:20-cv-00320-JMS-DML — the docket itself was pulled from the RECAP archive in this file’s pre-launch verification, and the case’s ending is stated at §06 from the court’s own papers (the May 2020 dismissal orders; the June 4, 2021 joint stipulation; the June 7, 2021 Order of Dismissal with Prejudice). Two narrower items remain genuinely not in hand: the confidential settlement agreement the docket references — its parties were not defendants in the suit, its terms sit under a protective order, and no figure from it is printed here — and a separate order recording Red Roof Inn’s exit from the case, which is not among the archived papers.
1:18-cr-00341-TWP-DLP (PACER) — the complete docket and the written judgment: the plea-entry date and terms, the per-count split of the 200 months, and the judgment’s conditions. The partial RECAP capture in hand carries the filings and the February 5, 2019 termination, and is registered in the Sources.
The Bureau of Prisons record — facility and projected release date under the 200-month sentence. Not pulled for this build; nothing about present custody is printed beyond the sentence itself.
Goelz held no teaching post — the district’s statement says so in terms. A confirming check of the state educator-credential record was not pulled for this build; nothing about a license is printed either way.
When a pull lands, this file is updated in place, at this same link, with a dated addition — the library’s standing practice.
Every file in the Public Court Records series, in one place. Counties: St. Joseph, Elkhart, Marshall, Allen, Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson and Sullivan in Indiana; Berrien, Cass and St. Joseph in Michigan; Middlesex in Massachusetts; Muscatine in Iowa; Will in Illinois; St. Tammany Parish in Louisiana; Sussex in New Jersey. Every file is free, forever.
Every material claim in this file traces to a record below. Anything named in this file but not registered here stands in the file as reporting until the paper itself is in hand. Last checked November 12, 2026.
“High school swim coach receives 200 months for sexually exploiting student-athlete” (justice.gov), read in full for this file. Carries: the conviction and the 200-month sentence; Goelz’s age (30); the conduct window (at least September 2017 through June 30, 2018) and its charge-level summary; the June 30, 2018 cellphone recording at a motel in Anderson, Indiana, and its recovery from his phone; the investigating agencies (ICE HSI; Hamilton County Metro Child Exploitation Task Force); the prosecutor (AUSA MaryAnn T. Mindrum) and the ten years of supervised release; and the statements of U.S. Attorney Josh Minkler and Lt. Cameron Ellison quoted in this file, including that a community tip led to the investigation. One graphic description in this release is deliberately not carried into the file — the charge language carries the fact. Named in: Intro, §02–§04.
“Indiana high school swim coach sentenced to nearly 17 years in federal prison for sexually exploiting student athlete” (ice.gov). Carries: that he was sentenced on the Wednesday before the release — January 30, 2019 — to 200 months after admitting to sexually exploiting one of his student athletes; the ten years of supervised release; the investigating agencies. Named in: §03, §04.
The arrest-stage release (announced by U.S. Attorney Josh Minkler; reproduced in full by the Carmel High School HiLite): John C. Goelz, 29, of Carmel, arrested July 3, 2018, in U.S. Marshals custody, charged with sexual exploitation of a minor and possession of child pornography; detention hearing July 10, 2018; the fifteen-year mandatory minimum stated at the charging stage. Named in: §03.
The PACER-derived docket records for 1:18-mj-00653-TAB (complaint case, filed July 3, 2018) and 1:18-cr-00341-TWP-DLP (filed October 29, 2018; Information, plea agreement and stipulation of facts filed the same day, entries 33 and 38; waiver of indictment November 6, 2018, entry 43; docket terminated February 5, 2019), via the RECAP archive on the Internet Archive. The criminal capture in hand is partial — it does not carry the plea-entry or sentencing minutes — and the file says so where it matters (§03, §07). Named in: §03, §04.
“Carmel swim coach facing fed time over exploitation” (WISH-TV | wishtv.com), read firsthand in the paper’s e-edition for this file. Carries: the arrest (Tuesday, July 3, 2018; Marshals custody; the July 10 detention hearing); the June 29, 2018 law-enforcement notification; the warrants for his residence and cellphone; the investigating agencies; the charging-stage minimum; and the joint statement of Carmel Clay Schools and Carmel Swim Club quoted at §01 (signed by Superintendent Dr. Michael Beresford and Swim Club President Kristin Sherman). This story is also this file’s photograph source — see the photograph card below. Named in: Intro, §01–§03.
The contemporaneous sentencing story (summarized, with the Star’s reporting, by Swimming World, January 31, 2019): guilty plea and sentence of 200 months on January 30, 2019. Named in: §04.
“Former Carmel Coach John Goelz Banned for Life; Detained Pending Trial” (read in full for this file): the U.S. Center for SafeSport’s permanent ban, effective August 6, 2018, after a July 7 suspension and an expired appeal window; the district-court detention order and its stated grounds; the termination of his positions with both organizations. Named in: §03, §05.
This file’s photograph ran on the front page of the Hamilton County Reporter’s July 6, 2018 edition, inside the WISH-TV report of his arrest, captioned “Goelz” directly beneath it. It was extracted from the paper’s own e-edition PDF for this file (the embedded image, extracted without alteration) and face-checked against the second source WISH-TV published with its sentencing coverage — a screenshot of his professional profile naming “John Goelz, Lead Age Group Coach at Carmel Swim Club,” the same man, wearing glasses. The photograph is a small image (93×139 pixels) and is printed at its true size, never enlarged. Named in: the home view.
The civil suit at §06, 1:20-cv-00320-JMS-DML, was verified filed on January 29, 2020 when this file was first built (defendants: Carmel Clay Schools, Chris Plumb, John Goelz, and Red Roof Inn), and its ending was carried as not yet verified while the docket itself was out of reach. In this file’s pre-launch verification (November 12, 2026) the docket was pulled from the RECAP archive on the Internet Archive — the docket record and its filed documents, including the complaint entry, the May 5 and May 14, 2020 dismissal orders (documents 32 and 39), the June 18, 2020 discovery-conference entry on the confidential settlement agreement (entry 53), the other parties’ intervention motion (document 62), the June 4, 2021 Joint Stipulation of Dismissal with Prejudice (document 119), and the June 7, 2021 Order of Dismissal with Prejudice (document 120). The ending at §06 is stated from those papers. Still not in hand, and stated nowhere as fact: the parties and terms of the confidential settlement agreement (its parties were not defendants in the suit; the agreement itself sits under a protective order), and a separate order recording Red Roof Inn’s exit. The complaint was filed under the plaintiff’s own name; the plaintiff is the student-athlete in this file, and that name does not appear here. Named in: §06, §07.